Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is being a SAHM a job?

who's talking here?

Berda Belle 1
Just Kim 3
blessed 6
outermaga 1
cat 1
GCan 2
MomofTwins 1
lindagail 2
Denise C 1
country momma 1
Fiona 2
JerseyGirl 1
Scottie's Hottie 7
mocha_mama 3
Fallon 3
txsweetpotato 3
likeke27 2
ambergris 3
kjones0125 1
Trillian 1
CountryChick 1
gking 2
SVloves 1
Ann72 2
sharky 3
SS (SmilingSurvivor) 3
jemezchick 2
thekat 2
AtascaMom 1
mykidsmom 1
jimmy 1
AuthorMan 1
cowboyswife 6
crrc 1
myself 1
celadon 1
missym 1
Mygirl01 5
Catgirl 2
lonesophist 5
Brian 1
Cicero 4
Froggyrisa♥ 1
CaMacabre 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is being a SAHM a job?

After another thread and someone saying that I don't contribute to my child financially because I am a stay at home mom I have to ask this to all of you. Is it a job? I messed up the other poll so here we go...

Yes Vote
 
 88.7% (94)
No Vote
 
 11.3% (12)
Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

After another thread and someone saying that I don't contribute to my child financially because I am a stay at home mom I have to ask this to all of you. Is it a job? I messed up the other poll so here we go... 

CountryChick --- 19 years ago -

Definitely a job! 

SS (SmilingSurvivor) --- 19 years ago -

Heck yes! Somedays I am ready to go back to work, it seemed so much easier at work, lol! 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

You're talking about two different topics. It's not a job that contributes financially, but that does not mean it's not important and a lot of work. 

outermaga --- 19 years ago -

Yes, it is a VERY important job. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Not a job, but work. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

It is most definitely a job. The way I see it is my DH wants me to stay home so that I can be here to raise our children and not have a stranger do it. Not every job has to pay you monetarily. There are many people in this world who work for no money because it is what they want to do. Being a mom is a job and anyone who thinks it isn't is being ridiculous. JMO. 

Ann72 --- 19 years ago -

I find it awarding to be a SAHM. I've had arguments w/ DH about it being a job....till after he stayed home unemployed and I gave him my role for a little bit. Now he sees how it's a job to do laundry, clean (especially bathrooms which he hates), help with homework, play mommy taxi driver, and fix breakfast/lunch before heading off to school. I do work some freelance and sell our stuff on ebay to keep me sane. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

You're talking about two different topics. It's not a job that contributes financially, but that does not mean it's not important and a lot of work. well then let's say that my DH pays me to be his kids nanny, the housekeeper, errand runner, etc. How much would he have to pay someone to do all of that? Let's lowball it and say $2000 a month. So I guess I do get paid. 

SVloves --- 19 years ago -

I definitely feel it is a job!! 

mocha_mama --- 19 years ago -

HELL YEAH IT IS!!! 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Not every job has to pay you monetarily. I agree, and as I said, I'm not saying it's not important. It's VERY important. I said it does not contribute financially to the family's income, i.e., you're not bringing home a paycheck. That doesn't mean you didn't make that decision to save on daycare, or whatever the reason. I have always envied women who can stay home with their children. I never could. 

mocha_mama --- 19 years ago -

I think it does contribute to the family's income. It helps the family's income by aving thousands of dollars a year on gas, child care, eating out and I'm sure I can come up with some other things. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

haha Amy J. I tell my husband that half his paycheck it technically mine because that is my pay to do the things he wants me to do. It would be a lot easier to just go to work and have a maid clean my house and someone else raise my kids but I do it because it is important to my dh and myself. 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

It's a job and then some. 

Denise C --- 19 years ago -

I said it does not contribute financially to the family's income. I disagree. I stayed home and I also worked full time. When I stayed home, we had more money. When I went to work ft we had to pay $14k in daycare (which took away from the household) and pay uncle sam (which took away from the household) So by me not working that added expense wasn't there, therefore it paid for me not to work. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

It's a job and then some. hell, it's a job with no sick time or vacation benefits. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I still say it contributes. What would daycare cost for my infant son? About $800 a month plus my 3 year old about $700? That doesn't even include all the other things I do for my family. Looks like I do contribute financially to my family. 

mocha_mama --- 19 years ago -

not only do you get no sick time or vacation...you don't even get pee breaks and your job starts before everyone gets up and doesn't end until well after everyone is asleep...that's if you have kids that will sleep thru the nights. Hell, I even work in my sleep...scheduling appt's and meals in my dreams...LOL! 

crrc --- 19 years ago -

Not just a SAHM anymore, but I once was. It is a tough job. I am however a SAHM today and I must say it is very nice (kids are at school). But the unnice part of it is I have a ton of laundry, some brownie crumbs on the floor (WTH??), I found a sock on one of my ceiling fan blades (??), dd's room looks like a hurricane hit it and ds has the OUTSIDE of his room looking clean (dare I open a drawer or a door?? Then I get to pic dd and ds up form school-- listen to them fight about who breathed on who first, and take dd to tumble class and run a few errands. Then we will discuss schoolwork and fight ds about how come he has to take a shower TONIGHT instead of in the morning. Whooo! I have to work the next two nights in a row--(I will seriously not worry about this stuff while dh is taking care of it all) I will however have to listen to him whine about it! LOL At least he does it, I guess it could be worse! To get to the point---- SAHM = more than a real job without the $$ reward. Actually, you end up in the hole! 

Fiona --- 19 years ago -

Amy J - don't let it get to you girl. What was said on the other thread was just plain stupid. You take such good care of your children that you could not be paid enough. You out weigh that 350 by a long shot girl. 

Berda Belle --- 19 years ago -

I think it is a job-especially when the mother is involved in the child's school, takes time for homework & cleans the house, taking care of her man. Now on the other hand if the mother is not involved in the school/homework (or progress of her child), doesn't cook or clean & is just plain lazy. Then in that case it is not a job. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

I said it does not contribute financially to the family's income. I think it does, maybe not with actual paychecks, but here are some examples no money to daycare no money to therapist that your child would have to attend once subjected to horrible daycares no money to tutors once they fail a class if you are not there to help with homework no money to gas that you would be paying to drive back and forth to work everyday. more time to cook healthy meals and not pay to eat out all the time. not spending as much at dr's offices for subjecting your child to all the germs at a day care. more time to spend watching your baby grow to a fine young adult...priceless. I'm sure I am missing some... I've never been a SAHM, I wish I would of had that opportunity. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I still say it contributes. I totally agree with you, Amy. I was trying to clarify that being a SAHM does not bring home a paycheck. I was not trying to undermine its importance or say that it did not affect the finances of the family in any way whatsoever. I doubt any women who are SAHM would want to fill out a W-2 and pay taxes on what they claim their job is worth. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

If you would pay someone to watch your kids when you were gone, then a SAHM is no different. I am a SAHM, and I know it is cheaper for me to be here with my dd. If I worked, then someone would have to watch her, feed her, shuttle her to and from school and extracurricular activities. Help her with her school work (not yet but when she gets to it), teach her to be a great person, responsible, mature and caring. What would you pay someone who did all of these things for your child? I will take the lack of a physical pay check to insure that my child is the kind of person I want her to be. It is easier (IMO) to wake up your children, feed them breakfast and send them to day care, go to work and at 5 or 6 PM, go by and pick them up, take them home, feed them, give them a bath and put them to bed. Then to stay at home every single day and do everything for your child yourself and keep your house together at the same time. 

Cicero --- 19 years ago -

Well, I've always said that one parent should be at home rasing the family's children. That being said, whomever is at home is contributing to the success of the family even if it isn't monetary. My wife has been at home for 5 years (she also goes to school) and I couldn't do it without her. 

celadon --- 19 years ago -

Hmm..well I am a SAHM but I worked for 6 years before and both my kids were in daycare. I thought it would be so much easier to stay home- wrong! But, I keep telling myself that how many times am I going to be able to cuddle with them, or meet them at the bus stop, or do things with them at school. You can't "re-do" those things later in life. However, there was a small article in the Parade magazine of the Chronicle this weekend that got me depressed about how staying home now is going to make it so hard for me to go back into the workforce. I have a B.S. but I feel in a few years it's going to be outdated and worthless. Oh well. Anyone else see the article?? 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I also believe that if I worked, my dh worked and a day care was taking care of my dd all day, then my house would stay a lot cleaner, since nobody would be here to mess it up all day long. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Most of you are getting upset that you somehow feel belittled or that your choice to stay home with your children is not a "job." However, most mothers who have jobs outside the home also do those things as well. People make choices based on their own personal circumstances and what is best for their family. This is really a useless debate because people are getting offended just because someone disagrees with them. If any of your husbands lost their jobs or could not work, I seriously doubt your financial contribution by staying home would allow you to continue doing so. It only works when there's another income, that's all I'm saying when I say it's not a "job with financial contributions," that's all. It's not a personal attack on anyone. 

Ann72 --- 19 years ago -

I have a B.S. but I feel in a few years it's going to be outdated and worthless. Oh well. I know what you mean. But, couldn't you take courses to keep you updated? Course, I should talk... Or away to work from home maybe to keep the skills up? 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I still say it contributes. What would daycare cost for my infant son? About $800 a month plus my 3 year old about $700? That doesn't even include all the other things I do for my family. Looks like I do contribute financially to my family. SO TRUE!! 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I am very proud that I stay at home with our daughter, I think it makes me a more important part of my daughters life, and that is worth every penny I don't make! 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

You would be working to pay for day care, Amy!!! Thats STUPID!!! 

Froggyrisa♥ --- 19 years ago -

what you contribute to the family as a stay at home mom is more valueable to the children and entire family's well being than money. You are providing them with the emotional and behavior foundation for her to rely on a as adult. If she is in daycare then it is the daycare working subconsiously providing and teaching these values to your children. When a mother stays home, it may be tight financially bt spiritually and for the family as a whole it is a priceless comparison. I believe the country started to go downhill when we started paying other people to raise our children for us, but on the other hand, i am a very independent minded woman who agrees in equality and the ability for the mother to choose whether she stays home or not, but it doesnt have to be the mother that stays home with the child, the father can stay at home too, but i believe a child, esp in the early years, benefits more from having a parent or family member stay at home with them in the years before school. Extended family is also helpful in instiliing the family values you treasure. I am a stay at home mom, but not by choice, i am forced to stay at home for medical reasons, but i feel , even though i have several days when i cannot get out of bed, i feel my children ae better off because i am emoitionally available for them at home, when i cannot physcially do something for them, i help them by teaching them independence by showing them how to do it themselves. A stay at home mother has been compared to the equivalant of a fulltime job for EACH CHILD, so i have 2 children which means the work i do ( when i can) is the same as holding down 2 fulltime jobs outside the home, not counting the hubby, depending on how helpless they are , they can also be counted as a partime job ( only because you can leave them at home alone without adult supervision leagally, although we all know even hubbies need a babysitter at times to "HELP" them make he right choices. LOL 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I saw on TV the other night, if a SAHM was PAID for all her work, it would EXCEED $700,000 a YEAR!!!!! In that case I would hire a NANNY!!!!! ROFL!!!! 

AtascaMom --- 19 years ago -

Being a mom is hard work.. period! However, it gets to me when I hear things like "being a SAHM is the hardest job there is". I feel like putting in a 40 hour workweek and then STILL having to clean, wash, cook is the "hardest job there is". I'm not taking anything away from the SAHM's... just wanna recognize the mom's with double duty! 

country momma --- 19 years ago -

How's the old saying go.... "from sun up till sun down a womans work is never done"..Hell, yes being a stay at home mom is hard work. I cook, clean, do yard work , iron clothes, do all of the shopping, paying the bills, and tind to my kiddos. I dont get time off for being sick, or a vacation day. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I saw on TV the other night, if a SAHM was PAID for all her work, it would EXCEED $700,000 a YEAR!!!!! A small fraction of that would be nice, but it is our choice to do this for our daughter, so if I don't get paid an actual paycheck, then I will happily work for all of the kisses and hugs I get daily, no amount of money can replace that love. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I'm not taking anything away from the SAHM's... just wanna recognize the mom's with double duty! I BOW DOWN to yall, LOL!!!!! 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I'm not taking anything away from the SAHM's... just wanna recognize the mom's with double duty! Thank you for saying that. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground