Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you think a 3 year old should be told the true story of Easter?

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
Keystone 1
FirePrincess 2
GCan 1
lindagail 1
Denise C 2
MissT 2
Fiona 1
Scottie's Hottie 7
mocha_mama 1
Mary C 2
ACwife 2
bbjones 1
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 1
ambergris 2
kjones0125 1
CyberSage 1
qpc 3
AuthorMan 1
cowboyswife 3
Pet Lover 1
myself 1
missym 1
Catgirl 1
lonesophist 2
*emily 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think a 3 year old should be told the true story of Easter?

My son is 3 years old. He attends a MDO here in Montgomery at a baptist church. I have been pretty happy with the program and the people are great. He seems to really like it too. Only one thing that is bugging me. He came home yesterday and told me that someone at his school died. I asked him a few questions and he says "they died at my school...Ms. Jennifer told me that." I kind of caught on then and I said do you mean Jesus died? He said yes Jesus died at my school. I am just not sure if a child of his age can understand the concept of death on any level. Do you think that it is appropriate for them to be learning this? I love that the school teaches bible study there among other things but should it be age appropriate?

Yes they should. Vote
 
 72.1% (44)
No they shouldn't. Vote
 
 26.2% (16)
Undecided. Vote
 
 1.6% (1)
Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

My son is 3 years old. He attends a MDO here in Montgomery at a baptist church. I have been pretty happy with the program and the people are great. He seems to really like it too. Only one thing that is bugging me. He came home yesterday and told me that someone at his school died. I asked him a few questions and he says "they died at my school...Ms. Jennifer told me that." I kind of caught on then and I said do you mean Jesus died? He said yes Jesus died at my school. I am just not sure if a child of his age can understand the concept of death on any level. Do you think that it is appropriate for them to be learning this? I love that the school teaches bible study there among other things but should it be age appropriate? 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Amy, I have been pondering this ALL day!! 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I don't know what I think about it. I think its good to teach about Christ and his sacrifice for us, but death and resurrection is, IMO, a difficult thing for a 3 year old to understand. With it being a church MDO, I am not surprised they taught about it. Maybe the emphasis was portrayed innapropriately for the age group? 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I am struggling with what to tell M now too. I was so shocked when he said it to began with. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I would love the people who said yes to tell me why they think that. I am just trying to understand it not debate it. 

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

i think that the easter story should be told to a 3 yr old at a 3 yr old level. there is plenty of time to explain more. i also think that whatever is told at school should be WAY simple. so maybe the school just told a more detailed version than he was ready for. 

Keystone --- 19 years ago -

I said yes because my 3-year old doesn't have a problem with it. She mainly likes to tell the risen from the grave part but she does talk about Jesus dying on the cross. 

kjones0125 --- 19 years ago -

My son was told the Easter story at age 3 at his MDO Christian-based school. He asked pretty simply questions and I answered them. I wouldn't dwell on it too much. They usually comment then move onto something else pretty quick. :) 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I would love to know how it was told to him. Maybe I should ask.... 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I did not vote yet. But I think when teaching our Children the "true" story of Easter, it doesn't have to be just about death. What set Christ apart from us and a very important part of Easter is Christs resurrection and the promise of everlasting life. His sacrifice is very important and gives us a reason to celebrate overcoming sin and being able to return to Him. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

Personally I think church based school or not they should just stick with the Easter Bunny for 3 year olds. jmo 

myself --- 19 years ago -

TOTALLY 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

Personally I think church based school or not they should just stick with the Easter Bunny for 3 year olds. jmo ditto 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I guess I am the minority. I just don't think my 3 year old is ready to hear about death. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

I just don't think my 3 year old is ready to hear about death. I think that they are too young! I just want to do what is right. J will not "get" it. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

I thought the 'age of reason' was 6 years old. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

I'm sure there's an age appropriate way to tell the story, but I have to say that our children know from birth who Jesus is and what he did for us. Children can understand a lot more than we give them credit for...after all, they believe in a God that they can't see or hear or touch. 

missym --- 19 years ago -

Amyj...No...I don't think a three yr old understands. When my daughter was three she came home after a Sunday School Class and told me that they had thrown a birthday party for Jesus. I asked her if she had fun. She replied, I had alot of fun, but Jesus never showed up. She was actually very angry that he didn't even show up for his own birthday party!!! She thought she was finally going to get to meet him...LOL. We have laughed about this for years. Kids are so cute at that age. 

Denise C --- 19 years ago -

Well since I don't believe in Easter, I say no. That should be left up to the parent. 

mocha_mama --- 19 years ago -

Amy J, I think it depends on the child. My now 4 and 5 year old remind me all the time that Jesus is in their hearts and that HE died for their sins. They will even tell you how HE had to carry his own cross and then was later hung on it. My dd will say mommy feel my heart, Jesus is in there. They learned it all in k3 and k4. I'm not sure if they really understand what they are talking about, but I do appreciate the fact that they acknowledge it. I just see it as a head start to what they'll be learning in Sunday school anyway. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

I think they should hear the story but it should be told in an age appropriate manner. My DS is 4 and he learns about the bible stories at school and then comes home and shares with us. It is not always exactly like we have heard them but it is his age appropriate interpretation of it. He loves to hear about God and Jesus and what they have done and do for us daily. He tells me all the time that church school is his favorite and he doesn't want to go to "real" school. LOL. 

ACwife --- 19 years ago -

Well since I don't believe in Easter, I say no You don't believe in the "Easter" with bunny rabbits, or the resurrection? 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

I would tell him in a manner appropriate to his age. When my mother was dying last year, I was finding it difficult to keep that fact from my boys. The most difficult thing I had to do was explain what was happening and why. The hospice worker who overheard me said that I said everything perfectly. All I can say is that I tried to answer the boys' questions to the best of my ability and without worrying them. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I would tell him in a manner appropriate to his age. I agree. I have found that smaller children want just enough information to satisfy their curiosity, but I think it's important to be honest as well, being careful not to scare them. My mother used to tell me that I should not be scared at night while I slept, because Jesus was watching over me through the window, instead of letting me have a night light. I had even more trouble sleeping because I kept seeing someone staring at me through the window. 

ambergris --- 19 years ago -

. I had even more trouble sleeping because I kept seeing someone staring at me through the window. that would have scared me too and I would not have cared who she said it was. LOL. 

Pet Lover --- 19 years ago -

Amy J, I just asked my dd (8) this very question. She said at first, no, it is not too young, and then she stopped and said, well they won't know what crucify means, and they will have to ask their parents. There you go...from the mouths of babes. I really think it depends on the maturity of the child, with that said, I think the school should send you a paper home to explain what they are going to talk about, so you will follow up with it. I think 4 or 5 is a better age to get into the details! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

For me, since Easter and Jesus' death and resurrection are what the real meaning and importance of life is, my children have know since birth the entire events of Easter. However, I will say that the emphasis is never on Jesus' death but on His resurrection, since that's the most important part. While I feel like children need to know that Jesus really hurt and died because He loved us SO much that He took the punishment for our sin. But more importantly, they need to know that He did not stay in the grave but was greater than death and left the tomb. I think that young kids CAN understand that. Yes, they are sad that He was hurt, but it's OK for kids to understand and feel sadness. THey can also be EXCITED that Jesus rose from the grave and because of what He did for us, we can live eternally in Heaven with Him. Hope that helps explain why I think it is OK for a 3 year old to know the truth of the story when told in an age appropriate way with the correct emphasis. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Thanks QPC, that really helps!! MAN, you know your Bible studies AND the grocery game.....You are amazing!!!...;) 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

Small children are too literal, they just get upset to learn about someone dying. I have always told my son that Christmas is celebrating his birth and Easter is celebrating the life he lived for us. Once he got older, then he learned more details about the crucifixion. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

> 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

What a movie!!! I don't pretend that I was worth one second of his pain. I cannot imagine how much God really loves us. I am so thankful for His mercy that renews every morning and so thankful for His grace. 

Denise C --- 19 years ago -

You don't believe in the "Easter" with bunny rabbits, or the resurrection? I don't believe in setting aside one day a year to celebrate Christ's death and resurrection. This should be celebrated everyday. And the bible teaches not to add or take away and I believe that celebrating in this fashion is adding to. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

I agree we should celebrate every day too! For me, Easter is similar to a special remeberance time, similar to when Jesus and the Jewish people observed (and still observe) Passover. It is setting aside a time to really observe and reflect a signifigant event in your spiritual history. While done every day, this is just an added time to reflect and give praise to God. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I believe that it is NEVER too early to tell a child about the truth of God! I think that they need to know that God loved us so much that God came to earth and died for us so that we could spend eternity with God in Heaven! 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

I think you should tell them in a way they understand it, and way that it doesn't scare them. I'm actually surprised at how much my son knows. I asked him one day if he knew Jesus loves him. He said "Yeah...but he's not here right now. We're waiting on Him to come back." I honestly thought that was a pretty good answer for a then 4 year old. 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Now that he has been exposed to it and it seems like he needs it to be explained to him, I would tell him. I think the "teacher" needed to send home a permision slip first. But what do you expect, you are sending him to a MDO (whatever that means) baptist church? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Amy J...something we have used with our kids is "resurrection eggs". You can buy them at Family Life, but they are easy to make. Here's the link for instructions. We've done this at a very young age with our kids and they all understood it and weren't emotionally harmed from it. I think it puts the emphasis on the empty tomb, while still showing the kids the other parts of the story in a way that they can understand. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

For those who voted NO: Do you personally believe the true story of Easter. A "yes" or "no" will suffice. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

I think it's important to tell kids the truth from the beginning..... for one, it lets them know they can trust you completely. Also, think about what could happen to a kid who has been told about Santa Clause, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and Jesus..... all of whom they never SEE..... but believe by faith..... then they grow up and find out that Santa is not real, the Easter Bunny is not real, the Tooth Fairy is not real.... so what about Jesus? 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

Very good points. My son is just turned 3 the middle of January. I still think he is way to young to understand death. He does go to Sunday school at our church but he has never came home and told me someone at our church died. qpc: I love how you put that. I am going to talk to him about it myself and try to explain. I did see a book at Walmart that was the story of Easter and it was an easy read for a 3 year old to understand. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground