Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Do you judge parents on how their young child misbehaves?

who's talking here?

adam 1
blessed 2
Paige 4
FirePrincess 1
bobbi 18
Doublestuff 4
Liane 1
~grandma again~ 2
Scottie's Hottie 10
cmi 2
Mary C 1
QueenCassie 3
justkilintym 1
bbjones 1
mikesgal 1
rrazl 7
kjones0125 1
My 3 and Me 1
TheJude 4
Splendor 1
lilmommy 3
jemezchick 2
cowboyswife 8
caitlin 1
Zionist NightOwl 2
Going off air 1
Catgirl 11
*Sunny* 1
Mela Mom 2
Syrah1214 1
zɹossıʞs 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Do you judge parents on how their young child misbehaves?

Do you judge parents on how their young child misbehaves?

Yes Vote
 
 65.8% (52)
No Vote
 
 26.6% (21)
undecided Vote
 
 7.6% (6)
Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Do you judge a parent by the way their young bad child behaves? 

zɹossıʞs --- 19 years ago -

I'd say to a degree, yes. It's hard to admit maybe but I think everyone does. Not that I think the parents are 'bad parents' but they just need to learn how to discipline their children more effectively. But it goes both ways, if someone has really good kids then some people are impressed.. My mom got lots of compliments about me when I was a kid ;P 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

This is a great poll! I know I am judged on the behavior of my kids. My kids are well rounded, exposed, and unconditionally loved. But they are much more active than most kids I see their age. My 3 year old displays NO self control. I know people would see my kids and assume they are from a bad family. However, it is quite the opposite. Isn't it possible for great, loving, involved people to just have kids that are rough around the edges? 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

But they are much more active than most kids I see their age. My 3 year old displays NO self control. MINE TOO!!!!!! 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

i have learned to NOT judge a parent by the way their child acts. I have a ds who has always been a angel when out in public....but my dd is my worst nightmare! She is language delayed and gets very frustrated when we do not understand her - I know its not an excuse for bad behavior - as it embarasses me to the point of not wanting to take her anywhere in public BUT I have learned since having a child with a disability to NOT judge every bad behavior by its cover. If you as an observer of bad behavior wants to help (and believe me - I sometimes need a strangers intervention)- go up to the child and just talk to them. You would be surprised at how much it helps - not only other customers sanity but the mom or dad's sanity also! 

*Sunny* --- 19 years ago -

Easy to judge until you have kids of your own 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

exactly... 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

I know I was judged in a negative light when my son was going through his proublems at a very young age. They didn't see all the love, effort, $$$ and time etc. I was devoting to my child. If I hadn't gone through this myself, I would of answered YES to this poll question. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

i think how we handle "challenging" moments shows a lot about who we are as parents. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

It depends on how old the child is. 

My 3 and Me --- 19 years ago -

I have to agree with bb (believe it or not). My boys never went through terrible 2s but 3s were a nightmare. It was like demons posessed them for awhile. Now, when I see a 2-3 year old having a fit, I don't judge! Now, if the kid is older, that is another thing. 

justkilintym --- 19 years ago -

I didn't vote but it depends on what is going on. I am sure people judge me when my dd is being bad in public WHEN my dh is with us. He will not punish her in public and at home and it is a issue we constantly fight about. 

QueenCassie --- 19 years ago -

I never had to worry about it with my oldest DD,she was always such a god kid. My little one is a different story,she is such a challenge! Very stubborn and independant,but makes me laugh so it's hard to punish her! 

Doublestuff --- 19 years ago -

I judge a parent more on how they react to a child's bad behavior than the bad behavior itself. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

meaning what doublestuff? Whether they spank them or just ignore it? I would like to know what is the best reaction when a 2 year old is throwing a fit in the store....:) 

Doublestuff --- 19 years ago -

It really depends on the situation. I know that there are a lot of different parenting styles. In the 2 year old example, I am not sure that there is a best reaction to a 2 year old throwing a fit. If they gave a single swat on the bottom, dragged them out of the store, or even just stood there and ignored them then those are all valid reactions. If they beat the snot out of them, not a good reaction. If they immediately give in and try to give the child whatever they are throwing a fit for then I don't look down on them, but think what a tough time both they and the child are going to have in the future. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

I have tried swatting my dd when she acts up in the store....only to get from strangers.."poor baby" and if I try to just ignore her and finish shopping...I get "the look". So somebody please tell me - what would you do if you child (2 yrs old) starts to throw a fit ? 

Mela Mom --- 19 years ago -

In most cases I don't think I judge a parent by how their child behaves, but more so how they react/handle that behavior...are they allowing it to happen and just sit their while it is happening or do they try to handle the situation. 

Doublestuff --- 19 years ago -

I feel for you bobbi. When my ds was little he used to throw a fit because he didn't want to be in the store, he wanted to go back out to the car and go home. I used to be so embarrassed, but I would let him scream throughout the whole trip. If I gave in to him and left the store he would have thought that it was a great way to get what he wanted. So I got 'the look' a lot and he could sometimes keep it up for a good 20 minutes. After a couple of very painful months he was doing it less and less since he realized that mommy NEVER gave in to him because he was throwing a fit. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

boy, doublestuff...that sounds exactly like my dd. She hates the carseat, the store, restaurants....you name it! We are at the point that we just try to ignore her but it sure is tough! We were at a restaurant one evening and she started in with one of her fits and we were just trying to ignore her and have a family dinner.....when this elderly gentleman walks up to our table, stands about 1 foot from us and just stares at us.....I was so upset! We were stressed enough with her tantrum and then he comes over and acts as though we were being bad parents. It is so embarassing to have a child act this way. 

Mela Mom --- 19 years ago -

what would you do if you child (2 yrs old) starts to throw a fit ? All you can do is remove them from the situation...When my DS was that age we went out to dinner together and he had an all out meltdown in the middle of La Madeline...I told him that if he didn't stop we were leaving and when he didn't I asked them to wrap our food up when it was ready and I took him home. I had a problem with him about a year ago acting up when we were out shopping...I finally told him that if he did not know how to behave when he was out with me that he could come out with me....I would only go out to the store when my husband was home and he would want to come and I would not let him...after a month or so he asked if he could come and I told him yes but if he acted up once he would not be coming with me again for a long time...I haven't really had a problem since. 

Doublestuff --- 19 years ago -

Hang in there. I know it seem like it will never end now, but it will pass. Try not to let others get to you (easier said than done I know). My ds is five now and it is more of a distant memory. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

Yes, EMS...with my son I was able to rationalize with him in that fashion....he knew the rules before we ever hit the door of where we were going. BUT my daughter, who is technically about 6-8 months behind developmentally and is tall for a 2 year old.....there is no rationalizing with her. I want to enjoy her at this age but I tell you....I am ready for her to be about 5 years old! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

. . .what would you do if your child (2 yrs old) starts to throw a fit ? If it's in a restaurant, or other place where it could be too disruptive, I would remove my kids for a short while (time-out in the car-seat, or foyer, or wherever). But if it was an errand in a not-so-crowded store, I used to say to my toddlers during a fit, "That doesn't work." Like a broken record, 2 or 3 times between long pauses. (Not necessary, but out of self-consciousness, if there were onlookers nearby, I would say it loud enough so they could hear and know that I was addressing the situation, just in my own way.) Then I would add, "That doesn't work; it will NOT get you what you want." And pretty much ignore the behavior and everyone else in the store while I shopped. Then when we were in the car, I would ask him/her, "Did your tantrum get you what you wanted? It didn't work, did it?" (Reinforcement). This response works on the principle that "behavior that does not get the desired result is extinguished". It took a couple of times for my kids to see that I meant business, but they learned it. If you as an observer of bad behavior want to help. . . go up to the child and just talk to them. You would be surprised at how much it helps. . . . One time there was a kid screaming and throwing a fit in line at the pharmacy where we were waiting. My 4-yr. old ds went up to the kid and told him, "That doesn't work!" All the adults in line cracked up. The kid was like, "huh? And my ds just said, "That won't get you what you want." The kid actually shut up while he pondered the wisdom of that. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

yes, one time while waiting in the check out line my dd was throwing a fit for candy and I was holding my ground and telling her that will not work...and she just kept throwing a fit...luckily an elderly gentleman came up and said to her "you weren't doing that a few minutes ago when I saw you"....she immediately stopped crying and wondered who this man was talking to her. I was so thankful for that moment. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

How about all the parents agree to quit judging how others react to their child? I always wonder who's watching what I do and that's just ridiculous. I know my children can behave and I also know they can be brats. I have seen plenty of kids from strict parents turn out rotten and plenty of kids from laid back parents turn out great. I know that noone knows the perfect way to parent, so everyone needs to stop judging each other. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 19 years ago -

I'll agree to that. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

Bobbi, your biggest problem is that your DD is too cute to possibly do anything wrong!!! She is just adorable. No one would want to see her get fussed at for ANYTHING! 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

Thanks Mary....I wish that was the case...she definitely deserves some of it! You just haven't seen her at her worst....she's got the wool pulled over you :) 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

I answered yes. However, I judge when I see a child talking to their parents in a really disrespectful way or seriously talking back. If a child has disabilities, that is different. KWIM? If you see a 3 year old kicking and screaming because the parent won't buy them something.....that is lack of training. If you see a 10 year old literally yelling disrespectfully at their parent because they are not getting their way....that is lack of training. 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

I agree with blessed on MOST of what she said. I think for the most part, a 3 year old kicking and screaming is lack of training. HOWEVER, sometimes it has to do with not having a nap or being hungry. And I don't necessarily mean kicking and screaming.....but my kids definitely act out if they are tired or hungry. But if I notice my kids are starting to act to where other people will notice, we LEAVE and go home and take a nap. LOL. My kids used to act up in the store because they KNEW I couldn't punish them in the store. I swear they have a sense for that. I was always afraid of getting the dirty looks so I didn't react. Now, if they act up in the store, there are CONSEQUENCES when we get home. I only had to do that once or twice and now they know they won't get away with it. Back on topic, if I see a small child throwing a fit....I don't think much of it. If I see an older child with a smart mouth, I lose respect for the parent. My kids will lose all of their privileges one at a time until they straighten up that mouth!!! 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

If I see an older child with a smart mouth, I lose respect for the parent. I got in sooooo much trouble for my mouth as a kid. It's sad that people assumed it was my parents' fault. It's just who I was. I knew it wasn't acceptable to them, but I "knew" when I was "right." So, I was pretty much a smart ass. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

OK.... I'll answer... I was blessed dearly with my oldest... He behaved properly and had the best manners any parent could have asked for... I was complimented many a times on him... Total strangers would compliment me.... So, I believed that I was a wonderful parent and that parenting was easy.... Boy, was I ever wrong!!!! Then comes son #2.... Screamed when he was a baby... Nothing, but nothing calmed him... Until he turned 1 and then it stopped... Skipping to about 3 years old.. That boy was WILD... He was clearly out of control, as others would have put it... Heck, his own doctor recommended putting him on meds (ADHD meds) to calm him down.... At 3!!!!!!!!!! But then he turned 4 and got a little better.... Now he's 5 and is wonderful!!!!!!!! Then #3.... He's just a mad man... I don't even know where to begin with him... He has two older brothers and wants to keep up with them... You can't keep that boy down... But for the past week or so, he's been getting better and better... Sleeping longer and longer at night... Playing more and more games with me... So, all in all, I think my kids are gonna be just fine... As for me, I'm not so sure... LOL But, when I take my oldest two out in public, people always praise their manners... I have goofy, loving, well rounded, children... They still act like kids but are growing too fast everyday... I love them dearly. 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

I totally agree that an older child should be respectful of their parent and other adults. I think everyone that voted "yes" is feeling that the "young" in the question is referring to kids age 4 and up. And I agree, this age and up with bad behavior does reflect on the parent. But kids 3 and under, do not understand being tired, or hungry....they just let it all out, when and where ever they please. So I think that maybe the poll should read - "If a child over 3 behaves badly, do you judge the parent? 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I have to be honest and say I do judge parents who's kids act out. Especially those parents that I know. I hate even saying that! LOL! It is the truth. My DD was always a complete angel until middle school but I will lay money on it that you will never be around her and think that she is anything but a sweet, well mannered kid. My DS is 3 and has his moments but just like with my DD I am always complemented on what a wonderful kid he is. Like fireprincess was saying he has his moment. If he hasn't had a nap or his hungry he can be very whiney but I am an adult and I do the same thing. Now the baby (5 months) is a complete doll. He is the most wonderful baby. I hope he stays the way he is forever. I have friends who have told me that I am a strict parent and that I make a big deal out of nothing but I want my kids to understand there are boundaries. It bothers me when I see parents who have children who appear to have no boundaries. My kids are by no means perfect but I try very hard to discipline the best I can. So many days it would be so much easier to just give in but it will only be a temporary solution. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I have to be honest and say I do judge parents who's kids act out. Especially those parents that I know. I hate even saying that! LOL! It is the truth. So, basically you judge me on the way my little guy behaves....? Wow, you must not think very highly of me... LOL 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

Ahhh, he is really good, lilmommy!! That kid never whines and he is still a baby. He just likes to be free!! 

bobbi --- 19 years ago -

Remind me to not bring my daughter to any functions...LOL 

Scottie's Hottie --- 19 years ago -

I have to ask, bobbi. Are you a mom who will let her kids play and be adventurous or do you hoover over every move? I ask this because a lot of times with my own kids I find if i just back off a little bit they are much calmer. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

Catgirl- I don't believe in calling kids BAD, I think thats awful. Yes their actions are bad, but never call the child BAD. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground