Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is it alright to let a child watch....

who's talking here?

mugglemom 2
Liane 1
~grandma again~ 1
MissT 1
2131MR 3
Curarie 2
RRay 1
I Love Horses 1
April 2
mikesgal 2
Justwatching72 1
Sandyr9111 2
Anderson 1
CountryChick 1
lLackCreativity 1
MommyL 3
wheres my list 1
Splendor 1
lilmommy 8
momofthreeatascosita 4
*Annie* 1
:)NewMe 1
qpc 1
Zionist NightOwl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

a natural child birth? Is it still alright to let a 5 year old boy watch? Especially if the child is down at the mothers feet. What do you think? 

CountryChick --- 19 years ago -

ewww...I don't know about that... 

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

that child would probably need some serious therapy later in life. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I just want people's opinions. This is not my child, I promise. 

*Annie* --- 19 years ago -

I'd start with puppies. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Let me explain a little more. A friend of mine just had her baby. She had it perfectly natural. No meds, no nothing. Her husband allowed the 5 year old son to stay in the room and watch. The boy saw everything. I just wanted to know if some people actually think this is alright. 

MommyL --- 19 years ago -

I would never allow my kids in during the actual birth maybe during labor, but not the birth... 

2131MR --- 19 years ago -

Nope, "family births" are just icky to me. I don't think that was fair to do to the son. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I'm so glad I'm not alone. The father seems to think that now his son will not want to go out and get a girl pregnant because of what he witnessed. The father now seems to think he's taught his son a lesson. 

2131MR --- 19 years ago -

WAY too early for that lesson, and the son probably thinks that the father has done something wrong in creating his sibling if that is his message. Both kids are going to wind up needing counseling, the 2nd one will be haunted by the "you are a mistake" syndrome. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I didn't even let it bother me until he (father) started explaining it all to me in front of my kids. In graphic detail. He seems to think he can tell me that I'm wrong for not telling my children all about it. And my hubby let him know where we stand on it. It's not his responsibility to teach my children about the birds and the bees. And I personally think he was way out there teaching his. JMO 

Curarie --- 19 years ago -

I think it is fine. I was raised on a farm and had to help in all situations and so did my brother.We learned early about life and also about death. Today people don't see births or deaths so they seem very ugly or ewwwwy and most times they are not. I think that if the child had things explained and was not forced to watch....it is his brother or sister and not a stranger. How is this diffrent than a spanking issue or maybe immunizations??? I just think people do thinks diffrent now days. 

Curarie --- 19 years ago -

Never tell someone else's children about the birds and bees---that's for their friends later on in life! 

April --- 19 years ago -

I don't even want to watch!!!!! And I've had two! 

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

I'm there with you April! 

2131MR --- 19 years ago -

I didn't want anyone there when I gave birth - not because it is "private" but because it was so very painful for me, and I'm not nice when I hurt. 

:)NewMe --- 19 years ago -

That kids gonna be like "WTF??" lol I agree with April! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

Well, I had three c-sections so I really didn't know if this was acceptable or not. I wouldn't dare let my children watch. But that's just me. I can only imagine what this little boy is thinking about it all. I've told my children the truth, so far, about everthing. That mommies go to the hospital and the doctor cuts the tummy open to take the baby out. For now that's all they need to know. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My mother is a midwife and i grew up watching childbirths and going to classes with my mom! but i wouldnt allow my kids in on my birth as iam way to shy about that i dont even like the idea of my husband checking me out down there its just alittle personal! i also think that a 5yr old is not going to remember a childbirth when he is a teenager. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

that child would probably need some serious therapy later in life. I have to agree... I once heard a definition of child abuse as putting a child in any situation meant only for adullts.... this is crossing a thin line...I personally don't think witnessing child birth is appropriate for a child's emotional well being... 

wheres my list --- 19 years ago -

I am actually speechless. Poor baby boy. I can't believe the mentality of some people. Even if the child was asking, HE'S FIVE. WOW! 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

-that's for their friends later on in life! or MTV's Spring Break 

Liane --- 19 years ago -

I don't even want to watch!!!!! And I've had two! I'm with you! 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

Well and the time from 5 to hormonal is WAY too long for it to matter and boy hormones override ALOT. The child will be scarred from having to see his mothers unmentionables. 

April --- 19 years ago -

Here's one for you...when my sister had her first, her husband took pictures of the whole thing. Okay, whatever floats your boat. But then they took the pics and showed them to my parents!!! I thought my father was going to have a stroke right there. I think my poor dad needed therapy after that one! 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

OK....I grew up on a farm. Childbirth, sow birth,cowbirth,rabits........after a while.......Its just like takin a good poop...happens pretty regular and you feel good when its over. besides......it wont hurt him. Looky how good I turned out! 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

Looky how good I turned out! Case closed....kid is gonna be MAJORLY screwed!!! LOL 

~grandma again~ --- 19 years ago -

You sure they didn't drop you on your head, Ray? I say the answer to this is no. I think a child can start with seeing puppies being born and then move on up but 5 years old? I have 2 grandsons that are 5 and can not even imagine what they would think about something like that. They have a panic attack when they have an oversized poop! 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

Jeff Foxworthy, the comedian, does a great bit about childbirth . . . He says something to the effect that it's like watching a wet St. Bernard come in thru the cat door . . . and who needs to see that? LOL 5 years old? My vote is absolutely NOT! I also don't think you can compare watching your family pet or farm animal giving birth to a young child watching his mommy going thru it. JMO I also declined watching my own son being born via a mirror. =) 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I was quite sickened by watching the doctor pull my sons out of my stomach. I think I might have been sick seeing him appear elsewhere. LOL Seriously, this was a huge discussion between my hubby and the father tonight. I didn't appreciate it one bit that the father expected me to tell my boys right then and there about it. Or he would. I asked him a few times to shut up but he just kept going. Urggg. 

mikesgal --- 19 years ago -

I didn't appreciate it one bit that the father expected me to tell my boys right then and there about it. Or he would. Unbelievable! Telling your children about birds and bees stuff is up to you and your hubby. You might want to consider nixing him off your list of 'friends'. He crossed the boundaries. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

That's what I'm thinking. I love his wife but just never quite understood him. He says things alot that I find offensive around my boys. Like over the summer we went to the lake. He was showing his son "all the hotties" in front of my boys, me, his wife, and everyone else. My hubby won't even talk like that, in front of me at least. LOL 

lLackCreativity --- 19 years ago -

His wife must not beat him enough. Dang women shirkin their duties to society. Doesn't every woman know you have to beat your husband at least once a day? Emotional/mental/physical...pick one and do it. If you dont, you end up with that guy! 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

I'd say no....the child can be in the other room. I've read where grown men can't deal with it---how can a 5yr. old process that information? 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

I actually considered letting my 8 year old daughter be in the room when my son was born, but the hospital wouldn't allow it. It was a somewhat special circumstance though. My husband's first wife (her actual mom) died in childbirth with her brother, and so I wanted her to have a positive experience with birth. I was drugged too, so I wouldn't have been yelling or anything. I guess I'm wierd because I don't see that it is all that horrible. Maybe because I'm a nurse and have seen it several times as well as gone through it several times. I guess it would just depend on the child. I actually think the younger, the better as far as boys go. I wouldn't want my older son to see everything more than I wouldn't want my younger son to see things. For girls, I wouldn't have a problem with them being there as long as they were not super young, like younger than 4 or 5. I also wouldn't let them go in without a lot of prep work and talking about what they would be seeing. 

momofthreeatascosita --- 19 years ago -

I had both of my DD in the room when my son was born they were 4 and 6.I do not regret the decision. They are all very close and loving siblings. I did not have them 1 foot from you know where but they were up in the bed with me. Now with him being a boy in might not be as easy of a decision.This was very common in the old days wasnt it. Anyway I think they are fine from it, So I guess I must be MENTAL.. 

Splendor --- 19 years ago -

I don't know which way to go with this. True, it's best that they know, but, at the same time, it should depend on their maturity level. 

momofthreeatascosita --- 19 years ago -

Okay wanted to add one more thing to this. They are going to learn this one way or another either with their parents in a loving setting welcoming their silbling. Or from some punk at school who tells them who knows what in what kind of misinformed detail. So I went with the first way.Like when another first grader told my DD what gay was..... in first grade in a way a first grader should not know.... 

MommyL --- 19 years ago -

ok I'm sorry about the comment I made.. when i read the question with little boy watch natural child birth. I would never let mine see me down there.. but I mayhave down it like motherofthreeatascoita .. when I had my youngest the hospital said they were not aloud in the room at all not even during the labor part. When I had my oldest dd I was 17 and my sister was like 15 my mo did ask if sister could be in the room to see the labor and such, just in hopes she would maybe think twice about sex.. It must of worked she had my niece when she was in her early early 20's 

momofthreeatascosita --- 19 years ago -

It was not your comment MommyL it was where's my list "I can't believe the mentality of some people" comment...... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground