Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can Iraq sustain a democracy?

who's talking here?

JDB2 4
KatieR 4
RRay 1
bbjones 11
planemom 1
Justwatching72 1
Anderson 2
jimmy 1
NoNameNoLastName 10
robbie 8
caitlin 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

After our troops leave Iraq, can it maintain a democracy? 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

only if it wants to.. ....keep in mind, we may not live long enough to see the end result....life isn't a "microwave". 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

OK, I'll rephrase - do you think Iraq will be a democracy once our troops leave? I'm talking about immediate future, not 50 years from now. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Not in the immediate future. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

"I'm talking about immediate future" Nope....something that big can't be immediate. The generation needs to flip at least once.....gotta let the "old school" of thinking die out or age....and educate and train the "new school" of thinking. 

jimmy --- 19 years ago -

No! As soon as we leave, Iraq will desend into wide open civil war, worse that now. Iran is going to take over Iraq. I think they are behind a lot of the bombings and attacks, etc that is going on now. Anderson is right, the current crop of leaders, Saddam's cronies and enemies need to age, die off, etc. They all remember and practice the "old ways". there is also way too much tribal warfare, revenge killings, honor killings, etc. I just hope we are not there when it gets real bad. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I think they are behind a lot of the bombings and attacks, etc that is going on now. Well yeah BAGHDAD, Aug. 14 -- Through proxies, Iran is giving weapons, bomb technology and training to Shiite Muslim militias in Iraq, U.S. military officials said Monday. "We do know that Shia extremist groups have received training through some sort of third element associated with Iran," said Maj. Gen. William B. Caldwell, a U.S. military spokesman. "We do know that weapons have been provided." yet we will do anything with Iran? No..why? because this war with iraq has pretty much screwed the governments chances of starting another war with the american people behind them. Hezbollah is training iraqi insurgents... I can venture a wager at what is going to happen.. First off GW made a statement a while ago about pulling out of Iraq.. something to the effect of 'We will not pull out until it is over and done, pulling out before that will be a sign of defeat for america. yet today after his meeting with the PM of Iraq bush says, well we are going to stay until the job is done ' or when the iraqi government wants us to leave' Here is what I think might happen. We end up pulling out because miraculously the attacks have dropped off enough that the iraq military can handle it. we leave, it all goes to hell. then when 2008 rolls around the repubs are in a position to say, well see we pulled out like the house majority anted and it al went to hell. I dunno, i'm not too happy with either of them so who the hell knows.. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I heard a couple of suggestions to work around the problem: 1) Install a "friendly" dictator there, who will have better chances to manage the conflict. It won't be the first time we do that... 2) Break Iraq into 3 different countries - Kurd, Shi'ite, and Sunni. However, the guy who suggested it never said what to do with Bagdad... But I agree with you - W is playing the game of "I don't want to leave until the job is done", so he and the republicans can "I told you so" the democrats in the 2008 election. The sad thing is that meanwhile, our troops continue to die there for no clear objective. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Anderson, I find it funny how you defend "educate and train" in certain situations, but when it comes to abortion, you seem to think that this is not the solution... Also, why did you lock the other thread? Common Sense had some good points, and bbjones twisted my points one more time, and I couldn't answer... 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

After our troops leave Iraq, can it maintain a democracy?  Did someone think the democracy is being maintained with our troops there now? I sure don't see it. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Hey, that's what the white house says... If you ask me, "civil war" is a better way to describe what is going on there. 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

Watch this Video - NBC calls it Civil War the White House not in so many words. Lauer-Certified civil War - Watch what Tony Snow calls it, to funny 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

Here is my take. Now my view is jaded as I have worked amoungst these moronic camel jockeys when I was overseas as a young un... These sumbitches only know one thing. Kill each other. They have been doing it for centuries, and will continue to do so after we leave. ..Any other thoughts differing on this one......lemme know. I still have a lot in New Oreans that dont flood.....(much) 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

KatieR, great video, thanks for sharing! 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

Here's what I think, Iraq will not sustain a democracy because they do not have a democratic way of thinking. They love killing each other in the name of Allah. We had no business going over there and have harmed our countries credibility amongst other countries. Now that we're over there, I support our troops. Just not the idiot that sent them to war. He made a mockery of this country and will some day have to reap what he's sewn. He's and idiot and so is anyone else who believes in him. JMO 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

It is a shame that people, who obviously do not have the level of education earned by President Bush, continually call him an idiot. People do not reap what they have sewn, eventhough they might reap what they sow. We had no business going over there and have harmed our countries credibility amongst other countries. Who are you kidding? The US did not have any credibility with other countries before the Iraq War, so how could they lose something they did not have? Now that we're over there, I support our troops. Does that mean that you did not support our military before they went to Iraq? 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

Now that we're over there, I support our troops. Does that mean that you did not support our military before they went to Iraq? Oh, I'm sorry should I have explained this slower? I am saying I support our troops but I never supported the idea of going to war with this country. Is that clear enough? I'm sure you don't have the high quality of education as Bush, either. I just have common sense and college behind me. Something I'm not so sure of others having. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I just have common sense and college behind me. It must be FAR behind you. Well, someone with a college education should know that you cannot explain something in writing slower. I am saying I support our troops but I never supported the idea of going to war with this country. Is that clear enough? That is not what you said. You said "Now that we're over there, I support our troops." That implies no support before they went "over there". Are you a little weak in English comprehension? I'm sure you don't have the high quality of education as Bush, either. I do not have an MBA, but then again I am not the one calling him an idiot. 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

People do not reap what they have sewn, eventhough they might reap what they sow. Yes that's a typo. You make them too. Here's yours. definition of an idiot is someone who disregards the fasts I guess that makes us even. No wait you had two typos to my one. Fasts and eventhough 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

Wow, while I do like debates, I hope everyone knows each have their own opinions, lets keep that in mind. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Yours was not a typo. You used the wrong word completely. 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

Sorry it was a typo just like yours. But that's for another debate. You clearly have nothing to argue about. So go research it and get back to me. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Sorry it was a typo just like yours. I missed one letter of a word and you used the wrong homophone. So go research it and get back to me. If reading liberal diatribes and believing their conspiracy theories is your definition of research - no thank you. 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

No, actually I meant to go research anything that would prove Bush to be worthy of my support. Am I to assume you haven't found anything yet? If reading liberal diatribes and believing their conspiracy theories is your definition of research - no thank you. You might want to research some views other than Republican propaganda. Get a independents factual article. You might be surprised at what you find. Democrats have always been better for our economy, overall. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

No, actually I meant to go research anything that would prove Bush to be worthy of my support. Am I to assume you haven't found anything yet? You did not say that. If you want to get a point across you must be clear and concise in your writings. Democrats have always been better for our economy, overall. What a joke. It has been proven time and time again that cuts in the tax rate generate the best economies. The ONLY Democratic administration to do that was JFK's. You might want to research some views other than Republican propaganda. Get a independent factual article. I already gave you one independent factual source - "Liberalism is a Mental Disorder" 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

I already gave you one independent factual source - "Liberalism is a Mental Disorder" I have to say I'm disappointed in you. I have been told that you were very intelligent. Like I said find some facts. I have to put my babies to sleep. I'll be back in a little while to continue. 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

BB, may I ask you a question? I see from reading your posts that you are a tried and true republican but why do you really hate people who are as strong in their beliefs about democrats as you are about your beliefs. Isn't everyone entitled to have an opinion, even if it doesn't agree with yours? I was just wondering, so attack away if you feel threatened, but I am only asking. 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

I would like to ask republican lovers why we went to war with Iraq who wasn't outright threatening us, but yet we left N. Korea alone? The admittedly said they were building nukes. And our intelligence knew this. I'm sorry but common sense would have told me that N. Korea would have been the imminent threat, not Iraq. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

we've left North Korea alone basically since the 50's. This same intelligence that you think should take us to NK is the intelligence that took us to Iraq and the same intelligence that your leaders believed for the past 10+ years. You guys keep picking and choosing what suits your argument de jeur rather than sticking with facts. One of your cohorts suggested that we should be doing something about Iran. How loudly are you guys going to complain when Bush does do something about those crazies? 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

and there is nothing independent in any of your posts. 

robbie --- 19 years ago -

Did you miss my point? 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

Your points are so extremely dull that they are not recognizable.... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Isn't everyone entitled to have an opinion, even if it doesn't agree with yours? I was just wondering, so attack away if you feel threatened, but I am only asking. Caitlin, I am not attacking anyone. I am just defending myself from robbie who called me an idiot. I also do not like people calling our President an idiot. I do not mind if someone has an opinion, if they can back it up with facts - not lies. why do you really hate people who are as strong in their beliefs about democrats as you are about your beliefs. I do not hate anyone. I hate evil and the Democrat Party has a platform of evil that is anchored by their commitment to murder babies. The Democrat Party used to protect human life, but now the secular progressives have taken over the party and are ruining our country. 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

It's ok bb, I think I understand your point of view. I just don't understand why two people cannot have an opinion totally different from each other and the only thing they do is argue to get their point across but never trying to understand the other person's opinion at all. Logic totally escapes any reasoning here. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I just don't understand why two people cannot have an opinion totally different from each other and the only thing they do is argue to get their point across but never trying to understand the other person's opinion at all. It is because opinions come from two sources for most topics - truth and untruth. What is the purpose of trying to understand opinions based on untruths? 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

nite bb, I'm out of this one but I will say a very big prayer for you 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Here is how Republicans are good for our contry -> http://www.uuforum.org/deficit.htm http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/graphic/2006/01/27/GR2006012700168.html So much for fiscal responsibility and small government. Let's look at some hard data (from the census bureau): * The top 5 highest murder rates per 100,000 in America? Louisiana (17.5), Mississippi (11.1), Alabama (10.4), Tennessee (9.5) and South Carolina (9.0). * 9 of the 10 lowest divorce rates are in blue states, especially in the Northeast. Lowest divorce rate? Massachusetts. Ha. * 6 of the 10 states with the lowest rates of teen pregnancy are blue states; 7 of the 10 states with the highest rates are red states. Our Texas, by the way, is one of only 5 states with a rate above 100 per 100,000 in population (3 of which are red states). And from the Tax Foundation: * Of all the states that receive more federal money than they pay in Federal taxes, 76% of them (25 of 32) are red states. And of the 10 states that pay the most in Federal taxes and get the least in return, 7 are blue states. But perhaps the US census bureau is not a reliable source of information. So please enlighten us, bbjones, what are your sources for truth? Fair and balanced "Faux" news? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The top 5 highest murder rates per 100,000 in America? Louisiana (17.5), Mississippi (11.1), Alabama (10.4), Tennessee (9.5) and South Carolina (9.0). Every one of those just recently became red states. they were mired in Democrat rule for at least 40 years prior to that. 9 of the 10 lowest divorce rates are in blue states, especially in the Northeast. Lowest divorce rate? Massachusetts. Ha. It is hard to get divorced when you never get married in the first place. In these bastions of liberalism, people "shack up" and do not get married. This is also where the highest concentration of homosexuals are located. I could go on, but there is no sense to it. Every state has a large contingency of liberals who dramatically affect those numbers. Try again! 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

I hate evil and the Democrat Party Someone who claims to be such an expert on bible as you do should know to hate an entire group of people is wrong. Their is a lot about both parties that make me sick, but I don't ever hate anyone 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

1. OK, so show me the relative position of the true, untainted republican states in the overall picture when it comes to crime, divorce, teen pregnancy, abortion, and overall wealth. I think you will find that liberal states are in much better shape than conservative states. 2. Do you know the difference between rates and absolute numbers? Or you just pretend you don't to make your point? 3. "Divorce rate" implies that a marriage took place first. I don't think you can get a divorce if you are not married. 4. You forgot to mention what your reliable sources of information are, where you get the absolute truth... 5. KatieR is absolutely right, you seem to be filled with hatred toward people who think differently from you. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground