Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Weaning advise...

who's talking here?

mugglemom 2
Tammy Clark 1
Punkalicious 2
Unichic 5
Momoftwo 2
MomofTwins 1
Denise C 4
sarah 3
I Love Horses 1
H and J 1
HIAAK 2
karenact 2
Sheri 9
crazyfun2baround 2
Sandyr9111 2
BluYonderRose 1
Just Tiffany 2
mdawg 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

My son just turned a year old and I wanted to begin to wean him. I feel like it's going to be impossible!! I work during the day and he is fine when he is with anyone else, but as soon as I get home he is a instant whiner and constantly yanks at my shirt trying to get "the goods". I think I've created a monster, he has a hard time going to sleep without "the goods" and most of the time during the day my husband has to drive him around to get him to take a nap. Any suggestions? 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Are you trying to wean him to a bottle?? 

mugglemom --- 20 years ago -

 

Tammy Clark --- 20 years ago -

Just tell him it is all gone and offer something eles. Don't go back even one time he will give up and take the bottle or cup. Be firm. You will not be mean and don't feel bad. What ever you change to make sure everyone uses the same thing. Good luck! 

Sandyr9111 --- 20 years ago -

I agree with Tammy. 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

He actually has no problem taking a bottle. It's just when he is tired and I'm around he will get extremely upset if he doesn't get "the goods". I really feel like a human pacifer at times. We've tried to give him pacifers and it doesn't work...he never really liked them. As sick as this may sound, sometimes when he is real upset, he'll just nurse for less than a minute and he'll jump up and be good to go. 

mugglemom --- 20 years ago -

He's just going to have to find another soother. Maybe get a new blankie, new pacifer, new bottle, new toy, etc. And once you decide to stop, don't go back! You'll have to stay firm or he'll learn that you'll give in. 

Punkalicious --- 20 years ago -

My first kiddo got off the boob at 11 months, my second was like 19 months...i always thought i would ween him at a year too, but he just wasnt ready...at 18 months he just totally stopped himself. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

First was 2 1/2 and the second...I think maybe 4...lol 

sarah --- 20 years ago -

Sheri, I am there with you! Mine is 17mo and is the same way. He can even go all weekend to his dad's and be fine. But if I am home forget it. It is mainly only now when he is tired, cranky and especially bedtime. I am hoping he will just wean himself soon. 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

Maybe I should wait and see if he'll eventually wean himself. I have been VERY lucky and I haven't had any problems so far, I was just hoping to have my body back for a little while before we decide to have another baby...selfish reasons I guess. He has his one year exam this afternoon so I will see what Dr Barnhart says...he is AWESOME! (sorry had to say that) He'll probably tell me to keep nursing. Thanks guys for the advise! 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

Sarah, It's good to hear I'm not the only one! It is exhausting at times, isn't it? 

crazyfun2baround --- 20 years ago -

Sheri-I did not wean straight to a bottle. I was told that would confuse my little one. I made a BIG production about buying her sippy cups for big girls. When she tried to get "the goods" I got her sippy cup then held her really close to me. I had to explain over and over that big girls drank from sippy cups. It didn't happen over night. However, it did work. Whatever you decide is right for you and your little one, is your decision. Don't let anyone tell you differently! Good luck! 

Punkalicious --- 20 years ago -

It is exhausting at times, isn't it? i know you were talking to sarah, but of course i have to chime in..it was never exhausting for me...since it is for you, maybe you should just tell him its all gone, or tell him you put it in the milk jug :-) 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

LOL Jessica...maybe I should tell him that! My son is very demanding for a 1 year old. I guess I'm a push over...I just need to show him who's boss :) It's just exhausting for me when I'm trying to get things done around the house, I've been working all day and he just wants me to be his pacifer. It is normally pretty relaxing. 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

I know this is going to sound so matter of fact, but just stop giving him the goods. It sounds like you are also having a hard time stopping it because if you weren't you'd just stop. I know, I have been there. If you just softly and nicely say "no more....", then after about a week or two, he will get the hint. Instead, replace that special time with maybe a little nighttime puppet play or a special book etc...I would also stop driving him around and let him fall asleep on his own before you cause him problems later in life with falling alseep on his own. I read a whole article on this about three years ago. I will see if I can find it. I was probably an army sergent when it came to that with my second child because I saw the angst it caused me and my first child when I did not let him cry it out. I was utterly exhausted. Good luck! 

sarah --- 20 years ago -

Yes sheri it can be exhausting at times. I have two teens and the baby. My oldest was not one that would cry it out, he never stopped. The middle no problem she learned very quickly. This last one is the same as my oldest. He doesn't stop crying. He eventually will vomit. To me that was very upsetting and did not seem soothing to let this go on. So we are still nursing to sleep most every night. During the day I usually can distract him with a cup or a bottle if necessary. I guess I am a pushover. He is probably my last and it's really hard to be mean :) The nursing/human pacifier has decreased significantly over the last few months so I am hoping we are on our way to self weaning. Hang in there. I agree with crazycmmom don't listen to any advice you are not comfortable with. 

H and J --- 20 years ago -

Boy do I have experience with this one!! My daughter REFUSED to wean - I tried to wean her from 18 - 24 months months and was exhausted. She also wanted to nurse all night and needed to nurse to get to sleep for naps. Finally - and I think I read it on here - I put bandaids on each nipple and told her they were broken. She accepted this since there was an actual reason she could not nurse - and her feelings were not hurt; before this she would get so sad and angry when I would say no. It actually worked - she still asks occasionally but we talk about how they are broken and she says "otay". She still likes that liquid full feeling and drinks alot of Pedisure but that is better then nursing a 2 1/2 year old!!! Hope this helps!! 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

H and J, that is a great idea! I literally had to let my child starve (rapid weaning really). I know this sounds really horrible, but she was starving anyway and went from the 75% percentile into the 25% ( I had no idea that I had little milk). I had to stop breastfeeding and she was certainly my booby girl. She refused to drink and eat anything for almost two weeks, just sips and snacks here and there - she is STUBBORN and still is lol. Listen, no one has to listen to my advice. SHe asked and I told her my advice. You can keep on the way it is until they get large enough that they will stop needing to be driven to sleep and breastfed if that is OKAY with you. I personally wanted something to change because I was very exhausted and also discovered that I had a raging thyroid problem. I NEEDED to get my life under control (with a newborn and a 1 1/2 year old). I dont't think she would be coming on here and asking though is she didn't want change :). 

Momoftwo --- 20 years ago -

I have a 20 month old that loves to nurse :) Just like my first, and she nursed for 29 months, lol. Both of mine were just like you are describing...nursers for comfort. I too, work outside of the house and my son is ready for me as soon as I walk in the door. He assumes the position, hehe. I have gone away for a week at a time a couple of times and he doesn't forget. I am okay with it though. I will tell you, for my dd, I had to gently put pressure on her to wean. I was pg with my second and she was 2.5, so she was old enough to understand more of what I was telling her. I would set limits....say, you can only nurse til I count to 20. She was fine wiht that and eventually just quit asking. Now, if I had to wean my son today...wow! He will not go to sleep for me without nursing. I am a softy though and love nursing, so I am sticking it out awhile longer. With that, I am not sure I am much help. Just set limits and try to gradually wean. I think for kids that are so attached to the soothing of nursing, it's hard to stop cold turkey. Maybe set a time on how long you nurse. 2 minutes, maybe then start decreasing it until he is okay with going to sleep without it. I don't know :) I do have a good book called "How Weaning Happens". You could try the local library, maybe it would have some good tips. 

HIAAK --- 20 years ago -

Sheri I'm curious to hear what your pediatrician has to say about this. My daughter is 12 1/2 months and we are doing the same thing. We are only down to a night nursing. all day long she could care less but at night she really gives me a time. Ha I really cracked up about "the goods". I can totally relate to you about a human pacifier and how at times they just nurse for about a minute and then good to go. :) I'm off to find the Gerber gentleflex pacifier today. She really hasn't taken to a pacifier. For a few short months she did and that was it. I'm hoping this one will work :) 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

Thanks for all of your advise! It is very good to hear that I'm not the only one going through this. My husband jokes around saying "I could just see him now, yelling hey mom give me some boob, as he's walking through the door from school". All I can do is laugh about it. Hopefully he will wean himself! I'll just have to find an alternative night time fix. 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

I'll be sure to let you know what Dr Barnhart says this afternoon. 

Momoftwo --- 20 years ago -

lol. I can only imagine Dr. Barnhart's advice. I love him, he's great! But, I remember talking about this with him. He told me to put my dd in the crib, tell her night night and walk out. If she cried (which you KNOW she did), to go in and gently tell her night night, rub her back, until she calmed down, but to NOT remove her from the crib. Okay, so that SOUNDS well and fine, but it did NOT go over well with my dd. Lots of screaming, crying, non-stop. I honestly don't think my kids know how to give up and go to sleep if they are set on something. :) Good luck today. I hope you find something that works. 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Crying it out does work, but you have to be able to NOT cave. It's hard! Everytime you cave, you re-inforce to your child that if I push the limits more and more each time, eventually Mommy will cave (if I cry, then have a caniption, then spit, then vomit etc...). Like Dr. Phil says, they just keep upping the price of poker :). 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

It is going to be VERY hard, but if I want to wean I'm going to have to suck it up! I've got another problem...he sleeps with us. I know this is bad! It is not my babys fault he is the way he is...it's all he's known. It is going to take A LOT of work to get him out of our bed and weaned. I just want to thank you guys again for all of the advise given!! 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

SHeri, I feel for you. What you could try is a little bed on the floor next to your bed. Maybe gradually moving it closer to the door and then outside the door and then in his own room. I know you have done it because you just love and care for him a lot. My husband had to tell me straight to my face that he needed more from me and that he was feeling left out. I quickly ppaid attention. You'll do just fine!! 

Sandyr9111 --- 20 years ago -

I could just see him now, yelling hey mom give me some boob, as he's walking through the door from school". OMG reminds me of the story Denise C told about her daughter and the "ninny milk tasting bad" LMAO 

I Love Horses --- 20 years ago -

I told my 2 year old i had bobo's on them and i put bandaids over them, he cried but was resolved to the fact he couldnt nurse 

sarah --- 20 years ago -

oh my goodness! I did not mean to step on anyone's toes when I said don't listen to anyone's advice you are not comfortable with. I only meant just do what you think will work best for your family and your body. I have tried some of the advice on KU and has worked very well for my children. So sorry if I came across wrong. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

dR. bARNHART TOLD ME TO GO AWAY BY MYSELF FOR 4 OR 5 DAYS ! Lol I DID 9/1 AND AFTER 5 DAYS AWAY THE FIRST THING THE LITTLE GUY DID WAS TUG ON MY BLOUSE!!!! i FEEL YOUR PAIN SHERRI! 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

Ack sorry for the caps! I accidently hit caps lock. 

Denise C --- 20 years ago -

OMG reminds me of the story Denise C told about her daughter and the "ninny milk tasting bad" LMAO You know what's funny...both these kiddos are so embarrassed when I told them they were always sucking those things. I'm for whatever works for whoever. What may be right for one, may be wrong for another :) 

Sheri --- 20 years ago -

LOL...I just got back from Dr. Barnharts office and he told me to go away for a few days and don't give in when I get back! Hey...I guess I'll give it a try, I wouldn't mind getting away for a few days! :) 

BluYonderRose --- 20 years ago -

I had a wise doctor who gave me the absolute key to this -- does anyone want to know? You have to be "ready" to hear this or it won't make sense. 

Just Tiffany --- 20 years ago -

I nursed my dd for 18 months and she stopped on her own. 

HIAAK --- 20 years ago -

I had a wise doctor who gave me the absolute key to this -- does anyone want to know? You have to be "ready" to hear this or it won't make sense. Do tell Nanna :) My 9 year old stopped when she was 10 months. My 12 1/2 month old shows no signs of wanting to stop :( 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Sarah, sent you a PM! 

mdawg --- 20 years ago -

I'm curious, being that my child is in elementry school now and I did not nurse her. We have a program that is held every day at various schools. There is a parent with in the group who whips her goods out in front of everyone and she nurses a 3 year old. The way she goes about it....is very alarming and some of the dads are embarrassed because the child is older not a baby. Is this appropriate? Are we being squeamish? Is there are an age when nursing is just not appropriate? We are in fit about what to do and I figured maybe someone would have some insight here! Thanks 

Just Tiffany --- 20 years ago -

I think 3 is a little too old to be nursing. That is my opinion. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground