Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Would you charge your child interest on a loan from you?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Warren Peace 3
SueRDH 1
genxer 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
AlphabetSoup 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
steinhoister2016 1
Ava 2
Dorothy Parker 8
Emperor of Kingwood 5
a889324uu 3
Not KU 1
Leila 2
mutton 3
Eclipse 3
logic 1
TruBluTexan 1
ugly yapper dog 3
Proud American 1
fuzz81 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Would you charge your child interest on a loan from you?

Bob's thread has me curious. If you were in a position to loan your child a large sum of money, would you charge them interest on it? If so, why?

Yes, I would. A bank would charge them interest, why should a loan from me be any different? Vote
 
 44.1% (15)
No, I wouldn't. Having them pay me back is good enough for me. Vote
 
 55.9% (19)
Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Bob's thread has me curious.

If you were in a position to loan your child a large sum of money, would you charge them interest on it? If so, why? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -

Yes, because it is a large sum of money that I would be actually losing money on to loan it to them in the first place. That doesn't mean I wouldn't maybe secretly set aside some of it to gift back to them at a later date or when they could then maybe qualify for a conventional loan at a lower rate. There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free. 

whatchamacallit --- 11 years ago -

Lucky girl --- 9 sec ago - quote - hide comments
Yes, because it is a large sum of money that I would be actually losing money on to loan it to them in the first place. That doesn't mean I wouldn't maybe secretly set aside some of it to gift back to them at a later date or when they could then maybe qualify for a conventional loan at a lower rate. There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free.?




This^ 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

No.

I recently gave my son a loan for some expensive speakers ($1500+) for his car (I advised him against getting them) but didn't charge him interest. I gave him 12 months to pay me back, and he paid it back in 4.

Years ago, I borrowed a significant amount of money from my dad for a show horse and we agreed to monthly payments. I intended to have him paid off within the year, but 6 months into it, he sent me a Mother's Day card telling him his gift to me was considering the loan paid in full.

But, my dad and I are both bleeding heart liberals that believe in equality, helping our fellow man, being kind and compassionate to those less fortunate than us, so I'm sure that's the problem right there.

If we were conservatives, I'm sure we'd charge interest LOL! 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

And tax 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free.?


If they're paying it back to you, it wasn't free.

How does interest teach someone a lesson? 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

And tax?

And we might remind them daily how awful they are to have to ask for the money/loan in the first place!! HAHA

But seriously, there are lots of lessons in life. Charging interest to your child doesn't have to be one of them. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -

There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free.?


If they're paying it back to you, it wasn't free.

How does interest teach someone a lesson?


Why would they accept a loan from me at a high interest rate to begin with? They are either trying to live beyond their means or they have already been irresponsible. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

I don't understand how it is a lesson...you're giving your child a penalty for asking for your help. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Why would they accept a loan from me at a high interest rate to begin with? They are either trying to live beyond their means or they have already been irresponsible.?


So, what you're saying is, your child knows better than to ask you for help, because if they do, you will punish them for it and think they're irresponsible.

Good parenting! 

steinhoister2016 --- 11 years ago -

If the money came from my business account I would have to but from my personal account, no... 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

no 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

Would never charge ANY family member interest... 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Yes, because it is a large sum of money that I would be actually losing money on to loan it to them in the first place. That doesn't mean I wouldn't maybe secretly set aside some of it to gift back to them at a later date or when they could then maybe qualify for a conventional loan at a lower rate. There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free.

Yes, exactly 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

You're not likely going to make 8.5% on that money Emp lol still ripping off your daughter 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

You're not likely going to make 8.5% on that money

Correct. It was making more than that. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

In what? 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

Yes, because it is a large sum of money that I would be actually losing money on to loan it to them in the first place. That doesn't mean I wouldn't maybe secretly set aside some of it to gift back to them at a later date or when they could then maybe qualify for a conventional loan at a lower rate. There is no lesson in responsibility to give it to them for free.

Yes, exactly


Everyone is in agreement that being able to help our children with a loan is a blessing.

What got everyone's attention is the interest rate on a home loan when the lending institution rates are currently between 3% and 4%, provided that person qualifies for a loan. 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

Correct. It was making more than that

Can I get the name of your Financial Advisor? I need to fire mine ... 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

You're not likely going to make 8.5% on that money

Correct. It was making more than that.?



Wow...I don't even know what to say to that.

You do realize the average interest rate is between 3% & 4%, right?

So, why would you set it so high on your own kid? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Can I get the name of your Financial Advisor? I need to fire mine ...

One of the things I do is Lending Club. For the past few years, I've been underwriting loans through them. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Only place I've seen where you can reliably get close to those kinds of returns are peer to peer lending like lending club. Savings interest is barely on par with inflation. Stock markets can give you large gains, but a diversified portfolio will have just as many with equal losses lol you haven't "made more than 8.5%" until you cash out, it's gambling 

SueRDH --- 11 years ago -

How does interest teach someone a lesson?

The lesson is to save up enough to pay cash without having to ask for help next time. It doesn't have to be a huge amount of interest. And if I were to ask for help from a family member, I would offer up front to pay interest, especially if it is a large amount of money. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Emp, it wasn't allowed to underwrite loans through LC as a Texas resident until a few weeks ago 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Emp, it wasn't allowed to underwrite loans through LC as a Texas resident until a few weeks ago

That's correct, but what you could do is buy shares of already funded loans from other members, which I did. Now that Texas allows original funding through them I have switched to almost exclusively doing that. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Cool, I'm an investor in lending club (the company) so thanks for making me money ;) 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I've had about 3 loans I bought from others go bad which has pulled the overall ROI down a few points. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -

Why would they accept a loan from me at a high interest rate to begin with? They are either trying to live beyond their means or they have already been irresponsible.?


So, what you're saying is, your child knows better than to ask you for help, because if they do, you will punish them for it and think they're irresponsible.

Good parenting!


Lol, what about the parents that don't have the money to give their kids interest free loans? I guess that makes them bad parents as well because they should have planned for it and made sure they were financially able to give their children interest free loans for their wants.

Should a parent that doesn't have the money but can get a loan for the money then do so and give that money to their child and pay the interest on the loan back themselves?

Should a parent that has money in an investment account making 8% take it out and give it to their kid and lose out on the interest for the life of the loan?

I'll buy my kids car, pay 100% of their college and be there for any emergency but interest free
mortgages or neither emergencies nor life threatening and are not a part of the deal. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

If a parent doesn't have the money to lend, they shouldn't be lending it. Otherwise they can cosign a loan so the kid is fully responsible for P&I with the parents assets as collateral. If you don't think your kid is stable enough to reliably pay that back, don't cosign a loan. Pretty simple, and best life lesson is that money doesn't come on a silver platter. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Fuzz summed it up beautifully.

If you don't have the money to loan, you don't loan it. That seems simple enough.

If you have enough money to front a mortgage, you don't really need to make a profit off loaning it to your kid. If you feel you do need to make a profit off of it, maybe rethink loaning it to them in the first place and invest that money elsewhere. 

Ava --- 11 years ago -

I paid interest when I borrowed money from my parents. I would have paid interest to a bank so why not my parents? I learned about the cost of borrowing, making payments on time, amortization schedules, etc. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Because you were unable to qualify for a conventional loan, or because your parents were able to afford to do so and trusted you? There's a difference. 

logic --- 11 years ago -

I paid interest when I borrowed money from my parents. I would have paid interest to a bank so why not my parents? I learned about the cost of borrowing, making payments on time, amortization schedules, etc.

Very responsible. 

Ava --- 11 years ago -

My parents loaned me money to buy some land and a used car. I paid them back with interest and was thankful. They were not rich but very frugal with money. I learned so much from them. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

We all have our own approach to the money and lending. To each his own... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 11 years ago -


If you have enough money to front a mortgage, you don't really need to make a profit off loaning it to your kid. If you feel you do need to make a profit off of it, maybe rethink loaning it to them in the first place and invest that money elsewhere.


It's not making a profit if you are recouping lost investment income.

Wealthy people really can't win. If you get a loan from your parents with no interest you're born with a silver spoon in your mouth, if your parents charge you interest they are bad parents.

People that can't afford to loan their child money get a pass. LOL

How about people do what works for them and chose their own methods of raising their kids as long as it doesn't include abuse and everyone else saves the judgmental attitude for something bigger. 

Leila --- 11 years ago -

How about people do what works for them and chose their own methods of raising their kids as long as it doesn't include abuse and everyone else saves the judgmental attitude for something bigger.

I completely agree with that! There are also situations where some kids have not been responsible with money, or have a spouse that might misuse funds or tons of individual reasons why lending money to family needs to be tied to interest or even avoided altogether.

Judging someone on their attitude with their money and their adult kids without knowing all of the background is pointless. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

Recouping what lost investment income? You haven't made anything and could stand to loose it all lol .. It's gambling.

Expecting family to repay in the case of someone who can't qualify for a loan is just as unlikely to pay you back, and it's going to be contentious.. What are you going to do, take their house? 

genxer --- 11 years ago -

I Didn't vote because my answer isn't there.
Yes i would charge interest but then put that money in an account for the kid for a later date. 

fuzz81 --- 11 years ago -

If I had a kid, I would buy him a broken car and let him use my tools. You wanna drive? Fix it yourself. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground