Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Research Shows WHITE PRIVILEGE IS REAL

who's talking here?

JHMO 1
SoupIsGoodFood 15
Red Heifer 1
Hiro Protagonist 5
AwesomeTattooedDragon 10
Work in Progress 14
Joe Blow 13
Emperor of Kingwood 7
a889324uu 3
Prolix Raconteur 4
mutton 1
jacobson 2
them 2
aragon 1
logic 1
alldayredux 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Written by a Law Professor at Yale



When Whites Get a Free Pass



NEW HAVEN ? THE recent reunion show for the 40th anniversary of ?Saturday Night Live? re-aired a portion of Eddie Murphy?s 1984 classic ?White Like Me? skit, in which he disguised himself to appear Caucasian and quickly learned that ?when white people are alone, they give things to each other for free.?

The joke still has relevance. A field experiment about who gets free bus rides in Brisbane, a city on the eastern coast of Australia, shows that even today, whites get special privileges, particularly when other people aren?t around to notice.

As they describe in two working papers, Redzo Mujcic and Paul Frijters, economists at the University of Queensland, trained and assigned 29 young adult testers (from both genders and different ethnic groups) to board public buses in Brisbane and insert an empty fare card into the bus scanner. After the scanner made a loud sound informing the driver that the card did not have enough value, the testers said, ?I do not have any money, but I need to get to? a station about 1.2 miles away. (The station varied according to where the testers boarded.)

With more than 1,500 observations, the study uncovered substantial, statistically significant race discrimination. Bus drivers were twice as willing to let white testers ride free as black testers (72 percent versus 36 percent of the time). Bus drivers showed some relative favoritism toward testers who shared their own race, but even black drivers still favored white testers over black testers (allowing free rides 83 percent versus 68 percent of the time).

The study also found that racial disparities persisted when the testers wore business attire or dressed in army uniforms. For example, testers wearing army uniforms were allowed to ride free 97 percent of the time if they were white, but only 77 percent of the time if they were black.

This elegant experiment follows in a tradition of audit testing, in which social scientists have sent testers of different races to, for example, bargain over the price of new cars or old baseball cards. But the Australian study is the first, to my knowledge, to focus on discretionary accommodations. It?s less likely these days to find people in positions of authority, even at lower levels of decision making, consciously denying minorities rights. But it is easier to imagine decision makers, like the bus drivers, granting extra privileges and accommodations to nonminorities. Discriminatory gifts are more likely than discriminatory denials.

A police officer is an out-and-out bigot if she targets innocent blacks for speeding tickets. But an officer who is more likely to give a pass to white motorists who exceed the speed limit than to black ones is also discriminating, even if with little or no conscious awareness. This is one reason the Twitter hashtag #crimingwhilewhite is so powerful: It draws attention to the racially biased exercise of discretion by police officers, prosecutors and judges, which results in whites getting a pass for the kinds of offenses for which minorities are punished.

Racial discrimination is more likely in settings in which both decision makers and bystanders cannot easily observe how comparable nonminorities are treated. A restaurant is unlikely to charge Hispanics higher prices for a hamburger, because the victim could compare her bill to the price listed on the menu. But one-off accommodations where the decision maker retains substantial discretion don?t offer any easy point of comparison. My kids, who are white, have never been turned down when I asked if they could use a bathroom designated for ?employees only.? After reading the Australian bus study, I wonder whether the same is true for minority families.

The bus study underscores this point. Drivers were more likely to let testers ride free when there were fewer people on the bus to observe the transaction. And the drivers themselves were probably not aware that they were treating minorities differently. When drivers, in a questionnaire conducted after the field test, were shown photographs of the testers and asked how they would respond, hypothetically, to a free-ride request, they indicated no statistically significant bias against minorities in the photos (86 percent said they would let the black individual ride free).

Of course, unconscious bias might play out differently in the United States than in Australia. But research in America, too, suggests that decision makers use discretion to bestow benefits in a discriminatory fashion. For example, a recent study of 22 law firms by Arin N. Reeves, a lawyer and sociologist, found that partners were less critical of a junior lawyer?s draft memo if they were told the lawyer was white than if they were told the lawyer was black.

What does white privilege mean today? In part, it means to live in the world while being given the benefit of the doubt. Have you ever been able to return a sweater without a receipt? Has an employee ever let you into a store after closing time? Did a car dealership take a little extra off the sticker price when you asked? When?s the last time you received service with a smile?

White privilege doesn?t (usually) operate as brazenly and audaciously as in the Eddie Murphy joke, but it continues in the form of discretionary benefits, many of them unconscious ones. These privileges are hard to eradicate, but essential to understand. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Straight Talk for White Men


SUPERMARKET shoppers are more likely to buy French wine when French music is playing, and to buy German wine when they hear German music. That?s true even though only 14 percent of shoppers say they noticed the music, a study finds.

Researchers discovered that candidates for medical school interviewed on sunny days received much higher ratings than those interviewed on rainy days. Being interviewed on a rainy day was a setback equivalent to having an MCAT score 10 percent lower, according to a new book called ?Everyday Bias,? by Howard J. Ross.

Those studies are a reminder that we humans are perhaps less rational than we would like to think, and more prone to the buffeting of unconscious influences. That?s something for those of us who are white men to reflect on when we?re accused of ?privilege.?

Protesters face off with police outside the Ferguson Police Department on Monday, Nov. 24, 2014 in Ferguson, Mo.


White men sometimes feel besieged and baffled by these suggestions of systematic advantage. When I wrote a series last year, ?When Whites Just Don?t Get It,? the reaction from white men was often indignant: It?s an equal playing field now! Get off our case!

Yet the evidence is overwhelming that unconscious bias remains widespread in ways that systematically benefit both whites and men. So white men get a double dividend, a payoff from both racial and gender biases.

Consider a huge interactive exploration of 14 million reviews on RateMyProfessors.com that recently suggested that male professors are disproportionately likely to be described as a ?star? or ?genius.? Female professors are disproportionately described as ?nasty,? ?ugly,? ?bossy? or ?disorganized.?

One reaction from men was: Well, maybe women professors are more disorganized!

But researchers at North Carolina State conducted an experiment in which they asked students to rate teachers of an online course (the students never saw the teachers). To some of the students, a male teacher claimed to be female and vice versa.

When students were taking the class from someone they believed to be male, they rated the teacher more highly. The very same teacher, when believed to be female, was rated significantly lower.

Something similar happens with race.

Two scholars, Marianne Bertrand and Sendhil Mullainathan, sent out fictitious résumés in response to help-wanted ads. Each résumé was given a name that either sounded stereotypically African-American or one that sounded white, but the résumés were otherwise basically the same.

The study found that a résumé with a name like Emily or Greg received 50 percent more callbacks than the same résumé with a name like Lakisha or Jamal. Having a white-sounding name was as beneficial as eight years? work experience.

Then there was the study in which researchers asked professors to evaluate the summary of a supposed applicant for a post as laboratory manager, but, in some cases, the applicant was named John and in others Jennifer. Everything else was the same.

?John? was rated an average of 4.0 on a 7-point scale for competence, ?Jennifer? a 3.3. When asked to propose an annual starting salary for the applicant, the professors suggested on average a salary for ?John? almost $4,000 higher than for ?Jennifer.?





It?s not that we white men are intentionally doing anything wrong, but we do have a penchant for obliviousness about the way we are beneficiaries of systematic unfairness. Maybe that?s because in a race, it?s easy not to notice a tailwind, and white men often go through life with a tailwind, while women and people of color must push against a headwind.

While we don?t notice systematic unfairness, we do observe specific efforts to redress it ? such as affirmative action, which often strikes white men as profoundly unjust. Thus a majority of white Americans surveyed in a 2011 study said that there is now more racism against whites than against blacks.

None of these examples mean exactly that society is full of hard-core racists and misogynists. Eduardo Bonilla-Silva, a Duke University sociologist, aptly calls the present situation ?racism without racists?; it could equally be called ?misogyny without misogynists.? Of course, there are die-hard racists and misogynists out there, but the bigger problem seems to be well-meaning people who believe in equal rights yet make decisions that inadvertently transmit both racism and sexism.

So, come on, white men! Let?s just acknowledge that we?re all flawed, biased and sometimes irrational, and that we can do more to resist unconscious bias. That means trying not to hire people just because they look like us, avoiding telling a young girl she?s ?beautiful? while her brother is ?smart.? It means acknowledging systematic bias as a step toward correcting it. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Joe, if you keep talking about it, they might take all the free Bentleys away. (Insert gigantic eye roll here.) 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

I'll pass on that BS. Whiny, self-loathing, guilt besieged, apologist liberals can roll around in their self imposed angst all day for all I care. More opportunity for me. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

It's more fun not being a moderator. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

True "privilege" is being raised by two parents who give a crap about the kind of adult that you become, and don't allow you to wallow in the cesspool of blaming everyone but yourself for your own faults.

True privilege is being taught about self control and self responsibility. It is about being able to deal with the hand that you are dealt without wishing others to have less. It is about taking ownership of what you CAN change and then doing it, without whining that someone else should have do it for you.

That's privilege. And no, not everybody had that. But you CAN give it to your kids if you can learn it for yourself now. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

Duh. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Joey likes to cut and paste- he also likes gifs- and he likes to shock people with his language- perfectly normal behavior for boys his age. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Now let me tell you how much Tatty loves boys my age. She likes to play games with me. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

I do! I tell Joey to play in traffic, and he does! 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

perfectly normal behavior for boys his age.

About 12? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Exactly! His testicles should drop soon! 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

I'm sure he will let us know when that happens. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Somehow I think he'll keep that to himself! 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

TD, you have outdone yourself. I am now stalking your comments because I know that I will thoroughly enjoy them. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Thou shalt not masturbate. That means you also WIP. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Bwa ha ha, touche Joe. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Joey, I think that might actually be good for you! A good release for all that adolescent angst and anger! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Why thank you, Work! 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

You may not play with me as much as I would like but fear not. I have others. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Really, Joey, it won't make you blind- I promise! 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Joe has a sense of humor! I'm loving it! This turned out to be a fun thread. Thanks TD for lightening the mood. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

I aim to please! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

CONFEDERATES!!!!! 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

But then we got some douchey downers. See above. Take member in hand for some release, SoupFer Brains. 

JHMO --- 11 years ago -

Joe, I think it's funny that someone who is not white is speaking about the privilege of being so. 

them --- 11 years ago -

I'll go ahead and admit that Eddie Murphy for two things right in his comedy skit:

1.) when no black people are around, white people are always partying.

2.) when a black person leaves the room someone will say "what a silly negro".

Absurd, yes, but that's what the liberals want black Americans to believe. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Now, Joey, I know you're conflicted about masterbation, but don't take it out on soup- 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

But then we got some douchey downers. See above. Take member in hand for some release, SoupFer Brains.

Awwww...... You mad now, bro?

Go git dem Confederates!!!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Written by a Law Professor at Yale

Gotta love this. No name, no date....... nothing.

Might as well have said "written by a barrista @ Starbucks.

Dude..... you're really reaching with this one. 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Sorry you're so upset about it SoupFerBrains as can be seen in your normal whiney arse postings. LMFAO Cry me a river. Of Soup. LMFAO again! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Joey you need your fa to make poo poo. 

mutton --- 11 years ago -

What this about again? 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

I'll go ahead and admit that Eddie Murphy for two things right in his comedy skit:

1.) when no black people are around, white people are always partying.

2.) when a black person leaves the room someone will say "what a silly negro".

Absurd, yes, but that's what the liberals want black Americans to believe.?


I love how you think you speak for liberals. It's so cute!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Sorry you're so upset about it SoupFerBrains as can be seen in your normal whiney arse postings. LMFAO Cry me a river. Of Soup. LMFAO again!


Do not even notice that you're a joke with this constant "white hate" whiny posts you constantly make?

Find them confederates yet? 

Joe Blow --- 11 years ago -

Find them confederates yet?


Look in the mirror. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

The Native American Council has offered amnesty to 240 million undocumented illegal whites in America.

Line up. 

alldayredux --- 11 years ago -

The bias is often unconscious bias and the culprits are mostly the ilk you see complaining the most about sciencey facts.
High irony. 

them --- 11 years ago -

Nothing beats the soft bigotry of low expectations. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Look in the mirror.

Is that were you found them? 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground