Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

God is - Deus Est

who's talking here?

AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
Puss In Boots 1
Dorothy Parker 2
Texan65 1
The Day I Tried to Live 2
a889324uu 1
mutton 5
Commoner Sense 13
jacobson 13
AMDG 28
Wicked 1
satsuma 4
Squatchy 3
aragon 3
alldayredux 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

There has been a tone on the board from some, that it is in someway unthoughtful to believe that God exists. Well over the next 10 days, I will try to post one argument per day, that God is, that He exists, in Latin Deus Est.

What these arguments do, is with logic, show a very reasonable case that a being, like God, must exist. They are nondenominational they work for Christians, Jews, Muslims, even rational theists.

What they do not do, is attempt to show the fullness of God, or prove the God of the bible, they are very limited and just point to a tiny slice of what God is. But each argument alone, is sufficient, I think, to prove that God is, and in total make a compelling case.

Of course these are not new arguments, and there are counter arguments to all of them. I will be more than happy to discus and argue them on here, but I will not just fight.


So here goes - the first few are cosmological, meaning they are outside of us. They are first cause arguments. Before the first one here is some background or premiss. And some agreement on terms.

It goes this way. Every being that exists either exists by itself, by its own essence or nature, or it does not exist by itself.

If it exists by its own essence, then it exists necessarily and eternally, and explains itself. It cannot not exist, as a triangle cannot not have three sides.

If, on the other hand, a being exists but not by its own essence, then it needs a cause, a reason outside itself for its existence. Because it does not explain itself, something else must explain it. Beings whose essence does not contain the reason for their existence, beings that need causes, are called contingent, or dependent, beings.

A being whose essence is to exist is called a necessary being.

The universe contains only contingent beings. God would be the only necessary being- if God existed. Does he? Does a necessary being exist?

Dependent beings cannot cause themselves. They are dependent on their causes. If there is no independent being, then the whole chain of dependent beings is dependent on nothing and could not exist? But they do exist. Therefore there is an independent being.

Argument 1 St Thomas Aquinas' first mover

First, he argues that the chain of movers must have a first mover because nothing can move itself. (Moving here refers to any kind of change, not just change of place.) If the whole chain of moving things had no first mover, it could not now be moving, as it is. If there were an infinite regress of movers with no first mover, no motion could ever begin, and if it never began, it could not go on and exist now. But it does go on, it does exist now. Therefore it began, and therefore there is a first mover.

The first mover, the being who put all things in the universe in motion, is God. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

AMDG, I'm not saying it is unthoughtful to believe in God. As you know, I have stated many times on the board that there is no way to know whether or not God exists. The atheist who comes across with ironic sanctimony that they KNOW God doesn't exist is just as uninformed as a believer who states that they KNOW God does exist. No one KNOWS. That is a fact. Some believe, some do not believe.

For me, the unthoughtfullness (is that a word?!?!?!) comes from trying to align what is in the Bible with realities. Or taking what is written in the Bible and trying to excuse it away by saying non-believers just don't understand (slavery, weird laws, misogyny, etal). Or believers who argue about where the Bible comes from (we do know EXACTLY how and by whom the books that were chosen for the Bible were chosen).

There is a definitive requisite suspension of belief to believe a LOT of what is written in the Bible. I'm not saying that goes for belief in God. There are still questions that science does not have an answer for, and for many, it is not too illogical to assign those answers to God (what sparked the Big Bang, what first breathed life into the first cells). However, the God of the Gaps argument only sets one up for retreat as science fills those gaps.

And careful, Jacobson says that Aquinas was a moron. LOLOLOL. Jake, Aquinas was probably one of the most intelligent humans to ever live. The fact that you called him a moron is just absolutely adorable and priceless. So good. So good. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Thank you AMDG. I believe this should be interesting (and not saying this in a snarky tone!). May give us something to think on... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

You certainly write intelligently and thoughtfully- it must be difficult to intelligently argue with you- 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Think it was Augustine that he called a moron, not aquinas but give him time.

My argument above, is not a, if not science - God argument. It is not a, God as placeholder, until science explains it argument.

I admins that the current physics of creation, are completely beyond my understanding. But I do not think that the first law of motion has been denied yet.

Something, by its own, and of its own ability must start motion. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

Oh, Augustine, my bad....yeah, that dude was a total moron. LOL. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

Yes, I acknowledge that we do not know what first put things into motion. If one wants to assign that to God, then that is still open for discussion. However, what if we learn what did first put things into motion? If an argument for God's existence is based on something that can be disproven (another non-word???), then theoretically God is disproven. Science has been explaining that which man could only attribute to Gods for thousands of years. Something as simple as thunder was once an unknown and attributed by thousands of religions as God. Will our great great great great grandchildren say the same thing about something as complex to us as Aquinas' First Mover notion? 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

And to those like WIP that take offense to something like that...there is absolutely nothing offensive about asking questions such as those. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

CS - all your reasoning is doing is substituting one faith for another, one religion for another.

You have "faith" in science, you "believe" because of things you have seen science do, that it will be able to do more, but more than that, I think you "believe" it can answer everything.

You can not refute argument 1 with reason, you can not refute the premiss, or the facts. You just can't accept it.

Not to speak for you, but in general, the reason most who do not accept it, do not accept it, is down very deep, they just don't want to give up control.

To believe in science as a tool for finding facts, is perfectly reasonable, to believe in science as a tool for finding truth, not so much. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

My question is,

Why do you want to make the argument? Why do you care what anyone else believes?

I guess that's two questions....lol. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -


You certainly write intelligently and thoughtfully- it must be difficult to intelligently argue with you-


Think I plagiarize well, and these arguments are hundreds of years old. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Dorothy,

I am making the argument here for 2 main reasons. Firstly, there are some on the board whose tone on the topic is intellectually condense ding down toward the believers. The how can you belief in a fairy tale argument. I want to make the rational case to be a theist.

The second point, is the argument from the believers side on the board is dominated by a segment of Christians with a deep belief in a literal bible. I have nothing against them or their beliefs. But I feel that if that is the major voice that the atheist or agnostic is hearing, they may be the best vehicle to express how many other believers view their faith. So wanted to provide another example

Why do I care what others believe. The easy answer, and I think the best one, is I care about others. Not sharing what I believe, would be like having a really great friend, and not introducing him or her to anyone. Now, I can't make anyone truly believe in God. What I hope I can do is remove a few obstacles people have that are preventing them from meeting Him. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

Yes, but science is testable, it is provable. If the ultimate truth someone seeks is the question of God's existence, honestly my feeble mind can not grasp how that is testable in any sense now or in the future. So, what is the correlation between truth and fact. As for Aquinas' argument, what put God into motion. If everything must be put into motion, then there can be no First Mover as this being when, by the nature of the law, must also be put into motion. Now, I know the simple response is that God is beyond the law, but if anything exists outside a law, then the law itself is flawed. It's just another ontological paradox.

As for acceptance and why "most" don't accept and it being about giving up control, I take issue with that. I cede control to my wife, to my parents, to my kids in some sense, to people I work with, to the government...I have no problem giving up control in these areas, why would I not believe in a god because of control issues if I can give up control in every other aspect of my life?

As for myself, and many that I have talked to, it is an unanswerable question so we choose not to ask the question. Logic dictates that this God is just another in a very long line created by man. We have much more definitive proof that many more people have created many more gods than any god has created any people. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

You have "faith" in science, you "believe" because of things you have seen science do, that it will be able to do more, but more than that, I think you "believe" it can answer everything.

Science is "the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment."

That is the definition of "good" science. Notice it requires "observation and experiment". The problem too many people have is believing that an assumption, which leads to an hypothesis, is "good" science. Assumptions are not "observation and experiment".

Yes, but science is testable, it is provable.

Only the "good" science is. The rest is just hypothesis, which really isn't science at all. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

I do enjoy the back and forth and very much appreciate the position of a logical, reasoned theist!!! 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

I spoke too soon. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Logic dictates that this God is just another in a very long line created by man.

Actually, logic would dictate that there is a Creator.

I spoke too soon. 

That's nothing new for you. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

Floods and exodus' and evolution and big bangs and such are not assumptions. They are realities. You can choose to ignore reality, but at that point I just have to say "have a nice life" and move on. It's no more worth talking about to someone who doesn't believe in reality than it would to go outside and talk to a bunch of ants. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

And I will go with an argument that one could logically assume there is a Creator. My counter is that yours is just another in a very long line of man made Creators who have been disproven and forgotten again and again throughout history. I will take you back to AMDG and Aquinas' first point, if logic dictates that there must be a Creator, then that same logic dictates that something created the Creator. If you posit that the Creator is eternal and beyond creation, that establishes that something can be eternal and not need a beginning. If something can be that, then that something can just be existence itself. Again, paradox. 

Squatchy --- 12 years ago -

Yo check this: the universe is in motion - it is expanding away from the Big Bang. !!BOOM!! Now makes me a sammich. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

evolution and big bangs and such are not assumptions.

Sorry, but they are. There is absolutely no definitive proof of either, just assumptions. You can't touch or see any proof of either.

If evolution and the big bang were actual realities, the "explanations" supporting them wouldn't have changed so much in the last 50 years.

It's no more worth talking about to someone who doesn't believe in reality than it would to go outside and talk to a bunch of ants.

That's why it's hard to talk to you. You don't believe in reality. You believe in the concoctions of fallible men. You don't even understand what science is. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

It makes me sooooo happy that you think I don't know science...reassures me that Im doing something right. And Squatchy, Im with you...if WIP or any other woman wants to have a position on this, all I have to say is 1 Timothy 2:12 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

if logic dictates that there must be a Creator, then that same logic dictates that something created the Creator.

Sorry, but it doesn't. God is spiritual, not bound by time. What God created is physical, and is bound by time. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

paradox 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

It makes me sooooo happy that you think I don't know science...reassures me that Im doing something right.

No, I know you don't know science by the body of your posts.

if WIP or any other woman wants to have a position on this, all I have to say is 1 Timothy 2:12

It's also apparent you don't understand Scripture either, but we already knew that. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Yo check this: the universe is in motion - it is expanding away from the Big Bang. !!BOOM!! Now makes me a sammich.

Yea squatchy - that is my point. So if there is (and I think there was) a Big Bang, who is the the big banger? What set it in motion. 

The Day I Tried to Live --- 12 years ago -

New thread, new topic = rinse and repeat. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

paradox

Man's invention of what "he" considers contradictory. Fallible men don't have a good grip on logic. 

Squatchy --- 12 years ago -

Yo need better telescopes to see that far back in time, ask again in 1000 years. Distribution of galaxies and stuff. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

CS - who created the creator? Well it must be a necessary being, as defined above, it must be infinite, it has to, unlike anything else in the universe be without a beginning or an end. Sound like any one to you. We call that being in this argument God. That is the entire logical conclusion to the argument. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

So existence itself could be God then. Or some other version of God can be God. The universe itself can be infinite, without beginning or end, then we can just change the name of the universe to god. I guess my point is that the answer to what that infinite without beginning or end thing is can not be found in the Bible or any other document written by men. It is beyond our comprehension. Most believers willingly admit that God is beyond comprehension yet they spend so much time trying to comprehend It, Him or Her.

Truth, that is something else. Many people find truth or purpose or deeper meaning within many religious works, obviously the Bible included. I completely understand this. I guess many of us non-believers get exasperated when it is implied that we can't find these truths without religion. I feel love and empathy and sacrifice and purpose and devotion and reverence and all these other things without God or belief. To me, these are human experiences, not divine gifts. Of course, I could be wrong. There's a first time for everything ;) 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

I'm off to enjoy a glorious Fall Houston day. If there be a God, I most graciously thank It, Him or Her for days such as these!!! 

Squatchy --- 12 years ago -

Let there be light! Have we pushed God to the edge of the Universe (one word) 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

CS - enjoy the day. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

So existence itself could be God then. Or some other version of God can be God.

No, God is God.

The universe itself can be infinite, without beginning or end, then we can just change the name of the universe to god.

But, according to the best science of today, that is a bad premiss. The best science, at least that I know of, says there is a begining. If there is a beginning, it can not be infinite. Now, it is you who have to disallow science, to have it fit your belief.

I guess my point is that the answer to what that infinite without beginning or end thing is can not be found in the Bible or any other document written by men.

I have made no reference to the bible. In fact, quite the contrary I admit freely I have no proof for the full God of the bible. What I think I can do, is make a very good case that God exists. I have made no claim that He is the Christian God of the bible, or for that matter that He is even good yet. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Truth, that is something else. Many people find truth or purpose or deeper meaning within many religious works, obviously the Bible included. I completely understand this.
I guess many of us non-believers get exasperated when it is implied that we can't find these truths without religion.


There are many, many truths that you can find without religion. I would say, almost all can be found without religion. Maybe all truths can be found without religion except for maybe 2. The first is the topic here, is there a God? The second is depended on the first, if the answer to the first is no, then the second question is why then are we here.

Ok maybe 3, if no God, then why the human drive to be good. This is a major theme of Camus in The Plague, as the doctor tries to reconcile his need to, in his words be a saint, yet continue to be an atheist.

I feel love and empathy and sacrifice and purpose and devotion and reverence and all these other things without God or belief.


Just because you don't believe they come from God, doesn't mean they don't. And just because you don't believe in God, doesn't mean he doesn't believe in you.

To me, these are human experiences, not divine gifts. Of course, I could be wrong. There's a first time for everything ;)


Yea, I remember once I though I was wrong, but I was mistaken :). I will get back to the issue of what if you are wrong. Part of the last proof, but that is down the road. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

OK, i thought this may be something more than what we usually get, but not so... 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Sorry, mutton, will try to do better, but you have to admit, there are not a lot of Camus references on the board. That was different. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I guess many of us non-believers get exasperated when it is implied that we can't find these truths without religion.

God doesn't call anyone to a religion. In fact, He wants nothing to do with man's religions, and He wants people to have nothing to do with them either. 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Not saying is you dear AMDG. You can actually make your point without making one feel indifferent... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground