Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Who gets to define what is a Muslim????

who's talking here?

smartypants 4
randyjet 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
SleightOfHand 2
zapper007 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Work in Progress 2
Dorothy Parker 2
FabFive 1
Wolfram 8
Emperor of Kingwood 2
witchywoman 2
DVaz 2
Not KU 1
mutton 4
You can call me Michelle 3
jacobson 4
RayofHope 1
Squatchy 1
logic 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Who gets to define what is a Muslim????

I keep hearing commentators and even our President telling us that ISIS are not Muslim. But ISIS insists that they are, in fact, Muslim. So who gets to define what it means to be Muslim?

Western Christians define what it means to be a Muslim Vote
 
 23.5% (4)
Actual people who profess to be Muslim define what it means to be Muslim Vote
 
 76.5% (13)
Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

I keep hearing commentators and even our President telling us that ISIS are not Muslim. But ISIS insists that they are, in fact, Muslim. So who gets to define what it means to be Muslim? 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

I would guess, that much like Christianity, there are many different factions. The Westboro Baptists claimed to be Christian, but other Christians would say otherwise.

Why do you ask? 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

he Westboro Baptists claimed to be Christian, but other Christians would say otherwise.

It is key that you said "other Christians would say otherwise."

Would we accept that a Muslim or a Hindu has the authority to decide who is and is not a Christian???

That is essentially what is happening in the US. Non Muslims are telling us all who is and who is not an authentic Muslim. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Are they being advised by actual Muslims?

That would be my first question. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

The comment about them not being muslims is calculated to drive a wedge between radical and main stream muslims so as to avoid the perception of another Crusades 1300 years later. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

So Bob are you saying that the Presidents assertion that ISIS is not Muslim, is a political calculation? 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

Anyone who wants to. I GET TO define people by my observations of them. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

So Bob are you saying that the Presidents assertion that ISIS is not Muslim, is a political calculation??

Yep. Everything this POTUS does is calculated to provide some sort of political advantage. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

So Pee BO is a Muslim, gotcha 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

Look at what the President actually said for a minute:

"we continue to face a terrorist threat. We cannot erase every trace of evil from the world, and small groups of killers have the capacity to do great harm. That was the case before 9/11, and that remains true today. That's why we must remain vigilant as threats emerge. At this moment, the greatest threats come from the Middle East and North Africa, where radical groups exploit grievances for their own gain. And one of those groups is ISIL ? which calls itself the "Islamic State."

Now let's make two things clear: ISIL is not "Islamic." No religion condones the killing of innocents, and the vast majority of ISIL's victims have been Muslim"
 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

and the vast majority of ISIL's victims have been Muslim"

Because they are the wrong type of muslim 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

If we're building a coalition, which is the only way to go here, it's clearly very important to be in agreement about the target. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

No religion condones the killing of innocents

I suppose that may be true, but it also depends on what the religion defines as "innocents". 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

I suppose that may be true, but it also depends on what the religion defines as "innocents".?

Kind of like Christianity during the Crusades. Too bad some of Islam is still stuck with similarly outrageous ideology. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

other Muslim countries are in agreement that ISIS is monstrous- most of their attacks have been on another faction of Muslims, but they're even killing other Sunnis- other Muslims who don't mind killing innocents even consider them monsters, so they're rather like white supremacists, that call themselves Christians- 

FabFive --- 12 years ago -

Why does anyone want to kill anyone else just because of what they are, or aren't? I can understand killing someone to protect yourself and your family in imminent danger. That's it. The rest I can not comprehend. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

Follow-up question...

Why is this poll posted on KU?

Trying to start a fight, eh... 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

Have any of you ever been around a Muslim or worked in a Muslim country?

Otherwise, do not vote... 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

Trying to start a fight, eh...

No. trying to stimulate thoughtful discussion.

Have any of you ever been around a Muslim or worked in a Muslim country?

Otherwise, do not vote...


That is an absurd assertion. The poll is really about who gets to define who is Muslim. A legitimate philosophical question.

Apparently many in the media and our President feel they are the arbiters of who is and who is not a Muslim. 

RayofHope --- 12 years ago -

People should be able to come up with their own labels. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

A legitimate philosophical question.

My question is meant for you.


What gives you the right or authority to discuss this topic unless you can answer my question - nuf said!!!! 

logic --- 12 years ago -

Free speech? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Zapper is only trying to protect and defend Obama....... at all cost. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

Have any of you ever been around a Muslim or worked in a Muslim country?

It is absurd that you think that your criteria are the only means by which to have the right to discuss the topic.

I can only surmise that you are confused as to what is being discussed.

To clarify, we are not pondering the legitimacy of anybody or group who calls themselves Muslim, rather if those who do not identify as Muslim have the legitimacy to define the nature of such a group that identify as Muslim.

An example may help you to understand the premise.

Let us say that I tell you I am gay. Would you have the right to tell me I am not gay because I do not believe in gay marriage?

And I will answer your ridiculous question. Yes. I have both been around Muslims and worked in a Muslim country. 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

we are not pondering the legitimacy of anybody or group who calls themselves Muslim, rather if those who do not identify as Muslim have the legitimacy to define the nature of such a group that identify as Muslim.

Lacking someone professing it for themselves, what would lend legitimacy to someone else doing it for them? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Islamic State in Iraq and Syria.

Regardless of what Obama says............. they're Islamic. It says so in their name. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

Lacking someone professing it for themselves, what would lend legitimacy to someone else doing it for them?

Rather, if a group declares themselves to be Muslim, what right does anyone to say they are not?

How would you feel if President Obama declared to the nation that Baptists are not true Christians because they do not believe in the holy Eucharist as the body and blood of Jesus Christ? 

smartypants --- 12 years ago -

People say what they say. That doesn't mean it's true. I don't think Obama chose his words very well in this case. That was kind of surprising.

It isn't necessary to deny that they are Islamic, but I can understand that he would phrase it that way. If we're going in, he needs those Muslims who are against ISIL. He could have gotten away with just saying extremists, imo.

Personally, I wish we could stay out of it and Saudi Arabia et al take responsibility for the job. 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

This whole conversation is silly.

Trust no one in matters of religion. 

witchywoman --- 12 years ago -

They pray to Allah and they pray to the Lord but mostly they pray about love and war.

" target="_new"> 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

Webster. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I think the book they follow defines who they are. So if you read the book, you should be able to define it, with the exception, of course, those people who don't believe that words have a literal meaning. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Their Koran, which they consider a perfect copy of a perfect book dictated to Mohammed from Allah himself through the angel Gabriel. It cannot be transformed or rewritten. It cannot be changed within orthodox Islam.

To make any sense out of the Koran (it doesn't have a narrative and is all jumbled up in terms of chronology, it is arranged from the longest chapter to the shortest, instead of chronologically), it has to be read along the Hadith, which is their traditions of the prophet by scholars, dating back to 800 AD.

The verses in the Koran which are "tolerant", that get quoted a lot especially here in the States, are from Mohammed's time in Mecca. At this point, he didn't have any power, and was trying to recruit Jews and Christians to his new religion.

Later, after he moved to Medina and became a warlord with power, the verses become all about killing and terrorizing unbelievers.

In Islam, they have a concept that when verses are contradictory, the later verses cancel out the earlier verses.

Unfortunately, the ones who follow the orthodoxy most closely, are the most violent. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I didn't know that- it's really surprising that any religion would promote violence, in their last verses- 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Just as there are many different Christian worships are there not within the Muslims? 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

Just as there are many different Christian worships are there not within the Muslims?

Yes there are many different sects, and one HUGE division between Sunni and Shia. But they all have to hold to the Koran to be considered orthodox or "real" Islam. They all started with Mohammed, and if you look at his life, which in EVERY sect they are supposed to imitate, he was a very violent man who killed unbelievers.

I don't know how they can get around that. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Just as there are many different Christian worships are there not within the Muslims?

Are there many different Christian worships? 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

You tell me Jacobson. 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

Who gets to define what is a Muslim????

I dont know what to make of that question. To me that's like asking: Aint she fine? or Are you rich? These are all relative questions. One persons crazy is another persons genius.

Who is anyone to define what another is or is not? 

You can call me Michelle --- 12 years ago -

There are many different Christian denominations, but it is mostly divided up based on certain beliefs (like whether Jesus was truly God) or worship (like how often we take communion). 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground