Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

A California School was within its rights to ban U.S. flag T-shirts on Cinco de Mayo

who's talking here?

ProudTXN 3
randyjet 3
sunshine1881 6
wayward1 6
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Polly Ester 2
Perfection 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 15
I_won't_tell 1
Dr Aborto 5
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Puss In Boots 1
Semper 4
Ender 2
JAMS 4
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Ogre13 3
tennismommy 1
Lord Cheezus DeSufferbus 1
Prolix Raconteur 1
The Master 1
Oregonian 2
ShadowHunter 1
MrVaz 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

Was shocked when I read this. I've learned over the years that people in Mexico don't even make a big deal out of May 5th why do American's make a big deal out of it.

http://www.cnn.com/2014/02/27/justice/california-school-american-flag-shirts/ 

Polly Ester --- 12 years ago -

why do American's make a big deal out of it.


same as st. pat's day. it's just a party day. 

ProudTXN --- 12 years ago -

Hmm, good point Hissy. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Was shocked when I read this.

Sounds like you only read the headline and not the article.

Judges said the civil rights case forced them to weigh the difficult question of what takes precedence: students' free speech rights or school safety concerns?

According to court documents, the incident occurred amid "ongoing racial tension and gang violence within the school, and after a near-violent altercation had erupted during the prior Cinco de Mayo over the display of an American flag."
 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

I went to mostly hispanic schools in SoCal. In Elementary school we would learn to dance traditional Mexican dances and perform them on Cinco de Mayo. I'm not even Mexican but it was in front of parents kinda thing. In high school we just had a crappy carnival. Cinco de Mayo isn't even a big deal to real Mexicans. But then again, there weren't any racially motivated altercations in my school that I knew of.

These kids with the shirts knew what they were doing and wanted to start some shiz. There's a history of it. Inciting a riot is kind of a no no. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Judges said the civil rights case forced them to weigh the difficult question of what takes precedence: students' free speech rights or school safety concerns?

that's nonsense...if the school was really concerned about school "safety"...they would have forbidden the wearing of shirts displaying the Mexican flag also 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

Was shocked when I read this. I've learned over the years that people in Mexico don't even make a big deal out of May 5th why do American's make a big deal out of it.

While the headline may be shocking, the actual basis for the decision isn't. It was a safety issue, and the T-shirts were being worn with the intent to incite. It's the yelling fire in a crowded theater issue. The first amendment doesn't protect speech intended to incite and never has. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

It was a safety issue, and the T-shirts were being worn with the intent to incite.

there is no proof of their "intent"...this is AMERICA...the AMERICAN flag is AMERICA'S flag...an AMERICAN public school shouldn't be sponsoring anything but an AMERICAN celebration 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

so,I am gonna be arrested for wearing celebratory clothes on St. Pats?? 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

It was a safety issue, and the T-shirts were being worn with the intent to incite.

Can the same not be said about the groups that wave other countries' flags at events? If we assume they are not doing it to rub it in anyone's face...but rather,solely out of ethnic or national pride; then why is that same courtesy not afforded to those waving or wearing the Stars and Stripes?



For the record...I wasn't born in the U.S., English wasn't even my first language. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

there is no proof of their "intent"...this is AMERICA...the AMERICAN flag is AMERICA'S flag...an AMERICAN public school shouldn't be sponsoring anything but an AMERICAN celebration

Bull. Have you read the decision? There were several reports to the principal that day, and there had been problems the year before. It was an ongoing issue.

Read the opinion

Direct link 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Can the same not be said about the groups that wave other countries' flags at events?

If the same school was having a Fourth of July celebration. YES, I would expect the kids wearing Mexican flags would be asked to turn them inside out.

This school is a special circumstance because there is a history of racial violence and gang activity. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

It was an ongoing issue.

It's an ongoing issue because there's a profound lack of assimilation that's been growing for decades now. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

there is no proof of their "intent"...this is AMERICA...the AMERICAN flag is AMERICA'S flag...

+1

This is nothing more than another example of race-baiting.

Completely ignoring that fact that California (unfortunately) is still a part of the United States, the decision to 'ban' flags should be universal.

In any other example of schools trying to quell "gang violence" they do not support one side or the other. If gang 'X' wears blue and gang 'Y' wears red, you ban BOTH colors (or go to uniforms for everyone).

This is just more limp-wristed liberal BS 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

I went to many different schools in several states with kids of all backgrounds. I remember celebrating and studying different cultures in school, especially during Christmastime. Kids would dress up to represent different countries or bring an ethnic dish to share with classmates. But the rest of the time, we were all just American kids and our parents expected and encouraged us to assimilate. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

This is nothing more than another example of race-baiting.

Yep, the students were using the American flag to race bait. I'm more upset that these little punks would use the symbol of our great nation (the great melting pot) to try to oppress others. What a perversion of our flag and the principals this nation was founded on. Our forefathers would be so upset. 

Ender --- 12 years ago -

Yep, the students were using the American flag to race bait.

lol

I am sure that the students wearing the Mexican flags were being little angles to the white students as well.

I know the point you are getting at and I do not disagree. I would bet a paycheck on the fact that a majority the kids wearing their American flag shirts ONLY do it on that day. That same paycheck would also bet on the fact that they were provoked in some way to begin that behavior.

The schools responsibility is to be objective. Either ban both or none at all. The ONLY reason that they don't ban both is because they do not want to be "insensitive" to the Mexican kids. 

Semper --- 12 years ago -

I would bet a paycheck on the fact that a majority the kids wearing their American flag shirts ONLY do it on that day.

I agree.

The schools responsibility is to be objective. Either ban both or none at all. The ONLY reason that they don't ban both is because they do not want to be "insensitive" to the Mexican kids.?


I agree here also. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

The schools responsibility is to be objective. Either ban both or none at all. The ONLY reason that they don't ban both is because they do not want to be "insensitive" to the Mexican kids.

Bulls eye. Lest the be called RACISTS. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

appeasement is america's new mantra 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

I think everyone is missing the point and pointing fingers. Instead of talking about the real issue. These kids (both sides) are s-heads. Instead of being cool with people's differences and celebrating, they instead try to start some shiz. Their parents are probably s-heads too. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

I think everyone is missing the point and pointing fingers. Instead of talking about the real issue. These kids (both sides) are s-heads. Instead of being cool with people's differences and celebrating, they instead try to start some shiz. Their parents are probably s-heads too.

Exactly. Instead of embracing the fact that we're all different and can all learn from one another, they're being taught hate.

The funny thing is, these parents probably party down on St. Patrick's Day and don't realize the roots and the history are the same. Heck, they probably use Cinqo de Mayo as an excuse to have a margarita or two, but get pizzed off when it's celebrated in their kid's school. It's just ignorance. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

and there had been problems the year before

yea...chants of USA...USA...

the Hispanics made an issue of that

fyi...i read the decision...did you?...what happened a year ago doesn't show intent of the present... 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Question. If your kids Elementary School was having a Cinco de Mayo day where they learn about Mexico, food, culture, etc. How many here would have fun with it and how many would be D's and send your kid with an American Flag shirt just to prove a point? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Exactly. Instead of embracing the fact that we're all different and can all learn from one another, they're being taught hate.

supporting your OWN country,,,doesn't mean you hate the country of someone else...they weren't chanting "hate Mexico"

people who irresponsibly throw out monikers like "hate"...especially based upon "their feelings"...are worse than the people they are accusing 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If your kids Elementary School was having a Cinco de Mayo day

the schools in AMERICA shouldn't be having Cinco de Mayo days... 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

If your kids Elementary School was having a Cinco de Mayo day

the schools in AMERICA shouldn't be having Cinco de Mayo days...


Yes, because heaven forbid we let our kids know we live in a global society and teach them for understand and appreciate other cultures.

We better ban St. Patrick's Day too! 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Yes, because heaven forbid we let our kids know we live in a global society and teach them for understand and appreciate other cultures.

nothing wrong with teaching them about other cultures...that's not what Cinco de Mayo is about

so next time...please try and compare apples to apples

We better ban St. Patrick's Day too!

that's fine with me...but again...please try and compare apples to apples 

ShadowHunter --- 12 years ago -

Large swaths of the former USA are now defacto Mexico. 

sunshine1881 --- 12 years ago -

that's not what Cinco de Mayo is about

Really? It is in most schools.

How is it not apples to apples comparing the current incarnations of both holidays.

St. Patrick's Day

"It is observed as a celebration of Irish and Irish American culture."

Cinco de Mayo
"today the date is observed in the United States as a celebration of Mexican heritage and pride"

Sounds pretty apples to apples to me. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Cinco de Mayo celebrates national unity and patriotism for MEXICO

St. Patrick's Day is a religious holiday...it's true that it's roots are in Ireland...but do you see the Irish wearing t-shirts with the flag of Ireland on them?...it's not about Irish patriotism...

so not apples to apples

i already said that a public school should celebrate neither...but especially not one that celebrates national unity and patriotism for MEXICO 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

but do you see the Irish wearing t-shirts with the flag of Ireland on them?...it's not about Irish patriotism...


Where in "H" have you been John? You obviously have not witnessed any St. Patty's day parade.

How about banning the Greek Festival here in Houston or October Fest? Only choose Cinco de Mayo because it is Mexican 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Where in "H" have you been John? You obviously have not witnessed any St. Patty's day parade.

LOL...do you even READ?...what does a PARADE have to do with a PUBLIC SCHOOL?

How about banning the Greek Festival here in Houston or October Fest?

AGAIN...what do those have to do with PUBLIC SCHOOLS? 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Only choose Cinco de Mayo because it is Mexican

where is your mind at?...didn't i say public schools shouldn't promote St. Patrick Day celebrations?...or did you just not comprehend what you read?...or do you think St. Patrick Day celebrations are Mexican also?

your attempt at racism is lame... 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

The article says nothing of the school promoting or engaging in Cinco de Mayo celebrations. The article doesn't even mention it teaching about the holiday. It was just trying to keep additional fights from breaking out, not thinking of the state of our country-wide culture norms and practices.
This is a beyond sad attempt of those who feel our culture is being worm away to keep rehashing this news story to keep the fight going. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

It was just trying to keep additional fights from breaking out

then restrict both "sides"... 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

Really. Was there another side. Can we not trust professionals to make appropriate calls for safety. Were there even t-shirt for the other side to turn inside out? The admins made a call based on events at hand and the courts sided with them. I say lets trust the professionals. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

And just maybe the "side" that more looks like you and I were acting like a bunch of a-holes. 

Perfection --- 12 years ago -

The issue isn't having a Cinco de Mayo celebration it is about allowing a US flag there.

To me that does not incite, it is respectful of this country.

Same as if we had a Canadian independence day and still had a US flag or attire there.

If the US Flag or attire is inciting someone then it will always incite them. That's on them. 

tennismommy --- 12 years ago -

If the US Flag or attire is inciting someone then it will always incite them. That's on them.

Agreed! This is America first. You can celebrate other holidays but no other flag should replace it. Put another little flag on the other holiday but always keep the big American flag up. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground