Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

possibly a more fair and balanced look at the previous sexual abuse thread

who's talking here?

Warren Peace 1
voice of reason 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
JohnLynch 17
It is I WhyWhyWhy 15
magicmom 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
PokerFace 4
JAMS 2
MissPris 1
Jepperd 4
Sangria 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Dylan Farrow Is Telling the Truth as She Believes It, But Is It the Truth as It Happened?

Chez Pazienza on February 02, 2014

If you haven?t read Dylan Farrow?s viscerally affecting open letter in yesterday?s New York Times, you should. As a matter of practicality it will help you to understand why Twitter has been on fire for the past 24-hours, with detractors and defenders of Woody Allen turning it into a virtual Battle of Pelennor Fields, and as a matter of conscience it?s important to know the version of events of 21 years ago as told by the woman who was once the little girl at the center of them. Dylan not only details her alleged abuse at the hands of Woody as a single act, she hints at what she believes is the pattern of inappropriate behavior that led up to it. It?s tough stuff, hard to read at times, whether you?re a fan of Woody Allen or not.

I have a five-year-old daughter, and if anyone ever did anything to her like what Dylan Farrow alleges Woody Allen did, he?d be dead ten minutes after I found out about it. I say this because I want everyone to know that I understand what?s at stake here and by no means take this subject lightly. There?s no doubt that Dylan Farrow believes she was a victim of abuse. There?s no doubt that Dylan Farrow was the victim of abuse. The doubt lies in exactly what kind of abuse she suffered and at whose hand.

Dylan?s story is as riveting as it is disturbing, but the fact is we?ll never know whether the events she recalls as searing memories really happened in the way she describes. This isn?t a case of ?attacking the victim,? and to argue in good faith doesn?t make someone a monster or a child sex abuse apologist; it makes him or her a realist who accepts that the family politics at play in the Woody/Mia custody battle which was ripping their family apart in 1992 were so brutal and ugly that unless there?s evidence to back up that claim, every claim deserves to be questioned.

Yes, Woody Allen began dating Mia Farrow?s adopted daughter, Soon-Yi Previn, when she was approximately 19 years old and maybe you think that?s creepy. But the fact remains that it was completely legal. Contrary to popular belief among people who are sure they know everything about this case and are therefore qualified to rage about it on Twitter, Soon-Yi was not Woody?s daughter; Woody and Mia were never married nor did they even live together. What can?t be denied is that when the relationship between Woody and Soon-Yi was revealed, it detonated a nuclear bomb in the middle of Woody and Mia?s family and she was understandably furious about it. The members of that family then took sides and the battle lines have, for the most part, remained stable. There have occasionally been breaks in ranks, though, now that years have passed. Although he initially decried the relationship between Woody and Soon-Yi, Woody and Mia?s adopted son Moses Farrow, who went on to become a family therapist, now thinks that Mia brainwashed his seven-year-old sister into believing she was assaulted. And before you dismiss this possibility, you should at least be willing to read the facts of the case, the opinions of those who followed the developments in the relationship closely throughout the years, and those who?ve spent a lifetime doing experiments with memory implantation.

Elizabeth Loftus is a psychologist and researcher at UC Irvine, and she?s spent most of her career studying the power of suggestion, even self-suggestion, on our memories and what she?s found is both fascinating and really not the least bit surprising. Basically, especially at a young age, we?re highly susceptible to suggestion and memory manipulation, particularly by people we trust and wish to please, and the kind of story Dylan Farrow is telling isn?t unusual during the total warfare of a custody battle, especially one as public as Woody and Mia?s and concerning someone as volatile and demanding as Mia Farrow and with the mercurial and neurotic reputation of Woody Allen.

Here?s what it comes down to: There are only two people who know what really happened between Woody Allen and Dylan Farrow. The former has consistently proclaimed his innocence and tells one story; the latter continues to tell another, much more harrowing story. The facts of the case have always favored Woody, from doctors saying that Dylan was inconsistent in her detailing of what happened 21 years ago and that her story had a rehearsed feel to it, to the actual amount of time witnesses say Woody was alone with Dylan at Mia Farrow?s home in Bridgewater, Connecticut on August 4th, 1992, a date which fell right in the middle of Woody and Mia?s vicious custody battle and a place where he was surrounded by people who didn?t much like him. He passed a lie detector test. He married Soon-Yi and they?ve been together for 17 years and now have a family of their own and there have been no other accusations of any impropriety from anyone. Dylan, meanwhile, sticks by her own version of events, and they may very well be true. Or, as difficult as it may be to accept, they could also be the product of severe manipulation at a very young age. Unfortunately, we?ll never know for sure.

So what this all means for the social media mob is simply whom you choose to believe: which side will confirm your already tightly held biases, fit your cultural ideology, potentially provide a rallying cry in a cause for which you advocate, or just help you sleep at night. Like the battle lines drawn two decades ago between Woody and Mia, the battle lines on Twitter are now drawn between those who?ve gathered behind the banner of Dylan Farrow?s column, which tells an indeed shocking personal story, or behind the banner of the Daily Beast article by Robert Weide, which lays out in detail the facts of Woody?s relationship with Soon-Yi, motivations of Mia Farrow, and details of the case. It?s a case that was decided two decades ago and which was only reignited, coincidentally, by Mia and Ronan Farrow?s questionable shots across Twitter the night of the Golden Globes.

Understand something: I don?t think there?s an ounce of subterfuge in Dylan Farrow?s decision to write the open letter she did or to make the claim she did 21 years ago. I don?t think she?s doing it to blackmail anyone or to bring fame upon herself. Other than the malice she has for Woody Allen, I don?t think there?s any malice in her words at all. I believe that Dylan believes she was sexually assaulted by her adoptive father. I also understand that there are those out there for whom this case is a cause célèbre because, indeed, there are plenty of women and kids who?ve been abused who are put in a position of no one believing them because there isn?t enough physical evidence to back up their claim. These people argue in favor of Dylan from a place of emotion and as a show of solidarity, and maybe they should. But in this particular case, there?s simply too much bad blood and destructive family politics at play and too little proof to light the torches and raise the pitchforks, demanding that Woody Allen be tried in court or, screw it, just thrown in jail 21 years after the fact.

None of this is Dylan Farrow?s fault. I have no idea what really happened to her and neither do you. But she?s a victim and a survivor either way. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

i know some wise acre's are going to accuse me of defending sexual abuse...but let me say this...if woody is guilty of this...he should fry

however...as the author of this article states...only two people...possibly three...besides God really know what happened

many people accuse me of being judgmental...but i want proof before i make my judgment...however some people don't care about that

this article just gives another point of view

fyi...i personally don't care much for woody 

Sangria --- 12 years ago -

Great article John, and thanks for sharing it. It definitely shines a different light on the matter. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

It's interesting to me just how often the benefit of the doubt always seems to go to the authority figure. I wonder why that is? I think it's a defense mechanism, to distance oneself from the fact that horrible things can and do happen all the time and they can happen to is just as easily as to anyone else. And so there is a bit of denial at play, people will think the wronged person is the one they most identify with. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

She should bring her case to a judge and have him tried like Sandusky was years after the fact.

I think it is extremely creepy that he and his wife/step daughter have adopted a daughter that looks a lot like Dylan did when she was little. I think its even more telling that in recent pictures she crosses her arms in front of her seemingly refusing to hug him or block him from getting close to her.


Dylan Farrow

0



Adopted daughters with step-daughter/wife this past week posing for the cameras.


0 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

0undefined 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

I think it is extremely creepy that he and his wife/step daughter

i think it's extremely creepy when someone changes the facts...i.e. his wife was NEVER his stepdaughter

I think its even more telling that in recent pictures she crosses her arms in front of her seemingly refusing to hug him or block him from getting close to her.

again creepy that you would make make that statement based upon that "evidence" 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

i think it's extremely creepy when someone changes the facts...i.e. his wife was NEVER his stepdaughter



He was in her life for 12 years in a parental role. Allen and Farrow adopted two children together and possibly had a third bio child together while she was growing up with them. To pretend that he was not a step father to her is to protect a predator. She is obviously a very sick girl now woman, just as he is. Its sad that someone she trusted was able to manipulate her and destroy her relationship with her entire family. Sad and sick. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

I think its even more telling that in recent pictures she crosses her arms in front of her seemingly refusing to hug him or block him from getting close to her.

again creepy that you would make make that statement based upon that "evidence"?



There are multiple pictures from that scene with Allen and his adopted dd's. In all of the pictures it is clear she is keeping him away for whatever reason. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

He was in her life for 12 years in a parental role.

how do you know that...since woody and mia never lived together?

To pretend that he was not a step father to her is to protect a predator.

there you go with the accusations...it doesn't surprise me that you were the first wise acre to weigh in...yep...i'm really PROTECTING him...but from what i must ask?

Its sad that someone she trusted was able to manipulate her and destroy her relationship with her entire family.

do you know that for a fact?...nope...you don't

There are multiple pictures from that scene

wow...ONE scene...she could be mad at him because he didn't buy her something she wanted...LOL...typical of people who judge without the facts... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

wow...ONE scene...she could be mad at him because he didn't buy her something she wanted...LOL...typical of people who judge without the facts...


As Always blame the child, protect the predator. Multiple things point to the fact that this man is a predator. Multiple accusations multiple improper relationships with his children. His wife was at most 8 when her mother began her 12 year relationship with Allen. Just because they didn't "officially" live together doesn't mean they didn't sleep at his house and he at theirs most nights.

Again believe in the predator just as you did in Sandusky and Paterno. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

As Always blame the child, protect the predator.

LOL...the twister of the truth strikes again...that's what you should change your screen name to...

blame what child?...the child in the photograph has made no accusations

Multiple accusations multiple improper relationships with his children.

what multiple accusations?...what multiple improper relationships with his children?...now you're just making stuff up

His wife was at most 8 when her mother began her 12 year relationship with Allen.

actually she was around 11...but what does that matter?...she was just having her affair with woody so she could star in his movies...

Just because they didn't "officially" live together doesn't mean they didn't sleep at his house and he at theirs most nights.

and just how do you know this?

Again believe in the predator just as you did in Sandusky and Paterno.

another false statement...first of all...i NEVER said that i believe woody...but I do adhere to what is known...something YOU don't do...if it doesn't fit YOUR scenario...you make up "facts"

and i also NEVER said i believed in Sandusky...and paterno wasn't a child predator...that's just more of your truth twisting 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Paterno was a protector of a predator which makes him the same thing. An assessory. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Where there is smoke there may very well be fire.

She was 7 years old, she's in her 20's now, I think she's capable of remembering fairly accurately.

I really hate him so I can't be objective but everything about his behavior is fricken OFF. He has no boundaries with young girls. Alarms going off. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

but everything about his behavior is fricken OFF.?


yep

She was 7 years old, she's in her 20's now, I think she's capable of remembering fairly accurately.



yep yep

Where there is smoke there may very well be fire.


yep yep yep 

magicmom --- 12 years ago -

These photos say alot. If I didn't know who they were of, I would guess it was a pimp with 2 of his girls. The current wife was a child when he met her. I would bet she went through the same abuse growing up with him. Can't imagine a normal teenage girl being even slightly attracted to him. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Paterno was a protector of a predator which makes him the same thing. An assessory.

again you state falsehoods...paterno didn't protect Sandusky in any way


Where there is smoke there may very well be fire.

what smoke is that?

She was 7 years old, she's in her 20's now, I think she's capable of remembering fairly accurately

just curious as to how you know this?

I would bet she went through the same abuse growing up with him.

did she grow up with him?...woody having sex with her adoptive mom doesn't necessarily equate to "growing up with him"

it is very evident that the truth doesn't matter to some people...they let their feelings get in the way of any rational thought... 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

These photos say alot.

what says more to me is that "Woody and Mia's adopted son Moses Farrow, who went on to become a family therapist, now thinks that Mia brainwashed his seven-year-old sister into believing she was assaulted" 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

JL will probably be in the news someday linked to a case like this?.somewhere in there protecting a pedo. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

JL will probably be in the news someday linked to a case like this?.

i doubt it...i'm not an attorney...nor am i a reporter

somewhere in there protecting a pedo..

nah...i'm not a bodyguard either 

Jepperd --- 12 years ago -

I rarely agree with JL, but this article is great and so is JL's objectivity.

I think we as a nation are programmed to immediately vilify as soon as sexual abuse accusations are thrown around.

If only you'd apply this to other subjects ;) 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

If only you'd apply this to other subjects ;)

although you don't believe it i do...i base the responses to the threads i participate in to Scripture and Biblical teachings...

the objectivity in this thread is based upon the 9th commandment..."Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor" 

Jepperd --- 12 years ago -

although you don't believe it i do...i base the responses to the threads i participate in to Scripture and Biblical teachings...

the objectivity in this thread is based upon the 9th commandment..."Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor"


I can respect that. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

I think we as a nation are programmed to immediately vilify as soon as sexual abuse accusations are thrown around.

I disagree. Most of us are skeptics. But when other oddities coincide with allegations, this influences how we view the probabilities of the accusations.

Would we be having this conversation if Woody Allen didn't cheat on his girlfriend with his girlfriend's daughter causing a split with his son who refers to him as immoral due to this relationship?

There's a mental oddity with Allen's decisions that goes beyond the standard observation that love isn't rational. 

Jepperd --- 12 years ago -

I disagree. Most of us are skeptics. But when other oddities coincide with allegations, this influences how we view the probabilities of the accusations.

Would we be having this conversation if Woody Allen didn't cheat on his girlfriend with his girlfriend's daughter causing a split with his son who refers to him as immoral due to this relationship?

There's a mental oddity with Allen's decisions that goes beyond the standard observation that love isn't rational.


Mia Forrow isnt exactly a peach either. She has admitted to cheating on Allen through the entirety of their relationship. Also her previous relationship she was the other women to a married man.

I do look at oddities that coincide with the allegation. I look at the bitterness and betrayal Farrow felt when Allen left her. I can also see her doing anything to discredit Allen. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

But him having a relationship that resulted in him marrying his stepdaughter is perfectly normal. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

But him having a relationship that resulted in him marrying his stepdaughter is perfectly normal.

LOL...you still can't get the facts straight...

are you really that uninformed...or do you just want to intentionally lie?

woody didn't marry his step daughter 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I don't think he did it- a relative of mine saw a psychiatrist for 10 years- he discovered "repressed memories" about his mother sexually abusing him as a baby- I know his mother-very well- she was a lot of things, but that wasn't one of them- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I believe Mia brainwashed her- I remember her fury at that time,when he left her- she was definitely capable of it- and Dylan's own brother, a therapist, thinks she was brainwashed- 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

When you take Farrow and Allen out of it you have a girl who is now 20 still telling the same story as when she was 7 and another girl married to a man who was her step father and alienated from her entire family as a result. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

woody didn't marry his step daughter?


You can sugar coat it all you want Lynch. He was in the girls life as her mothers partner whom she adopted two kids with and had a third. Thats a step parent no matter what you chose to believe. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

I believe Mia brainwashed her- I remember her fury at that time,when he left her- she was definitely capable of it- and Dylan's own brother, a therapist, thinks she was brainwashed-?


I believe the now 20 year old girl over everyone else. If she was still a child I might question it more however I think at 20 you know what memories are real or not especially one as violent as being raped as a child. 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

When you take Farrow and Allen out of it you have a girl who is now 20 still telling the same story as when she was 7 and another girl married to a man who was her step father and alienated from her entire family as a result.

your statement is completely false and has no merit

"doctors saying that Dylan was inconsistent in her detailing of what happened 21 years ago and that her story had a rehearsed feel to it"

he was NOT his current wife's stepfather

You can sugar coat it all you want Lynch. He was in the girls life as her mothers partner whom she adopted two kids with and had a third. Thats a step parent no matter what you chose to believe. 

nope...you're still wrong regardless of how many times you repeat the lie

mia had several "partners" at the same time she was having sex with woody

If she was still a child I might question it more however I think at 20 you know what memories are real or not especially one as violent as being raped as a child.

not according to the professionals

"Mia's adopted son Moses Farrow, who went on to become a family therapist, now thinks that Mia brainwashed his seven-year-old sister into believing she was assaulted"

"Elizabeth Loftus is a psychologist and researcher at UC Irvine, and she?s spent most of her career studying the power of suggestion, even self-suggestion, on our memories and what she's found is both fascinating and really not the least bit surprising. Basically, especially at a young age, we're highly susceptible to suggestion and memory manipulation, particularly by people we trust and wish to please, and the kind of story Dylan Farrow is telling isn't unusual during the total warfare of a custody battle, especially one as public as Woody and Mia's and concerning someone as volatile and demanding as Mia Farrow and with the mercurial and neurotic reputation of Woody Allen." 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

You always side with the pedophile, John. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Birds of a feather, and all... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

"Mia's adopted son Moses Farrow, who went on to become a family therapist, now thinks that Mia brainwashed his seven-year-old sister into believing she was assaulted"



Still not the person involved. Still siding with the pedophile as usual John. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Woody's biological son thinks he a douche too.


Seems not a lot of family holds him in high regard.


He's a weirdo at the very least. And next to that is the FACT that he digs young girls. He had an affair with a 17 YO when he was almost 50. She was on CNN last night. I think it's safe to say he barely keeps it legal. If you want a teen when your a middle age guy, you might be a pedo, or not, but where there is smoke there might be fire. Not a lot of people marry adopted children in their family. Oy 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

You always side with the pedophile, John.

has he been proven to be a pedophile?...nope he hasn't

i side with the truth...you side with falsehoods

if he's proven to be a pedophile...then as I previously said...he should fry


Birds of a feather, and all...

yep...look at who you hang with...all of those with that fine moral character

Woody's biological son thinks he a douche too

I don't care much for woody either...but that doesn't mean he's a pedophile

Not a lot of people marry adopted children in their family. Oy

another one that plays loose with the facts...his current wife wasn't in his family 

JohnLynch --- 12 years ago -

Still not the person involved. Still siding with the pedophile as usual John.

i'm still siding with the truth...you continue to side with lies... 

In AbsentiaW --- 12 years ago -

Who really gives a proverbial Tinker's Dam what took place....if it did. The whole family is a group of wierdos. Mia is out to discredite him since he won his last award. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground