Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Cash or Credit?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 4
Keystone 2
whatchamacallit 2
daveyjones 3
KWPlanner 2
ladybeachbum 10
Tylers Journey 2
Donkey Hodie 1
reh6110 1
AngieKaye 1
FANCY PANTS 1
Warren Peace 8
Dr Aborto 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
In AbsentiaW 1
TinktheSprite 1
Charli 2
Four Pinocchios 1
Ogre13 4
Not KU 1
MissPris 1
Sweet Cherub 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Cash or Credit?

I know it's all about using cash but I use a credit card for most purchases and pay off monthly. I use a cash back credit card, save the credit for the year and this past December I had $800 in cash rewards to use anyway I wanted. What do you do?

Cash Only Vote
 
 34.8% (16)
Credit card w/ rewards paid off monthly Vote
 
 60.9% (28)
Credit not paid off monthly Vote
 
 4.3% (2)
marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

I know it's all about using cash but I use a credit card for most purchases and pay off monthly. I use a cash back credit card, save the credit for the year and this past December I had $800 in cash rewards to use anyway I wanted. What do you do? 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

Cash ONLY but sometimes I sure wish I could just go on a big shopping spree! lol Got rid of all the credit cards and now if we don't have the cash we don't buy it! I think I'm gonna break down and get a new car soon but I sure don't want a car payment. That expensive first trip off the lot really bugs me. Maybe I'll just buy used and skip having something else to pay every month. I have been driving my car FOREVER and although she is starting to look bad she runs like a champ! I think I just changed my mind! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

whatchamacallit,
Did you have a bad experience with credit? I ask because when you know how much cash is in the bank you can still use credit. The key is paying it off every month. 

TinktheSprite --- 12 years ago -

Cash only, but from a debit card. Scary about what has been happening lately with the credit card system in some stores. Might have to switch back to cash or ugh, checks. ETA: I am about to put all my utilities on a CC to earn points. Just not so sure what to do with points. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

I think the cash back is better than points. I use Discover but I just got a Chase renewal that is doing 5% back. 

Sweet Cherub --- 12 years ago -

We were married very young and got into credit card trouble. Ever since then, we have always paid cash. It is just habit now. If we don't have the cash, we don't buy it. Because of this, we never got into debt again. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

I almost never use cash. Credit only, reap the rewards and pay the card off monthly. Every thing is put into Quicken. Even credit cards are broken down by expense so that we can see where we spend and save. 

Charli --- 12 years ago -

Cash is emotional. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Cash only, but from a debit card. Scary about what has been happening lately with the credit card system in some stores. Might have to switch back to cash or ugh, checks.

How does getting cash from a debit card feel safer than from a credit card? Both are safer than checks.

In terms of ranking the safety/security of financial instruments, I would rank them from most safe to least safe this way:

1) credit cards (most safe)
2) debit cards
3) paper checks
4) cash (least safe) 

Keystone --- 12 years ago -

Even if you pay them off every month, you are spending more using a credit card than you would if you had cash in your hand. Dave Ramsey says you are spending 20% more by using your credit card and paying it off each month. I hope your cash back cards don't have an annual fee. If so, you need to get rid of them. No one ever got rich on using a cashback credit card. Read "The Millionaire Next Door." 

Not KU --- 12 years ago -

With recent acct hacking's makes me want off the financial grid. ASAP 

Charli --- 12 years ago -

I have been dreaming on ways to go off the grid. Move to Belize. But until that time, cash is king when possible. 

Four Pinocchios --- 12 years ago -

Some hag in California got a hold of my Social Sec # in 1997 and wrecked my credit so for a long time, I was unable to get a credit card. I was cleaning up her messes every six months. Hag is now in jail until 2017 (yay!) and my credit is cleaned up. Anyway the point being, I got used to not having any credit cards and still do not have any.

It is nice not to have credit card debt. 

whatchamacallit --- 12 years ago -

whatchamacallit,
Did you have a bad experience with credit? I ask because when you know how much cash is in the bank you can still use credit. The key is paying it off every month. 



No, I just spend much more when I have credit cards and I have found it less stressful not to have them around! 

In AbsentiaW --- 12 years ago -

One and only one credit card that is paid off before due each month. It has cash back benefits that are credited to account balance. Cash can be a pain though. Checks are written for anyone we hire to work on/around house. That way we have a copy of what and when we paid in case there is any problem. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Even if you pay them off every month, you are spending more using a credit card than you would if you had cash in your hand. Dave Ramsey says you are spending 20% more by using your credit card and paying it off each month.

Bull. Dave Ramsey is wrong on this issue. Look closer at what Dave Ramsey is saying. His target audience is people who have gotten into trouble because they lack financial discipline and have accumulated credit card debt. He is telling those people that they are too mentally weak to use them. He is probably right about those people. But he's wrong about the rest of us and he makes no effort to draw that distinction.

When Dave Ramsey says, "Responsible use of credit cards does not exist", he is lying to you. When he says, "You will spend more if you use credit cards", he is showing how little faith he has in your ability to NOT spend more. 

Keystone --- 12 years ago -

All I know is that no one who has used Dave's program and is now debt-free says that they hate it. 

daveyjones --- 12 years ago -

Warren, I believe you're wrong. You are merely speaking from your heart and not from anything concrete. Dave Ramsey has looked at the research and is speaking from what has been proven.

Secondly, Dave doesn't lie to people. He does speak in generalities but to say he is a liar just isn't true. Just because you don't agree with him doesn't make him a liar.

And here's something for you to read, and it wasn't from Dave Ramsey's website, but I bet it's the research he is talking about:

According to the article "Cards Encourage You to Overspend" on Soundmoneytips.com, people will spend more with a credit card compared to cash. In fact, a Dunn & Bradstreet study found that people spend 12-18% more when using credit cards than when using cash. And McDonald's found that the average transaction rose from $4.50 to $7 when customers used plastic instead of cash. 

MissPris --- 12 years ago -

I also read that men spend more money on frivolous things in mid-life than at any other time ;)
I wonder if they pay cash or credit for their little convertibles? 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Cash only! We do use a Credit Card at the gas station so that we do not have to go into the convenience store. We pay the credit card off every month. I think it is harder for me to buy unnecessary stuff when I pay with cash. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Dave Ramsey made a lot of money on people that pay to listen to him. I doubt he walks around with a wad of cash in his pocket. To use a cash back card with no card fee is smart. There are people that can not handle it, but I am not one of them. I've had stellar credit since I first applied (a lot of years) and kept my credit mine and not joined with my husband which everyone should do. I did have great financial advice very young. I will use a card with 0% for a big purchase which again is smart money. I never use a card in a restaurant ever! My card does not leave my sight. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Warren, I believe you're wrong. You are merely speaking from your heart and not from anything concrete. Dave Ramsey has looked at the research and is speaking from what has been proven.

I'm speaking from my brain. I have faith in you that you can do it too and that you can see what Dave Ramsey actually knows but doesn't say. Ramsey is talking about spending behavior on additional purchases. He is not talking about equivalent purchases using different financial instruments. He is not talking about the true cost of spending transactions. His point is that research shows that people who get into credit card debt do so because they are financially undisciplined. When you are financially undisciplined AND you have a credit card, you are definitely more likely to spend more because you are undisciplined.

This is very different from what Ramsey says. The truth would be exactly what I have stated above. Ramsey avoids the above truth and knowingly repackages the message to something very different by saying untrue things like the quotes I included in my post above.

When he says "you will spend more", he's talking about a study that showed other people in financial trouble did spend more. But it's not predictive and has no bearing whatsoever on you.

I have more faith in you than Dave Ramsey does. Am I wrong to believe you are capable making responsible financial decisions regardless of which financial instrument is used to pay for that transaction? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Cash for 90% of everything.
Credit when I must. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

^^^truth^^^^ 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Another thing, how do you ever get credit established to buy a car or home? 

AngieKaye --- 12 years ago -

in the technological day and age we are in I dont trust credit cards. I use cash or debit only. Debit mostly just to pay bills online.

My feelings as the older we get if I dont have the cash and money on hand I dont need it. Why finance a nice shirt? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You ever wonder if maybe we're doing our kids a disservice by not having a required class in how finances work in high school?

I know I left school and money was a mystery because as far as my dad was concerned our money situation was none of our business.

To this day, I feel like I'm playing catchup. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Angie, we are talking about cards you pay off every month. There is no finance involved. You are mearly using their money for 30 days without interest. Credit cards are safer than debit because you are not held for the charges if they are not yours. I don't have a debit to my account but use a debit paypal account because paypal sends you a receipt for what was bought before I can get to my car. I would know instantly someone was using it and cancel. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

I use Debit like 99% of the time so I guess that's like cash. I do charge our Cable bill on the Credit Card but I pay it off every month. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13, I believe it should be a crime to give college kids a card. My son got one the day he entered college. He knew I wouldn't agree so didn't tell me. He had no income. It has taken years to teach a rather smart guy money smarts. 

Dr Aborto --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13, I believe it should be a crime to give college kids a card.

He was eighteen. It's his fault for buying stuff he didn't have money for. I got my first credit card from the little tents at my college quad. It's possible to not go crazy on it. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Actually, he was 17. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

It doesn't excuse good sense. I get that. He had plenty of talk and training about credit. I don't know many kids that didn't get in some credit problems in our financial circles. They are used to having nice things and think the card is their answer. A credit card company should have more rules on the kid having an income. Good for you for knowing the difference. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Here's a hypothetical to add to this conversation:

You have $1,000 cash (or any amount) in your wallet/purse along with a credit card and a debit card. Let's say you lose it or have it stolen. Is there any reasonable scenario where the cash is returned? Chances are you have lost all of your cash with no hope of recovering it. It is far easier for someone to use the cash than the credit and debit cards. You can call to have those cards disabled immediately. You cannot do that with cash.

If any charges have been made on debit or credit cards, there is a much better chance that you will not experience any financial losses due to fraudulent charges (because it's the law). Credit and debit charges are much easier to document and traceable than cash losses because credit/debit losses due to fraud can be documented. Good luck trying that with cash.

Having your credit card fraudulently used is not the same thing as experiencing financial losses due to misuse.

Here's what some legal minds have to say about it:
link title

If you pay by debit or write checks and a thief obtains your account information, your account could be wiped out, resulting in late fees on other payments as well as overdraft fees that will be up to you to dispute.

If you pay by credit card, there is less risk of being wiped out (I would say no risk), and the dispute process is as simple as a mouse click on the financial institution's website in most cases. 

ladybeachbum --- 12 years ago -

Totally agree. Keep any cash in your pockets and NOT in your purse! 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

Thanks to using credit cards for most of my expenses, reward points have enabled me to pay for lodging (for a family of 5) at a Disney resort for a full 7 days. This past summer, reward points paid for our lodging for a 10 day trip to New York.

If I had used debit cards, there would have been fewer reward points.

If I had paid cash over the year, I would have been paying more out of pocket (more in cash or cash value) than if I had used credit. Cash would have cost me more money over the year with the same spending decisions. 

Tylers Journey --- 12 years ago -

We are a cash only family. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Ogre13, I believe it should be a crime to give college kids a card.

Maybe, but I'm talking about basic education on finances. I never learned a thing about them and at your son's age hosed my credit up big time. I'm much better now, but I don't consider myself overly knowledgeable about financing and money.

But age isn't necessarily a factor. Now that my M.I.L. has passed and we're going through her estate, we're finding that she had over $60k in credit with four cards...one of them she had a $20k limit. She made about $24k a year. Now these cards are going to want to come after the estate, I'm sure (we're not there yet). But I intend to fight them ALL in court on the theory that giving that much credit to someone on a fixed income IS predatory and while my M.I.L. should have known better... the bloody credit card companies D@MNED WELL should have known better! Far as I'm concerned it's one step away from being a loan shark. 

daveyjones --- 12 years ago -

Warren, I never mentioned getting into debt one time in my post. What I said is not exclusive to people in debt. It happens to the best of us, I assure you.

Ladybeachbum, you have fallen for the "You need credit to buy things" fallacy. We buys cars with cash. We save and then buy. Weird!!!! When you need to borrow money for a house, for example, there is a thing called manual underwriting that has to be done by the lender. It's the "old" way they used to do it before the great and mighty FICO was born. And if you want to give the young people "great" advice, you might instead tell them to save money up and pay cash for their things. Nobody is guaranteed a job that allows for the payment plan you signed up for when you bought the item. 

Warren Peace --- 12 years ago -

You ever wonder if maybe we're doing our kids a disservice by not having a required class in how finances work in high school?

We are definitely doing them a disservice by not teaching them any basic life skills in school. If we really care about helping our lower income population, we would not be focused on costly programs that merely throw a portion of the money at them or at the institutions like schools were we would like to believe they get an education.

We should address the content of what we're teaching and should stop valuing the degree of our care by the dollar amount we spend. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground