Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The question nobody wants to answer

who's talking here?

smartypants 2
wayward1 1
d:-] 1
SoupIsGoodFood 3
SleightOfHand 1
Perfection 3
jtcitrus 1
JohnLynch 2
TexasOma 3
JustAskin' 3
Work in Progress 4
Clovis 2
FabFive 12
a672999uu 2
Ender 44
JAMS 11
Emperor of Kingwood 20
DVaz 1
EarthyBrie 1
Not KU 14
MissPris 8
Sweet Cherub 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ender --- 13 years ago -

How does a Republic like the United States survive the growing entitlement culture that exists today?

For simplicity's sake, i would like to ignore all other issues that plague us and focus on this one in particular.

We have created an entire culture of welfare dependent citizens that have ZERO motivation to remove themselves from the government dole, and without fail vote for the politician that promises to maintain or improve their way of life.

Just as a though experiment, suppose you are in charge. As the ruler of this situation, what do you do to keep the working people motivated to support the ones getting entitlements? 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

Remember, you have to solve this without turning this into a socialist society.

You have to explain why some people should work for a living when over half of their peers do nothing and are rewarded for it.

Why should ANYONE go to school to be a teacher? When i get home i can post sources (they arent hard to find), but when you combine medicaid, food stamps, tax liabilities, and other entitlements you quickly reach the 35-40k/year mark of total welfare benefits

Why go to school and become a productive member of society? 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

How does a Republic like the United States survive the growing entitlement culture that exists today?

it can't... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Nostradamus moment...........

"You're soon to be called a racist".

That is all........... 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

"You're soon to be called a racist".

Dang it, now you ruined it.

Now it is not going to happen because they don't want you to be right. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

It has been about a half hour, and still no responses.

Sure, the Veterans day thread gets liberals spouting their garbage, but if you ask them directly you get no answer.

I am genuinely interested in somebody answering the specific question asked in this thread. No generic Repuke bashing, no nonspecific flaming, just answer the darn question. I sincerely hope somebody can answer it, because like it or not this is the situation we are in now. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Well for one thing if the gvt is giving you money, you should be required to earn it. I'm not sure how to implement that, but I do think all things should be earned. Teaching people that basic necessities are free does nothing to help them. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

FabFive, do you mean that in some cases instead of freely giving benefits, the government should provide some kind of employment? 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I guess. I'm not really sure if it should be considered employment. Maybe more like community service. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

Patriot - can you break down by percentage what you mean by entitlements.

Can you put some numbers and more detail on your definition of the "entire culture of welfare dependent citizens that have ZERO motivation to remove themselves from the government dole" 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I took that to mean generation after generation of families. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

Here is a couple of sources that put it together.

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/356317/welfare-better-deal-work-michael-tanner

0 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

Jeez.. sorry that is so big, but that map is from Forbes

http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2013/09/02/on-labor-day-2013-welfare-pays-more-than-minimum-wage-work-in-35-states/ 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

FabFive, do you mean that in some cases instead of freely giving benefits, the government should provide some kind of employment?


They did after the Great Depression - the WPA put people to work. It was a government project and people worked for what they got. But, back then, it was a different work ethic. People WANTED to work. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

Keep in mind, the data shown on the map DOES NOT take into account all of the extra money that people can get for dependent's (read: more kids)

Each child adds a substantial amount of benefits 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

I took that to mean generation after generation of families.
That is correct.

When i say welfare culture I am talking about the groups of people who actively work the system to get as much money out of the government as possible. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

Just as a though experiment, suppose you are in charge. As the ruler of this situation, what do you do to keep the working people motivated to support the ones getting entitlements?

First I would recognize some can not work. Weather its a handicap, skill, or mental abilities. Second I would recognize wages have been stagnant since the 70's and cost of living has risen and the gap has spread to the dis-advantage of the regular worker. So recognizing the problems at hand. I would do away w/minimum wage and replace it with a living wage that stays with the cost of living. I would generate my infrastructure from the tax base of the workers as it is now. For those that cant work, would receive benefits paid by the top %. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

There was a video going around on Facebook about 2 weeks ago with a young female (was going to call her a lady but ladies don't sponge off society) who was bragging about how much she gets from the government and how they wangle to keep more of the monies they get. She said in the piece that I wouldn't pay for her or her friends to go to work - they make more off the government.

I wish I could find that YouTube that was floating around & paste it here. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

MrMark

So you would take a two pronged approach to the issue.

1. Weed out the ones that are able to work and keep those who are unable

2. Institute financial regulations to address the ever increasing income disparity between the upper and middle class.

3. Have only the top % incomes pay for the ones unable to work


Interesting, thank you for your answer. Let me know if i misunderstood what you meant to say.


Any more? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

For those that cant work, would receive benefits paid by the top %. 

Thats happening now. what are you going to do when money leaves the country? 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

The notion that all liberals sit online and jump on every thread is ridiculous. But, you know that.
Sorry that no one jumps when you say jump. You'll get over it.

But I'll play. The dirty nazi, fascist, communist liberal is here to take the bait ( because let's admit it, that's all you're doing!)
I have a feeling that any answer given you won't be acceptable, however.

The "welfare" situation in the country, on the surface, is alarming.
There are many able bodied Americans who either chose not to work, or they're unable to find suitable work (by this, I mean it's not realistic for someone to take a job that pays less than what it might cost for a babysitter, for example.)
The solution? Better wages. I'm not suggesting that a burger flipper should make as much as a judge, but the current minimum wage is no longer acceptable.
Multi-billion dollar corporations like McDs, as an example, can afford to pay their employees more. Period.
No, the government is not responsible for forcing corporations to increase pay to their employees, but can we not agree that this *could* be a part of the solution?

The average person would have to take in all "entitlement" programs - WIC, unemployment insurance, welfare, food stamps, etc. in order to receive monies equal to professions like a teacher.
Most don't. The ones that do are very few and far between.
So while it's easy to bash welfare people, claiming they make $40k a year, those people aren't the norm.


A large percentage of Americans on government assistance are working. Many are single parents and military. Many are elderly. Many are children.
There are a lot of Americans who are barely surviving. Certainly you aren't suggesting that we cut every single assistance program - then what?

Welfare isn't confined to a race, either. Statistically, there is a fairly equal number of blacks and whites using the system.
It isn't confined to political views as there are many democrats and republicans on assistance.
It's easy for republicans to say liberals are moochers and begging for "Obamaphones" but you know that isn't accurate. Greed has no limits; people of all races, religious affiliations, sexual identity, etc. choose to abuse the system. Long term, it won't help them.

I have a hard time answering your question though because
I. DO. NOT. HAVE. AN. ANSWER.

And apparently neither do you. Or Congress. Or Obama. Or anyone on Kingwood Underground.
It's all conjecture, spin, and what ifs.
The only solution I've ever seen here is "cut them off," but again I ask...what then?!?

I can say however that I do not need motivation from the government to work. I'm a lifelong liberal (who did not vote for Obama either time) and I have always worked.
I served in the military and married a military man.
Working for me is a great sense of value and integrity and aside from a few periods I chose to be a "housewife" I've always worked.
Welfare could never, ever provide me the life I want.
I realize my values were taught to me by hard working parents, and it's unfortunate that not everyone is as fortunate as people like me; I do not sit and stew over the choices they're faced with, however. I do me. I let them do them.

I did a college research paper on WIC abuse. It was of course an A paper, but being in a military town, in a classroom full of military members or their spouses, I was really condemned. My focus point was military members who abused WIC.
It's hard not to be angry when you see someone in line at the commissary, using WIC to obtain milk and cheese, and then climb into a Lincoln Navigator. We all know how much the military makes and from my vantage point, it was a gross misuse of the system.
My husband was an E4 when we had twins (and had three young sons too) and for three months, we used WIC. The expense of formula was extreme for two babies, and we weren't financially prepared for the cost. For the three months we were using WIC, we created a budget and stuck with it, and mostly due to pride and embarrassment of relying on the government to feed our children, we quickly got off.
I don't condemn anyone who truly needs help, short term, but absolutely, long term abusers should be ashamed.

So...I guess there is my half cocked contribution to your question...I won't be responding for awhile because I'm working from home (the life of a recruiter!!!!) and dealing with a sick child.

Since you're asking for everyone else to answer, I'm sure you'll share what you would do. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Mark you are all for redistribution of wealth. I don't think that works long-term. Also raising minimum wage makes everything else go up so it doesn't really solve the problem. A McDonald's meal is going to be $15 and the McDonald's employees are still going to br making $15/hr. It doesn't work. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

don't want to go look it up - but I think the last numbers I saw on entitlements was that over 90% was made up of the elderly, disabled, and the working poor in the form or Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, and unemployment insurance. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

 I would do away w/minimum wage and replace it with a living wage that stays with the cost of living. I would generate my infrastructure from the tax base of the workers as it is now.


Thank goodness you will never be in charge. Do you have any idea what your ideas would do to the value of the dollar and inflation? Then, do you even the slightest clue what that would do to investment? Finally, due you any clue what that would do to the cost of manufactured goods? From what online high school did you learn your economics? 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

The other most important thing is to cut out waste and fraud. This is going to mean new people coming in every year or so, so that people don't get complacent or take bribes. They need to find waste and fraud and reward those that find it. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I don't think anyone minds your three months of WIC, Jams. I think it's the long term usage that people get upset by. Food just isn't free. You specifically put long term "abuse" but to me long term use is the same as long term abuse. If you don't have a plan to feed yourself or your kids in a year from now, that's abuse. 

Ender --- 13 years ago -

So...I guess there is my half cocked contribution to your question
JAMS

Thank you for your input
(hope the kid feels better)
Not even close to being "half cocked", if found it to be well thought out. And yes, i will offer up my pathetic solution as well after we get some good discourse going. (not that it means much)

I would also like to highlight the fact that you mentioned the difference between your Liberalism and the crap that is coming out of "mainstream Liberals" today.

That is something that I will keep in mind as it reflects the difference between actual conservatives and the "legitimate rape" retards we have "representing" us in politics. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Why do men throw around the R word so freely? Most women cringe really bad when they hear it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

The notion that all liberals sit online and jump on every thread is ridiculous. But, you know that.

I know for a fact that they avoid certain threads on purpose.

Yay Texas thread 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Statistically, there is a fairly equal number of blacks and whites using the system. 

No, 28% of the black population, 6% of the white. 

DVaz --- 13 years ago -

Food stamps & other such free benefits should be time-limited and more difficult to obtain. Find a job or find a dumpster to find your food! This excludes legitimate disabilities and certainly wounded veterans. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Bob.............. his posts BLOW YOUR MIND........... don't they? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Multi-billion dollar corporations like McDs, as an example, can afford to pay their employees more. Period


Most McDs are franchised and not corporate owned. McDs has a responsibility to its shareholders to maximize profits. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Minimum wage was never intended to be a living wage. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"The notion that all liberals sit online and jump on every thread is ridiculous. But, you know that.
Sorry that no one jumps when you say jump. You'll get over it.

But I'll play. The dirty nazi, fascist, communist liberal is here to take the bait ( because let's admit it, that's all you're doing!)
I have a feeling that any answer given you won't be acceptable, however. "

Here you go JAMS, do us a favor please :P

0undefined 

Sweet Cherub --- 13 years ago -

Why do men throw around the R word so freely? Most women cringe really bad when they hear it.

retards we have "representing" us in politics.

Not just the 'r' word FabFive, but using the word 'retard' to put people down truly makes me ill. As the mother of a special needs child, and someone who has worked with these children for 15 years, it is unbelievably offensive! 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

The question nobody wants to answer


42 

JustAskin' --- 13 years ago -

Multi-billion dollar corporations like McDs, as an example, can afford to pay their employees more. Period.

McDonald's name gets thrown around a lot in these discussions, but no one ever seems to know the facts. The VAST majority of McDonald's are owned by individual franchise owners. They are individuals that more than likely have a family of their own to support. They put out ALL the risk, ALL the money, and ALL the effort to get the business started. If something happens to the business such as a fire or theft (and employees can sometimes be worse than someone from the outside) or a major event that causes a halt in the economy, the business owner is the one who assumes all the loss. The employees may lose out some, esp if they are in positions of management, but the general employee has very little to NO loss.

And raising the minimum wage will effect ever small business owner out there. There will be fewer and few jobs, and huge corporations WILL be the only job providers out there because small businesses will not be able to survive. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

For nearly the past twenty years there have been both work requirements and lifetime limits with no "added benefits" for additional children (past two or three, can't remember exactly which) for people receiving welfare. Has the Welfare Reform of the '90s been successful? Does anyone have the numbers on that? I am curious if it was deemed a success. I think 17 years should show if it's worked or not. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

FabFive, thank you for calling that out. I hate that word and I lose all respect for people when I hear them use it. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
politics
work


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground