Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Assisted Suicide For Emotional suffering?

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
Polly Ester 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 17
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 16
needsleep 1
I AM Innocent 10
Emperor of Kingwood 12
mutton 6
epic fail 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I thought this was so sad, and thought provoking.



"Painless death' or 'precipitous cliff'? Transsexual chooses euthanasia after failed operation"

By Alexander Smith, NBC News contributor

A high-profile case of a Belgian transsexual who chose to be killed by medical euthanasia after a sex-change operation turned him into a "monster" has highlighted the soaring number of people in the region electing to die this way – and has raised fresh questions over the controversial practice.

Nathan Verhelst, born Nancy, gave an interview to a local newspaper hours before his death this week citing his "unbearable psychological suffering" – rather than a terminal or degenerative physical illness – as his reason for dying voluntarily.

"When I looked in the mirror, I was disgusted with myself. My new breasts did not match my expectations and my new penis had symptoms of rejection. I do not want to be... a monster," Verhelst told Belgian newspaper Het Laatste Nieuws, referencing his double mastectomy and surgery to construct a penis last year.

Verhelst, 44, was killed by voluntary lethal injection on Monday according to local media reports.

Euthanasia, the act of a doctor directly killing a patient, is becoming more popular in Belgium and the Netherlands, which along with Luxembourg have all legalized euthanasia in the past 10 years and are the only three countries in the world where the practice is legal.

A "euthanasia kit" available in the 250 Belgian Multipharma chemist shops for the general practitioners who want to practice euthanasia at the patients' homes.

Last week the Dutch government released figures showing that in 2012 there were 4,188 cases of euthanasia or assisted suicide, or almost 1 in 30 deaths, while in 2011 there were 3,695 such cases – a yearly jump of 13 percent. Most of these were by lethal injection and the majority were lethal injections given to patients in their homes.

Far fewer people are killed in this way in Belgium, but government figures released earlier this year showed 2012's total of 1,432 represented a jump of 25 percent and a tenfold increase since it was legalized in 2002.

Bioethicist and NBC News contributor Arthur Caplan, Ph.D., said he has been following Verhelst's case with concern.

"When you move away from the realm of terminal illness, toward judgments about suffering, you are starting down a very dangerous path and one that's extremely slippery," said Caplan, who is a professor at NYU Langone Medical Center.

"Suffering is very subjective; you do not have any line or boundary. Who's to say, 'That's enough suffering?' And making an assessment on that is very, very hard," he said.

Rita Marker, executive director of Patients Rights Council, a secular anti-euthanasia group based in the U.S., said Verhelst's case represented a "precipitous cliff."

"Protecting the barriers between caring for someone and killing them is very important. And if suicide is offered to vulnerable people, like in this case, it puts them at tremendous risk," she told NBC News.

Verhelst's euthanasia procedure was carried out by Professor Wim Distelmans, a cancer specialist who late last year performed another widely reported euthanasia on two twins who were born deaf and were going blind. The twins said they feared they would not be able to communicate with the outside world and had nothing to live for.

Distelmans has defended the procedure, telling the U.K.'s Daily Telegraph newspaper there was a full psychological assessment of Verhelst and the euthanasia was carried out on the grounds of "unbearable psychological suffering." He said the case clearly met the requirements of the law.

For some advocates though, the law may hardly even matter.

Tom Curran, European coordinator of pro-euthanasia organization Exit International, says his 60-year-old partner Marie has multiple sclerosis and if she wants to end her life "I will help her, regardless of the law," he said.

Curran, who lives in Ireland where the practice is illegal, has just lost a high-court battle to let him help his partner die and is fully aware he will be prosecuted if he does so." 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

euthanasia

a subject too hot 2 handle

very sad that the entirety of her life was centered on a penis, how does one get to that place?

its too deep for me, I do not have the answers

U'd think they wud try and counsel em fore they off em but it almost looks like they enjoy offin em 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I think this person was in DEEP emotional pain, had gone through multiple surgeries and it seemed to have failed. Very disheartening when it affects every area of your life and the fixes are more of the same.

But is that a reason to want to die? 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

But is that a reason to want to die?

that's the thought provoking part u mentioned

all we no fer sure is they wanted to die over this

that is powerful feelings 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I think it's a personal choice and if they feel they can no longer live with out suffering or making someone else suffer and they want to end it who am I to say no? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Too bad criminals don't chose that over raping, robbing or killing others. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

But is that a reason to want to die? that's the thought provoking part u mentioned


I think he felt it was completely warranted, he was depressed, and that's what depression does. Steals every ounce of joy so all you see is the negative.

I don't think from a non-involved point of view it was warranted. I hate thinking someone that age who wasn't ill or disease ridden, felt there was nothing to live for. That's so very sad.
I can't help but think there were things he could do to live. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

And I guarantee you God didn't want him to die. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

And I guarantee you God didn't want him to die.


How do you know? Doesn't your god speak ill towards people like him? Maybe that was a part of the problem. He was an abomination in your gods eyes wasn't he? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

How do you know? Doesn't your god speak ill towards people like him? Maybe that was a part of the problem. He was an abomination in your gods eyes wasn't he?

So, you think God WANTS him to die?? You are hard to please. When someone says something about God you don't like, you diss them. When someone, like me, says something positive and good, you still aren't happy.

Have a margarita! 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

TUT

u r looking at the wrong god
the GOD of the Bible loved Verhelst more than words could describe or more than our mind could understand. 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I don't agree with euthanasia in any form besides a terminal, non curable illness. If I knew I was going to die I'd like to choose the when and how. But I don't agree with deciding to end your life just because it didn't turn out the way you envisioned it. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

I dont think she was a true transgender. I think he was rejected by his mother for being a girl and was tortured emotionally by her. his mother sounds like one sick woman.

his mother:

'When I first saw "Nancy", my dream was shattered. She was so ugly,' she told Belgium's Het Laatste Nieuws. 'I had a ghost birth. Her death does not bother me.'

She said the farewell letter that Mr Verhelst had written to her explaining his reasons for choosing euthanasia had not yet arrived, adding: 'I will definitely read it, but it will be full of lies.

'For me, this chapter closed. Her death does not bother me. I feel no sorrow, no doubt or remorse. We never had a bond which could therefore not be broken.'

Hours before his death Mr Verhelst had spoken of how, as a child, he 'was the girl that nobody wanted', describing how his mother had complained that she'd wished he'd been born a boy.

Rejected by his parents as a girl, he became a tomboy and later a lesbian. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

That's so sad. :( 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

That's so sad. :(

Dorothy his story was sad
his mothers story is sadder still

so terribly sad was both stories 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

His mother is sick in the head and ruined her child....horribly tragic and I bet he really was suffering. Rejection is a hard emotion to deal with but when it came from his own mother from birth onward? Terrible!

Very sad story and I hope Mr. Verhelst is finally at peace... 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

Rejection is a hard emotion to deal with but when it came from his own mother from birth onward? Terrible!


Its incomprehensible

hurts too much to think how it can even be 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

she was a victim of cruel child abuse. if the mother felt that way at the time of her birth you can only imagine how little love and nurturing she felt.

I think she tried to become a boy so her mother would love her. when that didnt make any difference to that wicked woman, she did not feel any point in living.

her mother wasn't even sad or guilt ridden when she died. how pathetically sad. even out of shame you would think that woman have pretended to feel something toward her child when she learned she had died, but she was brutally honest that she was not sad about her own child's death.

I dont know how I feel about her having assisted suicide. while I can totally understand that even her attempts to become a male only brought her self loathing, and her despair might have resulted in suicide anyway, maybe the right kind of counseling could have prevented it. I dont think it was the kind of depression that is brought on by a chemical imbalance that is hard to treat. the root of this seems pretty obvious.

it is just a shame the mother did not put her baby up for adoption and given her a chance at a real life where she could have been loved. the mother is the one guilty of killing her even if she didn't administer the life ending drugs.

I hope she is at peace now. I dont think she ever considered herself a man, even after surgery. 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

0
The mother of the Belgian transsexual who chose euthanasia after a botched sex change left him a 'monster' says she's 'not bothered' by her child's decision.

Nathan Verhelst, 44, died on Monday afternoon after being allowed have his life ended on the grounds of 'unbearable psychological suffering'.

Mr Verhelst, who was born a girl named Nancy, before his death told how he had been an unwanted child - a pain which had affected him deeply that was today confirmed by his mother. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I think it is everyones most basic human right to decide when they do not want to live any longer for whatever reason they want. There is such a concept as being tired of this life and being anxious to move on. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Its sad that this man or woman was in so much pain that he felt he couldnt go on. To some, there is no way out. 

needsleep --- 13 years ago -

A "euthanasia kit" available in the 250 Belgian Multipharma chemist shops for the general practitioners who want to practice euthanasia at the patients' homes.

This sounds so bizarre and I can't get tasteless advertising on the marketing of the kits and career to be euthanasiaologist. This story is so sad...I am sure someone would have loved him unconditionally. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

I am sure someone would have loved him unconditionally.

Someone did!... Jesus

if only he had known, if only he had heard, if only someone had cared enough to tell him 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I am sure someone would have loved him unconditionally. 

Maybe that wasnt the issue. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

Maybe that wasnt the issue.

There is indeed a spirit associated with these things 

epic fail --- 13 years ago -

Correct me if I'm wrong but nothing in the story says she wanted to be a man. Like some people say they feel they are a man trapped in a woman's body.

It seems this was all done to try to make her mother happy. To try to please the mother.

God doesn't want anyone to take their own life.

Theuglytruth needs to stop talking such nonsense and blaming God for everything. This woman was obviously tortured by her mother for years. The woman was definitely going through some kind of spiritual warfare. Did she turn to God for help, we may never know. But until you truly know God stop speaking for him or about him. It's getting ridiculous that you pipe up and blasphemy the Lord just because you don't agree with someone else's beliefs. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -


So, you think God WANTS him to die?? You are hard to please. When someone says something about God you don't like, you diss them. When someone, like me, says something positive and good, you still aren't happy.



I think that your bible and a bunch of the religious people that follow it drive people like this and others who are gay to kill themselves on a daily basis. Your god is quoted from the bible as a way to shame and humiliate. Having a margarita won't change that. I'm sure you realize that fact. Not sure what you missed about my comment or if it's just that you don't think anyone should be able to point those facts out.

You said god didn't want him to die but the bible and it's followers assure that it happens. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I think that your bible and a bunch of the religious people that follow it drive people like this and others who are gay to kill themselves on a daily basis.

Funny, I didn't read a word about the Bible or religion having any place in his decision to kill himself:


"Nathan Verhelst, born Nancy, gave an interview to a local newspaper hours before his death this week citing his "unbearable psychological suffering" – rather than a terminal or degenerative physical illness – as his reason for dying voluntarily. "When I looked in the mirror, I was disgusted with myself. My new breasts did not match my expectations and my new penis had symptoms of rejection. I do not want to be... a monster," Verhelst told Belgian newspaper Het Laatste Nieuws, referencing his double mastectomy and surgery to construct a penis last year. Verhelst, 44, was killed by voluntary lethal injection on Monday according to local media reports.Euthanasia


So, your comment is about another topic, not this one. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I guess you don't see being gay, having your gender changed and the emotional impact being gay has on an individual and the damnation of the bible as tied together. I do. I think a part of the reason they would go through such a process in the first place is because of how they are treated as a result of Christian damnation. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Not crying on Sunday. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I guess you don't see being gay, having your gender changed and the emotional impact being gay has on an individual and the damnation of the bible as tied together.


What does it have to do with this thread and this topic?

You paint all of Christianity with your broad brush of hate, the very same thing you think THEY do. And while I agree there is a definite issue with what you say, I don't see that as an issue on this thread about THIS man and his decision to end his life.

Where does it say he was affected by religious condemnation?

Not every gay/transsexual experiences your particular cultural take on religion. Lots of people who aren't gay experience it too.LOL 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I think the culture in our country is more likely to use God as a tool to condemn homosexuals and shame them into suicide than in European countries.

I think this woman was tortured by her mother and that's what caused this. Whether the mother used God as a way to condemn her child is unknown. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I think the culture in our country is more likely to use God as a tool to condemn homosexuals and shame them into suicide than in European countries. I think this woman was tortured by her mother and that's what caused this. Whether the mother used God as a way to condemn her child is unknown.


Totally agree! 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I think the culture in our country is more likely to use God as a tool to condemn homosexuals and shame them into suicide than in European countries. 

I guess youve not been to or spent much time in European countries. The thought that someone would intentionally use God to shame someone into suicide is an absurd statement and reflects a general disdain for religious people. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

The thought that someone would intentionally use God to shame someone into suicide is an absurd statement and reflects a general disdain for religious people. 


I don't think they are intentionally trying to shame people into suicide. I don't think any religious group does that. However the result of that shame is the same wether intentional or not. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

You paint all of Christianity with your broad brush of hate,


Umm show me where I said ALL christians? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I don't think any religious group does that

Muslims kill gay people. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Umm show me where I said ALL christians?


All your posts focus on negative things only. Lets narrow it down. Show me anything you've said that reflects any positive things about Christianity?
To only point out the negative things is imbalanced and one sided. Hence the big picture is LOST.

Religion has many components that are man made and have nothing to do with God and the actions of MEN which often don't even reflect God in any way.


Again, still waiting for what this subject has to do with religion in any way? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

All your posts focus on negative things only. Lets narrow it down. Show me anything you've said that reflects any positive things about Christianity?
To only point out the negative things is imbalanced and one sided. Hence the big picture is LOST.

Religion has many components that are man made and have nothing to do with God and the actions of MEN which often don't even reflect God in any way.


Again, still waiting for what this subject has to do with religion in any way? 



Oh grow up and stop the butthurt. Show me one thread that stays 100% on topic. If you can't see the connection to being gay, suicide and religion I say you are not being honest. I have said a lot of things about Christians that are positive and I don't think all religious people are bad in fact quite the opposite. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground