Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: For the abortion rights proponents/opponents: an honest question.

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
SleightOfHand 1
Perfection 8
FANCY PANTS 3
jtcitrus 15
AwesomeTattooedDragon 9
JohnLynch 2
mom2dx 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 12
Dorothy Parker 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
needsleep 2
TinktheSprite 1
Just stuck 1
Emperor of Kingwood 9
witchywoman 1
Tootiefrog 1
Not KU 1
Texashley87 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: For the abortion rights proponents/opponents: an honest question.

If an assailant were to shoot a pregnant woman in the stomach causing the woman and unborn entity to permanently cease functioning, 1) could said assailant be charged with a double homicide, and 2) what criteria (if any) should determine whether or not the shooter could be charged with a double homicide?

1) No: The assailant could not be charged with a double homicide, thus the second question is irrelevant. Vote
 
 13.6% (3)
1) Yes. 2) the criteria should be based on whether or not the unborn entity is functional at the cellular level. Vote
 
 50.0% (11)
1) Yes. 2) the criteria should be based on some developmental milestone of the unborn entity being attained. Vote
 
 9.1% (2)
1) Yes. 2) the criteria should be based on the circumstances under which the conception of the otherwise functional unborn entity occurred, or similarly, on evidence or testimony establishing that the mother felt said entity's presence within her body was Vote
 
 4.5% (1)
1) Yes. 2) the criteria should be based on the likely viability of the unborn cellular entity without being having been housed within the mother's body at the time of the shooting. Vote
 
 13.6% (3)
1) Yes. 2) Other. Vote
 
 9.1% (2)
jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

If an assailant were to shoot a pregnant woman in the stomach causing the woman and unborn entity to permanently cease functioning, 1) could said assailant be charged with a double homicide, and 2) what criteria (if any) should determine whether or not the shooter could be charged with a double homicide? 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

please elaborate on your vote, be polite, and be thoughtful.

:) 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

I posted this because my FB feed had several comments/memes/stories on this issue (from both sides).

However, I feel neither side ever really comes to grips or states the fundamental differences in their positions. I'm curious to have a little bit of that discussion.

I will comment on my opinion of the options in a bit.


Also, I will lock this thread in a heart beat if it becomes counter productive. 

witchywoman --- 13 years ago -

Just change the sentence by making it harsher if you kill a pregant woman and fetus....and leave the "life begins at blah blah blah" to another debate.

So my response is none of the above. 

Just stuck --- 13 years ago -

Lock it! Do everyone a favor. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

If the fetus is in the last trimester and could be viable outside of the womb as their own person, I would consider that a double homicide.

If that's not the case, it would be a single homicide. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

what DP said- as soon as it could be viable on it's own- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

it already is a crime, though-I'm not sure what states- 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

If the fetus is in the last trimester and could be viable outside of the womb as their own person, I would consider that a double homicide.

If that's not the case, it would be a single homicide.


Ok, but if that's the criteria, is it desirable to have the moment that we become endowed with basic human rights tied to the progress of technology? Whether it's purely legal or we are defining "humanity", would we want a moving target for that moment? I accept the practicality of it, but its not satisfying imo...

- what if we successfully create a synthetic womb? , essentially moving the viability marker to just after conception? 

mom2dx --- 13 years ago -

Yes, it's already a law. It's called the Unborn Victims of Violence Act and it protects a fetus of any gestational age. It's recognized in over 30 states - I believe it's 36 states but I could be wrong on the exact number.

I think the Laci Peterson case is part of what prompted the passing of the law. Scott Peterson was convicted with double homicide for the death of Laci and their unborn son. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

this is such a sensitive subject subject, it's really hard to give an objective answer- I don't think there should be abortions after 5 months- I'm trying to give a legal answer to you- 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

Lock him up/Death chamber no matter what! 

needsleep --- 13 years ago -

what criteria (if any) should determine whether or not the shooter could be charged with a double homicide


Intent

I looked at it different angles. 10 weeks a fetus has 90 percent the autonomy of an adult..babies have survived being born before the 3rd trimester. I even read up on different charges, murder 1,manslaughter, etc. IMO more to the shooting needs to be answered. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I think it should be a double homicide because he caused the death of the mother and a child that she did not intend to abort. Instead of calling it a homicide that could call it a homicide an intentional unlawful abortion of another person but really its just mincing words so that lawyers don't turn it around and f something else up. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Yes, it's already a law. It's called the Unborn Victims of Violence Act and it protects a fetus of any gestational age. It's recognized in over 30 states - I believe it's 36 states but I could be wrong on the exact number.


We've had those kinds of cases here already too.

Interesting, but if a woman gets shot and and she's pregnant and they both die, it's still two lives lost. Not sure how you can get around that...the people left behind to mourn will have lost 2 family members. How can you tell one set of family of a woman say 10 weeks pregnant that one life won't be recognized but a woman 30 weeks pregnant will? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

it's a very tough question- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

it's very hard not to think with your heart- 'cuz I really think abortion should be reserved for extreme situations, not BC, so how can I answer this? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

If a pregnant woman gets into a car accident and has a miscarriage, is anyone charged with vehicular homicide? 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

number 2 would be correct since the cells are functional at conception 

needsleep --- 13 years ago -

If a pregnant woman gets into a car accident and has a miscarriage, is anyone charged with vehicular homicide?

Was the accident caused by another driver who could have avoided the accident? Drunk driver I would call it that. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

DearestTattooedDragon --- 18 min ago - quote - hide comments

it's a very tough question-


Very 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

it's a very tough question-

Very 


not if you believe in Jesus 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

If a pregnant woman gets into a car accident and has a miscarriage, is anyone charged with vehicular homicide? 


I think it depends on whether or not the accident is a result of drugs, alcohol or intentional reckless driving by either driver. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

If a pregnant woman gets into a car accident and has a miscarriage, is anyone charged with vehicular homicide?

I think you were going for "Vehicular manslaughter".

And I agree that it would hinge on some kind of negligence, intoxication, or depraved indifference... 

Texashley87 --- 13 years ago -

Double homicide. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

So, if a pregnant woman engages in behaviors that harm the unborn, could she be charged with endangering a child? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Bob in Texas --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments
So, if a pregnant woman engages in behaviors that harm the unborn, could she be charged with endangering a child?



Great question. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

You can actually call it either one...but if you want to argue semantics over the point, that's fine.

Can anyone cite a case where a person was charged with a crime when a pregnant woman miscarried as a result of a car accident? 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"If a pregnant woman gets into a car accident and has a miscarriage, is anyone charged with vehicular homicide? "

Possibly. It depends if the at fault driver's actions were deemed grossly negligent 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

Interesting, but if a woman gets shot and and she's pregnant and they both die, it's still two lives lost. Not sure how you can get around that...the people left behind to mourn will have lost 2 family members. How can you tell one set of family of a woman say 10 weeks pregnant that one life won't be recognized but a woman 30 weeks pregnant will?

I have to agree here...

Is a miscarriage any less of a trauma to an expectant mom at 12 weeks than 30 weeks? I would think not. So a loss is a loss. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like folks are saying a person could be charged with a crime unless its the mother herself doing the harm. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Why aren't pregnant women allowed to use the carpool lane if she's alone? Why is she only charged admission for one person? Why does she only pay one co-pay at the doctor's office?

Why in some cases is she treated as one person yet in other cases, they are two separate people? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Conviction in unborn babies death. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

And I agree that it would hinge on some kind of negligence, intoxication, or depraved indifference... 


Agreed 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Laws regarding fetal homicide by state 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Good read WhyWhyWhy. Tks for posting. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

So, if a pregnant woman engages in behaviors that harm the unborn, could she be charged with endangering a child?


Yes. I thought this was already a law...Didn't that young woman who drove drunk and got in an accident get charged with that?? I can't remember now. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Perfection trying to stir the pot again? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Why in some cases is she treated as one person yet in other cases, they are two separate people?


I think it's b/c society hasn't found a way to draw lines that distinguish evenly across the board in all these situations with any continuity.

And laws/limits have a tendency to come from social activism...like Row v. Wade, for example.

I think when/if someone sues to allow preggo women to use the carpool lane, you'll see a determination.

But, again, what we have happening is one law determining a fetus is an viable entity to be considered and another situation where it isn't...no consistency. And IMO, there never will be if everyone wants the freedom to do what they want. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Perfection trying to stir the pot again?

By agreeing with your article and thanking you for posting it?

Huh? Now thats just confusing. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground