Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ding Dong Doma's Dead

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
randyjet 1
Perfection 1
Agent of Change 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
JohnLynch 5
kari.kolo 9
In AbsentiaW 2
hard shell 1
Four Pinocchios 1
JAMS 1
GeorgiaPeach 2
Loki 1
Ogre13 17
Gigolo Bloodline 2
oh no 2
Plain Bellied Sneetch 1
UR fake conservatives and moro 1
Polka Dot Duck 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

Not only did I write an article about this topic today, but I started a petition.

I know this is Neo-Con Neverland, but...Given the importance of the decisions reached on this day, I think that June 26th should become as big a holiday for the LGBT community as any. In fact, I have created a petition at Whitehouse.gov requesting just that. Go! Sign it! Forward this link to your friends, to your enemies, to strangers in the street. We have a month from June 26, 2013 to get 100,000 signatures. Good luck to everyone!

Freedom and Equality Day Petition:
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/freedom-and-equality-all-day/Y6ZQv3bW

Also, go like the Freedom and Equality for All Day Facebook page, I’ll be posting updates there.

https://www.facebook.com/FreedomAndEqualityForAllDay?hc_location=stream

You post hate... I will block you. You post vitriol, I'll do what I can to get your prosecuted under Texas' Cyberbullying laws... so just don't do it.

BTW.. that's Tx. Penal Code § 33.07 

Four Pinocchios --- 13 years ago -


You post hate... I will block you. You post vitriol, I'll do what I can to get your prosecuted under Texas' Cyberbullying laws... so just don't do it.



lulz. you iz scary! 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

Dude--their vitriol in the name of the good book suits KKKU just fine. 

Polka Dot Duck --- 13 years ago -

Oh dear. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

.

the SCOTUS said today that citizens in Texas and 38 other states can still "discriminate" against gay marriage all day long

For that matter, so does the First Amendment

Cyberbullying?! lol - that's funny

. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

No, Pinocchio, I'm not scary. I'm a big ole' teddy bear. But I can be a S.O.B. when need be and I find it's best to warn people.

Kari, look up the law. It's not funny, it's Statute. And yes, the Prop 8 decision was narrow and applied only to California, mainly because the MORMON CHURCH doesnt' have standing. However, the DOMA decision covers the entirety of the Federal system.

States CAN still decide to define marriage any way they want, but the decision against DOMA will be used as precedent when the first case against a state definition gets decided. And with Stare Decisis, the SCOTUS tends to support its own conclusions. When that happens, all such silliness ends.

We have bigger problems than a bunch of old geriatric men and women worrying about who is marrying who. It's time for this government to focus on what really IS their job, and not trying to force their religious faith on everyone. 

GeorgiaPeach --- 13 years ago -

But they can fly to CA which has no residency requirement and get married there. I'm so very happy for all my gay friends. 

GeorgiaPeach --- 13 years ago -

We have bigger problems than a bunch of old geriatric men and women worrying about who is marrying who. It's time for this government to focus on what really IS their job, and not trying to force their religious faith on everyone.

AMEN!!! 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

Me too, Georgia. BUT the topic that still interests me more than gay marriage...is gay divorce.

I a couple of friends who went to Canada to get married years ago now. Then one cheated. You can get married in Canada by staying for three days...but you can't divorced unless you've lived there a year. So what do you do?

The same it true or similar for many states in the U.S. that have marriage equality.

It's a big hairy mess that needs to be resolved. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

.
But they can fly to CA which has no residency requirement and get married there. I'm so very happy for all my gay friends.
.


the Feds may recognize it, but Texas does not

in any case, gay marriage is no more "Constitutional" today than it was yesterday

. 

Gigolo Bloodline --- 13 years ago -

in any case, gay marriage is no more "Constitutional" today than it was yesterday

Somebody has their feathers ruffled for nothing then. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

LMAO now talk about silliness 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

But they can fly to CA which has no residency requirement and get married there. I'm so very happy for all my gay friends.

so you are happy for their eternal future...how sad 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

gay marriage is no more "Constitutional" today than it was yesterday

You're right. It's always been Constitutional. Equal Protection Under the Law is the concept that has made it so.

It's simply been unrecognized up to this point.

What the SCOTUS decision did was end the FEDERAL ban on same-sex marriage.

What Kennedy said in the decision was: "The federal statute is invalid, for no legitimate purpose overcomes the purpose and effect to disparage and to injure those whom the State, by its marriage laws, sought to protect in personhood and dignity, by seeking to displace this protection and treating those persons as living in marriages less respected than others, the federal statute is in violation of the Fifth Amendment."

Based on that argument alone (I have not read the full opinion nor the desents as of yet), while THIS decision was specific to DOMA (and the law is nothing if not specific) it is not a far cry for the SCOTUS to apply the Supremacy Clause to the FIRST case of a state law coming before them and overturning every single one of them in one fell swoop for being in violation of the 5th Amendment.

It may be years before that happens. The system while generally sure, is also very slow. But with the long-standing concept of Stare Decisis, that is, the supporting of the decisions the court has already made, you can rest assured, that is what would happen. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

You're right. It's always been Constitutional. Equal Protection Under the Law is the concept that has made it so.

nope...not true 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

In case anyone is wondering, I blocked Lynch years ago and don't really give a rats butt for his opinion.

But if any of you wish to respond to him, and I can't imagine why you would want to engage him other than to ridicule him, please, feel free. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

.
in any case, gay marriage is no more "Constitutional" today than it was yesterday

Somebody has their feathers ruffled for nothing then.

.


lol

gays think these cases changes their lot in life - it clearly doesn't

yeah, in the 11 states in the US that recognize gay marriage, married gays can get federal benefits, but even that can clearly be overturned at the state level if the state legislature passes laws banning gay marriage

even in California, Prop 8 really isn't "dead" - the SCOTUS simply said that the pro-Prop 8 side lacked legal standing because Gov Moonbeam didn't fight in Court for the 52% who supported Prop 8 in 2008. That could change with a moderate governor and new court filing

. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

I'll check out your blog. I like your rational and pragmatic type of thinking.

Oh, and I also took a quick look at your wife's cooking blog. very cool. And her first set of favorite books are also mine.

"Stranger in a Strange Land" of course got a lot of attention, but "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" was underrated by many. Lots of interesting concepts about freedom from tyranny (and other stuff) in that one. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

[i]It may be years before that happens. The system while generally sure, is also very slow. But with the long-standing concept of Stare Decisis, that is, the supporting of the decisions the court has already made, you can rest assured, that is what would happen. [/i

the 10th Amendment trumps Stare Decisis, as the majority clearly ruled today

. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

Kari,

gays think these cases changes their lot in life - it clearly doesn't

It does actually, in very specific circumstances, but it does.

The throwing out of the Prop 8 case: If you live in California and your marriage was negated by Prop 8, it very much affects your life. If you are gay and live in California and WANT to get married, then it very much affects your life.

As to DOMA: If your husband is about to be deported because your gay and your marriage isn't recognized, it certainly does. And yes, a NY judge today stopped deportation proceedings on a couple.

That's just TWO examples, I'm sure I could come up with more. How about if you're a gay federal employee, married to your partner...You have been denied benefits for that partner since the Clinton years. Not so any more. That ALONE will be huge.

So yes, there are MANY people who will be directly affected by this ruling. Will they be in Texas? Probably not, unless it's a federal case like the one above.

And on what theory do you think the 10th trumps Stare Decisis, which is the cornerstone of ALL legal theory? Without Stare Decisis, all else falls flat. BTW... Majority Rules... in some cases, yes. But in this case the SCOTUS overturned the law, which means that Civil Rights are not subject to the tyranny of the Majority. And rightly so. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

GoodTimeCharlie,

Thanks! You'll either love it or hate, there's very little in between.

Stranger is like a Bible to me and I do love Moon is a Harsh Mistress... Heinlein in general is one of both my and my wife's favorite authors. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

even in California, Prop 8 really isn't "dead"

It effectively is overturned. Since the plaintiff didn't have standing, when it makes its way back to the lower court, the court will have to do one of two things: Make a 2nd "standing" determination (which I don't see changing unless they attach some new plaintiff to the case), or dismiss it for cause.

Again, at not time should civil rights EVER be decided by the Tyranny of the Majority. EVER. That Constitution is designed to protect everyone, including the least of us from those that would force their wills upon us.

And I can GUARANTEE you that the last thing Prop 8 supporters want to happen is for yet another of their cases wind up before the SCOTUS... those old farts get cranky when that happens. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

Stare Decisis: Latin for "to stand by things decided." Stare decisis is essentially the doctrine of precedent. Courts cite to stare decisis when an issue has been previously brought to the court and a ruling already issued. Generally, courts will adhere to the previous ruling, though this is not universally true. See, e.g., Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey, 505 US 833 (1992).

And since the SCOTUS is the arbiter of all things Constitutional, I would argue that Stare Decisis trumps EVERYTHING. With the caveat that all decisions are made with the Constitution and Bill of Rights at the forefront. That's their bloody mission statement, their entire purpose.

That's not to say they don't change their minds, they do. But even in their WORST decisions, i.e. Dred Scott, Plessy v. Ferguson... it was DECADES before they changed their minds. Which sadly means that Citizen's United will likely stand through my lifetime...what a travesty that is. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

unfortunately, it wont stop gay bullying, but it's a start! YAY!! 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

unfortunately, it wont stop gay bullying,

I have a whole different set of solutions for that! 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

Again, at not time should civil rights EVER be decided by the Tyranny of the Majority. EVER. That Constitution is designed to protect everyone, including the least of us from those that would force their wills upon us.

if it was a Constitutional civil right, the SCOTUS would have said so today - it didn't

it would have been as if the pre-Civil War Slaughterhouse cases were overturned, but only for 20% of the states

instead, the SCOTUS clearly said states don't have to recognize gay marriage if they don't want to

in fact, the SCOTUS specifically let the part of DOMA (Section 2) stay intact which says states don't have to recognize gay marriage from other states

Gay marriage is not a US Constitutional right - the SCOTUS reaffirmed that today!

. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

if it was a Constitutional civil right, the SCOTUS would have said so today

Uh, No. The SCOTUS DID Say so. It's called EQUAL PROTECTION and they addressed it. No where does the Constitution specifically address marriage, but then, no where does the Constitution address specifically MANY things. For instance, no where, NO WHERE does the Constitution address specifically a Right to Privacy...and yet, it is considered one of MANY implied rights. Of which there is oodles and oodles of case law in support of our implied rights.

What the SCOTUS addressed today, and I've already quoted Kennedy above, is the RIGHT TO BE PROTECTED EQUALLY BY THE LAW and not be singled out arbitrarily for arbitrary reasons.

AND AGAIN, I think it's already been said that the DOMA decision was specific to a FEDERAL law. SCOTUS allowing DOMA sect 2 to stay intact does NOT indicate an actual opinion on sect 2, what it really indicates is that sect 2 was not considered in the court of origin. And in this case, the SCOTUS can only consider what was considered in the Court of Origin (In the original case...United States v. Windsor.)

HOWEVER, I predict it won't be long until someone gets tired of the issues created by having multiple laws related to marriage and brings suit. Possibly even under the Hague Marriage Convention which normalizes marriage laws in 74 different countries, including the United States.

IN THAT CASE, the lower courts may not even hear it. As this is a TREATY, The SCOTUS could very well be the Court of Origin. If that happens, then you can say goodbye to marriage restrictions on consenting adults of any stripe. 

UR fake conservatives and moro --- 13 years ago -

Let the celebration begin...


0 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Butthurt still strong!!!!!!!

DOMA is dead!!! Hahaha!!!! 

Polka Dot Duck --- 13 years ago -

on the 8th day --- 4 min ago - quote - hide comments
Let the celebration begin...


 

8th day are over the line with that one. 

Agent of Change --- 13 years ago -

Ogre - Great to see you back!

This is a wonderful step in advancing equality for all!! 

smartypants --- 13 years ago -

at not time should civil rights EVER be decided by the Tyranny of the Majority. EVER.

Amazing that in this day and age, this is STILL a difficult concept! There seem to be huge numbers of people here who think Paula Deen's plantation wedding ideas are merely quaint, for example. Today, I give thanks, for checks and balances! 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

What the SCOTUS addressed today, and I've already quoted Kennedy above, is the RIGHT TO BE PROTECTED EQUALLY BY THE LAW and not be singled out arbitrarily for arbitrary reasons.


remember that DOMA was signed by Bill Clinton and a Democrat-led Congress

regardless, equal protection does not protect gay marriage because as you said, marriage is not mentioned in the Constitution. That's why the SCOTUS has always deferred to the 10th amendment and states rights as it relates to marriage. The court reaffirmed this today

The Hague Marriage Convention won't apply because gay marriage is still only recognized in 15 of the 195 countries in the world

. 

oh no --- 13 years ago -

It's time for this government to focus on what really IS their job, and not trying to force their religious faith on everyone.


The government does not recognize marriage because of religious reasons first of all. The government had to step in because men were leaving their "wives" and children, remarrying, and leaving the kids with no money and the women were now marked. There was an epidemic of women and children living on the streets with no education and the man was not required to pay support by law. The US Government came in and defined marriage between man and woman because a child could result from that union...a child that needs to be protected and cared for. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

.

..a child that needs to be protected and cared for

.



then that certainly can't be referring to gay marriage

. 

oh no --- 13 years ago -

child that needs to be protected and cared for.then that certainly can't be referring to gay marriage


I even put in there... between a man and a woman... 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

actually...doma isn't dead...just one section of it 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

actually...doma isn't dead...just one section of it

yep - but doesn't stop them from lying that it's been declared "unconstitutional"

lol

. 

Plain Bellied Sneetch --- 13 years ago -

even that can clearly be overturned at the state level if the state legislature passes laws banning gay marriage

Wrong. Under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, state laws cannot trump federal laws. So, moving from CA to TX would not affect a gay, married couple from enjoying the married tax benefits conferred under federal law, as but one example. Same thing for Social Security survivor benefits, etc. So, they have plenty to celebrate. 

Ogre13 --- 13 years ago -

DOMA was signed by Bill Clinton and a Democrat-led Congress

it's a bit more complicated than that, but yes, it was. It was a mistake then too.

The Hague Marriage Convention won't apply because gay marriage is still only recognized in 15 of the 195 countries in the world

Not relevant. 195 countries are NOT signatories of the treaty. How many SIGNATORIES recognize marriage equality. THAT's the question. And there are several. Nine which out and out recognize Marriage, another 12 (that's a bit MORE than 15, I'm afraid) which recognize some form of union. And one which calls it "unregistered habitation" - Croatia...whatever the heck that is. Every one of these countries ARE signatories of the Convention. So that's 21 (+1) out of 79 that recognize some form of gay marriage. Almost 38%. That's enough to cause a LEGAL issue.

But don't get hung up on the Hague Convention, that's just ONE theory that I find entertaining as a possible scenario. There are many, many others.

The court reaffirmed this today...

No. You're putting an affirmation in where there was not one. The courts DIDN'T CONSIDER IT, and in legal terms, that's completely different. Think of it like this... they rejected the shrimp at the buffet and didn't even consider the oysters (with sect. 2 being the oysters) In other words, the neither supported, nor rejected it, they simply ignored it (which by default, leaves it, or any law in place unless it is fatally flawed by the overturning of the other section). Which, I said above, quite clearly I thought.

Yep, there it is.. Read again, SLOWLY for comprehension:

AND AGAIN, I think it's already been said that the DOMA decision was specific to a FEDERAL law. SCOTUS allowing DOMA sect 2 to stay intact does NOT indicate an actual opinion on sect 2, what it really indicates is that sect 2 was not considered in the court of origin. And in this case, the SCOTUS can only consider what was considered in the Court of Origin (In the original case...United States v. Windsor.)

IN GENERAL the SCOTUS is not allowed to consider things willy nilly. They are GENERALLY, except in the cases of Treaties or cases against officers of the United States, NOT a Court of Origin. They can only consider what is put before them. Since Section 2 was NOT part of the original case, they cannot consider it and MUST, by law, leave it intact (Again, barring some fatal flaw resulting from the overturning of the other section.)

DOMA has, in part, been declared unconstitutional. I would argue that the IMPORTANT part of DOMA has been gutted, that is the FEDERAL restrictions. Without them, then we do fall back to the 10th Amendment. BUT the 10th Amendment is NO PROTECTION against the SCOTUS at a later date being presented with arguments against Sect 2 and their overturning it.

It's happened before, on numerous occasions... I.E. SLAVERY. CIVIL RIGHTS ACT. Just about everything having to do with the blasted Commerce Clause...ad infinitum, ad naseum.

So It's just a matter of time. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground