Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Go to foxnews.com to see the new info on Flight 800

who's talking here?

randyjet 11
AngieKaye 6
latemom 2
Aah Grasshoppa 1
In AbsentiaW 2
Dorothy Parker 3
gunsnroses 3
kwgraniteguy 9
Loki 1
Badger1950 3
Beachbum 1
Superunknown 3
Sphincter 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

gunsnroses --- 13 years ago -

Very troubling news about this ! 

latemom --- 13 years ago -

My friend Amy Miller was on that flight. Her and her husband Kyle were going to Paris to celebrate their 5th wedding anniversary. I will never forget that night watching it on the news. The shock. Her sister posted a link to this on her FB earlier today. 

Sphincter --- 13 years ago -

It is becoming harder and harder to ignore the corruption of our government.

When will we have enough? 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

This is nothing but a ploy on the producers to draw attention to their upcoming special.

Who but FAUX News would feature this?

As Hilary said, "What does it matter?"
The idea is to find out what happned so it won't happen again. [and it hasn't happend again, has it?]

Let's reopen the Kennedy killing too. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 13 years ago -

It does matter if the truth was covered up. 

gunsnroses --- 13 years ago -

obviously inabsentia is too ignorant to understand factual reporting on Fox News. It absolutely does matter. Especially if this is another cover up. I never believed the story about the fuel tank exploding.  

gunsnroses --- 13 years ago -

obviously inabsentia is too ignorant to understand factual reporting on Fox News. It absolutely does matter. Especially if this is another cover up. I never believed the story about the fuel tank exploding.  

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

I never believed the story about the fuel tank exploding.

As a retired Captain and former ALPA accident go team member, the NTSB findings are more than plausible. I have not had a chance to look at the new theory yet. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

WOW you mean another coverup by the impeached President Clinton... SAY IT AINT SO! :/ 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

BTW this story was just aired on ABC... so those thinking Fox is lying... well guess ABC is too. 

Beachbum --- 13 years ago -

So what happened then? Did we blow it up ourselves? 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

So what happened then? Did we blow it up ourselves? 


Good question 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

As a retired Captain and former ALPA accident go team member, the NTSB findings are more than plausible.

As a retired captain myself, with over 15,000 hrs, I have to disagree with the NTSB findings on the cause of the explosion. You obviously have more knowledge and experience in this than I, but the thing that disturbs me the most is the stretch they did to avoid any hint that an external cause was at fault.

I do not accuse the NTSB or the FBI of bad faith and cover-up, but I do think that they came to their conclusions tailored to political needs rather than facts. The problem is that they dismiss any FACTS that do not fit their theory.

For example, there were a number of ex military or military pilots who reported SEEING a missile track the plane. I take those sighting to be a good as GOLD. THAT for me is a FACT. it is not for the NTSB.

Then they try and dismiss a missile based on falacious tests which neglect any scenario which will be consistent with the findings on the airframe. For example, one guy I saw on TV said that they found no explosive pattern on the skin of the fuselage. There does NOT need to be such, nor does there have to be a hole where a missile hit. We all agree that what brought the plane down was the center wing fuel tank exploded. To do that you only need a small part of flaming debris from a missile explosion in the air behind the #2 engine cowl to produce a shading from the main pattern, or even a near air burst from the self destruct feature as it neared the missiles limits. A part of flaming debris no bigger than a match would be sufficient to bring the plane down.

They leased an Evergreen B747 to run tests on various scenarios for the systems that they theorized could cause the spark. From what I have read, they failed to produce such a spark or ignition source. But no matter, they said it MUST be the source, no matter that they could not duplicate the events given the evidence as shown in the wiring harnesses. If you say that table salt is flamable, and run tests to make it burn, and it doesn't,you do NOT then claim despite all your efforts that it IS flamable.

My best guess is that it was a shoulder fired missile that exploded in proximity or hit the aft part of the #2 engine. All that was needed was a small piece to enter the tank and that is the end of story. From what I have seen of the wreckage, they most certainly did NOT have enough to show that a small piece did not penetrate the fuel tank. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

but the thing that disturbs me the most is the stretch they did to avoid any hint that an external cause was at fault.

I have looked through the NTSB report for flight 800 but haven't given it the scrutiny I have of other reports, so I had not noticed that. I do find the official version still to be plausible though. I did get the chance to view the video at Fox and given the choice between believing NTSB vs. FBI I would likely take NTSB. The one thing in this case that always gave a little question in the back of my mind was that the CIA did the failure analysis video, that just seemed odd.
I was aware there were eye witnesses as to the missile trail but was not aware many were military and ex military pilots, I would definitely give them more credibility than Joe Bystander. I remember an Eastwind 73 driver was interviewed, 800 was vectoring around Eastwind, I don't recall him claiming to have seen a missile trail but only an explosion.
What type of missile would be available other than a warship in that area? I do remember that being a theory at the time.
This is going to get interesting, time to pull out the report. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

a warship in that area

bingo 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

What type of missile would be available other than a warship in that area? I do remember that being a theory at the time.

That was a BS thing since there is NO possible way on a US Navy ship with hundreds of sailors on board could keep such a thing secret. The missile would be a US Stinger and TWA 800 was well within its range from a small boat in the Sound. Which some people said that they had seen. The CIA gave out Stingers like candy when they armed Bin Laden and his boys. After the war they tried to get the ones they did not use back, with a buy back program. It was not a big success.

There are lots of other types out on the market too with even better range. There is one country that had enough motive to sponsor such an attack and who would NOT want to publicize it, Iran. Since we shot down their Airbus over the Gulf and killed about the same number of people, my guess is that they finally returned the favor. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

What type of missile would be available other than a warship in that area? I do remember that being a theory at the time.

That was a BS thing since there is NO possible way on a US Navy ship with hundreds of sailors on board could keep such a thing secret. The missile would be a US Stinger and TWA 800 was well within its range from a small boat in the Sound. Which some people said that they had seen. The CIA gave out Stingers like candy when they armed Bin Laden and his boys. After the war they tried to get the ones they did not use back, with a buy back program. It was not a big success.

There are lots of other types out on the market too with even better range. There is one country that had enough motive to sponsor such an attack and who would NOT want to publicize it, Iran. Since we shot down their Airbus over the Gulf and killed about the same number of people, my guess is that they finally returned the favor. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

This got posted before I wanted to. The FBI and the NTSB had great political reasons to fight against the missile theory. It would NOT do air transport any good if people realized that a terrorist in a rowboat could take down a 747. It was just bad luck that TWA got nailed. The easiest thing to stop such a thing would be to put about 1000# in the center tank and that would put the stoichiometric mix too rich to go bang. It would also act as a good heat sink to keep the fuel cooler and below the flash point. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

Think about this. The American government doesn't want to pay all those families for a mistake that happened. So they covered it up. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

In the grand scheme of things, if a cover up were to occur, it would be to prevent mass panic and the economic back lash that would hit the airlines if it was deemed unsafe. I doubt a monetary payout to those families even made it to reason number 5, if a cover-up really did take place. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

It was easier to blame the airplane then to put blame on the government. I also remember rumors back then of a training accident, that our guys were training on missles and hit the plane. Everyone blew it off as a conspiracy against the government. Well it would be a shock if most of these old conspiracy theories start coming to be the truth. 

Superunknown --- 13 years ago -

Who but FAUX News would feature this?

Looks like other news outlets are featuring it:

Washington Post 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Yes, but most (all) conspiracy theories aren't true. It's like saying wouldn't it be shocking if Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny were real?

Yes...shocking and impossible. 

Superunknown --- 13 years ago -

Think about this. The American government doesn't want to pay all those families for a mistake that happened. So they covered it up.

I don't think the government cares about spending OUR money... 

Superunknown --- 13 years ago -

Opps, we can't track down 9 trillion dollars.

.

 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

Opps, we can't track down 9 trillion dollars.


it paid for all those "vacations" the obaminations have taken 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

There are lots of other types out on the market too with even better range.

Does a shoulder fired really have the range and accuracy? They were out of 10 or 11 cleared to 15 when they exploded. Missiles are not my forte'.

it would be to prevent mass panic and the economic back lash that would hit the airlines if it was deemed unsafe.

I remember the fallout of 9/11, we were laying off crews and parking aircraft, fortunately it didn't get up to my senority. Not a happy time in the industry. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Exactly....so, if there was a cover-up, that's why.

I hate to think of someone with a hand held weapon, able to take down a plane full of people.I also believe had something like that happened, the sicko doing it, would want full credit.

If it was a military accident, I think we would have heard about it long before Fox News reported it 17 years later. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

If it was a military accident, I think we would have heard about it long before Fox News reported it 17 years later.

I agree, I don't buy the military exercise theory, but had discounted shoulder fired as out of range. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

I remember the fallout of 9/11, we were laying off crews and parking aircraft, fortunately it didn't get up to my senority. Not a happy time in the industry.

I was one of the first flights back into LGA after 9/11. I had ONE pax on boaard and the WTC was still burning. When I landed, the terminal was deserted and I ran into another US Airways pilot. I told him remember how we were complaining about all the delays? Well we don't have that any more. It was the fastest I ever got in and out of LGA. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

I agree, I don't buy the military exercise theory, but had discounted shoulder fired as out of range.

Look up Stinger missile on wikipedia and check out the range. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

Look up Stinger missile on wikipedia and check out the range.

Wholly Crap FL250. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

Think about this. The American government doesn't want to pay all those families for a mistake that happened. So they covered it up.

The US government would not have to pay anything for TWA 800. They had insurance enough to cover the loss. Unlike Texas where you can have a hazardous business and have no insurance and let the people of Texas pay for your company's screw up. That is called being business friendly, but people unfriendly. Too bad most voters are too stupid to figure that out and keep voting for Guv for Life Perry. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

I was one of the first flights back into LGA after 9/11. I had ONE pax on boaard and the WTC was still burning. When I landed, the terminal was deserted and I ran into another US Airways pilot. I told him remember how we were complaining about all the delays? Well we don't have that any more. It was the fastest I ever got in and out of LGA.

I remember those flights had a few with one or two and some with none. My October schedule was reduced to one R/T a week on Sunday eve. What was really creepy was my house was literally across the street from the outer marker for 36R in CLT, so I heard airplanes all day every day, silence is very odd when you used airplane noise around the clock. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

Wholly Crap FL250.

As the DHL 757 proved in Iraq even a direct hit by such a missile will not bring a plane down unless it is unlucky as TWA 800 was. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

As the DHL 757 proved in Iraq even a direct hit by such a missile will not bring a plane down unless it is unlucky as TWA 800 was.

After I left the airlines I turned down an offer from Ryan Air, one of those you know someone, ground school starts Monday deal. Just could not do the Bagdad one arrival. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

Just could not do the Bagdad one arrival.

I loved doing those kinds of approaches when I was flying air freight, but of course, dodging bullets and missile would take some of the fun out of it. When I flew out of OAK in PA-31 and BE-99s, we had the 29 approach. We would come in on a right downwind, the tower would clear us for a short approach, so we would drop gear, flaps, just at the end of the approach lights, and make a steep diving curving approach from 1000' altitude. I mentioned to the controllers that I loved doing short approaches, and they told me they loved watching us do them. Until the president of the company came by one afternoon and watched our performance. HE was NOT charmed at all End of fun. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

Reminds me of the old J 31/32 days in CLT, we had a similar approach we called the "slam dunk". Started at 10K abeam the numbers, went to flight idle and pushed over to 250KIAS, about 6K FPM. About 2500 MSl pull into a chandelle and start throwing flaps and gear, the goal was to hit the touch down blocks. Fun Fun times. If done right no one in the back ever noticed. 

randyjet --- 13 years ago -

Reminds me of the old J 31/32 days in CLT,

The J-31 was without question the worst turboprop I ever flew. It was a turbine powered equivalent of the Apache, an accident waiting to happen. I loved the SF-340 since I could do that with it and since the cabin was always pressurized to sea level or takeoff altitude all the way up to the service ceiling of 25,000', you could really dump it without any ear discomfort. The Junkstream gave me more gray hairs than any other airplane, bar none. It was underpowered, lost pressurization easily, had the stiff landing gear, would not heat the cabin in winter with just the packs, you had to preheat the cabin, and I got Jetstream knee since I am 6'5" and the seat would not go back far enough, so my knees were always pressed against the rocker switch panel of the instrument panel. AND it had NO lav, which was lots of fun for pax on a 2.5 hrs flight from YYZ to CMH. I hated that plane! I always said that the worst plane I flew was the SA-227, UNTIL I flew the J31. THAT was even worse. 

Badger1950 --- 13 years ago -

AND it had NO lav, which was lots of fun for pax on a 2.5 hrs flight

At Eagle, we flew the Super 32 that had the -12 powerplant ... huge improvement over the 31's that had the -10 / -11.

Our's were outfitted with lav's in the rear that made it nice for passengers. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground