Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Born that Way

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
Fiona 1
sunshine1881 4
SoupIsGoodFood 2
ghostpost 2
Polly Ester 5
Hiro Protagonist 1
believer 11
Warren Peace 4
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 19
It is I WhyWhyWhy 16
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 10
Defcon1 2
Nurse Ratched 8
waterfall 1
JAMS 2
Emperor of Kingwood 3
Job 40 4 3
OneEyedManRedux 17
Smoochie and The Bean 1
The Day I Tried to Live 1
Plain Bellied Sneetch 3
Tootiefrog 1
WinstonC 1
publicserviceA 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Parents sue South Carolina for surgically turning child into a female
By Holly Yan and Joe Sutton, CNN
updated 6:35 AM EDT, Wed May 15, 2013


"M.C." was born with both male and female organs
As a baby, he was in state custody when doctors removed his male genitalia
The child, now 8 years old, is living as a boy and refuses to be called a girl
The state social services department and a hospital spokeswoman decline to comment

(CNN) -- The adoptive parents of a child born with male and female organs say South Carolina mutilated their son by choosing a gender and having his male genitalia surgically removed.

The surgery took place when the child was 16 months old and a ward of the state, according to a lawsuit filed by the parents against three doctors and several members of South Carolina Department of Social Services.

The child's biological mother was deemed unfit, and the biological father had apparently abandoned him, according to the suit. So others made the decision.
The child, now 8 years old, feels more like a boy and "wants to be a normal boy," his adoptive mother said.
"It's become more and more difficult, just as his identity has become more clearly male, the idea of that mutilation was done to him has become more and more real," Pamela Crawford said in a video released by the Southern Poverty Law Center, which is assisting in the case.

"There was no medical reason that this decision had to be made."

Marilyn Matheus, spokeswoman for the South Carolina Department of Social Services, said the agency does not have any comment on the pending litigation.

The defendants named in the suit also include doctors from Medical University of South Carolina and Greenville Memorial Hospital.

Sandy Dees, spokeswoman for the Greenville Health System, said she could not comment because of the litigation.

Assigned to be a girl, but identifying as a boy
The child, identified in the lawsuit as "M.C.," refuses to be called a girl and lives as a boy. His family, friends, school, religious leaders and pediatrician support his identity.

"We just let him follow his instincts as much as we can," his adoptive father, John Mark Crawford, said in the video.

Pamela Crawford said performing gender-assignment surgery on a baby robbed her child of the ability to make the decision for himself.

"I would have never made the decision to choose the gender either way," she said. "What I would have been working with is how do we preserve as much functioning in either direction because we can't know what this child's gender identity is going to be."
The lawsuit claims doctors at a state hospital and Department of Social Services workers "decided to remove M.C.'s healthy genital tissue and radically restructure his reproductive organs in order to make his body appear to be female."

The suit says the surgery violated the Fourteenth Amendment, which says that no state shall "deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law."

The suit also asks for "compensatory damages in an amount to be determined at trial."

But the adoptive father said the real intent of the lawsuit "is just to uphold these constitutional principles -- integrity of a person's body, and some kind of due process for infants where people around them in power are considering doing surgeries like this."

Pamela Crawford agreed.
"I would give anything for this to not have been done to our child," she said. "I don't want it to happen to any more kids." 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

"M.C." was born with both male and female organs


Born with both male and female organs, yet people find it totally impossible to be born gay. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

I don't want it to happen to any more kids

Indeed, because we all know there is an epidemic in America of children being born with both sets of genitalia. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Indeed, because we all know there is an epidemic in America of children being born with both sets of genitalia. 


Seems like there are quite a few men on KU that have both. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Born with both male and female organs, yet people find it totally impossible to be born gay

By equating being born with both sets of genitalia and being gay, you seem to have reached a conclusion that being gay is a birth defect......

Interesting.... 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

its sad for him. he was taken from his unfit parents so right from the start he had it bad. you would think dna would have helped determined gender but I dont know that much about it.

I wonder if modifying him into a female surgically was an easier operation than the other way around and that is why that surgery was chosen.

it seems they should wait until the child starts demonstrating some gender specific behavior. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

it seems they should wait until the child starts demonstrating some gender specific behavior.


Bingo. Don't know why they felt the need to rush into such a major life impacting surgery. Makes no sense. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

By equating being born with both sets of genitalia and being gay, you seem to have reached a conclusion that being gay is a birth defect......



Of course it is a birth defect. I know people don't want to think of it that way but I believe it is. Doesn't change the fact that they are that way and cannot be changed and therefore should be allowed to live a normal happy life and be married just like anyone else who has a birth defect. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Of course it is a birth defect.

Well if we accept this conclusion, then why can it not be changed?

These days the wonders of modern medicine are able to correct all manner of birth defects in children, sometimes in utero.....

How wonderful that a child is given a chance at a normal life through early identification and treatment for their birth defects..... 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Well if we accept this conclusion, then why can it not be changed?



There are many birth defects that have no cure yet. It would obviously be wonderful if all birth defects could be corrected.

I'm sure there will be many who will argue against label it a defect. All humans have some type of defect. It may be a hormone imbalance, one leg shorter than the other, learning disability, what ever the case may be no one is without something. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

Bingo. Don't know why they felt the need to rush into such a major life impacting surgery. Makes no sense.

I am not condoning this at all. They should not have done anything like this until the child was old enough to determine which gender he/she associates with or feels to be.

Maybe they thought it would be harder to have this child adopted if there were two sets of genitalia. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

It would obviously be wonderful if all birth defects could be corrected.

I agree. We should,as a a society, work towards this goal..... And not leave any child to the burdens of their malformations due to a misplaced political calculation. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I agree. We should,as a a society, work towards this goal..... And not leave any child to the burdens of their malformations due to a misplaced political calculation. 


Politics have no place in this nor does religion. All humans should have the same rights regardless of someone else's feelings or opinions of them. 

Fiona --- 13 years ago -

All humans should have the same rights regardless of someone else's feelings or opinions of them. 

True! I do not believe for one minute that a person would choose to be gay. They are born that way.

Disability is the consequence of an impairment that may be physical, cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, developmental, or some combination of these. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

I do not believe for one minute that a person would choose to be gay. They are born that way.

If that is true, and most Gay advocates insist that it is, why is there not an outcry for research into correcting this problem??

Excellent and groundbreaking work is now being done with in utero gene therapy..... Would it not be possible to eradicate homosexuality? 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

Maybe they did the surgery because he would have been less likely to be adopted while having both male and female genitals 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

If that is true, and most Gay advocates insist that it is, why is there not an outcry for research into correcting this problem??


maybe because the people involved dont consider it a "problem" that needs correcting.

some might consider being left handed a birth defect too, but as a left handed person I wouldn't change it, even though at times it might be inconvenient. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

maybe because the people involved dont consider it a "problem" that needs correcting

And we have seen blind and or deaf parents that do not want their children to be able to see and or hear.... Is that ethical?

Sould we allow parents to stop a child from seeing or hearing, when a simple procedure could correct the problem at birth? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Excellent and groundbreaking work is now being done with in utero gene therapy...


How do you know that research is not being done? 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

How do you know that research is not being done?

Because GLADD is not protesting at the research site. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

How do you know that research is not being done?

Because GLADD is not protesting at the research site. 



rolling eyes 

voice of reason --- 13 years ago -

it seems they should wait until the child starts demonstrating some gender specific behavior.



total stupidity that they felt the need to make the decision at 16 months. they should be hung. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

How do you know that research is not being done?

Ok, you want a serious answer to that question???

Well for gene correction to be made the scientists would first need to know of the gene that causes the defect...

As far as I know, the gay gene has so far eluded discovery. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Well for gene correction to be made they scientists would first need to know of the gene that causes the defect...

As far as I know, the gay gene has so far eluded discovery.


..... and that's the end of the discussion.

Thanks for joining us! 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

Sould we allow parents to stop a child from seeing or hearing, when a simple procedure could correct the problem at birth?

define simple? some people think a cochlear implant is simple, but some parents elect not to have that procedure performed on their child. should they be forced?

again, there are different degrees of birth issues that some may consider a defect and some others may not.

it is possible that one day people will be putting in their order for a "designer" baby. Some of that science is already possible. Does that mean we should do it? it opens up an ethical can of worms.

maybe we will be able to get rid of red heads too...and freckles while we are at it.

maybe left handed people will will be a thing of the past and so will short men and even bald guys.

maybe one day we will all be born the same and all mutations and differences will be scientifically erased and diversity will be a thing of the past.

I don't put being born gay in the same category as being born deaf or blind, and I don't think many gay people would either. that doesn't mean that gay people dont experience hardships and perhaps some (or maybe even most-- I dont know) wish they were born hetro.

what is one person's "defect" though is another person's unique quality. I think it is an interesting conversation, but a slippery slope when we start defining individual differences as defects.

where do we draw the line? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

maybe we will be able to get rid of red heads too...and freckles while we are at it.


watch it now:))


what is one person's "defect" though is another person's unique quality. I think it is an interesting conversation, but a slippery slope when we start defining individual differences as defects.


Agreed and yet we are all defective in some way. That in and of itself makes us all the same. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

If we can get rid of left handed redheads, I'll be happy.

LOL


j/k 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

my curiosity got this best of me, so i decided to read a little about this condition.

this sort of blew my mind:
"Sometimes, the parents must choose whether to raise the child as male or female (regardless of the child's chromosomes). This choice can have a big social and psychological impact on the child, so counseling is usually recommended.

Note: It is often technically easier to treat (and therefore raise) the child as female (it is easier for a surgeon to make female genitalia than it is to make male genitalia), so in some cases this is recommended even if the child is genetically male. However, this is a difficult decision. You should discuss it with your family, your child's doctor, the surgeon, your child's endocrinologist, and other health care team members."


so if gender is just arbitrarily assigned based on ease of surgery or regardless of what chromosomal testing shows, then it should come as no surprise that the child would have gender identity issues if the toss of the dice went the other way.

I guess those making the decision that this would work out are of the theory that sexual identity is a "choice" and not a condition usually determined before birth. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Someone needs to chop their ***** off and tell them meh see a shrink everything will be ok.

Unbelievable 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

Why, why do you even bother? inevitably anything having to do with gender ends up with some people interjecting into the conversation that "gay" is a choice-no one in their right mind would not choose that life- but no amount of logic will ever convince those people,who want to believe it- 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

but no amount of logic will ever convince those people,who want to believe it-

I think Dragon, you need a little better understanding as to what comprises logical thinking.....

When thinking logically, one does not use a premise based on one's personal opinion, ie "no one in their right mind would choose that life", but begin with the known facts and create a logical chain of supporting statements to reach a conclusion.

If one begins the process with a premise rooted in nothing more than subjective belief, then the conclusion will not be sound. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

oh, thank you great sage, for explaining that to me-really, you need to chill, oneye- your opinion of gays, abortion and apparently everything else are just your opinions- everyone has them, just like something else- 

believer --- 13 years ago -

no one in their right mind would not choose that life-

??? 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

your opinion of gays, abortion and apparently everything else are just your opinions

Perhaps, but every one of my opinions has been subjected to a true logical thought process which I can replicate for the purpose of debate.....

You, however, continually subject us to opinions which you support only with conjecture, hearsay and feelings. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Seems like there are quite a few men on KU that have both. 

*spewing water*

Naaaaaa, that's being too generous. I've NEVER seen the likes of so many whiny boys than I have on here. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

maybe we will be able to get rid of red heads too...and freckles while we are at it.


NO!! I like being a red head. While all my friends are turning grey, I still have gorgeous, colorful hair.
I don't have freckles. Wish I did though! 

believer --- 13 years ago -

I do not believe for one minute that a person would choose to be gay.

People choose to be gay every day.

I wonder if modifying him into a female surgically was an easier operation than the other way around and that is why that surgery was chosen.

Hermaphrodites, although born with genitalia of both sexes, have only on functioning reproductive system. Maybe the child's only system was would be able to function was that of a female. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

typo, believer...like you didn't know that...ZZZZzzzzzzzzz 

believer --- 13 years ago -

typo, believer...like you didn't know that

Incoherent sentences can't be blamed on typos. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

LMAO!!!!! that what everyone of your sentences are!!!! 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground