Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Don't you hate when they base a movie on a book...

who's talking here?

Rubicon 3
Hiro Protagonist 5
moltobella 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 7
tinman 2
Dr Aborto 3
Work in Progress 7
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Feeling Blue 2
LitlJay 2
tredanis 1
BellaLaVie 2
Ashley87 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

and they change it so drastically that the movie is ruined for you.

I'm watching Silver Linings Playbook. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I wanna see that movie, haven't read the book, maybe that's better, lol. 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

Seriously. Don't read the book if you want to enjoy the movie. It's not even the same story. I don't think I've ever seen a movie be this different from the book. 

Feeling Blue --- 13 years ago -

The TV show True Blood is radically different from the books...once I read the books, I couldn't watch the show anymore. Now Game of Thrones is almost word for word...except on TV they throw a bunch of sex in there that isn't in the books at all. 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

The TV show True Blood is radically different from the books...once I read the books, I couldn't watch the show anymore. Now Game of Thrones is almost word for word...except on TV they throw a bunch of sex in there that isn't in the books at all.

I thought about reading the Sookie Stackhouse books but I wasn't into the show so I figured I wouldn't like the book. Now I might actually try the books out.

I tried to read Game of Thrones and it was really hard to get into. Same for the show. There was too much talking and not enough (fighting) action. :) 

Feeling Blue --- 13 years ago -

Yea the Sookie books are waaayyy better. They don't divert into all these other story lines, its written from her perspective. 

Rubicon --- 13 years ago -

Yep! Sometimes you just got to tell yourself it's not going to be like the book and just go and enjoy it like its a whole different story. 

Rubicon --- 13 years ago -

I hate to admit this, but I loved the Twilight series, and hated the movie. (I don't want anyone to think I'm one of those crazy Twilight moms.) None of the characters were as I pictured them in my mind and the acting was horrible. 

BellaLaVie --- 13 years ago -

Yes :/ They ruined Amityville Horror...
And Where the Red Fern Grows...
And Of Mice and Men.. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

there is nothing like your imagination! even if the movie completely sticks to script, your imagine is better!! was there a remake of Of Mice and Men? GREAT book-the only movie I've seen is a '30's movie, I think- 

Rubicon --- 13 years ago -

there is nothing like your imagination!

True, but wouldn't it be nice if you could project it into a movie?! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

oh, yeah!! I'll bet that's what the director was doing! 

BellaLaVie --- 13 years ago -

Of Mice and Men 1992 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

you're right- if Malkovich played Lenny, it was nothing like I imagined-noway he could have the empty, goofy but sweet look in his eyes that I pictured- 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

Don't even get me started on what they do to Tom Clancy and Elmore Leonard! Chili Palmer was such a better badass then even John Travolta could ever portray him as.

Who Framed Roger Rabbit also could not have been more of a bastardization of Who Censored Roger Rabbit. Not only was the book better, but everything from the storyline to the villain to the conclusion was changed. Spoilers (if you haven't read the book): Roger DID do it but was dead the whole time, Jessica never really loved him, and the villain was the Genie from the Arabian Nights. Christopher Lloyd was no where to be found. 

tredanis --- 13 years ago -

Best book to movie in my opinion - The Shawshank Redemption.

The book was "Rita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption". 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Best Book to Movie results?

The Shining
The Hunt for Red October
Shawshank Redemption
The Body....(Stand By Me)
Most of the Harry Potter movies
The Godfather


Worst Book to Movie results?

Lord of the Rings...Return of the King
The Hunger Games
All other Stephen King books not mentioned above
All other Clancy books not mentioned above


I am on the fence with Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. I loved the casting and the cinematography was incredible. I did not like the deviations in plot from the book. Overall though, I thought they did a credible job with the adaptation. 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

Most of the Harry Potter movies

I totally disagree with you on this one. I absolutely LOVED the books but the movies bored me to death! It followed the story pretty well but in my imagination there was more drama.

The acting may have been sub par in The Hunger Games but it followed the story so closely that I can't complain too much. It's probably not a movie I would watch a second time but I enjoyed it.


By the way, if you enjoyed The Hunger Games (book) you should check out the Divergent series. The author is Veronica Roth. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

"Justified" is a fabulous series! everytime anyone opens their mouths, I can picture it in an Elmore Leonard book!!! the humor and timing are uncanny!!! 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

"Justified" is a fabulous series! everytime anyone opens their mouths, I can picture it in an Elmore Leonard book!!! the humor and timing are uncanny!!!

Justified is a TV series? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

oh, girl!!! it's the best on TV!!!!! this is at least it's 3rd season!! we're in the middle of this season,now-try to find a way to watch it from the beginning- it's AWESOME!!! 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

I just looked it up. Interesting. I like the main character as well. I can't remember what I've seen him in but I remember liking him. 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

I just looked it up. Interesting. I like the main character as well. I can't remember what I've seen him in but I remember liking him.

He played the villain in the 4th Die Hard movie, as well as doing the voice of "The Spirit of the West" in Rango. He's also been in a lot of other flops or had small parts in bigger movies, like one of the detectives in the "Gone in Sixty Seconds" remake. 

Ashley87 --- 13 years ago -

I loved the movie The Notebook and that was based on a book .. Right? 

Ashley87 --- 13 years ago -

I think i am going to watch it with my Husband now lol. 

moltobella --- 13 years ago -

It was Ashley. I'm not a romance reader but someone let me borrow that book. I cried reading the book and watching the movie! 

Ashley87 --- 13 years ago -

We just finished watching it for the hundredth time :D I also love the movie Dear John 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

moltobella --- 12 hours ago - quote - hide comments

Most of the Harry Potter movies

I totally disagree with you on this one. I absolutely LOVED the books but the movies bored me to death! It followed the story pretty well but in my imagination there was more drama.

The acting may have been sub par in The Hunger Games but it followed the story so closely that I can't complain too much. It's probably not a movie I would watch a second time but I enjoyed it.


By the way, if you enjoyed The Hunger Games (book) you should check out the Divergent series. The author is Veronica Roth.





I understand what you are saying. For me, I look for the plot of the book and the movie to be identical. I want the details of the book acted out on screen. I do not want the screenwriters taking liberties with plot, characters, or location in order to make the movie seem more marketable.

If the book is good enough to warrant consideration for a screen play then the writer should be duty bound to follow the guide lines I stated above.

That's why I stated that the Harry Potter movies were faithful to the books.

Personally, I love seeing how my imagination and the film maker's imagination compare as well as the casting director. I love picturing famous people in the title roles in each book I read. Sometimes, the movie guys get it right, and sometimes they don't.

A great example of a casting director getting it right was Woody Harrelson as Haymitch in The Hunger Games. He nailed that role and I certainly hope he gets to reprise the role in the upcoming movies.

I totally disagreed with how The Hunger Games movie went from the point that the games began to the end of the movie. The producers were very loyal to the book up until that point. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

the character in "Justified" was in the other western that was on HBO- he was also the Marshall on there-about 150 yrs ago- he was fab on that, too- the main antagonist (lovable in an Elmore Leonard way) was on a police detective show, where they were all rogue, and got lots of Emmy nominations) and a lot more- 

Dr Aborto --- 13 years ago -

Aside from the Potter Books/Movies. The ONLY other movie I thought was as close to the source material was The Watchmen. Aside from like 3 little changes. It was an exact replica of the Graphic Novel.

 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

So what movies did you think were BETTER than the book?

The only one I can think of offhand is Kubrick's The Shining.

Kubrick took King's "meh" book and made it the scariest visual experience EVER in the history of film. And if you study all that he did with that movie, he added depth that just wasn't there in the book.

I'm sure there are others, but I can't think of them right now. 

Dr Aborto --- 13 years ago -

The only one I can think of offhand is Kubrick's The Shining.

YES YES YES. I read the book and was so disappointed, the movie was way scarier. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

Kubrick took King's "meh" book and made it the scariest visual experience EVER in the history of film. And if you study all that he did with that movie, he added depth that just wasn't there in the book.



That's funny. I love the atmospherics that Kubrick used in the film, but the book is much more in depth and has some fantastic elements that were left out of the film. (topiary animals, roque mallet, furnace etc.) 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

I wonder with that one, if it's a matter of which you did first. I read the book before I saw the movie, so the book was better to me. 

Dr Aborto --- 13 years ago -

So what movies did you think were BETTER than the book?

World War Z doesn't look like it will hold up to the book. The trailer already pisses me off because the zombies didn't act like that in the book.

Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter the book was kinda Meh. The best parts were not the vampire hunting but the actual historical facts. I haven't seen the movie but it wouldn't be hard to make it better than the book. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

the book's almost better- nothing can compare to your imagination! not even Nicholson! 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I wonder with that one, if it's a matter of which you did first. I read the book before I saw the movie, so the book was better to me.

I saw the movie first. Maybe you are on to something. I thought the book was boring. But the movie???? I STILL to this day check behind every shower curtain!

And I have an unnatural fear of twin girls. . .GAH!!!!! 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

And did you notice all of the Native American motifs in Kubrick's version?

It's kind of the unspoken statement--the slaughter of the hotel mirroring the slaughter that happened to the Native Americans. Kubrick was a film genius. Just brilliant. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

A movie that I think is better than the book, is The Princess Bride. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I love that movie! I never read the book, so I'll take your word for it.

And I've never read Victor Hugo's Les Miserables, but everyone tells me that the movie version (the recent one) is much better. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground