Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

To start Kinder or to not????

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
ToidBoid 1
momma0204 1
ProudNana 1
Jen 1
Fiona 1
sunshine1881 5
*JR* 1
My 3 and Me 1
Saturn 1
SpottedPuppy 2
Matalli 4
Polly Ester 4
Perfection 2
Mommyto3kiddos 10
latemom 2
ladyjane 1
BBBX3 1
luv2massage 1
mom2dx 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
Photomomof2 10
Dorothy Parker 10
itstxdaddy 10
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
IbarraFam222 3
WaitWhat 1
sheddy 1
gr8t2bme 1
snowprincess 2
FabFive 7
PokerFace 2
Semper 2
JAMS 1
Smoochie and The Bean 2
iteachpk 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Photomomof2 --- 13 years ago -

Any teachers on here to help or if anyone else has made this decision, would love any input.
My oldest boy will be 5 at the end of June. He has never been in MDO. I'm a SAHM and they are with me all the time. I'm terrified of throwing him into Kinder in Aug. I'm not sure if he is mature enough. We interact with other children almost daily with playgroups. I have been reading and hearing a lot of stories of teachers holding back children in Kinder b/c kiddos are not ready.
Anyone have any input or suggestions? We will probably start him in a summer program to see how he does.
Recommendations for Summer programs or a pre-school ? TIA. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I think if he's old enough, he should go. He will learn and mature while he's there. Unless he has some sort of cognitive issue, why hold him back?

I have a child who turns 5 in June, has never done MDO or preschool/daycare and she's going! I can't wait! :) 

Keystone --- 13 years ago -

Agree with DP. 

Photomomof2 --- 13 years ago -

I guess if he'll need the extra year anyways why put him in? I could start him in a pre-school to help transition easier. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Pines or another Montessori is a good option for a first experience. My dd was born in Oct so she was not eligible to start at 5 so we had to wait the extra year. It was well worth it because she is a pretty shy girl anyway. Now instead of being one of the youngest and more influenced she is one of the older kids. You son would be going off to college as a young 18. Depending on his readiness in maturity and academics I would wait. Unless he is super mature for his age and ready academically I would put him in Montessori for a year and let him get a good foundation and then start him in Kindergarden the following year. My too cents. Good luck. 

PokerFace --- 13 years ago -

If he's with you all the time, he knows the basics for sure. The thing I'd be concerned about is the adjustment period kids go through when starting any program. I think it's smart to get him in an MDO for the summer to get him accustomed to a school environment.

There are a ton of church programs- I know how intimidating it is at first- but do a search on here. People have recommended some good Kingwood MDO's. He may be very resistant at first, but hang in there, and good luck! 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

My wife was a teacher and we had the same situation for 2 of our boys. Both times we held them until they turned 6.

Both of them are flourishing, academically and socially.

There are several different schools of thought. Since my wife was a teacher, she felt that it was best for boys to be held back and it has worked out great.

As a side note, I wanted them in at 5, but she was able to convince me to wait and I could not be happier that she did. 

PokerFace --- 13 years ago -


I guess if he'll need the extra year anyways why put him in? I could start him in a pre-school to help transition easier.


You should do the summer thing, and see how it goes. He may just love it, and then you'll know! 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Why would he need an extra year? What does that mean?

If your child meets the age requirement and has no developmental delays, why hold them back? 

Matalli --- 13 years ago -

I have two boys who are now teenagers. I can tell you that 75% of their friends who were born in the summer months were held back. Therefore, they are a full year older than those that were born in the summer and went to Kindergarten on time. It makes a huge difference especially in middle school when the boys begin to go through puberty. In observing boys and how they interact, physical development and athleticism are king in middle school.

If it were me, I would find a very good Pre-K 5 program for him and wait for Kindergarten. I have a lot more I could say on this subject, so PM me if you would like to discuss it further. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

If your child meets the age requirement and has no developmental delays, why hold them back? 


Some times its a maturity issue. My dd was totally not ready and it would have been awful to send her. Traumatizing probably. She is a very shy kid and barely spoke at all in school until probably 2nd grade and then in an almost whisper. She was an off the chain freak and home but she just wasn't ready. I'm glad I was able to let her wait. Now she is in 7th grade and in almost all honors and excels in just about anything she does. She is still shy but not like she was. 

ToidBoid --- 13 years ago -

I started 1st grade when I was 5!!!! No kindergarten. . . went into my senior year of high school at 16. . .

Started college at 17 . . . and I lived! 

Photomomof2 --- 13 years ago -

Thanks. DP as researching many kids are not ready for Kinder at 5. Even though they are 5 they all develop differently and may not be ready.
Matalli- ill send you a pm. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

There is a "movement" to hold kids back until they are 6 for kinder.

Studies have shown that it gives the child a leg up on their peers socially, academically, physically, etc. And those gains are pretty lasting as they progress through school, just by virtue of competing with kids a year younger.

Of course, it only works if the majority of parents DON'T also hold their kids back.

I'm not sure how I feel about it. Well, I guess I do know how I feel about it. My soon to be 5 year old will be starting kinder this fall. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

If your child meets the age requirement and has no developmental delays, why hold them back? 

There is actual reasons to hold a child back who is not "ready for Kindergarten". For example Kindergarten is a critical year for young children, it truly sets the stage for their continued enjoyment and success in later grades. A child who is placed into Kindergarten when he/she is not ready could very possibly have a bad experience and develop a fear/hatred for school.

Having said that, if the child is placed with a teacher who cares, nurtures and meets the child's needs, the experience can be positive, which in turn would create a love for learning.

So basically it comes down to 2 things, are they ready and what type of teacher will the child be placed with.

You also have to keep in mind that between the ages of 5-7 children develop a WIDE range of abilities. Not all 5 year olds can do the same things and in fact, its not until the age of 7 that children all catch up to each other.

As a teacher my advice is simple, YOU and only YOU know your child, nobody other than you knows him. He has been interacting with children on a daily basis, I assume you have been reading to him and working on basic letter/numbers. My suggestion would be to maybe place him in a summer day camp situation a few days a month this summer. THe little gym has 3 hour day camps which are really cool, and I believe kids in action have them too.

Enroll him and start the separation in the summer , this way he will not be overwhelmed with both a new school, and also being away from you for the first time. See how things go this summer and then decide.

A few other tips would be to visit the school in April/May. The schools are more than welcoming and would allow you to tour the school. Judge his excitement.

Take a deep breath and relax, it will be an exiting experience for both. Just remember ultimately it does not matter what any of us say, you know your child best. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Where I grew up, being held back was a bad thing. It normally meant you couldn't keep up academically and had to repeat the same grade.

Obviously purposely holding them back before they even start is a different scenario. My son has a March birthday, he went to preK and started K on time with no issues. There's only three months between March and June...I don't see much difference there.

If what Matalli says is true, I think it's unfair where sports are concerned to have an older, more physically mature child on the same teams with kids of the same grade. If they are a full year older, they should be on an older team with kids their own age/size. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Studies have shown that it gives the child a leg up on their peers socially, academically, physically, etc. And those gains are pretty lasting as they progress through school, just by virtue of competing with kids a year younger.



Absolutely, this is what we studied closely during my masters program, but its up to each and every family. 

latemom --- 13 years ago -

Photomomof2 - I agree with the Pines Montessori thing. Theirs is not the typical Kindergarten. It goes by age. A 5 year old would be with other kids his age and then also 4yr olds. The older kids help the younger ones. Then when they turn 6, they go into a class that is 6yr olds to 9 yr olds. Again the older students help the younger ones. Small classes and great teachers. This at least would give you the chance to have him in "Kindergarten" but not your typical one. Then if he passes your test, you could put in any first grade next year or keep at Pines. Just a thought. My ds goes to Pines (I'm biased! LOL) and we couldn't be happier with his academic level and maturity there. Trust me, it was NOT an easy road to get here. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Obviously purposely holding them back before they even start is a different scenario. My son has a March birthday, he went to preK and started K on time with no issues. There's only three months between March and June...I don't see much difference there.

HUGE difference, at the age of 5, 3 months is a very very very big difference. I cant tell you how many of my students, especially those with late birthdays and youngest in the class left for winter brake in December still being babyish and returned in January acting like kindergartners. 3 months is very big. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Photomomof2 - I agree with the Pines Montessori thing. Theirs is not the typical Kindergarten. It goes by age. A 5 year old would be with other kids his age and then also 4yr olds. The older kids help the younger ones. Then when they turn 6, they go into a class that is 6yr olds to 9 yr olds.

LOVE the Montessori concept! 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Most moms of boys wait. Aside from the academics, it's a physical thing. If you hold him back a year he might have a chance in sports. It sounds like you really want to wait just wanted people to reaffirm you. I would just do whatever you want, without our opinions. I think that not putting him in a program this year was a mistake and if you don't do a summer thing it will be awful for him in kinder. That is a big leap. When my daughter went to PS we had her in a half day pk the year before to help adjust. Now we homeschool so it doesn't matter. Good Luck and do what makes you and him happy. No one else. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

so is it fair to put kids together who aren't the same age so one child can be "superior" to others?

I'm with Dorothy Parker on this one, a parent's job is to prepare their child to be ready at 5 not 6. Holding them back is not appropriate because the parent hasn't prepared the child to be ready for school. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Yeah but sports are by grade until high school. My other kids have First of the calendar year birthdays and it wasn't an issue.

For my other one since she turned 5 after the sept 1 deadline she couldn't go anyway but I still wouldn't have done it. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

so just start school for everyone at 6 to make it fair.

Would you hold your child to 7 then? 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

It sounds like you really want to wait just wanted people to reaffirm you. I would just do whatever you want, without our opinions. I think that not putting him in a program this year was a mistake and if you don't do a summer thing it will be awful for him in kinder.

I dont think she made a mistake, she did what she felt was best, telling a parent they made a mistake is a big deal especially when they are already worried about it. As a teacher if I ever told a parent they made a mistake I would have been fired. Suggestions always work best. Just my humble opinion. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Would you hold your child to 7 then? 

By 7 all kids are caught up to each other. Keep in mind most 5 year olds are ready, it may be those with late birthdays who are not. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

a parent's job is to prepare their child to be ready at 5 not 6.

not actually true. the law say the child can start at 5 or 6, so as long as the parent have their child ready by 6, they are good to go. 

latemom --- 13 years ago -

Having a class with kids of different ages (Montessori) works great. It is not about being "superior". It's awesome watching the older kids help the younger kids and actually teach them while learning themselves. It teaches the older kids responsibility, compassion, patience and the younger kids look up to the older ones and really work hard. They also know that one day they will be the teachers. Very cool to see and it works. The Montessori way teaches respect, not competition. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

I'm with Dorothy Parker on this one, a parent's job is to prepare their child to be ready at 5 not 6. Holding them back is not appropriate because the parent hasn't prepared the child to be ready for school. 

wow, that is a very weird way of thinking about it. Just because society says 5 is the age does not mean its correct. By the way did you know that kindergarten is not a requirement in Texas? these are the only states where kindergarten is required. So in Texas its not her job to have him ready by age 5.

Alaska

Arizona*

Delaware

District of Columbia

Florida

Louisiana

Maryland

Ohio

Oklahoma

Rhode Island

South Carolina*

Tennessee

Virginia 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

What I meant was this: if you want to put him in a full day program and he's never been away from you is a mistake. It just sounded like she's at the 11th hour on this and is now worried and scrambling.

I didn't mean it rudely and apologize if it came out that way.

Of she holds him back now she's got another year to work with, but expecting a child to go from 100% home to a full day of kinder is too difficult, in my opinion. I should have been more clear. Thanks for catching that. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Texas is required to have a kinder program, but parents are not required to send their kids. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 13 years ago -

Of she holds him back now she's got another year to work with, but expecting a child to go from 100% home to a full day of kinder is too difficult, in my opinion. I should have been more clear. Thanks for catching that. 

agreed! summer camp may be good too. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

photomom...at the very least, i would try to get him in some kind of school type program so he can adjust to the seperation from you a little easier. might just help to prevent the meltdowns i have seen...lol 

Photomomof2 --- 13 years ago -

I want to hold him back, my husband on the other hand is on the fence. We will defiantly start him in a summer program. I was looking at weekday Learning Center. I can choose 2 or 3 days a week. Anyone expierience their summer program?
I appreciate the feedback and opinions. I don't want to hold him back for sports he is already very athletic. He's played soccer at the Y and already knows how to swim, and can hit a throwing baseball. He is does very well. It's the maturity and academics that I worry about. 

snowprincess --- 13 years ago -

The most important thing about montessori is the kids are with the group they belong with SOCIALLY, but work at their individual pace academically. In my case my 4 year old is working on late K/early 1st grade work but with kids his own age. 

BBBX3 --- 13 years ago -

My child has a July birthday. SHE is the youngest in the class and has done well academically and socially. Don't think I would have held her back if she was a boy. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I think people that hold back for athletics do so for size, not just athleticism. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Holding back for athletics is 100% wrong, imo. It's like cheating on a test. 

Matalli --- 13 years ago -

ToidBoid, I also graduated and went off to college at 17. Most of my good friends were in the grade below me because they are the ones that I felt most comfortable with socially. I was an athlete, and competed at a high level even though I was a year younger. It was socially that I struggled. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I also think a child's personality makes a difference. My youngest is very outgoing and social...she hasn't been in any type of school, but we've done babysitting swaps with friends and she loves it. She loves people, so I don't think it's a mistake to go from being home with Mom to being in school all day.

If she was an only child or extremely shy or had some sort of cognitive or emotional issue, I might wait to put her in school..but, we face none of those issues and we're both excited for her to start school! :) 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

kingwood


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground