Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: should teachers be allowed to strike during the school year?

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
reh6110 2
txlady67 1
Perfection 6
Cookin' Queen 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
Warren Peace 7
combatkenpo 1
Banjos and Squealing Pigs 6
Longhorn Mom 1
Quicksilver Messenger Service 1
Kimberly 1
Tipsyhic 1
Dorothy Parker 1
itstxdaddy 1
Defcon1 1
justforfun1 2
Nightshade 1
I Love Reading 1
kwgraniteguy 1
LillyDivine 1
Tejas mom 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: should teachers be allowed to strike during the school year?

Yes Vote
 
 41.7% (20)
No Vote
 
 58.3% (28)
itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

i didn't vote because it all depends on their contract. if it is collectively bargained that they have the right to strike during the year, then yes they should be allowed to. if it is not, then they should not be allowed to. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

They should be able to strike and then be promptly replaced. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

They should be able to strike and then be promptly replaced.


True, there are a lot of unemployed teachers out there who would work for twice the average salary of anyone else in the city and only have to work 9 months a year for that. 

I Love Reading --- 14 years ago -

If they didn't strike during the school year, what would be the point? This puts the pressure on. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

So instead of negotiating in good faith they use the pressure to coerce and bully.

Well isn't that a positive message for our young people 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Every individual should have the right to strike...and face the consequences for walking off on the job.

I see collective bargaining as part of the problem. When businesses band together to influence wages or prices, that is considered illegal. Yet when workers do it, we call it a right? Do as I say and not as I do? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

I never thought of it that way Warren Peace.

Thanks for bringing that up. 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

So instead of negotiating in good faith they use the pressure to coerce and bully.

Is'nt that union 101? 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

Exactly. Collective bargaining is a joke. If you can't keep a job due to poor performance, you should be replaced. It's really that simple. It's called motivation. 

Cookin' Queen --- 14 years ago -

I has always felt that teachers shouldn't have jury duty during the school year! When I taught I was always able to change mine to the summer. Think of all the $$$ that would be saved on subs if this was done! 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Take a guess at how much money the teacher's union gave to Obama's campaign. It was 50 million. If they can donate 50 mil for favors then they are making to much money to begin with. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

"allowed?"

lol I don't think anyone "allows" or forbids a strike. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Yes. 

Longhorn Mom --- 14 years ago -

YES! YES! YES! If you are not a teacher, you can't understand the HELL we go through every time contracts come around. The media just talks about the issues that will get the most uproar from the public. If you want to rate me on my performance, then have a principal, asst principal or anyone QUALIFIED to evaluate me sit in my room and not rate me on the test of a kid that never listens in class, never does his work at school or home, sleeps in class everyday and tells you he doesn't care what he makes on his test.....
GO TEACHERS!!!! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Ok Longhorn Mom, I can appreciate that, you would want to be judged not on results but on performance.

So let's go with that. Should a grocery store checker be judged on the results/perceptions of others or on the tasks of being a checker, the speed, accuracy etc?

Every profession is judged on results and sometimes those results are out of one person's complete control. But is it fair if they aren't judged on results? 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

YES! YES! YES! If you are not a teacher, you can't understand the HELL we go through every time contracts come around.
0 0


If you want to rate me on my performance, then have a principal, asst principal or anyone QUALIFIED to evaluate me sit in my room and not rate me on the test of a kid that never listens in class, never does his work at school or home, sleeps in class everyday and tells you he doesn't care what he makes on his test.....

Your remarks are a perfect example of why I've lost any sympathy for teachers and their phony, immature grievances. Perhaps the lack of maturity comes from spending all day with children. The truth is your job is no different than anyone else who has a responsibility to manage others. Stop making excuses.

Regardless of the hand you've been dealt, it is absolutely fair game to judge you on how you manage the performance of others. If students fail to show improvement in your class, we owe it to the children to try a different teacher.

Your job should be no different than any other. If you can't perform, find another job. Children come first, not teachers. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

If the contract was negotiated or not during the summer as it should have been then a strike would take place during the off time. But it always delays and the strike comes when they return to work without a contract. Judging on results of a test is not fair, especially when you count in all of the children that are not in regular classes. Tests at grade level are given to even those not taking classes on grade level. Kids with adjusted curriculum for behavior, disabilities, and other 'situations' are taught at the grade level they are at but tested at the grade level of their 'age' Including these results in state test scores in unfair to everyone. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

I see collective bargaining as part of the problem. When businesses band together to influence wages or prices, that is considered illegal. Yet when workers do it, we call it a right? Do as I say and not as I do? 


That is a ridiculous statement. That assumes that workers have equal power in the workplace. If employers had the freedom to collude they could and would artificially keep wages low and whatever the workers value or skill it wouldn't matter.

Secondly, collective bargaining came about as the ONLY way that workers could protect themselves from getting taken advantage by co.'s who would refuse to spread any profits through their workforce. If it wasn't for the power of collective bargaining the middle class in this country would not have grown like it did.

If you believe that collective bargaining is no longer needed, because companies can't or won't take advantage of their employees anymore, I think you live in a dream world. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

I'll debate you on that a bit later Randle. I need to go pick up my son. 

txlady67 --- 14 years ago -

How yall are talking yall are from from union states. Texas is a right to work state. I am a native Texan and a teacher. The state of Texas has a teacher miniumn salary. Each school district can add to the salary, however they can not lower the miniumn salary. Teachers do get evaluated each year either by formal evauations or walk throughs. If you do not like the working conditions you can ask for a transfer to another school in your district or leave your district and go to work in another district. In Texas teachers do not have unions. We do have several professional organizations we can belong to if we want to. We are not forced to belong to anything. I personally believe that teachers should not strike. Teachers are not teachers because of the money. Teachers are teachers because they believe that they will be a positive influence for their students. Our students come first.
A Texas teacher for 20+ years and proud of it. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

In Union states they can lower your pay, take away health benefits, lengthen your day, up your class size, and remove your sick time at contract time. They can also raise and increase those things as well. .... 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

How yall are talking yall are from from union states. Texas is a right to work state. I am a native Texan and a teacher. The state of Texas has a teacher miniumn salary. Each school district can add to the salary, however they can not lower the miniumn salary. Teachers do get evaluated each year either by formal evauations or walk throughs. If you do not like the working conditions you can ask for a transfer to another school in your district or leave your district and go to work in another district. In Texas teachers do not have unions. We do have several professional organizations we can belong to if we want to. We are not forced to belong to anything. I personally believe that teachers should not strike. Teachers are not teachers because of the money. Teachers are teachers because they believe that they will be a positive influence for their students. Our students come first.
A Texas teacher for 20+ years and proud of it.





Bingo and thank you for your post. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

How yall are talking yall are from from union states. Texas is a right to work state. I am a native Texan and a teacher. The state of Texas has a teacher miniumn salary. Each school district can add to the salary, however they can not lower the miniumn salary. Teachers do get evaluated each year either by formal evauations or walk throughs. If you do not like the working conditions you can ask for a transfer to another school in your district or leave your district and go to work in another district. In Texas teachers do not have unions. We do have several professional organizations we can belong to if we want to. We are not forced to belong to anything. I personally believe that teachers should not strike. Teachers are not teachers because of the money. Teachers are teachers because they believe that they will be a positive influence for their students. Our students come first.
A Texas teacher for 20+ years and proud of it.


And I'm damned proud of you for standing up and saying this. Texas is a "right to work" state. You knew what you were getting into when you signed up. If teaching is something you can't do well, tough crapola. Find another job or go back to school for something else. Your arm wasn't twisted to go into that profession. And if you didn't realize what you were getting into, you're too stupid to be teaching anyway. That's the harsh reality that all employees in all workplaces have to deal with.

Don't mire in your bad judgements. Do something about it. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

I'm pretty sure this thread was about Teachers and their Unions being allowed to strike. Not if Texas Teachers specifically are allowed to strike. I think it is more of a current events thread (Chicago) not a 'poor me, I'm a teacher thread'

And I hope that those that are judged on the performance of their subordinates and charges have some say in the standards. In some cases the rules keep changing from what they were when you accepted the job.

I don't teach here. But I do support people's right to a fair workplace. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

An Oregon grade school principal suggested in a newspaper interview that peanut butter and jelly sandwiches might be racially and culturally offensive.

“What about Somali or Hispanic students who might not eat sandwiches?” Verenice Gutierrez told the Portland Tribune.

FOLLOW TODD ON FACEBOOK FOR CULTURE WAR NEWS. CLICK HERE.

Gutierrez, principal of Harvey Scott K-8 School, was being interviewed about the school district’s equity training program designed to narrow the achievement gap. The newspaper said she “picks up on the subtle language of racism every day” and used the peanut butter sandwich to illustrate her point.

“Another way would be to say: ‘Americans eat peanut butter and jelly, do you have anything like that?’ let them tell you,” she told the newspaper. “Maybe they eat torta. Or pita.”

The equity program is called “Courageous Conversation” and it involves taking educators through an intensive program so they can understand their own “white privilege,” the newspaper reported.

Robb Cowie, the communications director for Portland Public Schools told Fox News they were aware of the story and to their knowledge it was factually accurate.

“What we’re trying to do in our school district is to ensure that we have instruction that is meaningful and relevant to ever student in the classroom,” Cowie said.

In some cases, that means offering programs strictly for students of color.

The newspaper provided information about a drum corps that was set up for black and Latino boys. One parent complained that the class discriminated against women, Asians, whites and Native Americans.

Guitierrez defended the class and denied it was discriminatory.

“When white people do it, it is not a problem,” she told the Tribune. “But if it’s for kids of color, then it’s a problem? Break it down for me. That’s your white privilege, and your whiteness.”

Cowie said the district did not have a problem with the principal’s statements.

So does the school system provide clubs strictly for white students?

“I’m not aware of that in Portland,” he said.

FOLLOW TODD ON FACEBOOK FOR CULTURE WAR NEWS. CLICK HERE.

“Big picture – what we are trying to encourage in our district – are educational experiences that are relevant that give kids support, encouragement, engagement,” Cowie said. “We are certainly not trying to create situations where students are excluded.”

He said the district was addressing the issue of so-called ‘white privilege’ to even the playing field so that all children have an opportunity succeed.

“It’s an understanding that families and students come into the educational setting with different backgrounds and different strengths and in some cases different advantages,” he said. “That translates into different educational outcomes.”

Cowie said the district wants to narrow the achievement gap for “students of color.”

“Persistently we have not done a good enough job educating students of color and specifically African-American students,” he told Fox News. “That’s what the program is addressing. How can we find a way to support African American students, their families – so that we are producing better outcomes and narrowing the achievement gap.”

The story generated a number of comments from local residents outraged over the equity training program. One reader suggested that under the school’s policies, the phrase “American as apple pie” could be considered offensive.

“I am sick of progressives’ attacks on our culture. I am offended when people coming to our country find it necessary to denigrate our culture and teachers who are teaching our children somehow feel like they have to apologize for being American,” the reader wrote.

Another wrote: “Teaching against peanut butter sandwiches and white privilege is critical thinking? No – that is racism and radical activism.”

And that brings us back to the peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

“It’s not really about a sandwich,” he said. “It’s about how do we reach kids and speak to them through experiences that are meaningful to them – that are understandable to them so that they have an entry point into the curriculum and can engage in learning.”

He said they don’t want to make any student feel unwelcomed – intentionally or unintentionally that might disconnect a child or a family from the educational system – even if it’s a PB&J.

“Certainly a sandwich isn’t going to do it in itself,” he said. “But it is one of those things that we want to be aware of in all aspects of our instructional practice.”

]http://radio.foxnews.com/toddstarnes/top-stories/principal-sees-racism-in-peanut-butter.html?fb_action_ids=756681088101&fb_action_types=og.likes&fb_source=other_multiline&action_object_map={%22756681088101%22%3A280596245374992}&action_type_map={%22756681088101%22%3A%22og.likes%22}&action_ref_map=[]



Especially when these things become issues in the job of teaching 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

What the crap is wrong with a PB&J sandwich, regardless of where the heck you're from? I'm not Mexican and don't like those taco stand tacos but I wouldn't be offended in any way if that was an offering at school for lunch.

It's simply amazing how people wear their emotions on their cuffs these days. I'm offended that you're offended that I'm offended.

They must have not got enough mother love when they were children. 

reh6110 --- 14 years ago -

I agree teachers need to be assessed in some fashion, but not all classes are created equal. Just because a student doesn't pass a grade level test doesn't mean they haven't made progress. Ex. A student who goes into 3rd grade reading on a 1st grade level may improve during the course of a year to reading on a second grade level (they made a years' progress) but they are still not going to be able to pass a 3rd grade test. Should the teacher be penalized for that and possibly even lose his/her job over it? 

Kimberly --- 14 years ago -

My son went through kindergarten and half way through 1st grade without knowing his alphabet or knowing how to read. I tried my best to get him to learn but nothing worked, finally they put him with a specialized reading teacher and she had him reading at a 3rd grade level before he left 1st grade. Mrs. Farner is an amazing reading teacher that can teach what others think of as "unteachable." My has been an A/B honor student since Mrs. Farner changed his life. Some teachers have a talent for teaching and some just give up on students. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

Should the teacher be penalized for that and possibly even lose his/her job over it? 

Frankly, yes. You either have the ability to effect progress with students or you don't. If you don't, make way for someone who does like Mrs. Farmer. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

That is a ridiculous statement. That assumes that workers have equal power in the workplace. If employers had the freedom to collude they could and would artificially keep wages low and whatever the workers value or skill it wouldn't matter.

Ridiculous? I don’t think it means what you think it means. It does not assume that workers have equal power. It’s ridiculous to believe that power can ever be equal between one who is a provider of labor and one who is a purchaser of labor. Power is never equal, but it is different. In a labor market where jobs are hard to come by, the power is more likely to be in the hands of the job provider. But in a healthy economy where unemployment is low, workers are more likely to have the power – the power to seek better employment elsewhere (by whatever definition they use for “better”). But we’re not debating the need to regulate power according to the changes in an economy are we? You seem to be suggesting that it is better to flip the power to the workers by giving them the power to collude while forbidding employers from doing it.

Collusion doesn’t work. It doesn’t work because it creates an incentive to be the first to deviate. Even among business who entertain the thought that despite their role as competitors, that they would somehow find a common need to keep wages equal even though the quality of labor will never be equal is what is ridiculous. Such a notion is so ridiculous that it can only be advanced by high school civics teachers who fail to grasp concepts of basic economics. The only place I’ve heard such concepts are in high school and in political debate where so called “progressives” cling to archaic notions of economics.
-------------------


Secondly, collective bargaining came about as the ONLY way that workers could protect themselves from getting taken advantage by co.'s who would refuse to spread any profits through their workforce. If it wasn't for the power of collective bargaining the middle class in this country would not have grown like it did.

Bull$hit. Collective bargaining initially came about as a result of a naïve understanding of basic economics. It continues to exist in today’s world because it remains an effective tool to advance elitist notions of “the masses” being weak and ignorant. So government decides to erode the power of an individual in order to enable a collectivist mentality of dependence. But politicians who favor such a dependence mentality LOVE it when “the masses” play along and blindly embrace the belief that collective bargaining is the ONLY way.
-------------------


If you believe that collective bargaining is no longer needed, because companies can't or won't take advantage of their employees anymore, I think you live in a dream world.

You seem to have completely missed the point. It is not that collective bargaining is no longer needed, it is that it was never needed in a market that embraces free enterprise, or in a market that simply expressly forbids collusion of any kind.

Regardless of which side of collusion you favor, the sole purpose of collusion in the form of collective bargaining is to keep the price of labor from being what it would be otherwise in free and open competition in the market. Market competition aims to base rates of pay on the productivity of the worker, thereby bidding labor away from where it is least productive to where it is more productive. This is contrary to the belief you’ve described. You’ve described it as a compulsion to always keep it low regardless of worker productivity, value, and competence (in your belittling words, “take advantage”). Markets are wiser than that. Free enterprise seeks to outbid competition for a product that is worth paying for. But organized efforts to make wages artificially low or artificially high defeat this process and thereby make the allocation of resources less efficient in the economy as a whole.

The maximum employment in any industry is achieved under free and open market competition, without organized collusion among either employers or employees.

The very basic economic reality is that under any other terms, whether set higher or lower, and whether set by collective actions of employers or unions or imposed by government decree, favoring one side or the other causes the disfavored side to make fewer transactions. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Randle,

Yesterday when I left to pick up my son, it turned out that he experienced something relevant to the topic being discussed here. The son I’m referring to is only 17 years old. He showed up to orientation at Kroger yesterday eagerly awaiting the experience of his first job.

When I picked him up, he told me something happened there that he didn’t feel right about. He said that a union representative came in and gave a sales pitch about how joining the union was in his best interest. He said he asked if he could go home and think about it, but the union rep told him that agreeing to being protected was not something he should need to think about. He explained that he ultimately signed an agreement to join the union and pay dues. He said the union rep told him the first payment was only $7 and would be deducted from his check. But he didn’t know how much additional payments were. He had no documentation with him which even addressed this.

I asked him what he would do if it turned out that a manager didn’t like him for reasons other than employment and wrongfully fired him. He said that he wouldn’t want to work for an organization with a manager like that and that being fired would probably be a good thing. He said that if he was a good worker, he should be able to find another job with a manager that saw things differently.

So I asked him how he would view it if one of his co-workers was not performing – they did not show up on time, did not stay busy, made more errors than he did, yet kept getting the same pay increases he did, instead of getting fired. He said there was no way that could happen. He insisted that it was so nonsensical that there’s no way a free society or even a true democracy would want things to be that way.

I smiled and told him about my experience with a union when I became a state worker back in the early 90s. I told him I absolutely found it frustrating that even though I was routinely one of the first to arrive and one of the last to leave, consistently volunteered to help out others when they failed, that I still got the same pay increases that others did even though these others could not show up on time and required far more supervision. I told him about how union representatives even came in to “protect” employees who engaged in wrong-doing in order to leverage a compromise that resulted in that poor performing employee with terrible judgment to keep his job.

I asked him how he felt about devoting an entire hour of his labor toward giving money to an organization he may never use. He said he felt scammed.

So tell me Randle, where did I go wrong in my conversation with my son? Do you believe I lied to him or misled him? Do you believe that his instincts before he even asked me about it - were wrong? 

reh6110 --- 14 years ago -

You either have the ability to effect progress with students or you don't.
But there was progress...a year's worth just like any other child in the class would be expected to make. Teachers like Mrs. Farmer are wonderful but the case with that studnet is the exception not the rule. Plus that was one on one instruction, not a regular classroom situation. More progress can be made one on one than 22:1. I can promise you that I have never "given up" on a student, but that doesn't mean I can work miracles. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

Ex. A student who goes into 3rd grade reading on a 1st grade leve

If this student's kindergarten, 1st, and 2nd grade teachers were held accountable along the way you would expect that a 3rd grade teacher would not be put in this situation. Of course not all children will progress at the same speed but by holding the teacher accountable from the beginning, one would think a child that was having problems would be identified and addressed and not just passed along to the next grade. 

Banjos and Squealing Pigs --- 14 years ago -

LIKE!
Replaced! 

LillyDivine --- 14 years ago -

Teachers have long been underpaid imo, though not all teachers are passionate about what they do and could care less about the students actually getting a quality education. Maybe if the job paid more, they would care more.
This is really a vital issue imo because these kids are our future and education is KEY. I wish that more teachers and parents took more pride in the education that their children get. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Teachers have long been underpaid imo, though not all teachers are passionate about what they do and could care less about the students actually getting a quality education. Maybe if the job paid more, they would care more.

So Lilly, what is the correct amount of money that teachers must be paid in order to care more? 

Tipsyhic --- 14 years ago -

should teachers be allowed to strike during the school year?
I think they should all be made to bowl a spare. A strike is too good for them. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Appreciate the attempt at levity, but keep your day job Tipsy. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

So they care only because of the payment?

Well at least that is finally an honest response. These responses that they care about the kids have been lies all this time and everyone knew it. The actions of the teachers not just on this strike and their comments to get as much as they could, their indifference to the citizens of Chicago who pay their salaries, their already pay and benefits twice what others in Chicago make, their pay and benefits already one of the best in the Country and their performance some of the lowest, these are what show what is in these peoples hearts and souls - greed and selfishness. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

greed and selfishness.

All traits of that union mentality. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground