Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What if the Catholic Church Responded to Its Sex Scandal The Way the NCAA Did to Theirs?

who's talking here?

smartypants 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Porter Wagoner 1
Hiro Protagonist 3
voice of reason 6
JohnLynch 9
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 9
Dorothy Parker 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 7
txsassy 4
MavMan 1
Pat Barry 8
FluffyPenguin 1
a672999uu 3
Edgar Po Wong 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Many were pleasantly surprised by the severity of the sanctions the National Collegiate Athletic Association placed on Penn State following its investigation of the Jerry Sandusky child abuse scandal. The NCAA's measures evidenced an appropriately serious approach to unspeakable crimes. At the same time, however, the athletic association's aggressive sanctions contrasted sharply with the lack of appropriate response to much greater crimes on the part of Roman Catholic clergy.   It made some wonder what it might look like if the Catholic Church handled its infinitely larger scandal in a fashion similar to that of the NCAA.     
Of course, the Penn State's board of trustees had initially tried to defuse its shameful situation by having the institution's president resign and by firing Joe Paterno, the football program's legendary coach. Eventually, they even removed "Joepa's" statue that (dis)graced the entrance way to the football stadium in Happy Valley.       
But the NCAA went far beyond that -- even further than most had expected.   It appointed high profile Independent Counsel, Louis Freeh, to investigate responsibility for Sandusky's crimes and the cover-up that followed. Then in the wake of Freeh's damning final report, it fined the University $60 million dollars -- the amount the football program takes in annually. It ordered the program to vacate its winnings since 1998 (thus depriving Paterno of his legacy as the winningest coach in NCAA football history). It forbade the program to extend any football scholarships for the next four years, and released all of its current players from their ties to Penn State, making them immediately eligible to play elsewhere. The football program will be devastated for years to come.
The NCAA's bold sanctions couldn't be further from the response of the Roman Catholic hierarchy to its child abuse scandal. There instead the "old boy" defense of the institution and the members of its all male club kicked in just as it did at first inside Penn State's football program when the Sandusky crimes initially came to light. At Penn State, the wagons were circled, Sandusky was mildly chided while everyone in charge from the University president and Joe Paterno on down denied any knowledge or responsibility. The attitude that "boys will be boys" threatened to carry the day. 
The equivalent of that attitude and (non)response still prevails within the Holy City despite the shameful involvement of priests in raping and otherwise sexually abusing children on a worldwide scale that absolutely dwarfs anything that happened in Happy Valley. In the face of thorough investigations by independent groups (e.g. the absolutely devastating indictment published last year in Ireland) the Cardinal of New York invoked the "bad apples" defense, and protested that "only" a small portion of the clergy was tainted. 
But what would it have looked like if (impossibly!) the Catholic Church had responded like the NCAA?
If it had done so:


-           Pope Ratzinger would have resigned immediately.
-           All cardinals and bishops who had covered up the scandal would have been removed from office.
-           The canonization process for John Paul II would have been terminated, because of the way he down-played the sex scandal. This would be the equivalent of removing Joepa's statue.
-           An investigation independent of the Vatican would have been launched headed by an unimpeachable figure -- say the Dali Lama, perhaps joined by Sr. Pat Farrell, President of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (LCWR) which is currently being investigated by the Vatican.
-           Upon completion of its investigation (assuming it would have reached conclusions similar to the one in Ireland), the commission would have:
o    Fined the Catholic Church $500 billion -- the equivalent of one year of the R.C. church income. The money would be used world-wide to aid victims of sex abuse and to institute programs to educate clergy about human sexuality using the best insights of current sociology and psychology.
o    Removed from the list of genuine popes all those whose public crimes made them unworthy of the title "Vicars of Christ." Here the Borgia popes come to mind, as well as Pope Pius XII for his silence about the Jewish Holocaust. (Obviously, the process of his canonization would be abruptly ended.) This would be the rough equivalent of Penn State's vacating its football wins since 1998.
o    The exclusion of women from the priesthood would be reversed, and seminary scholarships would be extended world-wide to women desiring to receive Holy Orders.
o    Mandatory celibacy would of course be set aside as a requirement of the priesthood -- and a major contributor to the issue at hand.
o    A reforming Church Council (Vatican III?) would be ordered to deal with the sex abuse and related problems -- to be attended only by bishops not involved in the abuse scandal and subsequent cover-up. Their places would be taken by women elected by national bodies equivalent to the LCWR in the United States. 
Of course, nothing like the results just described is remotely possible. Roman Catholic insulation from the external processes necessary to achieve such outcomes prevents that eventuality. The only external source capable of moving the church in the desired direction belongs to the Catholic faithful itself. It alone has the authority to withhold church attendance and contributions till the desired decisions of reform are taken. 
But not to worry: such pressure from the faithful will eventually be applied willy-nilly. That is, the faithful will either wage a purposeful campaign of withholding attendance and financial support in the light of failed church leadership.
Or alternatively (and more likely) the once-faithful will be driven away from the church as the realization dawns that a college sports organization possesses sounder moral character than what pretends to be the "Mystical Body of Christ."




On another note-


I hear Sandusky had to stop going to church. The priests kept fighting over who got to hear his confession. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Yawn 

Porter Wagoner (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

You left out the most important - they would not be able to participate in any bingo championship bowl games for 4 years. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

You left out the most important - they would not be able to participate in any bingo championship bowl games for 4 years.


LOL 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

It's odd to me that both Paterno and Sandusky are Catholic. More scandal for the Catholic church and why are so many homosexual child molesters catholic and why do other catholics find it acceptable to cover it up?

Does any other domination or religion have this issue? Maybe I'm just not aware of it being so wide spread in other dominations. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

The Catholic church's main problem is no outside body for checks and balances.

Even tho Penn St. was all about the institution of college sports at a very high level of success, they still had an outside source very interested in saving it's own arse and reputation- even if it meant sacrificing Joe Paterno and the great tradition of college football at Penn St. to do so. Obviously the right decision since it sent a message of rejection to those who dropped the ball with their decisions in the matter.

The Catholic church is it's own form of nepotism, advancing it's own with blinders on for anything else, EVEN AT THE EXPENSE OF INNOCENT CHILDREN. That's very EVIL IMHO. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

More scandal for the Catholic church and why are so many homosexual child molesters catholic and why do other catholics find it acceptable to cover it up?

I don't really know if more abusers are actually Catholic, but they go where the children are...just like boy scouts/ camp leaders, where better to seek out victims than in church?

I also think it's in all denominations. But the Catholic churchs secrecy and successful cover ups has probably created a network where these pedophiles can just about guarantee being hidden, so they gravitate toward it. Just my guess. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Sandusky and Paterno are/were both catholic. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

:( 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

The Catholic church needs to get a handle on this and not let their church me hijacked by predators. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

They Catholic church needs to get a handle on this and not let their church me hijacked by predators.


Agreed. But again as we have seen, they really aren't outing these guys yet and they have been hidden for years. The layers of abuse through the generations has got to be deep and penetrating. When you have that kind of insidous/evil activities going on, it would take a huge movement toward transparency to really institute change. And I mean institute literally. And I don't think the church is there yet.. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Wow. Feeling the need to stir the pot with this thread.

What about the child molestation problem with illegal aliens? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I just saw MavMan's link...

"The first U.S. church official convicted of covering up sex-abuse claims against Roman Catholic priests was sentenced Tuesday to three to six years in prison by a judge who said he “enabled monsters in clerical garb ... to destroy the souls of children.”

What a loser judge. He says this man 'aided in the destruction of children's souls', yet he gets 3-6 years?? WTH.

That's part of the problem too, that sentence is purely ridiculous. He'll probably get off even earlier for good behavior. What a travesty. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

What about the child molestation problem with illegal aliens?

Weak. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

What a loser judge. He says this man 'aided in the destruction of children's souls', yet he gets 3-6 years?? WTH.


I think her point was the actually rapist only got about that amount of time. She probably felt she couldn't give him more for the cover up.



Lynn, who handled priest assignments and child sexual assault complaints from 1992 to 2004, was convicted last month of felony child endangerment for his oversight of now-defrocked priest Edward Avery. Avery is serving a 2½- to five-year sentence for sexually assaulting an altar boy in church in 1999.


That sentence is absurd as well. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

What about the child molestation problem with illegal aliens?


Is there a story in the news currently about this issue? My topic is based on a current news story and conviction. Why is there a problem with that? LOL 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Is there a story in the news currently about this issue? My topic is based on a current news story and conviction. Why is there a problem with that? LOL

Probably not but it's a shot at something non-white from a weak mind. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

There was a huge scandal involving a Mormon church leader recently in Utah. The guy was a prominent member of the church, a successful doctor and had founded a church mission in Ethiopia. He also adopted 6 children from there in addition to having his own large family with his wife. Not only was he accused of molesting his own kids, a bunch of victims from his church came forward to say what he did to them when they were kids. :(

Sick shiz.....his wife filed for divorce the day after he was arrested. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

his wife filed for divorce the day after he was arrested.


Wow, that's refreshing to see. Maybe not all the wives harbor and protect these sickos?? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I don't for one second believe she didn't know what was going on....she was just humiliated when their dirty secret was exposed. :( 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Wow, that's refreshing to see.

It would have been a tad more refreshing for the B to step up before they got caught. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

It would have been a tad more refreshing for the B to step up before they got caught.

Well, yes, but I'm keeping within the context of what normally happens, and they often look the other way if not assist.

It's all mind disease. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Well, yes, but I'm keeping within the context of what normally happens

So the norm is refreshing to see? 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

What if the Catholic Church Responded to Its Sex Scandal The Way the NCAA Did to Theirs?



that would be heaven on earth!

btw i am all for the death penalty for child molesters. ALL OF THEM.
it is a known fact that they cannot be fixed, rehabbed or otherwise.
KILL THEM ALL! start with sandusky
lock up any accomplices for life. start with paterno. oh right. god's already got his hands on that rotten scoundrel and he's burning at the stake. yeeha! justice has been served. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

ticketspronto --- 1 hours ago - quote - hide comments
Yawn



lmfao!
that bores you because?
i get it.
in your opinion it is okay what the priesthood does to young children. 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

In some degree of fairness the Catholic Church did respond to these awful acts with action - no excuse -
for even one instance - but again in the interest of fairness,

In 2002 they established the Charter for the protection of Children and Young People that pledged a safe enviorment by:
- communicating a zero tolerance policy
- established uniform procedured for handling any allegations that require
alerting the authorities
conduct an internal investigation
and imediate removal of the accused from duty.
- required background checks for all Chuch employees.

by 2008 the church had trained 5.8 million children to recognize and report abuse.

had run criminal checks on 1.53 million volunteers and employees. 162,700 educators, 51,000 clerics and 4,955 candidates for ordination.

and had trained 1.8M clergy, employees and volunteers in creating a safe environment for children.


(numbers from wikipedia - i know i know not the worlds best source - but this is a internet board - not a PHd thesis) 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

thanks for posting that a-------uu but if they don't turn over their priests and continue to protect them, the whole dam catholic church should be prosecuted as an accomplice ( see my above post) and shut down! 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Good idea - Let's just shut it down and tell the 1 Billion members world wide after 2,000 years it's over. Interesting suggestion for a "Voice of Reason" - 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Let's just shut it down and tell the 1 Billion members world wide after 2,000 years it's over. Interesting suggestion for a "Voice of Reason" -

Can't they have their faith without the multitrillion $$ vatican protecting child molestors.

If you're a catholic and still give to the church, you're an accessory to sex crimes. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

In 2002 they established the Charter for the protection of Children and Young People that pledged a safe enviorment by:
- communicating a zero tolerance policy
- established uniform procedured for handling any allegations that require
alerting the authorities
conduct an internal investigation
and imediate removal of the accused from duty.
- required background checks for all Chuch employees.

by 2008 the church had trained 5.8 million children to recognize and report abuse.

had run criminal checks on 1.53 million volunteers and employees. 162,700 educators, 51,000 clerics and 4,955 candidates for ordination.

and had trained 1.8M clergy, employees and volunteers in creating a safe environment for children.




Awesome to hear!!! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

If you're a catholic and still give to the church, you're an accessory to sex crimes. 


I would say that is a bit harsh. It's not the entire faith but its staggering to me the numbers involved. The steps they are finally taking give me hope that they will no longer be a place to hide and destroy children's lives. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

a problem with the premise of your thread...the ncaa overstepped its bounds...the sandusky crimes had NOTHING to do with any sport or any ncaa rules

btw...the author of your article...is into that social justice liberation theology nonsense 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

If you're a catholic and still give to the church, you're an accessory to sex crimes i am catholic even though i dont attend church and that is harsh.. i dont agree how they cover this up. but if i was to go to church i would give money to my church not to the child molestors.. i was raised with great priests and i dont think all should be given a bad name due to what others do.. JMO 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

If you're a catholic and still give to the church, you're an accessory to sex crimes.

Lol...

The same could be said for pretty much any kind of 'party', be it Christians, Republicans etc... It's all a matter of generalizing the entire party, or seeing that there's bad in said parties. You really can't condemn an entire party for what some people do. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

The same could be said for pretty much any kind of 'party', be it Christians, Republicans etc... It's all a matter of generalizing the entire party, or seeing that there's bad in said parties. You really can't condemn an entire party for what some people do.

That's the kind of attitude that allows this stuff. Just imagine a pious mother and father sending their beloved child to the Church of a Thousand Hands for spiritual instruction, only to have him raped and terrified into silence by threats of hell. And then imagine this occurring to tens of thousands of children in our own time -- and to children beyond reckoning for over a thousand years.

But hey, every organization has few bad seeds. Get a grip. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Consider the ludicrous ideology that made it possible: The Catholic Church has spent two millennia demonizing human sexuality to a degree unmatched by any other institution, declaring the most basic, healthy, mature, and consensual behaviors taboo. Indeed, this organization still opposes the use of contraception, preferring, instead, that the poorest people on earth be blessed with the largest families and the shortest lives. As a consequence of this hallowed and incorrigible stupidity, the Church has condemned generations of decent people to shame and hypocrisy. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

The evidence suggests that the misery of these children was facilitated and concealed by the hierarchy of the Catholic Church at every level, up to and including the current Pope. In his former capacity as Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope Benedict personally oversaw the Vatican's response to reports of sexual abuse in the Church. What did this wise and compassionate man do upon learning that his employees were raping children by the thousands? Did he immediately alert the police and ensure that the victims would be protected from further torments? Repeated and increasingly desperate complaints of abuse were set aside, witnesses were pressured into silence, bishops were praised for their defiance of secular authority, and offending priests were relocated only to destroy fresh lives in unsuspecting parishes. It is no exaggeration to say that for decades (if not centuries) the Vatican has met the formal definition of a criminal organization, devoted not to gambling, prostitution, drugs, or any other venial sin, but to the sexual enslavement of children.

We mortals can finally glimpse how strangely perfect are the ways of the Lord. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

Consider the ludicrous ideology that made it possible: The Catholic Church has spent two millennia demonizing human sexuality to a degree unmatched by any other institution, declaring the most basic, healthy, mature, and consensual behaviors taboo. Indeed, this organization still opposes the use of contraception, preferring, instead, that the poorest people on earth be blessed with the largest families and the shortest lives. As a consequence of this hallowed and incorrigible stupidity, the Church has condemned generations of decent people to shame and hypocrisy.


brilliant post. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

The evidence suggests that the misery of these children was facilitated and concealed by the hierarchy of the Catholic Church at every level, up to and including the current Pope. In his former capacity as Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope Benedict personally oversaw the Vatican's response to reports of sexual abuse in the Church. What did this wise and compassionate man do upon learning that his employees were raping children by the thousands? Did he immediately alert the police and ensure that the victims would be protected from further torments? Repeated and increasingly desperate complaints of abuse were set aside, witnesses were pressured into silence, bishops were praised for their defiance of secular authority, and offending priests were relocated only to destroy fresh lives in unsuspecting parishes. It is no exaggeration to say that for decades (if not centuries) the Vatican has met the formal definition of a criminal organization, devoted not to gambling, prostitution, drugs, or any other venial sin, but to the sexual enslavement of children.

We mortals can finally glimpse how strangely perfect are the ways of the Lord.



a beyond brilliant post.
and all this in the lord's name, how disgusting! 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground