Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

THE CASE AGAINST JOE PATERNO: WEAK TO NON-EXISTENT ON THE CURRENT RECORD

who's talking here?

Lillabeth 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 31
Clock 4
idontplaynice 2
thankfulformyfour 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Joe Blow 1
sheddy 4
Pat Barry 5
a672999uu 5
pantherdadx2 14
Edgar Po Wong 1
BuiltinTX70 1
Himura Hitokiri 2
Lynol 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I haven’t followed the Penn State child molestation scandal closely. My interest in sports is an interest in sports, not investigations of crimes by people involved (or formerly involved) with sports.

Nonetheless, I am aware that a consensus exists that former Penn State football coach Joe Paterno acted improperly in connection with Penn State’s response to allegations of child molestation committed by one-time assistant coach Jerry Sandusky. This consensus led to the removal of a statue of Paterno, whose contributions to Penn State as a coach and financial contributor were enormous.

The consensus emerged from the report of Louis Freeh regarding Penn State’s actions related to the sexual abuse committed by Sandusky. But a friend of mine — a top-notch lawyer and former federal prosecutor — has carefully reviewed the Freeh Report. He concludes that the Report does not establish wrongdoing by Joe Paterno. Having now looked at the Freeh Report, I agree.

Here is what my friend wrote:

I believe the media, the Freeh Report, and many others have misrepresented Joe Paterno’s culpability in the Jerry Sandusky matter. The evidence against Mr. Paterno amounts to virtually nothing. After more than 430 interviews and a review of more than 3.5 million documents and other information, the Freeh Report concludes that three emails from other people – former Penn State President Graham Spanier, Athletic Director Timothy Curley, and Senior Vice President Gary Schultz – prove that Mr. Paterno was a co-conspirator in a cover-up. I do not read the evidence in the Freeh Report that way, and I do not believe the conclusions about Mr. Paterno are either warranted or fair.

The claim seems to be that Mr. Paterno knew about a 1998 allegation and did nothing, and that in 2001, when he learned about Mike McQueary’s information, he waited a day before he reported the information to the athletic director (Curley) and the vice president in charge of the University Police (Schultz) and then did nothing else.

First, with respect to the 1998 incident, the Freeh Report says that several authorities promptly investigated and reviewed the matter, including the Department of Public Welfare, the University Police Department, the State College police, and the local district attorney’s office. Freeh Report at 42-47. A “counselor” named John Seasock issued a report that found “no indication of child abuse.” Freeh Report at 42-46. Mr. Seasock interviewed the alleged victim and determined that “there seems to be no incident which could be termed as sexual abuse, nor did there appear to be any sequential pattern of logic and behavior which is usually consistent with adults who have difficulty with sexual abuse of children.” Freeh Report at 44 (quoting Mr. Seasock’s 1998 evaluation of the alleged victim). The Freeh Report adds that Mr. Seasock “couldn’t find any indication of child abuse.” Freeh Report at 45.

The police investigated and “did not question Sandusky at this time,” and the Freeh Report says that “the local District Attorney declined to prosecute Sandusky for his actions.” Freeh Report at 45-46. A “senior administrator” explained that “the case against Sandusky was ‘severely hampered’ by Seasock’s report.” Freeh Report at 46. The University Police also investigated the matter and unlike the local police, they interviewed Sandusky. Sandusky claimed “nothing happened” (Freeh Report at 46) and the University Police concluded that “no sexual assault occurred.” Freeh Report at 47.

The only evidence of Mr. Paterno’s involvement is a passing reference in an email from Curley to Spanier and Schultz that says that Curley “touched base with the coach. Keep us posted.” Freeh Report at 20, 48. A second email from Curley to Schultz that says “Coach is anxious to know where it stands.” Freeh Report at 20, 48. There is no other information about Mr. Paterno’s involvement in the incident. In fact, the Freeh Report does not even establish that the references to “Coach” refer to Joe Paterno. The most it can and does say is that “[t]he reference to Coach is believed to be Paterno.” Freeh Report at 49. The Freeh Report cites no evidence to support this assertion, but even if “Coach” refers to Coach Paterno, what do these emails prove? The answer is: nothing. At most, these emails suggest that Mr. Paterno was concerned and wanted to know whether Sandusky was guilty of any wrongdoing.

Of course, if Mr. Paterno did express concern about the matter, then the question becomes: what did anyone tell him about the allegations and the investigation?

The Freeh Report provides no answer to this question. The Report does not provide any evidence about what Joe Paterno knew about the 1998 allegations against Sandusky. The Report does not provide any evidence about what Mr. Paterno did or said, or what anyone said to Mr. Paterno. Indeed, the Freeh Report suggests that both law enforcement and the University police agreed that nothing improper happened and that the allegations lacked merit. Did anyone tell Joe Paterno about those findings?

The Freeh Report concludes that the “record” is “not clear as to how the conclusion of the Sandusky investigation was conveyed to Paterno.” Freeh Report at 51. The Report includes many statements that assert things like “nothing in the record indicates that Joe Paterno spoke with Sandusky.” See, e.g., Freeh Report at 51. The absence of evidence or information proves only that Mr. Freeh did not find evidence. It does not affirmatively prove anything about Mr. Paterno.

Furthermore, despite the lack of evidence about Mr. Paterno’s culpability with respect to the 1998 incident, the Freeh Report accuses Mr. Paterno of “allow[ing] Sandusky to retire in 1999, not as a suspected child predator, but as a valued member of the Penn State football legacy.” Freeh Report at 17. The Freeh Report’s expression of outrage may sound compelling now, with the benefit of hindsight and the evidence that now exists about Sandusky’s criminal misconduct. But given that (1) law enforcement officials and other people investigated the 1998 incident and found no wrongdoing; (2) Seasock’s report exonerated Sandusky; (3) the District Attorney declined to prosecute the case; (4) Sandusky denied the allegations; and (5) the complete lack of evidence about Mr. Paterno’s knowledge, involvement, and actions, it is difficult to see how Mr. Paterno can be subject to ridicule because he “allowed” Sandusky to retire “not as a suspected child predator.”

As to the issue about whether Joe Paterno should have done more with the McQueary information, I keep coming back to one critical missing piece of evidence: what did Curley and Schultz tell him? Schultz, in particular, is the important actor here because he was the top university official in charge of the University Police. Freeh Report at 33. If JoePa wanted to cover this up, he would never have reported McQueary’s information to Curley and Schultz within a day of receiving it. Is waiting one day on a weekend evidence of a cover-up? Mr. Freeh and others seem to think so. The Freeh Report repeatedly cites Mr. Paterno’s comments about not interfering with the weekend as evidence of some kind of evil intent. But, again, this proves nothing. Would the Report conclude differently if Mr.Paterno had spoken with Curley and Schultz on Saturday evening instead of Sunday?

Furthermore, if Mr. Paterno had reported the McQueary information to me (were I, like Schultz, the official in charge of the University Police), I would have told him to keep his mouth shut going forward and let the authorities handle the matter. Otherwise, Mr. Paterno could have tainted the investigation. And, because he was a potential trial witness (to McQueary’s prior consistent statements, see Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(1)(B) and Pennsylvania Rule of Evidence613(c)), any further statements or action by Mr. Paterno could have become cross-examination fodder for the defense. Any further action by Mr.Paterno could only have damaged the integrity of the investigation and any prosecution against Sandusky.

Indeed, Mr. Paterno explained his actions before died by saying that “I was afraid to do something that might jeopardize what the University procedure was. So I backed away and turned it over to some other people, people I thought would have a little more expertise than I did.” Freeh Report at 77-78. This statement makes perfect sense, and the notion of a football coach supervising a criminal investigation is ridiculous. It is very possible that Curley or Schultz or both told Mr. Paterno to stay out of the matter; in fact, Schultz should have told him as much. But we don’t know because Schultz and Curley are under indictment and not talking, Paterno is dead, and the Freeh Report did not find any information about this issue.

Much of the case against Mr. Paterno seems to rely on (1) the theory that the Athletic Director, Curley, was JoePa’s “errand boy”; and (2) an email dated February 27, 2001 from Curley to Schultz and Spanier which says that Curley gave the matter “more thought” after “talking it over with Joe” and was “uncomfortable with what we agreed were the next steps.” Freeh Report at 74-75. But the “errand boy” evidence amounts to a reference by an unidentified “senior Penn State official” (page 75), and what does it prove anyway? That one person viewed Curley as Paterno’s “errand boy”?

There is no evidence that Curley-as-errand-boy covered up because Joe Paterno told him to do so. And the February 27 email at most suggests that Mr. Paterno spoke with Curley. It does not say what Curley and Paterno discussed, and without any explanation from either Curley or Paterno, it is absurd to read into this that Mr. Paterno was the puppet master behind a coverup orchestrated by Curley, Spanier, and Schultz.

Mr. Paterno was a football coach, not an expert in criminal law or investigations, and this notion of him as some kind of omnipotent and omniscient God who callously turned his back on a serial child molester is unsupported by any evidence.

This is a rather sorry record upon which to condemn Joe Paterno.


People are rarely as good or as bad as they seem at any given time. In Paterno’s case, however, I believe that the old, highly favorable narrative — to which some of the same media types who condemn him now contributed — is much closer to the mark than the revisionist narrative.

- BY PAUL MIRENGOFF 

idontplaynice --- 14 years ago -

Paterno is dead. I don't think he cares about his record anymore. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Paterno is dead. I don't think he cares about his record anymore. 

but his family does...and many others who want the truth to be recognized 

idontplaynice --- 14 years ago -

but his family does...and many others who want the truth to be recognized 

You can post all you want, but I will never be convinced Paterno was not partially responsible for the perpetuation of the child abuse. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

You can post all you want, but I will never be convinced Paterno was not partially responsible for the perpetuation of the child abuse. 

no one can force you to believe the truth...not even God

i just hope no one falsely accuses you of something in the future 

Joe Blow --- 14 years ago -

Great Sports Illusatrated cover.

"An unprecedented failure of institutional itnegrity..."
WE WERE PENN STATE

They get what they deserve! 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

An unprecedented failure of institutional itnegrity...

there goes that lying media again...i wonder how many lies their article contains in its rush to judgment

"At 9:00 am on Monday, a crime took place masquerading as a farce. NCAA President Mark Emmert, a man who in 2010 called Joe Paterno “the definitive role model of what it means to be a college coach,” levied a series of unprecedented sanctions against the football program Paterno built, the Penn State Nittany Lions."
said piously, “Programs and individuals must not overwhelm the values of higher education.”

howver, mark emmert, when he was chancellor of lsu in 1999, had this to say when hiring nick saban as the new football coach: "The critical role of our football program is clear: it is of vital importance to the entire community: Our students, our fans and alumni worldwide and the state of Louisiana."

Upon receiving criticism for making Saban one of the highest paid coaches in the country, Emmert responded: "Simply put, success in LSU Football is essential for the success of Louisiana State University." 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

morning lulz 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

good night Johnboy,....your not worth it 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

good night Johnboy,....your not worth it 

i can see why you have problems understanding what is truth...it's not night...and it's "you're" not "your" 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Only a moron can't see what was covered by the institution and by doing so any and everyone in power at the institution that knew about Snadusky is guilty.

Paterno died of shame. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

only a moron can't see that nothing was covered up by the university...COVERING SOMETHING UP...LESSON NUMBER ONE...DON'T TELL ANYONE

it's apparent that you don't read...you just listen to other people's twisting of the facts

Paterno died of shame

so are you saying that people who get cancer do so because of shame? 

Lynol --- 14 years ago -

Thank you JohnLynch! Keep up the good posts! 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Paterno's knowledge of the 1998 Sandusky situation is brought to light, as are the actions he took in the aftermath. Paterno was told about the details of the case by Tim Curley and had the power to ban Sandusky from Penn State facilities if he chose to do so.

According to the report, witnesses said that Paterno was in complete control of the football facilities and "knew everything that was going on."

Sandusky used the Penn State locker-room shower as the site of his sexual assault in 1998, and while he was cleared at the time and it was determined that no criminal behavior had taken place, Paterno could have taken measures to prevent any similar incidents from taking place.
Sandusky wasn't monitored closely by Paterno or anyone else after the incident, and he was even allowed to continue running football camps on campus. Former president Graham Spanier said he had no knowledge of the camps, but Paterno likely did since he was in charge of all football operations 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

Thank you for the morning spelling lesson, John. Now that I've made your morning, no, I take that back, more than likely, seeing as though in your own mind you are Supreme Lord and Master of the Internet, your morning won't be made until you've made at least 2,384 corrections and disagreements to anything posted on KU. (You really need some professional help, brother. If we were to conduct a poll on KU, I'm sure the majority would be in agreement.) As far as Paterno goes, the mans heart hurt so bad because he knew deep down he could've done more to prevent what transpired, so he did what was best, rolled over, and died. I'm sure you'll find at least 4 things wrong with what I posted in that last statement, so you better get busy, you'll have 2,380 to go before the afternoon rolls around. As far as th sun being up, and I still haven't figured out if you live in the twilight zone or on the dark side of the moon, goodnight, Johnboy, will do just fine. Goodnight, Johnboy. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Paterno was told about the details of the case by Tim Curley

no proof of that

"In fact, the Freeh Report does not even establish that the references to “Coach” refer to Joe Paterno. The most it can and does say is that “[t]he reference to Coach is believed to be Paterno.” Freeh Report at 49. The Freeh Report cites no evidence to support this assertion, but even if “Coach” refers to Coach Paterno, what do these emails prove? The answer is: nothing. At most, these emails suggest that Mr. Paterno was concerned and wanted to know whether Sandusky was guilty of any wrongdoing."


and had the power to ban Sandusky from Penn State facilities if he chose to do so.

false statement...even the freeh report stated that paterno didn't have the power to ban sandusky from the campus

According to the report, witnesses said that Paterno was in complete control of the football facilities and "knew everything that was going on."

false statement...btw...do you even know EVERYTHING that happens in your own house?

Paterno could have taken measures to prevent any similar incidents from taking place

false statement...repeating false statements over and over again won't make them true

but Paterno likely did since he was in charge of all football operations

sandusky's "capms" weren't a part of penn state football operations


IT'S VERY OBVIOUS THAT YOU DON'T WANT TO KNOW THE TRUTH...BECAUSE EVEN YOUR OWN POSTS CONTRADICT THEMSELVES 

Lynol --- 14 years ago -

I don't see why you are all so bothered by John stating the facts? I guess it would be alot easier to sit back and believe everything the media tells us. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

You really need some professional help, brother. If we were to conduct a poll on KU, I'm sure the majority would be in agreement

LOL...that statement shows that it is YOU who needs professional help...do you live your life by polls?


As far as Paterno goes, the mans heart hurt so bad because he knew deep down he could've done more to prevent what transpired, so he did what was best, rolled over, and died.

so NOW you think that you're God...good to know...someone will bring you that white jacket...

it's still daylight kittydad...maybe you don't know that because you "see through a glass, darkly" 

Lillabeth --- 14 years ago -

Lynol --- 4 min ago - quote - hide comments
I don't see why you are all so bothered by John stating the facts? I guess it would be alot easier to sit back and believe everything the media tells us. 


As opposed to the "All and Knowing Oz of KU"? Pfft. You're less then an hour old. JL likes to call those people, "Trolls". Oh, and it's "a lot". Not one word. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I don't see why you are all so bothered by John stating the facts? I guess it would be alot easier to sit back and believe everything the media tells us.

because they don't want to admit that 1) they were duped by the media...that 2) someone is a better person than they are...they need to bring everyone down to the same level so they hope that they won't feel so bad about themselves...and 3) it makes them feel more self-righteous 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

All and Knowing Oz of KU

i know that i'm not all knowing...only God is...however...it is obvious that i know more than you...


JL likes to call those people, "Trolls".

another one of your false statements lillabeth...i call people trolls who come on a thread...as you just did...and post something that has absolutely nothing to do with the topic of the thread...even in an ancillary way 

Lynol --- 14 years ago -

Troll? I guess so if it means I'm new on here.
Thanks for the warm welcome, it means "alot" to me. 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Let me try and posts some truths -
Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar - all could have done more, and all did not do enough. The factual evidence of that statement is that the heinous acts continued after each of them either saw or heard something that raised their suspicions.
That does not make them monsters, good people do bad things, and good people make poor judgments. I am sure in each of their minds they had some rationalization that made them believe they had done enough – and they were wrong. And they all will suffer come consequence for those mistakes.
Curley and Schultz will have their day in court to see if they are guilty or not guilty of a criminal act. Notice I did not say innocent - our courts don’t prove innocence . Spanier, and McQueary lost their jobs, Jim Calhoun is an elderly man with dementia, and both Ray Gricar and Joe Paterno are dead.
The leson, and the tragedy here is summed up best by Joe Paterno in a statement before he was fired , Paterno said “"This is a tragedy. It is one of the great sorrows of my life. With the benefit of hindsight, I wish I had done more." Hopefully, out of all this misery what the world learns is that if there is any suspicion, or reason to believe children are being harmed by these monsters – no one can assume he has done enough until they are 100% sure that either the suspicion was false or the monster is under arrest. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Let me try and posts some truths -

your attempt failed...because you posted suppositions...not facts

Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar - all could have done more, and all did not do enough.

not a factual statement

no one can assume he has done enough until they are 100% sure that either the suspicion was false or the monster is under arrest.

you just contradicted yourself...no one can ever be 100% sure 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

no one can ever be 100% sure

Are you 100% sure god loves you? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Are you 100% sure god loves you?

i'm 100% sure that God loves me...but since God isn't a human...that has nothing to do with my statement 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

...but since God isn't a human...

You're not in god's image? 

Lynol --- 14 years ago -

Thanks JohnLynch. I am not up for all of the narrowmindedness and meanness that is coming through in this thread. Keep posting the facts. I will be cheering you on from under my bridge... 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

JL - one simple question. In your opinion - in your own words, do you think any of these men, Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar did ALL they could have done to prevent this abuse from continuing. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

do you think any of these men, Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar did ALL they could have done to prevent this abuse from continuing.

ray gricar possibly could have done more...don't know why you mentioned jim calhoun...i guess that the rest could have murdered sandusky (not trying to be facetious
here)...but short of that...only putting sandusky in jail for life could accomplish that...and none of those men...except possibly gricar...could have accomplished that 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

(not trying to be fascious here)

did the non-spelling alt ID take over so John could get some sleep. 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

It's good to know you have a freind on here, John. I'm eagerly awaiting your correction on the use of Lysols word "alot". Just think, the next time you sing the song, "What a freind we have in Jesus", you can substitute a few words and sing a new song, "What freinds I have in Jesus (and Lysol)" 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Yes Gricar had the job that could put Sandusky in jail, and didn't - think he could have done more. Maybe needed more evidence ???

Calhoun told co-workers and a supervisor in 2000 that he witnessed Sandusky engaging in sexual activity with a boy in a campus locker-room shower. - being a janitor gets the biggest pass from me for just telling his supervisor

Paterno said - he wishes he had done more - assume he meant it.

the grand jury believes Curley and Schultz actions, or lack of actions may be criminal - I will go out on a limb and say they could have done more.

and McQueary said he witnessed the abuse, didn't stop it at the moment - and has stated he wished he had done more -

trying to figure out what part of

Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar - all could have done more, and all did not do enough.

not a factual statement


is not factual

and by the way it is "facetious" 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

Glad to see "Igot" your goat, John-boy. "kittydad" - further proof you don't "walk in the light" as you claim you do. Was pretty funny, though 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Paterno said - he wishes he had done more - assume he meant it

in HINDSIGHT...people keep forgetting that part of the statement


the grand jury believes Curley and Schultz actions, or lack of actions may be criminal - I will go out on a limb and say they could have done more.

and McQueary said he witnessed the abuse, didn't stop it at the moment - and has stated he wished he had done more


they possibly could have done more...but not anything they could have done...short of murdering sandusky...to STOP the abuse


trying to figure out what part of

Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Mike McQueary, Jim Calhoun and Ray Gricar - all could have done more, and all did not do enough.

not a factual statement


only gricar could have possibly done more to PREVENT the abuse from continuing...that's why your statement isn't factual

and by the way it is "facetious"

already corrected myself before i saw anyone's comment...i mispell things all the time while i'm typing...but i go back and correct them most of the time because i know i did...

btw...using "your" instead of "you're" is a grammatical error...the wrong use of a word 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Glad to see "Igot" your goat,

what's an igot?

further proof you don't "walk in the light"

what???...you haven't been drinking this morning, have you?...thought maybe you have since you think it's night 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

Go ask your new freind, Lysol, maybe he (or she) knows what "igot" means. That's why I put it in parenthesis. It IS night.....in your "twilight zone". Goodnight, John-boy. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

That's why I put it in parenthesis

lol...you used "quotation marks"...NOT (parenthesis) 

a672999uu --- 14 years ago -

Firstly – this entire argument is in hindsight – agreed – and I gave the entire quote the first time, didn’t think had to repeat the entire quote again. Thought that was a kind of obvious - my whole point is, looking back at what did happen, what could have happened that would have helped prevent further abuse.
“they possibly could have done more...but not anything they could have done...short of murdering Sandusky...to STOP the abuse”
“only Gricar could have possibly done more to PREVENT the abuse from continuing...that's why your statement isn't factual”
Let me try this out FALSE STATEMENTS – can’t see why you find it so easy to lie like this – (sorry that was facetious)
OK – in no particular order – short of murder –
Mike McQueary and Jim Calhoun could have physically intervened when they saw the abuse happening in front of their eyes. I don’t think any of these options would be unreasonable - yell, scream, hit him, jump on his back , call 911 - again this is in hindsight – but I would call this more, and not murder. I think it is reasonable to assume that a locker room full of police 15 minutes after the abuse would have started an investigation that could have prevented further abuse.
Joe Paterno - any number of times between 2002 and 2011, when he saw Sandusky on campus - follow up with his bosses. “ hey since I reported to you about this man, and I still see him around, did the authorities investigate this and clear him” if yes - “what are we doing about Mike going around making up such heinous false reports” if no - “why not.” - I think this is a very reasonable scenario for a leader after reporting a possible child molestation issue to his boss. - Or how about – hey Jerry, I know we go back, but until these allegations are proven uncalled for to my satisfaction, I don’t want you anywhere near the program. - again this is in hindsight - I would call this more, and not murder.
Gary Schultz and Tim Curley - how about - Jerry we have to bar you from using the campus facilities and any official association with the university until the authorities clear you of these allegations. Or to Ray Gricar and his successors at the Center County DA office - Hey, if you can say, where are you guys in the Sandusky investigation - do you think it is safe to let this guy on campus, been a few years now. - I would call this more, and not murder.
To end - the empirical evidence that none of these men did enough is that the abuse continued. By definition if they had done enough – it would have stopped. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Mike McQueary and Jim Calhoun could have physically intervened when they saw the abuse happening in front of their eyes.

mcqueary didn't SEE any abuse...and since he didn't see anything taking place...sandusky wasn't convicted of raping victim #2

don't know about what calhoun actually saw...he has dementia now

Joe Paterno - any number of times between 2002 and 2011, when he saw Sandusky on campus - follow up with his bosses.

you don't know that he didn't...

Or how about – hey Jerry, I know we go back, but until these allegations are proven uncalled for to my satisfaction, I don’t want you anywhere near the program.

from the attorney and former federal prosecutor who reviewed the freeh report:

"Furthermore, if Mr. Paterno had reported the McQueary information to me (were I, like Schultz, the official in charge of the University Police), I would have told him to keep his mouth shut going forward and let the authorities handle the matter. Otherwise, Mr. Paterno could have tainted the investigation. And, because he was a potential trial witness (to McQueary’s prior consistent statements, see Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(1)(B) and Pennsylvania Rule of Evidence613(c)), any further statements or action by Mr. Paterno could have become cross-examination fodder for the defense. Any further action by Mr.Paterno could only have damaged the integrity of the investigation and any prosecution against Sandusky.

Indeed, Mr. Paterno explained his actions before died by saying that “I was afraid to do something that might jeopardize what the University procedure was. So I backed away and turned it over to some other people, people I thought would have a little more expertise than I did.” Freeh Report at 77-78. This statement makes perfect sense, and the notion of a football coach supervising a criminal investigation is ridiculous. It is very possible that Curley or Schultz or both told Mr. Paterno to stay out of the matter; in fact, Schultz should have told him as much."

Gary Schultz and Tim Curley - how about - Jerry we have to bar you from using the campus facilities and any official association with the university until the authorities clear you of these allegations.

they didn't have the power to do that...since sandusky had emeritus status...only the president could do that

To end - the empirical evidence that none of these men did enough is that the abuse continued. By definition if they had done enough – it would have stopped.

actually...even if these men could have done what you suggested...none of that would have PREVENTED anything...sandusky abused children other places other than the penn state campus

not trying to be mean...but it is this type of narrow-minded thinking and belief that the media is telling the truth...that is causing people to lay the blame on paterno for sandusky's actions 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground