Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bear Branch Trail Association - Vote NO on Special Assessment for Tree Removal

who's talking here?

marthas attic 2
whatchamacallit 1
Maria C 2
AuthorMan 1
iwaveatcows 3
No Neck Nick 1
SuperFantastic 1
kingwood resident 1
dirtygert 1
zapper007 2
Spinqueen222 1
Gigix4 3
It is I WhyWhyWhy 9
LiveFreeOrDie 1
ganderif 1
evie 4
u uic 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
andreweggplant 1
Nightshade 2
stuck in the middle 1
GoFixMeTurkeyPotPie 1
tdbrueggen 11
The Day I Tried to Live 2
pinky 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

Is it not obvious enough that there is a problem when they have to ask twice? For anyone in Bear Branch Trail Association (BBTA), this should hit home. For those not involved, here's the story:

BBTA has volunteered to undertake the massive effort of removing all the drought killed trees from their trail properties. Already they have exhausted the annual budget, and far exceeded it, for tree removal, eating into their reserve funds. And they aren't close to done. So they've elected to try and collect another $95 from every paying member (about 2700 homes) to continue to pay for this effort.

In my eyes it is a frivolous and endless project. Trees continue to die, and they are having to go back and redo areas that were thought finished. Meanwhile, areas of the actual trails are being neglected. Broken concrete, standing water issues, graffiti, just to name a few, cannot be fixed, because the funds have been blown on tree removal. In addition, they want to pay to clean up all the trees that Centerpoint has cut down and left.

I went to the meeting and here's the results. I wish I'd have posted this sooner.

Initially they needed a 60% quorum from the community to place a vote. That means they had to hear 60% participation, whether yes, no, or abstain. They only received 28%. Of that, the vote was nearly split 50/50 on yes/no, with the usual 10% or so sitting on their hands.
There were about 15 concerned citizens that showed, a record for these sorts of meetings, and there was no support for the project. By the end of the 30 minute verbal assault launched by the public, one or two older ladies had moved to the middle of the fence, but that was it.

So the board of BBTA is going for round two. As the letter mentions, they only need 30% quorum this time. That's how their bylaws are written. On the second attempt, they only need half the quorum from the first attempt. So they only need an additional 2%. At the meeting they discussed only sending the letter to the people who didn't respond the first time. Seems unfair to me, as some of the initial voters may have changed their minds at this point, and since it is a new vote, they should be granted that chance. I suppose some "no" votes could change to "yes" but I find it unlikely.

The board admitted that they knew they wouldn't get the first quorum, and were already prepared to send the second letter. They also admitted that there was heavy debate among the board as to whether or not even pursue the money in the first place.

But now their hearts are set on it, and they will battle to try and get it. Of course if they don't, maybe they'll just up all of our dues at the end of the year to try and get the money then. These people must be watched! They send the letters with a postage paid return envelope, just check "no" and send it back. On that note, they are already grossly over their mailing budget as well for the year. I looked at the financials. As of march, the mailing budget was at 150% of annual. Tree removal was around 180%.

If anyone is benefiting here, it is not the citizens, but rather the tree removal companies. Contracts for tree removal are typically $30-40,000 per set, usually for about 200 or so trees. We're talking about removing thousands of trees.

The trees are hauled to disposal, where I assume they are either burned or turned into mulch, which is then sold back suckers like us. Anyone that has seen "Fight Club" would enjoy the quote "we're selling their own fat a** back to them" when referring to making soap using rendered fat from a liposuction clinic...I digress.

Anyway, please be active here, and vote NO! Giving them more money like this is just feeding the beast. It's just like taxes going up so that more people can claim unemployment and welfare, while a few of us keep working our lives away to support them. The trees will die, fall, and rot on their own. Give it 10 years, and you'd never even know that half the forest died in a drought. 

stuck in the middle --- 14 years ago -

I live next to a reserve in BB & let me tell you - months ago they came by & cut the dead trees and left such a mess. You could tell it was a private company. It's hard to tell where my property ends & the associations property begins. I was waiting for a letter, I figured they would blame us. 

kingwood resident --- 14 years ago -

Where is the City of Houston in all this. Since we were annexed and they collect all property taxes shouldn't they be responsible with the tree removal? The trails should be considered an easement and/or a public right of way. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Where is the City of Houston in all this.


The city has said it has exhausted all it's tree removal money, and every one is on their own now.

Plus the trails are private property, I'm not sure they would even be responsible for the removal of the trees in the trails. 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

Where is the City of Houston in all this

That's what I'm thinking? That's why I asked who actually owns/maintains the property. There is not a doubt in my mind that Kingwood got screwed when they got annexed. We should have done like the Woodlands and paid them off. They just want our money so they can send it down to the ghettos.

I have looked at the financials for BBTA and cannot find where their are unnecessary expense, aside from the $67000 contract to mow and maintain 14 miles of trails...how many miles of those run through the woods and don't need mowed? And then they neglect the area behind my house because it doesn't directly border a trail. Their excuse is that the costs would be prohibitive.
I suppose an audit on the landscape company, perhaps a few competing bids, and a contract review might get some work out of them. Just to be clear, I have no personal hate for the landscape company, I just think they need to put out and earn their money rightly. I work in the oil and gas industry. Let me tell you, contractors that don't do what they say they will don't stick around. It's not uncommon to run them off in the middle of job. We pay a premium for their services, and likewise we expect to receive that service. The trail association should be run likewise.

In an email to a board member, I proposed an audit. The response I got just said something along the lines of how hard our board worked, and how great the landscape company was, and that I should come to a meeting to learn how things work. So I went to the meeting, and the landscape contractor was there. No way I could voice my opinion with him there. Instead of auditing him on trail maintenance, they granted him another $40000 contract on tree removal. That's right, the same guy that has his hooks set on the trail maintenance contract is also bidding on tree removal. Sounds like we are paying him twice for trail maintenance. I think he contract for trail maintenance should include removal of any problematic trees within a certain proximity of the trail. As is, I think he only has to cut back limbs that hang directly over the trail. 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

The only trees that should be removed are the ones that pose a danger to persons or property, not just in Kingwood but everywhere. It is not like this is the first drought to ever happen, it's natural and silly to try and impossible to make it seem like it never happened. 

Maria C --- 14 years ago -

landscape contractor was there. No way I could voice my opinion with him there. Instead of auditing him on trail maintenance, they granted him another $40000 contract on tree removal. That's right, the same guy that has his hooks set on the trail maintenance contract is also bidding on tree removal.

If some "checking" is done here...do not be SURPRISED if there is a "connection /relationship" between the CONTRACTOR and a BOARD MEMBER,,,Otherwise they WOULD have asked for and accepted the lowest "OPEN BID" and the cost would have dropped by about 50%...

Maybe MARVIN ZINDLER or Wayne..can do a STORY ON THIS...searching out and exposing the details.... 

Maria C --- 14 years ago -

LIKE I SAID DO NOT BE SURPRISED....

I AM NOT MAKING A STATEMENT OF
FACT based on personal knowledge...
JUST AN OPINION 

Spinqueen222 --- 14 years ago -

Marvin Zindler passed away. 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

You're right, I would not at all be surprised to find a personal connection like that. To me it's an obvious conflict of interest. With my company, even if my brother had the best possible service, he would not get the bid, purely on the public perception that it could be a conflict of interest.
At one point in the meeting, the public and all contractors were asked to leave so the board could have their "executive" meeting where they discussed contracts and such. I sat outside and waited to address the board on other matters. As I waited patiently, I watched as the three "competing" tree removal contractors laughed and joked in the parking lot for 15 minutes, just like old (or current) friends. Not to say that they can't be friends, but they just seemed extra chummy for guys that are technically competitors. I'd be interested to see how different their bids come in. They must all be getting some work, or the one that feels he is getting screwed out of business would take his efforts elsewhere. The board probably just has a list and they rotate through. "Who's next in line...?" They probably find this is the easiest thing to do since all the bids are damn near the same.
I am still pursuing copies of the contracts, and a copy of the contract for the trail maintenance. I figure it up, and $67000 across 14 miles comes out to $4,785/mile. I would gladly mow/blow 1 mile of trail for almost $5000! 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

I just remembered a key point in the meeting. Someone asked what would happen if BBTA didn't get the funds to continue tree removal. Their response was that they would have to post signs at every entrance to the trails warning people to walk at their own risk and look out for dangerous trees that could drop limbs or fall at any time...

Why not just post those signs now and stop begging for money? Why aren't those signs always posted. I would think as an entity such as BBTA, I would want to have that "not liable for accidents" sign posted at all entrances, for reason just like this.

Think about this: If I trip and fall on one of their trails because the concrete is broken, can I sue them? I could try, but I'm sure they would just say they aren't liable. So it's kind of an unwritten law as far as I'm concerned. We know they aren't liable, so why do they try to act like they are? Do they want to be liable? 

iwaveatcows --- 14 years ago -

I have sent in my NO proxy two times. 

iwaveatcows --- 14 years ago -

 

AuthorMan --- 14 years ago -

The city has said it has exhausted all it's tree removal money, and every one is on their own now.

Since they cannot take care of business, maybe they should get out! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

The city has said it has exhausted all it's tree removal money, and every one is on their own now.


But hey lets build another sports arena or how about we make Hobby an international airport we have money for that. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Why not just post those signs now and stop begging for money?


They should also post a sign that says if a tree falls on your kid and kills them they are not responsible and you cannot sue. 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

But hey lets build another sports arena or how about we make Hobby an international airport we have money for that.

Well I'm sure the sports arena is tax dollars, but should be an investment, and should net a profit for the city in the long run. Although personally I believe in free enterprise, and if a sports team wants to move to Houston, the owner of that team should be paying every penny for a new stadium. In exchange he would get every penny of revenue from it. The city would benefit from tourism, jobs, etc.

They should also post a sign that says if a tree falls on your kid and kills them they are not responsible and you cannot sue.

That's what they said they would do in the meeting. I'm wondering why they are wasting all this time and money to begin with. Why not just post the signs and go home? It's like they want to help, when they want to. We'll do as much as we can as long as we feel like it. If I asked them to come behind my house and cut out trees, assuming the drought had never happened, they would have told me to get bent (my choice of words). But all of sudden there is a drought and they want to play hero.

I think the problem stems that someone out there thought they could save some money by demanding BBTA remove all the trees, thus getting their own cut out as well. That person did not see the scope of the project, nor did BBTA, so they agreed.

Then again, if you are a conspiracy theorist, you'd believe that the landscape companies are the ones that planted that dirty little seed. These guys are pulling down huge contracts after all.

What burns me just as much, is all the waste. They claim that some logs are being salvaged and brought to the mill, but that the mills are already overstocked and are not offering worthy prices. That's BS! There is always a market for lumber. If I had a mill I'd be stockpiling that lumber and waiting for a hurricane. But instead, the wood is hauled to disposal, where it is turned into mulch, and then we pay to get it back. I think they should set up a community mulching center in Kingwood where citizens could dump/collect mulch free of charge. I can't believe that a town seemingly as prosperous and advanced as Kingwood does not already have a service like this. Even if they sold the mulch just to cover expenses we'd all be better off.

How about this: BBTA sets up an interim mulching business. They get all tree removal contractors to bring the tree and forestry product to them, where they dump it for free. Then BBTA sells that mulch to the community at a competitive rate to recoup costs of tree removal. I'd support vertical integration in BBTA if it meant they could cover their own operating costs. Heck, I'd even be OK if people on the committee got paid, so long as their check came from profits generated by the association, not from "tax" dollars assessed to the association homeowners.

I'm thinking they could buy a used tub grinder for about $75000. If they get the money they are asking from us, they will have almost $300000. So they get the unit, start making mulch, and sell it back to the public for $20/yd (competitive with retail costs). I've already bought 3 yards of mulch this year, and could use another 2. So if I buy 5 yds, I've just spent my $95, but not as much has gone to waste, and the benefit is mutual. Heck, they even stand to gain here as they will get all the material that Centerpoint left behind free of labor costs. The only labor would be in gathering, but no expenses of cutting.

I suppose I am just an enterprising dreamer. These are just obvious things that I have pointed out, like asking citizens with chainsaws to help out. These sort of proposals are answered with a "Not a chance!". How dare we infringe upon the profits of the tree removal companies...? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I'm wondering why they are wasting all this time and money to begin with.


So I'm assuming your ok with it if its your kid? I not really ok with it being anyones kid. I'll pay my 95.00 to allow the kids in KIngwood to use the greenbelts without fear on a tree falling on them. I'm sure most families spend that much a month on crap food from McDonalds and the like. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I'm thinking they could buy a used tub grinder for about $75000. If they get the money they are asking from us, they will have almost $300000. So they get the unit, start making mulch, and sell it back to the public for $20/yd (competitive with retail costs). I've already bought 3 yards of mulch this year, and could use another 2. So if I buy 5 yds, I've just spent my $95, but not as much has gone to waste, and the benefit is mutual. Heck, they even stand to gain here as they will get all the material that Centerpoint left behind free of labor costs. The only labor would be in gathering, but no expenses of cutting.



I suppose I am just an enterprising dreamer. These are just obvious things that I have pointed out, like asking citizens with chainsaws to help out. These sort of proposals are answered with a "Not a chance!". How dare we infringe upon the profits of the tree removal companies...?


I think thats an awesome idea. Any reason why you are not doing it? 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

So I'm assuming your ok with it if its your kid? I not really ok with it being anyones kid. I'll pay my 95.00 to allow the kids in KIngwood to use the greenbelts without fear on a tree falling on them. I'm sure most families spend that much a month on crap food from McDonalds and the like. 

I appreciate your concern for my children (first one on the way!) I do believe I'll teach my kids to look up. Common sense really can save lives. Not to say that most kids don't have common sense, but from what I've seen in today's society, I struggle to find much hope. I pray I will never look back at my children and think "I could have done better". On the other hand, I don't eat McDonald's, and certainly won't be feeding it to my children, I don't care how much they beg. They'll thank me when they aren't obese in grade school.

As for the tub grinder, if I had the capital, I would do it in a heartbeat. And BBTA did have the capital, before they wasted it on tree removal. Heck something like this can be proposed to non-profit groups, or government grants. Put it this way, if BBTA sent me a letter asking for $95 so they could invest in a tub grinder, and in exchange I'd get 5 free yards of mulch, I'd do it. I like to see physical value in the money I spend. I don't put much stock in investments that pay out in personal satisfaction or peace of mind. Call me a stubborn engineer, but it's all about the numbers for me. Overly analytical? Perhaps. Do I make bad investments? Possibly, but if the numbers show that it should pay out, then I always consider it. Unforeseen losses are just that; unforeseen.

You probably know as well as I do, but Kingwood was designed and built to be profitable enterprise. One in which vertical integration to make our community better than those around us should be considered. But then we assigned a bunch of committees to do the leg work but didn't teach them how. And then we got taken over by Houston, who promised to take care of everything, but left it up to the aforementioned committees. All this non-profit BS is what gets them in trouble. Show me an HOA or trail association that is allowed to operate as business, and profit likewise, and I'll gladly pay the dues. But when I am paying "taxes" for projects in which there is no physical return, I get upset. I may as well just burn my $95. Actually, I guess I'll have to pay someone $5 to burn the other $90 for me.

Rant over. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Well, looks like they are going to get their money anyway ... one way or another.
I just got my assessment notice in the mail today and it went up from $250 to $325, mostly because of the costs related to the dead tree issues.
Somehow, I knew they would get the money out of us. 

zapper007 --- 14 years ago -

We are all scr*wed!!!!!! 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

We are all scr*wed!!!!!!

Yup! Not only did we have to pay outrageous electric and water bills from last summer, now we have to pay for the removal of the trees lost due to an act of Nature! 

SuperFantastic --- 14 years ago -

save the squirells 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I just got my assessment notice in the mail today and it went up from $250 to $325, mostly because of the costs related to the dead tree issues.

OMG, that's a big increase! Mine didn't go up where I live. But after Ike they assessed a fee for the storm clean up...OY. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Mine didn't go up where I live.

Lucky you ... I'm in Bear Branch and if you have been through our greenbelts, it is sad. It looks like a war zone. I stay out of them if I can. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

We all have options. We can buy homes in a deeded subdivision, we can buy homes in an untrestricted are, and we can buy homes on acreage out in the country. I chose to live in a master planned deed restricted community. I knew when I bought my first home here that maintenance and up keep were a part of the deal. Its not stocking to me that after a storm or drought additional fees are needed. I'm just glad that it is done evenly by home rather than by income level. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

Well, looks like they are going to get their money anyway ... one way or another.
I just got my assessment notice in the mail today and it went up from $250 to $325, mostly because of the costs related to the dead tree issues.
Somehow, I knew they would get the money out of us.



Different association. That's BB Village.

It's BB Trail that has the special assessment of $95 hence doubling the normal $95 annual assessment.

So BB residents get a double whammy this year is BB Trail passes.


Its not stocking to me that after a storm or drought additional fees are needed. I'm just glad that it is done evenly by home rather than by income level.



I wonder why none of the other villages have this issue due to tree removal costs. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

Lucky you ... I'm in Bear Branch and if you have been through our greenbelts, it is sad. It looks like a war zone. I stay out of them if I can.


I walk the big loop through Hunters Ridge and BB. The HR portion is horrible and has the sun shining through for most of it. BB has tree cover due to proximity of Buckeye Creek on one side and Ben's Branch on the other. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Lucky you ... I'm in Bear Branch and if you have been through our greenbelts, it is sad. It looks like a war zone. I stay out of them if I can.

I have no idea how they are assessing the fees for tree damage..But I ride a lot all over town and BB got hit HARD with tree damage. If you walk/ride from WLHP to Deerbrook through to Woodbridge, just YIKES...There are bald patches in some of those areas. Some folks who had nothing but forest in the back of their homes and privacy, have nothing now..:(((( And they aren't even done yet cutting stuff down. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think part of the reason is because BB is one of the older areas and has a larger area too. The further back you go the fewer trees there e in general. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I think part of the reason is because BB is one of the older areas and has a larger area too. The further back you go the fewer trees there e in general.

Very likely. What's funny is there is only WLHP that separates Greentree from BB, but what a difference. I'm saying if you stay on that greenbelt that runs between them and under WLHP, Greentree has had very little tree loss in comparison, but you're probably right, BB just has more. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Trust me other villages are suffering due to the cost of removing trees! 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

BBTA claims to be the biggest trail association, encompassing three villages and +/-14 miles of trails.
Keep in mind the only tree removal they are doing is on trees considered to be in dangerous proximity to the trail or homes. If you're off the end of a trail spur like me, all the dead trees will be left to the will of nature. Unless Centerpoint takes them down. 

evie --- 14 years ago -

I know this is after the fact, but who is checking the count on the special assessment fee? How do we know that the same people weren't counted twice? Has anyone audited them? I am a senior citizen and NEVER use the Trails, (and did anyone offer a lower rate to the residents to pay for their trees that were hit because of the drought?) Now we have a problem with someone almost raped in the Trails. Wouldn't it be wiser rather than a Special Assessment to have a walk at your own risk, because who is protecting the residents? I read on the Internet that one can challenge Special Assessments in court. I am disgusted that there was no e-mail advising of the count, just a bill that I can't afford to pay with the little income seniors receive! How about giving Seniors a break on these fees - most of us don't use the Trails or is that unethical? I moved here because I had to find a place north of town after being hit with Hurricane Ike, that is safe after losing my house. My whole question is was the count accurate, or was it sent out without a true audited count? I can't afford to pay it after just paying $320 for HOA fees in July does anyone have any suggestions? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Special assessment was approved by vote. Extra 95.00 to remove all the dead trees is fair imo. I sent the check in with my yes vote. 

andreweggplant --- 14 years ago -

Special assessment was approved by vote. Extra 95.00 to remove all the dead trees is fair imo. I sent the check in with my yes vote.

Not approved in the first round so they continued to have votes until the rules allowed a minimum quorum and it passed. The HOA has a $900,000 reserve. This is above and beyond the budget,(which I understand they are opearting below right now). Some of these funds should have been used to remove the trees. Since the $95.00 special assesment is only going to remove the hazardous trees (not all of the dead trees) it is my feeling there will most likely be another "special assesment coming, especially if we have another storm come through. I agree homeowners should have been notified of the vote not just sent a bill. I do not even live in Bear Branch so why do I have to pay the same $95.00 as the rest of Bear Branch? It should be prorated like the annual fees are. 

iwaveatcows --- 14 years ago -

i received two vote notices ... voted no two times -- then just recently got the bill 

tdbrueggen --- 14 years ago -

I'll chime in here since I started it. I went to the first meeting, where they discussed the vote. At that time, they had sent out the first notice, but had not received enough response to actually take a vote. So they decided to send out a second notice. I think I explained it all pretty well in the original post, but they have the rules set so that the less response they get from us, the easier it is for them to pass rules. My concern was with the discussion of whether they needed to send a second round of letters to everyone, or just to those who didn't reply the first time. Then there was the question about how the percentage of response really was counted. I don't imagine that they "cheated" on the count, since they are subject to an audit if anyone wants it. But instead what they do, is just push and grind on things like this until they get their way.

I would think after the first round failure, they should have just dropped it. But like with all politics, there was someone with enough cash or influence pushing it, that it got done. Seems to me that the tree removal companies have a lot to gain here. I wonder which one of them is married or close friends with someone on the board.

To Tatertot1158, you should know that Bear Branch Trail Association encompasses three villages; Bear Branch, Hunters Ridge, and one other. I am in Hunters Ridge, and was really confused at first as well. Also, there will not be another special assessment. They are only allowed one per year by their own rules. But what they can do is just up the amount next year if they want. The sad part is, they are going to blow all their funds on tree removal that really isn't needed. What happens if we have a big storm blow through, after they run out of money again?

My original proposal was if they wanted to cut down trees, they should just drop them where they are, and leave them to nature. Disposal is the most expensive part of the removal.

My final consensus after trying to figure out how the BBTA operates is this: They are OK people, and may even have good intentions. But they don't seem to have much fiscal sense, or common sense. The thought process seems to be that they are just executing demands from the community. They are not obligated to really think things through. Just pay someone to do the work.

Here I'll get sentimental. If you want to build a strong community, encourage community involvement. I offered to help cut down the trees, offering my own labor and chainsaw to save some money. I was sat down with a "Hell no" because of liability. I even offered to sign a waiver, but still not allowed. Just like our great government, they think they know best. They want us all to shut up and just pay the "taxes". They'll take care of the rest.

Long story short, if you don't like it, they don't care, and they won't change it. You may as well start looking elsewhere. Good luck escaping any sort of HOA, BTW. You better look long and hard to make sure any property you buy is free and clear from deed restrictions. Or buy a house in the ghetto where no one cares what you do. 

u uic --- 14 years ago -

I know some people came on here yapping 500 dollars a tree is a good deal. When was the last time you went out in the thicket? 40 to 50 percent of the trees are 2 and 3 inch diameter. Its not like a tree on the lawn allowed to expand out. Cant tell you people anything though. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
kingwood
news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground