Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Universal Reconciliation is True, but Universal Salvation is False.

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Donkey Hodie 4
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 16
Work in Progress 17
SwollenBlade 8
Dorothy Parker 1
JRG79 5
Odin 4
Loveday 1
Insurrection 26

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

are the sins of all mankind forgiven?... YES!

is everyone saved because their sins have been forgiven?...NO!


"Many are the attempts made by those who understand nothing of the real character of God to save Him from the undesirable reputation He must acquire if He does not in compassion rescue all beings from eternal retribution. Such is the doctrinal confusion which arises when one truth is stressed without regard for other truths which qualify it. God is holiness and righteousness as well as love It is the holiness of His Person and the righteousness of His government which preclude Him from any mere generosity which would make light of sin. In fact, sin is sufficiently sinful to require eternal retribution as the divine penalty for it. There is no field for argument at this point. The Word of God must stand and man must be reminded that of the two issues involved---sin and holiness---he knows nothing about their depth of meaning. Being absolute, divine holiness cannot be varied or altered in the least degree. This truth is the key to the entire problem which the idea of retribution engenders. If God could have forgiven one sin of one person as an act of mere kindness, He would have compromised His own holiness which demands judgment for sin. Having thus compromised Himself with sin, He would need Himself to be saved because of the unrighteous thing He had done. He would, by such supposed kindness, have established a principle by which He could forgive all human sin as an act of divine clemency, and thus the death of Christ is rendered unnecessary. This truth must not be overlooked if the doctrine of eternal retribution is to be understood at all. Let it be restated that, if God could save one soul from one sin by mere generosity, He could save all souls from sin by generosity and the death of Christ thus becomes the greatest possible divine blunder.

It is the fact of unyielding divine holiness which demands either the retribution of the sinner or the death of Christ in his room and stead. God is love, and that love is demonstrated by the gift of the Son that men might be saved; but love and mercy did not circumvent the demands of holiness to save the sinner: they paid its every demand. The conclusion of the matter is that God, because of His holiness, cannot save the lost unless His holy demands are met for the sinner, as they are met in the death of Christ; and to be unsaved, or outside the grace of God as it is in Christ, is to be destined to eternal retribution. God can do no more than to provide a perfect salvation, which is provided at infinite cost. When love will pay such a price that a sinner may be saved and holiness remain untarnished, it ill becomes finite men to tamper with these immutable realities. Those who resent the idea of eternal retribution are, in fact, resenting divine holiness. However, the message of God's grace to sinful men is not merely a proclamation of eternal condemnation; it is rather that the chief of sinners may be saved through the Savior that infinite love has provided."

- from http://www.1john57.com/unitdefeated.htm 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

Tl;dr but i'll summarize the above post for anyone else who couldn't finish it.

Basicly can we all be saved and go to heaven? Yes

But are we all going to heaven? No

The logic behind this is even better, because God is omnipotent he knows our future before he creates us. That means God creates some people specifically for the purpose of packing hell. Yay jeebus! 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

That means God creates some people specifically for the purpose of packing hell. Yay jeebus! 


Yeah, that's a hard pill to swallow when trying to understand Christianity. It also kinda makes a farce of "free will," doesn't it?

If Christianity makes someone a better person or feel good about themselves, more power to them.

It's definitely not for me...too many things you have to take on "faith" alone that make zero sense in reality. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

That means God creates some people specifically for the purpose of packing hell.

people will pack themselves into hell...God has given them a way out...they will just refuse The Way

if you continue with your current beliefs...and end up in hell...it won't be because God didn't give you a choice


.too many things you have to take on "faith" alone that make zero sense in reality

there's only one thing you have to take on faith...and your "reality" isn't the truth

the sad thing is...you're hurting yourself 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

God created the people knowing where they would end up, he created earth and put the people there, he created hell and after death he puts people in there.

Where is the free will? Does not everything move according to God's plan? He planned to create hell with the intention of packing it.

He then created people knowing they would go to hell but told them they have free will, knowing full well he would send them to hell after death.

So then what is the point of creating those people at all? Why not just create only the people who will go to heaven and avoid the pointless eternal torture?

Why would God create me just to torture me for eternity? What kind of God does this? Oh and my other option is to kiss God's butt for eternity?

Personally if thats the case I would preferred for God to have never created me in the first place. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Swollen, you are likely a deist.

I thought as you did but didn't have a name for it until I read an autobiography by one of our Country's founding fathers. And I was like "damn, that's that I believe".

I didn't know it had a term before. Figured my views were "uniquely my own" 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

Beaver, that is most likely a masonic point of view on religion. I agree with masons on alot of their views on religion. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Beaver, that is most likely a masonic point of view on religion.

It just might be... 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Where is the free will?

you have the free will to choose heaven or hell...btw...God didn't create hell for people

He then created people knowing they would go to hell but told them they have free will, knowing full well he would send them to hell after death.

i'm not going to hell...and you have the choice to not to go there either

Why would God create me just to torture me for eternity?

that's not why you were born...you will be the one to choose that ending if that is where you end up

Swollen, you are likely a deist.

a deist will find the same ending as any other person who doesn't accept Christ 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

God creates us without our consent. He forces us to live life on earth. Then with as much consent as we gave in our choice to live he takes that life away. And while all this is being forced on us we have to choose to love him or burn eternally. He then forcefully takes our life as he chooses and he then crams us in heaven or hell, but we have "free will" righhht.... 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

God creates us without our consent.

actually...your parents created you

life is eternal...God doesn't take that away...and each of us choose where our eternal destination will be

you are using your free will right now to post your disapproval with God...you are also using your free will to reject God...i use my free will to choose God...i know that what He has for me in the future is infinitely better than i could do on my own 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

My parents gave birth to me, but both my parents and I are creations of God, we exist because of his will to create us.

I have free will to voice my displeasure inside a box, a system with 2 paths, with a beginning and ending none of which was my choice. Despite of my rage i'm still just a rat in a cage?

Our free will amounts to nothing more than to rabble in line to the right or the left, what if i dont want to be in the line in the first place? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I have free will to voice my displeasure inside a box, a system with 2 paths, with a beginning and ending none of which was my choice.

there could only be two paths...good or evil...you have the choice of following good or following evil

the bottom line is...you do exist...so you have a choice to make...so make the correct one 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

The threat of eternal hellfire is a doctrine that didn't exist in the early church until Augustine and the Fifth ecumenical council. Emperor Justinian played a large part in that council which was concerned with condemning the teachings of Origen, Theodoret, and Theodore of Mopsuestia. Their teachings were causing too much free-thinking in the uneducated masses and Justinian wanted a way to bring the people under control by use of the church, Condemning the concept that all men will be saved and reconciled to God through Christ and teaching a doctrine of eternal damnation proved an effective way for the empire and church to enforce obedience through fear. Fortunately, the Eastern Church was wise enough to resist this oppression, thus the beginnings of the Catholic/Orthodox Schism.

there could only be two paths...good or evil...
You're absolutely right, and a doctrine of fear and oppression that enforces obedience through psychological manipulation and spiritual abuse to maintain its structures of power is inherently evil. Love and good do not manipulate people through fear and threats of hell, nor do they seek to continue systems of oppression and subjugation to closed-minded dogma. Love and good seek to break down barriers and overthrow systems of oppression. Anyone that seeks to continue a system of enforced obedience through fear and doctrines of oppression is not acting out of love and goodness; they're merely seeking to maintain power over others. 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

"This is the teaser trailer for "Hellbound?" (www.hellboundthemovie.com), a feature-length documentary that takes an in-depth look at today's highly contentious debate over the Christian doctrine of eternal punishment. Does hell really exist, and if so, what factors determine who ends up there? Written and directed by Kevin Miller ("Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed," "Sex+Money," "spOILed" and "With God On Our Side"), "Hellbound?" features interviews with an eclectic group of high profile authors, theologians, pastors, social commentators, musicians, exorcists and individuals who claim to have experienced the fires of hell firsthand. The film will hit theaters across North America in September 2012 through a combination of major metropolitan area theatrical runs and special event screenings."



 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

The threat of eternal hellfire is a doctrine that didn't exist in the early church until Augustine and the Fifth ecumenical council.

actually, you are incorrect...Jesus...whom the Church was built upon...preached of hell


Love and good seek to break down barriers and overthrow systems of oppression.

love and good did break down barriers and overthrow systems of oppression when God Himself died for us and rose from the dead...He gave us a Path...a Way...all we have to do is to accept that gift He gave us...if we do that...hell is no longer a concern


Does hell really exist, and if so, what factors determine who ends up there?

we don't need to listen to an eclectic group of high profile authors, theologians, pastors, social commentators, musicians, exorcists and individuals who claim to have experienced the fires of hell firsthand to know the answer...the Bible contains the answer...and the answer is...YES 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

we don't need to listen to an eclectic group of high profile authors, theologians, pastors, social commentators, musicians, exorcists and individuals who claim to have experienced the fires of hell firsthand to know the answer...the Bible contains the answer...and the answer is...YES 

And we don't need to listen to narrow-minded internet street prophets like you that claim that they know the only truth about God.

actually, you are incorrect...Jesus...whom the Church was built upon...preached of hell


For someone that loves to beat people over the head with Greek root words when it suits him, you sure do back off of this one and stay purely in English. Jesus never once preached about "hell." You only want to use the original Greek text when it suits your purposes of spiritually and psychologically abusing people. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

And we don't need to listen to narrow-minded internet street prophets like you that claim that they know the only truth about God.

LIKE!!!! 

Loveday --- 14 years ago -

I didn't know it had a term before. Figured my views were "uniquely my own"

Every Deist I've ever met has said the same thing!

There's also Christian Deism, which is closest to what I believe. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Every Deist I've ever met has said the same thing!

There's also Christian Deism which is closest to what I believe.


I'll read up on that later today. Not sure if that fits but maybe it does.

I am a deist but I also consider Jesus to be a great teacher. I do believe he existed and I do believe many of the stories about him. Now, that does not mean I believe in "immaculate conception", the trinity, and some of the other stuff. 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

There's also Christian Deism which is closest to what I believe. 

Thanks for that link, Loveday.

From that site:

"1. There is only one God, Creator of the Universe and the natural laws that govern it.

2. Every human being is a Child of God, and infused with the spirit of God. When we do God’s will we become closer to God.

3. Jesus taught that it is God’s will for you to “love your neighbor (including enemies) as yourself,” (Matthew 22:39; 5:43-44) which means that “whatever you wish that people would do to you, do so to them.” (Matthew 7:12).

4. God’s will is taught to everyone by God (John 6:45) in the design of human nature, and is learned through human experience and reasoning. We worship (honor) God by doing God’s will.

5. Failures to love others, by causing human suffering or by being indifferent to human suffering, are offenses (sins) against God, and are destructive to your soul.

6. If you repent of your sins and you forgive others who sin against you, God forgives your sins (Matthew 6:14-15), and restores your soul.

7. If you try to live by love for others, and sincerely repent of your failures to love, you will enjoy satisfaction with yourself in this life, and you have reason to hope that God will give you another life."


While I can't consider myself a deist, Christian or otherwise, I think these points of faith are much more constructive to producing people who demonstrate Christ's love towards the sick, suffering, and outcast than any sort of revivalist hellfire preaching and fundamentalist exclusivity and stifling of free thought. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

monday school 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

And we don't need to listen to narrow-minded internet street prophets like you that claim that they know the only truth about God.

that is a lie...i have never claimed that...i do know the Bible which is the truth about God

Jesus never once preached about "hell."

yep...He did..."geenna" is the Greek word for hell


There's also Christian Deism, which is closest to what I believe. 

christian deism is an oxymoron...you can't be a Christian unless you believe in "the trinity, and some of the other stuff.".

While I can't consider myself a deist, Christian or otherwise, I think these points of faith are much more constructive to producing people who demonstrate Christ's love towards the sick, suffering, and outcast than any sort of revivalist hellfire preaching and fundamentalist exclusivity and stifling of free thought. 

you're nothing but a liberal who wants to pretend to be a Christian...unless you believe in the fundamentals...you aren't a Christian 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

I don't think Jesus spoke greek.

There is a good chance that humans wrote the entire bible and your totally wrong.

If humans did write the bible than what are we to belive?

If God wanted his word spread by people perhaps he should not have given people the ability to lie?

Well in the end all you can do is live a good life and hope God doesn't send you to hell for watching soft core porn on Cinemax.

Adhering too strongly to your opinions, being unable to adapt or shift your paradigms, and blind ignorance are the only sins I see here.

Well they would be sins if I was God but I'm also applying common sense. Maybe God gave me common sense cause he uses it too. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I don't think Jesus spoke greek.

yep...He did...alomg with Aramaic and Hebrew

There is a good chance that humans wrote the entire bible and your totally wrong.

no chance of that at all

Maybe God gave me common sense cause he uses it too.

people can WRONGLY apply common sense...and some people can WRONGLY believe that they have common sense 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

christian deism is an oxymoron...you can't be a Christian unless you believe in "the trinity, and some of the other stuff.".

That's a narrow-minded false hood.

And we don't need to listen to narrow-minded internet street prophets like you that claim that they know the only truth about God.

that is a lie...i have never claimed that...i do know the Bible which is the truth about God


And you've just proven yourself to be a liar and a fraud, since you just claimed that your interpretation of the Bible is the only valid one.

yep...He did..."geenna" is the Greek word for hell

No, it isn't, and you're just proving your ignorance of the Scriptures and history by making that claim. Gehenna was nothing more than a garbage dump, and it was used figuratively by Jesus in a parabolic form. Had Jesus meant the place of eternal punishment described by Greek philosophers, He would have used the word "Tartarus" which was the place underneath Hades of eternal punishment. Since Jesus was a Jew, and not a Greek, that concept would not be a valid one from His Father.

Seems like you really don't know squat about the Bible, lynch... 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

My common sense says that greater of God's gifts rests between your ears and not in the peices of paper and glue that you run around bonking people with.

Well the gift of a brain I mean generally and not you specifically.

Even if my common sense is lacking or wrong and I burn in hell because of it. At least it will be my actions that get me there and I wont have to blame it on some idiot from the internet.

no chance of that at all? Prove it.

hurrrrrrrrrr. 

JRG79 --- 14 years ago -

-by Gregory Koukl (excerpts from article, full link to article at bottom)

"Let me make an observation as a person who is committed to defending the Gospel—and that’s what an apologist does. I hope that’s what all Christians do. They proclaim it, and in a certain sense, proclaiming it accurately is a defense of it. By ignoring the Gospel, you’re acting as if it’s inconsequential. By not talking about the Gospel, it’s like it doesn’t matter, and that is almost an attack on the message itself. A careful, accurate proclamation of the Gospel is an acknowledgement that it is true, an affirmation of its importance. It’s a bare minimum, but this bare minimum is under attack. It is certainly under attack outside of broader Christian circles, because people think it’s ridiculous to think that one religion is the only true religion.

People don’t mind Christians who love Jesus. You’re welcome to Him and to your truth. They do mind Christians who love Jesus and say the same things about non-Christians that Jesus Himself said: They are lost. “I have come to seek and to save that which was lost.” (Luke 19:10) “He who believes in the Son has eternal life. He who does not believe, the wrath of God abides on him.” (John 3:36) “If you do not believe that I am He, you will die in your sins.” (John 8:24) “He who believes is not judged, but he who does not believe is judged already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.” (John 3:18)

Every one of those sentences is from the mouth of Jesus Himself. There is no twisting or distorting them when you cite just the verse, because understanding the context only intensifies the meaning that is obvious in the verse itself. So when someone argues there is no final reckoning and there is no Hell, either because of annihilationism (nonbelievers cease to exist when they die) or because eventually all nonbelievers are drawn into Heaven, then they are communicating a message that is diametrically opposed to the Great Commission, the last command that Jesus left the Church."

"Anybody who teaches that Hell doesn’t satisfy God’s justice is teaching contrary to the Scripture, and contrary to Jesus. They’re giving people, especially in the case of those who are universalists, false hope: Don’t worry about it. Everybody gets in. Their message gives false comfort and keeps sinners from receiving the forgiveness of sins they desperately need. It undermines the Gospel because if everyone will be reconciled to God no matter what their decision about Jesus is, then there’s little reason to appeal to people to put their trust in Him for rescue. They don’t need it."

"n the end, it’s not faithful to the Bible and it’s not a loving act to avoid offending people, but to let them die in their sins. Loving people and being faithful to God means telling the truth as the Bible teaches it."

Full Article: Hell and the Gospel 

SwollenBlade --- 14 years ago -

^ short version: Believe in God or go to hell. (because it says so on this piece of paper) 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

Anybody who teaches that Hell doesn’t satisfy God’s justice is teaching contrary to the Scripture, and contrary to Jesus. They’re giving people, especially in the case of those who are universalists, false hope: Don’t worry about it. Everybody gets in. Their message gives false comfort and keeps sinners from receiving the forgiveness of sins they desperately need. It undermines the Gospel because if everyone will be reconciled to God no matter what their decision about Jesus is, then there’s little reason to appeal to people to put their trust in Him for rescue. They don’t need it."


This is a demonstration of profound ignorance of what Christian Universalism teaches. And his whole article is nothing more than puling a few proof-texts out of the totality of Scripture and using them to debate a strawman built of false assumptions of the opposing view. Pure intellectual dishonesty. 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

My common sense says that greater of God's gifts rests between your ears and not in the peices of paper and glue that you run around bonking people with.


The gift of logic and reason is indeed a great gift from God, and it allows us to look past the surface meaning of the parables, and to take in all of the Bible to come to a proper synthesis.

From my belief, though, I would submit that the greatest gift He gave to us is the ability to love and to show compassion to the suffering. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

This is a demonstration of profound ignorance of what Christian Universalism teaches.

Can you tell me, in a few sentences, what Christian Universalists do believe? I mean the nuts and bolts, especially regarding hell?

Christ spent more time speaking about hell than he even did heaven! Do you believe that he spoke as hell as being judged out of existence? Meaning, that at the white throne judgment, those not sealed by God are eradicated and cease to exist?

Or do I have it all screwed up? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Oh, just read over some of the beliefs from the Deist site listed above.

I'm pretty sure that I can come up with scripture to defeat pretty much every point there. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It will take me some time to find the scriptures, but this is where mainstream Christianity differs from this.

"1. There is only one God, Creator of the Universe and the natural laws that govern it.


There is ONE God, who is triune in persons. He created a perfect universe. The universe we live in is marred by sin, and everything is leading to decay.

2. Every human being is a Child of God, and infused with the spirit of God. When we do God’s will we become closer to God.

Nowhere in the Bible are unbelievers referred to as "children" of God. One must accept Jesus Christ to be adopted in. One must be filled with the Holy Spirit, we are not born with it!

3. Jesus taught that it is God’s will for you to “love your neighbor (including enemies) as yourself,” (Matthew 22:39; 5:43-44) which means that “whatever you wish that people would do to you, do so to them.” (Matthew 7:12).

Yes, this is the second greatest commandment. The first is, "Love the Lord, your God, with all of your heart, mind and soul."

4. God’s will is taught to everyone by God (John 6:45) in the design of human nature, and is learned through human experience and reasoning. We worship (honor) God by doing God’s will.

God's will is taught through scripture and prayer. Our reasoning is flawed, faulty, and will lead us astray.

5. Failures to love others, by causing human suffering or by being indifferent to human suffering, are offenses (sins) against God, and are destructive to your soul.

Fair enough.

6. If you repent of your sins and you forgive others who sin against you, God forgives your sins (Matthew 6:14-15), and restores your soul.

If you believe in your heart that Jesus is Lord, and confess with your mouth God raised him from the dead, you shall be saved.

7. If you try to live by love for others, and sincerely repent of your failures to love, you will enjoy satisfaction with yourself in this life, and you have reason to hope that God will give you another life."


First, and greatest, is our love of God, and acceptance of His son's sacrifice so that we CAN repent of our sins. Christ paid the price that we cannot pay, so that we can be reconciled to God. 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

you can't be a Christian unless you believe in "the trinity, and some of the other stuff.".

I guess the Apostles and the other early disciples weren't Christians. Since "The Trinity" was decided as a doctrine at the first Council of Nicea in 325. Even then, it wasn't widely taught until after the Council of Constantinople in 360. 

JRG79 --- 14 years ago -

Insurrection: I went back and found your thread about the 7 myths of universalism. It does state a universalist believes in hell it's just everyone will exit eventually. I guess this is what makes Christ's death on the cross relevant because He's still the "bridge" so to speak. I don't understand scripturally how people would come to faith in Christ in hell which is the absence of God. What about Revelation and the final judgement? I feel like universalism is a "feel good" view so people don't get offended. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

That's a narrow-minded false hood.

nope...it's what the bible says

And you've just proven yourself to be a liar and a fraud, since you just claimed that your interpretation of the Bible is the only valid one.

nope...i didn't claim that at all...in fact...i don't claim to interpret the Bible


He would have used the word "Tartarus" which was the place underneath Hades of eternal punishment. Since Jesus was a Jew, and not a Greek, that concept would not be a valid one from His Father.


the word "tartaroo" or "tartarus" is defined by Strong's as "the name of the subterranean region, doleful and dark, regarded by the ancient Greeks as the abode of the wicked dead, where they suffer punishment for their evil deeds; it answers to Gehenna of the Jews"

you do remember that Jesus is a Jew...don't you?

Seems like you really don't know squat about the Bible, lynch...

apparently somewhat more than you do


From my belief, though, I would submit that the greatest gift He gave to us is the ability to love and to show compassion to the suffering.

not by a long shot...the greatest gift He gave us was Himself 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I guess the Apostles and the other early disciples weren't Christians. Since "The Trinity" was decided as a doctrine at the first Council of Nicea in 325. Even then, it wasn't widely taught until after the Council of Constantinople in 360.


once again...you have guessed wrong...the earliest Christians believed that God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit were ONE 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Dh, christ claimed to be God, and told the disciples about the coming of the Holy spirit. The trinity was known before council of nicea. Even in the OT, the prophets referred to the Holy Spirit. 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

Where is the word "trinity" in the Bible?

JL claimed that believing in the "trinity" is one thing that is required of a Christian. Where is it in the Bible? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground