Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ethicists Argue in Favor of ‘After-Birth Abortions‘ as Newborns ’Are Not Persons’

who's talking here?

Carla 1
sunshine1881 11
planemom 1
AuthorMan 1
Donkey Hodie 6
SoupIsGoodFood 11
Hiro Protagonist 3
JohnLynch 9
TheMasticator 7
Work in Progress 14
LiveFreeOrDie 14
FabulousFinder 1
Pat Barry 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Two ethicists working with Australian universities argue in the latest online edition of the Journal of Medical Ethics that if abortion of a fetus is allowable, so to should be the termination of a newborn.
Ethicists Argue for Acceptance of After Birth Abortions

Alberto Giubilini with Monash University in Melbourne and Francesca Minerva at the Centre for Applied Philosophy and Public Ethics at the University of Melbourne write that in “circumstances occur[ing] after birth such that they would have justified abortion, what we call after-birth abortion should be permissible.”

The two are quick to note that they prefer the term “after-birth abortion“ as opposed to ”infanticide.” Why? Because it “[emphasizes] that the moral status of the individual killed is comparable with that of a fetus (on which ‘abortions’ in the traditional sense are performed) rather than to that of a child.” The authors also do not agree with the term euthanasia for this practice as the best interest of the person who would be killed is not necessarily the primary reason his or her life is being terminated. In other words, it may be in the parents’ best interest to terminate the life, not the newborns.

The circumstances, the authors state, where after-birth abortion should be considered acceptable include instances where the newborn would be putting the well-being of the family at risk, even if it had the potential for an “acceptable” life. The authors cite Downs Syndrome as an example, stating that while the quality of life of individuals with Downs is often reported as happy, “such children might be an unbearable burden on the family and on society as a whole, when the state economically provides for their care.”

This means a newborn whose family (or society) that could be socially, economically or psychologically burdened or damaged by the newborn should have the ability to seek out an after-birth abortion. They state that after-birth abortions are not preferable over early-term abortions of fetuses but should circumstances change with the family or the fetus in the womb, then they advocate that this option should be made available.

The authors go on to state that the moral status of a newborn is equivalent to a fetus in that it cannot be considered a person in the “morally relevant sense.” On this point, the authors write:

"Both a fetus and a newborn certainly are human beings and potential persons, but neither is a ‘person’ in the sense of ‘subject of a moral right to life’. We take ‘person’ to mean an individual who is capable of attributing to her own existence some (at least) basic value such that being deprived of this existence represents a loss to her."

[...]

"Merely being human is not in itself a reason for ascribing someone a right to life. Indeed, many humans are not considered subjects of a right to life: spare embryos where research on embryo stem cells is permitted, fetuses where abortion is permitted, criminals where capital punishment is legal."

Giubilini and Minerva believe that being able to understand the value of a different situation, which often depends on mental development, determines personhood. For example, being able to tell the difference between an undesirable situation and a desirable one. They note that fetuses and newborns are “potential persons.” The authors do acknowledge that a mother, who they cite as an example of a true person, can attribute “subjective” moral rights to the fetus or newborn, but they state this is only a projected moral status.

The authors counter the argument that these “potential persons” have the right to reach that potential by stating it is “over-ridden by the interests of actual people (parents, family, society) to pursue their own well-being because, as we have just argued, merely potential people cannot be harmed by not being brought into existence.”

And what about adoption? Giubilini and Minerva write that, as for the mother putting the child up for adoption, her emotional state should be considered as a trumping right. For instance, if she were to “suffer psychological distress” from giving up her child to someone else — they state that natural mothers can dream their child will return to them — then after-birth abortion should be considered an allowable alternative.

The authors do not tackle the issue of what age an infant would be considered a person.

The National Catholic Register thinks that these authors are right — once you accept their ideas on personhood. The Register states that the argument made by the ethicists is almost pro-life in that it “highlights the absurdity of the pro-abortion argument”:

"The second we allow ourselves to become the arbiters of who is human and who isn’t, this is the calamitous yet inevitable end. Once you say all human life is not sacred, the rest is just drawing random lines in the sand."

First Things, a publication of the The Institute on Religion and Public Life, notes that while this article doesn’t mean the law could — or would — allow after-birth abortions in future medical procedures, arguments such as “the right to dehydrate the persistently unconscious” began in much the same way in bioethics journals. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

that if abortion of a fetus is allowable, so to should be the termination of a newborn.
Ethicists Argue for Acceptance of After Birth Abortions


Well, duh. What pro-lifer did NOT see this coming? And the age limit of what is considered a "person" will continue to be pushed up.

We are truly, an evil, evil society. May God have mercy! 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

what we call after-birth abortion should be permissible.”


I still call it MURDER!!! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I still call it MURDER!!!

Because that's what it IS, and you aren't afraid to call things by their name.

We need more like you. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

The authors cite Downs Syndrome as an example,


Sick Sick Sick!!! No different than the Spartans who tossed their unwanted babies over a cliff. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Yes, because the status of human logically is determined by whether or not they are "loved" by the mother. Because this makes perfect sense.

It's everything that the pro-lifers have been saying since Roe vs. Wade. The pro-life argument is the ONLY sound argument. Pro-choice--where the mother "chooses" whether or not her baby is human and worthy of life, has NOTHING. It is evil, and deplorable. And yes, reminiscient of Sparta, and OT paganism where they passed their babies through the fires of Molech.

Horrifyingly evil, and yet, people argue for this right everyday! Their minds are so twisted, that they can't recognize logic or right or wrong anymore.

I have to walk away, before I get anymore upset. This issues nauseates me. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Well, duh. What pro-lifer did NOT see this coming? And the age limit of what is considered a "person" will continue to be pushed up.

Push it up to the age limit of these "ethicists", abort them, and then move it back down. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

One more thing, and then I'll have to get off, because I feel my blood pressure rising, as it always does when I think about the murder of innocents. . .

I keep thinking about how the Christians didn't do anything to stop the holocaust in Nazi Germany. The trains would pass by the churches, and the Christians would sing LOUDER so that they wouldn't have to hear those trains, because they knew enough about what was going on to know it was evil.

Why don't we rise up to stop the holocaust of babies? Don't get me wrong, when I say that I am pro-life, I mean exactly that, I am pro-life for all. I don't desire a violent uprising, but I do desire a stop to this holocaust of our most innocent, and least protected humans. It is SICKENING that we allow this to continue! It is pathetic, that we have allowed people to justify murder, as if it is some kind of right! What is wrong with us that we have not fought harder for these babies?

Politicians pander to the pro-life movement sometimes, but they never do anything, meanwhile, babies are being murdered by the millions, and we are paying for it, and we just sit around arguing on messageboards about abortion, all while actual human beings are being burned to death with salt, or decimated within their mothers' wombs, or decapitated once they exit the birth canal! This is barbarity beyond all extreme, and yet, we sit idly by while it all happens every day! Why????? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I just feel like we are going to have to answer to GOD about why we didn't do more to stop the murder of babies that was happening before us every day.

And before some liberal jumps on here twisting my words, I do not advocate violence for ANYONE. But I do think that we have an obligation to fight legally for the life of these precious ones. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I just feel like we are going to have to answer to GOD about why we didn't do more to stop the murder of babies that was happening before us every day.


We absolutely will and are, have you noticed the state of our nation?? 

AuthorMan --- 14 years ago -

Guess these people will evolve to killing babies if the hair color is wrong. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

The circumstances, the authors state, where after-birth abortion should be considered acceptable include instances where the newborn would be putting the well-being of the family at risk, even if it had the potential for an “acceptable” life. The authors cite Downs Syndrome as an example, stating that while the quality of life of individuals with Downs is often reported as happy, “such children might be an unbearable burden on the family and on society as a whole, when the state economically provides for their care.”

It is sick but how much burden can we expect the state to bear is always my position and why oh why doesn't the church EVER step in to assist the underpriveleged and the thousands of children with no home. It's becasue their mission is $$ not lives or anything of substance other than maybe selfish afterlife aspirations.

You've never seen me argue abortion so don't lump me in.

However, your churches do nothing. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

It is sick but how much burden can we expect the state to bear is always my position and why oh why doesn't the church EVER step in to assist the underpriveleged and the thousands of children with no home. It's becasue their mission is $$ not lives or anything of substance other than maybe selfish afterlife aspirations.

You've never seen me argue abortion so don't lump me in.

However, your churches do nothing.


YES THEY DO!!!!! There are thousands of organizations out there that help women in crisis pregnancies, and in raising children. There is no shortage of charity out there for women in these situations!

I support Foundation for Life, which has a wonderful ministry of helping women through crisis pregnancies. They seek to convince the woman to keep the child, and offer assistance mentally, financially, emotionally, and spiritually all along the way.

There are so many programs at my church alone set up to help the less fortunate. But sometimes, they don't want the help, they want the government check. But we try, oh boy do we try. But I agree on one thing, we need to do more. Millions are being murdered everyday right in front of our eyes! And yet, we haven't risen up to stop this! 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

With barely 8 families in poverty PER CHURCH in texas I'd say the churches' mission is a miserable FAILURE.

With foster children and unwanteds lining the facilities I'd say again the church is a MISERABLE FAILURE.

Just admit it's about a selfish afterlife. That's all ya'll post about is who is going to hell and who isn't. It's already obvious the state HAS to provide the care the church won't. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

With barely 8 families in poverty PER CHURCH in texas I'd say the churches' mission is a miserable FAILURE.

With foster children and unwanteds lining the facilities I'd say again the church is a MISERABLE FAILURE.

Just admit it's about a selfish afterlife. That's all ya'll post about is who is going to hell and who isn't. It's already obvious the state HAS to provide the care the church won't.


But Text, you can't help those who don't want to be helped, and often, that's the problem. There is no shortage of money in Christian churches, and some abuse that, but the churches I have been a part of have a multitude of programs to help people, and we can't get the people to accept it!

For instance, we have offered free English lessons, free job skills classes, free education, free money management classes, etc. They don't come! And we went to their neighborhoods to try to market for it, they weren't interested. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The government just cuts them a check, but doesn't try to help them OUT of poverty. And for whatever reason, that's what they want.

And I know from my time teaching inner city that they've been told from birth that that's the way life is always going to be. Waiting on a welfare check, barely scraping by, no success, no pride, no responsibility.

It's incredibly sad. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

However, your churches do nothing.

the churches do a lot...but they can't do it all...and just as it isn't the government's responsibility to take care of everyone...it isn't the church's responsibility to take care of everyone...the responsibility lies on each individual to do their part in their own lives...but that is only in a perfect world...to many people expecting a handout...and too many people rejecting God...that is why Jesus said "For ye have the poor always with you" 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

WIP, your falling into the trap. Typical Liberal blaming everyone else for not taking responsibility for someone else's responsibilities. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, I was just realizing that. Back to the murder of babies, which is what this thread is about. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

WIP, your falling into the trap. Typical Liberal blaming everyone else for not taking responsibility for someone else's responsibilities.

Well not to worry, they don't vote.

THOSE people are no threat. However you'd probably be surprised how many of your christian sisters in Kingwood abort.

The atheist families are the ones I know who have children with disabilities, Downs, etc. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

THOSE people are not threat. However you'd probably be surprised how many of your christian sisters in Kingwood abort.

What does that have to do with anything? What is your point? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

THOSE people are not threat. However you'd probably be surprised how many of your christian sisters in Kingwood abort.


And that is a VERY VERY sad fact..

But no I would not be surprised.. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

The Register states that the argument made by the ethicists is almost pro-life in that it “highlights the absurdity of the pro-abortion argument”:


I'm pretty sure that's what they were attempting to do. They're pro-lifers making a point by going where no pro-choice person is willing to go. JL has even attempted to use this "logic" on KU. If you poll most pro-choice people they don't think that abortions should be performed after the first tri-mester. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

But what does it have to do with anything? Is he suggesting that because some teenagers from Christian homes have aborted children, that we don't have the moral authority to call it wrong?

How is that logical? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

If you poll most pro-choice people they don't think that abortions should be performed after the first tri-mester.

Ok then, what is so magical about the first trimester. What is it about that 12th week (or whereever the line is) that suddenly makes it a human being?

There is NO argument for abortion that stands up to logic or reason, and yet people hold on these ridiculous ideas all of the time. Do we delude ourselves for political reasons? Nobody on here wants babies to die, and yet you argue for it! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

However, your churches do nothing

Ahhh, here's the diversion.

Send this thread into another church/Christian bashing thread. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

English lessons, free job skills classes, free education, free money management classes, etc.

Why does it always go back to mexicans? I'm assuming you are referring to folks from south of the border with the english speaking classes?

They multiply at rates 3 times that of Anglos and blacks who are the ones having abortions.

Careful how you stereotype. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Why does it always go back to mexicans? I'm assuming you are referring to folks from south of the border with the english speaking classes?

Right on queue. Here's the race card.

This one is playing out like the typical liberal debate. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

What is your point text? You still havent offered anything toward the argument here.

Should abortion ne legal, and why? Should imfanticide be legal, and why? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

What is your point text?

He/she has no point.

They already conceded the argument when they played the race card. That is supposed to quell the argument because now you've been labeled as "racist". You're no longer supposed to have a voice in the argument because your the "worst of the worst" - a racist.

Don't you know how this is supposed to work?

Hahahahahaha 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

If you poll most pro-choice people they don't think that abortions should be performed after the first tri-mester.

Ok then, what is so magical about the first trimester. What is it about that 12th week (or whereever the line is) that suddenly makes it a human being?



In my opinion, as long as the fetus must rely solely on the mother to live (not viable at all outside the mother) then the mother should have full say over what happens inside her body. So, around 20 weeks. But, for the sake of playing it safe, let's back off to 13 weeks, or the first trimester. That's what's "magic" about the first trimester, in my opinion.

Again, I have never been involved in an abortion, and probably never will. But I also don't want to control what women do with their own bodies.

You want government in your bedroom? Inside your womb? Really? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

You want government in your bedroom? Inside your womb? Really?

Obamacare.............. anyone?

Really? 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

What is your point text? You still havent offered anything toward the argument here.

My point was that there are only 8 families PER CHURCH in Texas alone that are in poverty, need.

If there was ever a mission and you seem to be on a pro life mission then raising those people up should be first and foremost.

But we all know the true mission is selfish, raise thyself up indignation. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

Obamacare.............. anyone?

Funny. It's Romneycare renamed. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

In my opinion, as long as the fetus must rely solely on the mother to live (not viable at all outside the mother)


Is there a magic day that this happens??

How is this determined?? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Funny. It's Romneycare renamed.

Funny. You trying to lay it off on someone else. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

My point was that there are only 8 families PER CHURCH in Texas alone that are in poverty, need.

Might you have a link to this data? 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

Obamacare.............. anyone?

Insurance coverage for everyone is not anywhere close to the government telling you what you can do inside your own body. If anything, it makes healthcare choices more available to all. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Merely being human is not in itself a reason for ascribing someone a right to life.

THIS is the point that hinges the argument for abortion......

This is why it is so important NOW to push for laws declaring "personhood" to babies, otherwise these "academics" will label any life not "capable of attributing to her own existence" as subject to being "aborted" (killed to those sane enough still to know better) 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

There is NO argument for abortion that stands up to logic or reason,

Bzzzzzt. False. Just because you don't agree doesn't make it not true. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground