Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are We Raising a Generation of Helpless Kids?

who's talking here?

Carla 1
Fiona 1
planemom 2
April 1
ghostpost 2
Red Heifer 2
Perfection 4
NOLA 1
Dr Aborto 1
TheMasticator 3
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Work in Progress 2
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Dorothy Parker 11
itstxdaddy 3
momof6monkeys 2
MandyPants 1
TinktheSprite 1
justforfun1 1
Winning 1
SmoochieAndTheBean 1
Pat Barry 1
Lets Be Fair 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Article by Mickey Goodman of the Huffington Post.


Warning signs

When a college freshman received a C- on her first test, she literally had a meltdown in class. Sobbing, she texted her mother who called back, demanding to talk to the professor immediately (he, of course, declined). Another mother accompanied her child on a job interview, then wondered why he didn't get the job.

A major employer reported that during a job interview, a potential employee told him that she would have his job within 18 months. It didn't even cross her mind that he had worked 20 years to achieve his goal.

Sound crazy?

Sadly, the stories are all true, says Tim Elmore, founder and president of a non-profit, Growing Leaders, and author of the "Habitudes®" series of books, teacher guides, DVD kits and survey courses. "Gen Y (and iY) kids born between 1984 and 2002 have grown up in an age of instant gratification. iPhones, iPads, instant messaging and immediate access to data is at their fingertips," he says. "Their grades in school are often negotiated by parents rather than earned and they are praised for accomplishing little. They have hundreds of Facebook and Twitter 'friends,' but often few real connections."

To turn the tide, Growing Leaders is working with 5,000 public schools, universities, civic organizations, sports teams and corporations across the country and internationally to help turn young people -- particularly those 16 to 24 -- into leaders. "We want to give them the tools they lack before they've gone through three marriages and several failed business ventures," he says.

But why have parents shifted from teaching self-reliance to becoming hovering helicopter parents who want to protect their children at all costs?

"I think it began in the fall of 1982, when seven people died after taking extra-strength Tylenol laced with poison after it left the factory," he says. Halloween was just around the corner, and parents began checking every item in the loot bags. Homemade brownies and cookies (usually the most coveted items) hit the garbage; unwrapped candy followed close behind.

That led to an obsession with their children's safety in every aspect of their lives. Instead of letting them go outside to play, parents filled their kid's spare time with organized activities, did their homework for them, resolved their conflicts at school with both friends and teachers, and handed out trophies for just showing up.

"These well-intentioned messages of 'you're special' have come back to haunt us," Elmore says. "We are consumed with protecting them instead of preparing them for the future. We haven't let them fall, fail and fear. The problem is that if they don't take risks early on like climbing the monkey bars and possibly falling off, they are fearful of every new endeavor at age 29."

Psychologists and psychiatrists are seeing more and more young people having a quarter-life crisis and more cases of clinical depression. The reason? Young people tell them it's because they haven't yet made their first million or found the perfect mate.

Teachers, coaches and executives complain that Gen Y kids have short attention spans and rely on external, instead of internal motivation. The goal of Growing Leaders is to reverse the trend and help young people become more creative and self-motivated so they can rely on themselves and don't need external motivation.

Family psychologist John Rosemond agrees. In a February 2 article in the Atlanta Journal Constitution , he points out that new research finds that rewards often backfire, producing the opposite effect of that intended. When an aggressive child is rewarded for not being aggressive for a short period of time, he is likely to repeat the bad behavior to keep the rewards coming.

Where did we go wrong?

• We've told our kids to dream big - and now any small act seems insignificant. In the great scheme of things, kids can't instantly change the world. They have to take small, first steps - which seem like no progress at all to them. Nothing short of instant fame is good enough. "It's time we tell them that doing great things starts with accomplishing small goals," he says.

• We've told our kids that they are special - for no reason, even though they didn't display excellent character or skill, and now they demand special treatment. The problem is that kids assumed they didn't have to do anything special in order to be special.

• We gave our kids every comfort - and now they can't delay gratification. And we heard the message loud and clear. We, too, pace in front of the microwave, become angry when things don't go our way at work, rage at traffic. "Now it's time to relay the importance of waiting for the things we want, deferring to the wishes of others and surrendering personal desires in the pursuit of something bigger than 'me,'" Elmore says.

• We made our kid's happiness a central goal - and now it's difficult for them to generate happiness -- the by-product of living a meaningful life. "It's time we tell them that our goal is to enable them to discover their gifts, passions and purposes in life so they can help others. Happiness comes as a result."

The uncomfortable solutions:

"We need to let our kids fail at 12 - which is far better than at 42," he says. "We need to tell them the truth (with grace) that the notion of 'you can do anything you want' is not necessarily true."

Kids need to align their dreams with their gifts. Every girl with a lovely voice won't sing at the Met; every Little League baseball star won't play for the major leagues.

• Allow them to get into trouble and accept the consequences. It's okay to make a "C-." Next time, they'll try harder to make an "A".

• Balance autonomy with responsibility. If your son borrows the car, he also has to re-fill the tank.

• Collaborate with the teacher, but don't do the work for your child. If he fails a test, let him take the consequences.

"We need to become velvet bricks," Elmore says, "soft on the outside and hard on the inside and allow children to fail while they are young in order to succeed when they are adults."



link to article.... 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

i love this article.. it is so true in some cases..

i know for me my son's father could not do anything without his mom.. it was horrible when my son was born.. i made sure than when i raised mine he could and would take care of himself plus it is okay to fail at times but always strive for doing your best.. i also wasnt able to give him everything he wanted but he had all he needed.he is now 22 living on his own and going to college in boston.. ( i think i did pretty well) 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

yes we are. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I think you did, too, Funmom!

I loved this article...it makes so much sense. I don't understand why we are such a paranoid society now, when crime was much worse when we were kids, but we act like the boogeyman is around every corner just waiting to get 'em! :( 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

video games.

enough said. 

momof6monkeys --- 14 years ago -

LOVE this!!!!! This letter should be sent home with every parent when they leave the hospital!!! Some people think that I am so hard on my kids because they have so many chores, or that they have to work and earn money for those things that they want like ipads, etc. or because I wont insist that they be put into another class when they hate the teacher that they were given because they were hard. And so many other things that were mentioned in this article. I agree 100% with everything it says. I end up looking like the bad guy to my kids when they go to some of their friends houses who parents are who are referenced in this article but I just tell them Im sorry.....go live with them if you want their life.

Some people are just in awe at how independent all of my kids are and look down on me sometimes i believe for not babying them. My kids are all loved and very well taken care of and will be able to be productive members of society when they are on their own. I know I am so appreciative to my parents for teaching me what they did or i wouldnt be the strong person that i am today and have been able to handle all of the curve balls that life has thrown my way!!!! 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

I know people who filled out the college applications, whose kids email their college papers to them for mommy to proofread and edit...just amazes me.

It isn't enough to have happy, well adjusted..dare I say "average" kids any more. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

My oldest is in high school and has a friend that's not allowed to go to the mall without her parents.

Yet, she's expected to be independent and make good decisions when she's on her own in 2 years at college?

When should teenage kids have some freedom away from their parents? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

"We need to let our kids fail at 12 - which is far better than at 42," he says. "We need to tell them the truth (with grace) that the notion of 'you can do anything you want' is not necessarily true."



WHAT!!!! No participation trophies!?!?!? 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

This is a consequence of the '60 generation which values feelings over all else.... Thanks to The Worst Genreation, many of our kids are inept bafoons. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

This is a consequence of the '60 generation which values feelings over all else

Try the math again because it doesn't add up. DERP 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

This is a consequence of the '60 generation which values feelings over all else

Try the math again because it doesn't add up. DERP


Yes it does.... The idiots from the failed ideology born in the 1960' are the professors and psychologists that wrote the books and taught the classes read and attended by the parents of generation Y.... Derp... Derp... 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

This is a consequence of the '60 generation which values feelings over all else.... Thanks to The Worst Genreation, many of our kids are inept bafoons. 


How do you figure?

The kids who are in high school and entering college now, were born in the late 80's and 90's and their parents were born in the 60's and 70's. Many of my generation bought into the "hands off" discipline movement because our parents, those "baffoons" from the 60's were very hands on and seemingly harsh. 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

I have to say I agree with this article to some extent. In middle school if you fail a test they automatically give you a retest then if you don't turn in your homework no worries you just go to tutoring and complete it. There is no accountability. I see nothing wrong with doing extra credit but retaking the test for the full grade is just ridiculous. When they mess up at work there will more than likely not be a whole lot of redos. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

How many of us watch shows like Dance Moms or Toddlers and Tiaras and do that for our own kids?

I've seen parents go off on teachers because their precious darling didn't do assigned work therefore would be ineligible for a trip - yet instead of assuming responsibility, the parent and child throw hissy fits and demand they be allowed to go - regardless whether they earned the right or not.

No, parents don't want to see their own children fail - they are okay with telling other parents to do that, but don't let it happen to their precious darlings.

Is it easy seeing a kids heart break - of course not, but the only way kids can learn how to be successful is if they experience failure once, and honestly, I would rather that be at high school or Jr High than as an adult. Once they know what it's like not to get something they want they learn quickly to do those behaviors to ensure they get it next time.

So in the example above, what did that child learn? Did they learn that not doing assigned work have consequences, no. They learned that mom throwing a hissy fit and screaming like a banshee at a teacher got them what they wanted. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

As an addition and a sort of ancillary problem with modern parenting, I recently had a mother of a 2 month old tell me I could not hold her child unless I slathered anti bacterial goo all over my hands.... She does this to anybody who might touch her little Precious.....

So friggin annoying.. I told her no thanks, I really did not need to hold the little bag of beans.... 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

So in the example above, what did that child learn? Did they learn that not doing assigned work have consequences, no. They learned that mom throwing a hissy fit and screaming like a banshee at a teacher got them what they wanted.



Bingo!!!! 

April --- 14 years ago -

When we started visiting colleges for my older one (now 23), I asked a few times what was the most important thing for me to do to get her ready to go to college. The answer I got on more than one occasion was "teach her to do her one laundry and to get herself out of bed in the morning". And yes, they were dead serious. Kids go to college and can't do those two basic things on their own. That just floors me. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

So in the example above, what did that child learn? Did they learn that not doing assigned work have consequences, no. They learned that mom throwing a hissy fit and screaming like a banshee at a teacher got them what they wanted.


You also need to ask what is it teaching the students who work hard and hand their work in on time? I 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

"teach her to do her one laundry and to get herself out of bed in the morning".

That is done for the three oldest, don't quite trust the youngest with the laundry yet. 

momof6monkeys --- 14 years ago -

All great points. I also believe its rediculous as was stated that they just get to re-take if they fail rather than just failing and maybe not getting to participate in sports or whatever the consequence may be. The schools want their own grades to be good though so they wont allow the kids to fail. If our kids in middle school dont turn in work they are "zapped" which is detention and made to do the work. The schoold doesnt even give them the chance to face the consequences. They send emails and updates for every little thing to the parents letting them know what is missing, what is coming up due, etc. When we were in school if you didnt turn it in..you failed. The notice your parents got was the F on your report card and you dealt with your parents!!

In fifth grade my son HATED his teacher. She was very what i call military and alot of the kids hated her. He begged me to have him moved to another class!! I personally didnt care for her either but I told him that her job was not to make him like her. Her job was to teach him math and she had done her job. I also told him that when he went to college he was going to have professors that he didnt like, he was going to have coaches that he didnt like and when he got a job he was going to have a boss that he didnt like. Did he want his mom to go and "talk to them??". I dont think so. They have to learn to deal with every kind of person in the real world and school is their first chance to learn to find a way to do that.

We can not be there to hold there hands when they are on their own. I know so many people that theyre kids will either be at home forever or will fall flat on their faces when they are on their own because they have no real world experience of how to do life on their own and make their own decisions and mistakes. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

"teach her to do her one laundry and to get herself out of bed in the morning"


add to that balancing a checkbook, understanding how to budget and to say NO to any and all credit card offers. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

I remember one parent asking at admitted students' day "who is going to check their homework"? You could hear my eyes roll.

Kids have to learn to make their mistakes, take responsibility, and learn how to succeed when they're kids, not when they're 30 or 40. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I remember one parent asking at admitted students' day "who is going to check their homework"? You could hear my eyes roll.


Someone really asked that?

What was the response? 

Carla --- 14 years ago -

"We need to let our kids fail at 12 - which is far better than at 42,"

This is what the Love and Logic program is based on, let your children learn the hard lessons while the consequences are cheap.

WHAT!!!! No participation trophies!?!?!?

I know. Actually, getting an ribbon for participating, I don't have a problem as long as that is what it is, something to recognize participation.

But what I really have an issue with is giving an actual award for something that they don't actually deserve.

I used to judge at high school dance competitions before I moved to Texas. At one competition, the organizers were insistent that every team win an award.

The problem was they had already set what the awards were (things like "Best Kicks," "Best Costumes," etc.) There was one team that absolutely sucked. They were just horrible. It would have been a complete joke to give them an award that had anything to do with talent or presentation.

The judges went over and over what to about it and what we could possibly "award" them that wouldn't be ridiculous. Finally, we just gave the organizers what our scores were and let them do what they wanted.

No, parents don't want to see their own children fail - they are okay with telling other parents to do that, but don't let it happen to their precious darlings.

You mean like not making a sports team? 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Exactly Carla. Heaven forbid a child not get on a sports team here or the lead in a school play or head debater or lead chair in the band.



And yes, I have had people come to interviews before with mommy in tow - and when I made mom wait in the lobby, she would text the interviewee while I was talking to them. Both mom and interviewee felt this was appropriate professional behavior. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

And yes, I have had people come to interviews before with mommy in tow - and when I made mom wait in the lobby, she would text the interviewee while I was talking to them. Both mom and interviewee felt this was appropriate professional behavior. 


Was this for a position at McDonald's? 

Winning --- 14 years ago -

Was this for a position at McDonald's?

LULZ 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I like the article. I had never heard of the mindset tracing back to the tainted tylenol before, that's interesting.

I definitely encountered this mindset a lot when I taught. I fully expected to be chewed out whenever I called a parent about their child's behavior. It's just par for the course. Mostly because a parent who makes their child take responsibility for their actions very rarely has a child who acts up in class! I'd meet those parents at "Meet the Teacher" and wouldn't hear from them again the rest of year, unless I called to tell them a delight it was to teach their kid!

As a parent now, I do understand the temptation of it though. It's HARD to watch your kids fail, even when you know it is for their own betterment. It's easier to fix things for them, than to allow things to work on their character development. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

There's a fine line between advocating for your child and negatively taking over the situation.

I never thought I'd have my child removed from a class because of the teacher, because I feel it's important to learn to deal with all sorts of personality types, and you're not going to like everyone you come into contact with, however, that doesn't mean you can't learn to coexist amicably or at least be civil.

However, after a few phone call conferences and one in-person meeting with the teacher and principal, it was best that my child be removed from the class.

I have no regrets. :) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

There's a fine line between advocating for your child and negatively taking over the situation.

I never thought I'd have my child removed from a class because of the teacher, because I feel it's important to learn to deal with all sorts of personality types, and you're not going to like everyone you come into contact with, however, that doesn't mean you can't learn to coexist amicably or at least be civil.

However, after a few phone call conferences and one in-person meeting with the teacher and principal, it was best that my child be removed from the class.

I have no regrets. :)


You know what? Some teachers "be crazy" too. I taught with them. I sure as heck would have removed my child too. But you have to weigh the situation. If they are being bullied or taken advantage of, or hurt by the process, then by all means, have them removed. But if they are simply learning some of those tough lessons of life which will build character, let them sweat it out. I'm sure that you made the right decision. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

interesting...i didn't know we were allowed to mock KUer's screen names.

good to know. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

add to that balancing a checkbook, understanding how to budget and to say NO to any and all credit card offers.

I just talked to a friend who found out recently that her son (in his late 20's) has never filed his income taxes..and now has a tax lien for back taxes.

She said he just "procrastinated" and had she known she would have paid her accountant to do it. She was more frustrated that she wasn't able to rescue him than the fact that he didn't have enough responsibility to take care of his personal affairs. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

You know what? Some teachers "be crazy" too. I taught with them.


That's exactly where we were with that situation. I tried going down the right avenues to resolve the situation, but after phone calls to my home with insults and hanging up on me and then her tantrum in front of the principal, my husband and I were done...I feel it was definitely the best choice in the end. Now I just have to hope my other kids never get her as a teacher. Hopefully, she'll retire before that happens. ;) 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I just talked to a friend who found out recently that her son (in his late 20's) has never filed his income taxes..and now has a tax lien for back taxes.

She said he just "procrastinated" and had she known she would have paid her accountant to do it. She was more frustrated that she wasn't able to rescue him than the fact that he didn't have enough responsibility to take care of his personal affairs. 



His late 20's???? That's crazy! 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Nope momof5 it was my previous job. I posted about the types of unprepared interviews I would see. People chewing gum, taking calls while in the interview and moms were just the tip of the iceberg. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Taking calls in the middle of a job interview??

Seriously? C'mon.... 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

I have witnessed parents coddle their kids to the point of paralyzing them. Dressing 2nd graders while they sleep in bed, doing school projects for them (You've seen it on display!), sitting with them daily during lunch at school, etc., etc.. Further, I have seen the consequences with whiny, entitled, spoiled children. There IS a balance. It is up to parents of ALL generations to find that balance of guidance to help our children reach independence. 

SmoochieAndTheBean --- 14 years ago -

WHAT!!!! No participation trophies!?!?!?

Ha!! Were you watching How I Met Your Mother last night? LOL. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Yes seriously. They did ask if it was okay first. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground