Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bad workout advice

who's talking here?

Tylers Journey 3
Jpgirl 5
Dr Aborto 1
Work in Progress 15
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
FabulousFinder 1
Dorothy Parker 2
itstxdaddy 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 7
elliemae 2
One Nation Under God 5
snowprincess 2
4leafclover 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

So I'm pretty new to this fitness stuff, and all I can say is WOW at the amount of bad fitness advice out there!

I speak to "experts" who give me all sorts of advice that is just wrong, according to quick internet searches that test the validity of the fitness myths.

Why is there so much misinformation out there? 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

People just want to make a buck. Most of them aren't really even qualified to give fitness advice. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

Why is there so much misinformation out there?

because people want the quick fix and they will PAY for the lies.

i get so sick of seeing this garbage about wrap yourself in my poop for a week and you will lose weight. ugh.

these people should be arrested but the bottom line is if no one would pay them, they would not exist.

something else...most of these things offer free 30-90 day money back guarantees...ya know why? that is the time period where if you change your diet and start exercising, you will lost the most weight...after those 90 days, the real work begins...also, very few people actually take them up on the offer...they just pay for something else that "will work"

burn more calories that you take in, you will lose weight. very simple and has been since time began. 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

I don't listen to any of that stuff. I just walk/run every day and strength train with hand held weights 3 times a week. :) How is your weight loss going? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

What I have found time and time again is that the fitness advice that tries to make it more complicated than "calories burned vs. calories consumed" is almost ALWAYS wrong, and has no actual science to back it up.

Even the commonly held myths that EVERYONE believes are wrong. Like, did you know that it ISN'T true that muscles burn more calories than fat? Building muscle will not make you burn more calories during the day, other than the calories you are expending during the exercise itself.

And you don't have to eat protein within an hour of working out.

And stretching does absolutely nothing to keep you from injuring yourself during exercise. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Stick to the basics, Cruella. Eat well, and FRESH food. Exercise but start slow and gradually work up to more or else you'll get hurt and be laid up and have to start all over again.

Weight loss is an industry unto itself b/c so many people are trying to lose...and they all want instant or quick results. Unfortunately, that isn't best. And fast weight loss comes back on quicker too.

Don't be in a hurry. See it as a lifestyle plan, not a weight loss/diet plan. I promise you it will work. When you take the accent/pressure off weight loss and put into good eating and exercise, it comes off and will stay off. 

elliemae --- 14 years ago -

Eat well, find some type of exercise you enjoy doing and just do it :) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Pretty much everything that the "trainers" are telling me is BS.

But I've just been doing my own thing, working out at least 4 days a week, usually for around an hour, and counting calories.

Lost 51 lbs.

Oh yeah, another myth is that your body can go into starvation mode if you don't eat enough. The effect on your metabolism is very little, and temporary. As soon as you eat anything, it goes back to normal.

Basically, everything that I thought I knew about dieting and exercising is crap. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

cruella...DON'T take any of those supplements. you'll just have the most expensive *urine* in kingwood.

they are worthless. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

I lift 3 hours per week, I do 3 hours of cardio a week along with a good diet. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

cruella...DON'T take any of those supplements. you'll just have the most expensive piss in kingwood.

they are worthless.


Yep, that's another myth that has been busted. You are right, a healthy diet doesn't need supplements. Or even just a cheap multivitamin will work. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -


Yep, that's another myth that has been busted. You are right, a healthy diet doesn't need supplements. Or even just a cheap multivitamin will work.


I would still take vitamins because fruits and veggies don't carry the nutrients that they once did. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Oh and another that everyone believes that isn't true. It doesn't matter what time you eat. Eating late at night doesn't make it turn into fat.

It's just that people who eat more at night are consuming more calories throughout the day, so they tend to be fatter.

And there is nothing magical about eating breakfast. It doesn't boost your metabolism. But people who don't overeat at dinner tend to be hungrier in the morning, so they tend to eat breakfast. People who don't overeat tend to be thinner, so we confuse it with being causation, rather than just the correlation. 

Tylers Journey --- 14 years ago -

I do a 300 calorie breakfast, 400 calorie lunch, 500 calorie dinner, and 1-2 small snacks. I do fruit/veggie smoothies for breakfast and sometime for lunch. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Like, did you know that it ISN'T true that muscles burn more calories than fat? Building muscle will not make you burn more calories during the day, other than the calories you are expending during the exercise itself.


No, that isn't true. Everything I've ever read says muscle requires more energy out put. But it's not a huge difference....it adds up tho and it's healthier.

Oh yeah, another myth is that your body can go into starvation mode if you don't eat enough. The effect on your metabolism is very little, and temporary. As soon as you eat anything, it goes back to normal.


There is a starvation mode when one greatly resticts calories according to plenty of medical experts.. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Like, did you know that it ISN'T true that muscles burn more calories than fat? Building muscle will not make you burn more calories during the day, other than the calories you are expending during the exercise itself.


No, that isn't true. Everything I've ever read says muscle requires more energy out put. But it's not a huge difference....it adds up tho and it's healthier.

Oh yeah, another myth is that your body can go into starvation mode if you don't eat enough. The effect on your metabolism is very little, and temporary. As soon as you eat anything, it goes back to normal.


There is a starvation mode when one greatly resticts calories according to plenty of medical experts..


But that's my point. EVERYONE believes these two especially, but it's not true!!!!!

I was just as surprised!!!!!

Let me see if I can post the articles. They are based on flawed scientific studies that have since been disproved, but the myth still keeps going and going and going and going. . .

The muscle thing, it adds up to maybe 30 calories more a day for a bodybuilder than for a regular person. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

It doesn't matter what time you eat. Eating late at night doesn't make it turn into fat.


It doesn't necessarily turn to fat b/c it's all about your intake vs. expenditure. BUT your metabolism is slowest at night as are your activity levels, so if you are trying to lose, it is best to avoid heavy meals before bed time. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I remember a little about the starvation mode one. There is no point that your body would "hold onto fat stores", but there is a slight dip in your metabolism if you don't eat enough.

So if you calculate your calories eaten vs. calories burned and figure out that you could lose 3 lbs/week by eating 500 calories a day (which is way too little, I know) then you would truly only be able to lose 2.5 lbs/week instead of 3, because of the metabolism dip.

But the body will digest ITSELF if you don't give it food, so it's still unhealthy not to eat enough. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Let me see if I can post the articles. They are based on flawed scientific studies that have since been disproved, but the myth still keeps going and going and going and going. .

I'd like to see them if you can find them. :) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Here is the eating late at night one:




Eating at night myth 'exploded'









A calorie is a calorie at any time of the day, say experts

Eating late at night does not make you fat, according to a study.
Scientists at Oregon Health & Science University in the United States carried out tests on 47 female monkeys.

They found no link between when the animals ate and whether or not they put on weight.

Speaking at a Society for Neuroscience meeting in New Orleans, the scientists said claims that eating late lead to weight gain may be "an urban myth".

Dr Judy Cameron and colleagues came across the finding almost by accident.

Their study was originally designed to find out more about the relationship between female hormones and weight gain.









Your body doesn't really recognise what time of day it is. It is a little bit of a myth



Nigel Denby,
British Dietetic Association

As part of the study, they surgically removed ovaries from 19 of the 47 monkeys.
Removing the ovaries causes levels of the female hormones estrogen and progesterone to drop, in much the same way as happens with the menopause.

The scientists found that monkeys who had their ovaries removed started to eat more and put on weight.

"The absence of these hormones resulted in a 67% jump in food intake and a 5% jump in weight in a matter of weeks," said Dr Cameron.

They also found that levels of a hormone called leptin increased in these monkeys. Leptin is produced by fat cells and is known to influence food intake.

Previous studies have found that many women start to put on weight during menopause. The scientists believe their findings could lead to treatments to help tackle that problem.

Meal time

During the study, the scientists also found the monkeys ate their food at different times of the day. Many ate mostly in the evenings and at night.

However, perhaps unexpectedly the researchers found no link between when the animals ate and how much weight they put on.

"Time and again, we've been told that eating late at night should be avoided because it will cause weight gain," said Dr Cameron.

"However, there isn't a lot of research to back up this commonly held belief, which may in fact be somewhat of an urban myth.

"In conducting this study, we noted the times that animals ate. Some of the monkeys ate most of their food during the evening and night-time hours.

"However, weight gain and the time of day that the animals were feeding had no correlation whatsoever."

Nigel Denby of the British Dietetic Association backed the findings.

"The bottom line is a calorie is a calorie whenever you eat it," he told BBC News Online.

"Your body doesn't really recognise what time of day it is. It is a little bit of a myth.

"I think it dates back to when people started taking an interest in diets. People are more likely to eat fatty snacks at night when they are watching television. In order to try to avoid that, they put restrictions on when they should eat.

"Certainly, if you need to eat after 6pm or 8pm it is probably healthier to sit down and have a meal. Otherwise, you risk grazing on fatty foods." 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Starvation mode myth:


The Starvation Myth

The idea that "not eating enough" causes the body to stop losing weight because it goes into "starvation mode" is a popular myth among dieters.

Article By: The Weight Watchers Research Department




Restricting calories during weight loss lowers metabolism1 because the body becomes more efficient, requiring fewer calories to perform the necessary daily functions for survival. Consequently, this can slow (but not stop) the anticipated rate of weight loss.

For example, if an individual needs 2,000 calories per day to maintain weight, reducing intake to 1,500 calories, assuming exercise stays the same, should provide a 1 pound per week weight loss (Note: 1 pound of weight is equivalent to about 3,500 calories). Furthermore, reducing to 1,000 calories should result in a weight loss of 2 pounds per week and going down to 500 calories a day should result in a weight loss of 3 pounds per week. However, if an individual actually reduces their intake to 500 calories, the weight loss would not likely be a steady 3 pounds per week because of the reduced metabolic rate. It would likely be around 2¼ to 2½ pounds. This "lower than expected" rate of weight loss is a lot different than "no" weight loss as the "starvation mode" notion proposes.
It is unclear as to whether the relationship between reduced caloric intake and a lower metabolism follows a straight path or becomes more pronounced the greater the caloric reduction. Some studies have found no significant reduction in metabolism until the caloric restriction is quite large (e.g. 800 calories or less per day).2 Others suggest a linear relationship with small reductions in metabolism accompanying small reductions in caloric restriction, with the gap increasing as the caloric deficit is enlarged.

While there is no biologic evidence to support the "starvation mode" myth, there may be behavioral reasons why weight loss stops when calories are severely reduced. Over-restriction of calorie intake, known as high dietary restraint is linked to periods of overeating, hindering successful weight loss.3 (For more information on dietary restraint, read the Science Center article, The Skill of Flexible Restraint).

Metabolism after Weight Loss
The good news is that after the weight-loss goal is achieved and weight has stabilized, it does not appear that the dip in metabolism is permanent. Several rigorous studies done at the University of Alabama in Birmingham showed that metabolism goes back to expected levels with sustained weight loss,4 discounting the theory that a lowered metabolism helps to explain the common phenomenon of weight regain following weight loss.

Weight Watchers Approach
The 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The breakfast and small meals myth. It's still ALL about the amount of calories that you eat, not when or how you eat them. Eating small meals does keep you from getting too hungry and overeating when you do get to food, but that's about it.

Myth #2: Always eat breakfast
Fact: Eat some time during the morning
If you wake up at 7 a.m., you don’t have to immediately eat a big breakfast. You’re probably not even hungry right after you wake up. You don’t have to jump start your metabolism. You simply have to structure your eating throughout the day, so you’re not too hungry later on. It's best to eat within three hours of waking. If you get up at 7 a.m., eat something by 10 a.m. Have some yogurt or a piece of fruit. If you don’t eat in the morning, you will be too hungry when you finally have a meal, and then you’ll likely overeat. Remember, what counts is your total daily calories.

Myth #3: Eat three times a day — don't snack
Fact: Eat when you want to maintain calorie intake
Once again, it’s all about calories. You can eat three times a day or six times a day, as long as you have the same caloric intake. However, you should have at least three meals a day. That structures your daily eating, so don’t become too hungry. And if you eat six times a day, you won’t be having six full meals. 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

that it ISN'T true that muscles burn more calories than fat? Building muscle will not make you burn more

Source for this??? Muscle IS more metabolically active than fat. Muscle needs energy constantly even at rest. I suggest you do some more research
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/metabolism/WT00006
Building muscle is a very important component of a healthy lifestyle. Aerobic conditioning( cardio), strength training, and flexibility are the components of physical fitness- add proper nutrition to complete good health.

As a nationally certified ( 1 of 3 national certifications) personal trainer for 17 years I DO agree with you that there is a lot of BS that goes around. I am shocked by the number of personal trainers who have no degree or a national certification! And I do not believe that everyone has to hire a personal trainer to get fit. Education abounds- you just have to make sure that it's the right information. If you do hire a trainer make sure they have a Bachelors in exercise physiology or a related field AND a nationally accepted certification (ACE, ACSM are two excellant certs) and get referrals.
I review all the scientific research that I can and have never come across any study that has been able to verify or repeat clinical studies that muscle is NOT more metabolically active than muscle. I am very curious to see your source 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

I would still take vitamins because fruits and veggies don't carry the nutrients that they once did.

Yep. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

I review all the scientific research that I can and have never come across any study that has been able to verify or repeat clinical studies that muscle is NOT more metabolically active than muscle. I am very curious to see your source

probably newsweek 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

I have to disagree with you Cruella. Eating smaller meals throughout the day keeps metabolism up because your body is constantly working, digesting and taking in nutrients. More meals doesn't necessarily mean more calories either. Here's what I'm gonna eat for today just to give you an idea what a fit 150lb male eats.

Breakfast: Oatmeal
Snack: banana
Lunch: Kashi frozen lunches
Snack: apple
Dinner: whatever the wife cooks
Snack: handful of cheerios 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Do you strength train? No?! Well, you know, muscle burns more calories at rest than fat does, so you should build more muscle to boost your metabolism and help you lose weight.

How many times have you heard (or said) something similar yourself? I've heard it (and even said it) hundreds of times myself, mainly because that little fact can motivate people to start (and stick with) strength training—especially women who fear "bulking up" or cardio bunnies who only exercise to burn as many calories as possible. Raise your hand if YOU want to burn more calories while at rest. (I'm right there with you.)

Well, exactly how many calories does that newly sculpted muscle really burn? Not as much as you'd think, according to an article written by fitness expert, Dr. Cedric X. Bryant, the Chief Science Officer for the American Council on Exercise (ACE).

The common stat experts and laypeople alike tend to cite is that a single pound of muscle can burn 30-50 calories per day—so the more muscle you build, the more calories your body will burn all day long. But Dr. Bryant writes that research indicates otherwise. According to an article he wrote for the ACE FitnessMatters newsletter:


"[M]uscle tissue has been observed to burn roughly seven to 10 calories per pound per day, compared to two to three calories per pound per day for fat. Therefore, if you replace a pound of fat with a pound of muscle, you can expect to burn only approximately four to six more calories a day. Given the fact that the average person who strength trains typically gains approximately 3 to 5 pounds of muscle mass over a period of three to four months, the net caloric effect of such a training regimen is very modest—only 15 to 30 calories per day (the equivalent of a few potato chips)."


Hmm...that doesn't sound too motivating. But then again, every little bit helps, right? If you were to decide to either burn 15-30 more calories per day or NOT, wouldn't you still choose to burn it? I would. Over time, it adds up. That's 450-900 more calories burned per month, or 5,400-10,800 more calories burned in a year—that's about a 3-pound weight loss, simply by building and preserving your muscle mass. That sounds pretty good to me!

But remember, strength training offers your body many more benefits than just increased calorie burn! If you're cutting calories to lose weight, it will help reduce the amount of muscle you lose in the process, which could be significant. Plus it helps you improve your appearance, remain strong and independent, decrease joint pain, strengthen your bones and improve your athletic performance. Those all sound like valuable reasons to keep lifting weights to me.

To read Dr. Cedric X. Bryant's full article, click here. 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

I have never said that to a client. My approach is that strength training is a very important component to physical fitness particularly for women because it helps to strengthen the bones and joints. When you exercise the muscles stress the bones ( because the muscle is attached to the bones via tendons and cross the joint enabling movement)
I am very familiar with Dr Bryant- he is on the board at ACE- I will research it and get back with you- I have never heard him say that muscle is not more metabolically active than fat- I have heard him speak
Might I suggest that you visit Dr Len Kravitz site- he is another highly respected person in the field of exercise physiology 

4leafclover --- 14 years ago -

Exercise but start slow and gradually work up to more or else you'll get hurt and be laid up and have to start all over again.

This is accurate. If you are in the Kingwood area, there are many places you can walk. Start there and build your endurance level up slowly. Eas small meals and slowly increase your exercise regimen. (drink water, cut out soda and alcohol) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Here is another article that cites the same study.


Calories burned by muscle vs. fat: another myth bites the dust

by Lani on August 28, 2009





Not to rain on anyone’s muscle parade, but this myth has been perpetuated one too many times.

This is the problem with the proliferation of fitness information on the web.

Something is said somewhere – no matter how substantiated or not – and then picked up as “fact” by someone else, and the ball starts rolling.

But this one – the one about calories burned at rest by muscle vs. calories burned at rest by fat – has been a challenge of which to get to the bottom!

The gossip on muscle and metabolic rates

In a quick Google search on “calories burned by muscle”, no less than 124,000 hits pop up. A quick glance down the list reinforces the prevalent myth: that each pound of muscle “burns” an extra 50 calories a day. This in contrast to fat tissue which apparently doesn’t burn energy.

But if you look deeper, and find the leads to the research, there isn’t a resource to be found supporting this claim. At least not that I could find.


It’s more like 6 – 10 calories/day.


Don’t get me wrong – keep up your resistance training!

Does this mean we shouldn’t be building muscle?

Why bother with weight or other resistance training if we’re not going to get the metabolic bang for our buck?

Keep in mind, there are multiple reasons for challenging your musculature.
1.First, resistance training protects the muscle you DO have – whether you are in weight maintenance or seeking weight or fat loss.
2.Second, muscle is what gives shape to your physique – your appearance is largely a reflection of your muscle mass.
3.Third, functionality of your body, strength, and protection of joints is largely a function of muscle strength. To not use it means to lose it. And if you lose it you don’t have it to use.
4.Even though the high numbers of “50 calories a pound” are not accurate, as muscle IS more metabolically active than fat, you have the potential for a negative energy balance, which can result in weight loss - or fat loss – due to your metabolic rate by year’s end. And that can add up.

As it turns out, the metabolic expenditure of our muscle mass is best accessed with their active use. This means doing muscle-challenging exercise that puts said muscle into contraction action.

And that allows us to access the metabolism rate boosting EPOC, or excessive post- exercise oxygen consumption.


From the experts: Dr. Cedric Bryant

Dr. Cedric Bryant, from the American Council on Exercise, gives a great overview of the situation to reinforce the key points.


Q: One of the more common perceptions in some fitness circles is that strength training individuals lose weight because one pound of muscle can burn approximately 30-50 calories per day. Is this claim valid?

A: It is true that muscle in its resting state is similar to an idling engine and burns energy (fuel) in the form of calories. However, according to reputable scientific research conducted on the subject, the actual number of calories burned by a pound of resting muscle in a day is considerably less than 50.

In fact, the caloric expenditure that can be attributed to lean muscle mass is not very significant. For example, muscle tissue has been observed to burn roughly seven to 10 calories per pound per day, compared to two to three calories per pound per day for fat. Therefore, if you replace a pound of fat with a pound of muscle, you can expect to burn only approximately four to six more calories a day. Given the fact that the average person who strength trains typically gains approximately 3 to 5 pounds of muscle mass over a period of three to four months, the net caloric effect of such a training regimen is very modest-only 15 to 30 calories per day (the equivalent of a few potato chips).

Despite the limited calorie-burning potential of muscle, strength training should be an integral part of any exercise program aimed at weight management. Here are just a few of the weight management-related benefits of strength training:
•Helps to prevent or minimize the loss in lean body mass that is typically a by-product of dieting.
•Burns calories (i.e., a modest caloric expenditure of approximately 150 calories per average 30-minute training session.
•Strength training favorably affects an individual’s overall body composition, resulting in a greater proportion of lean tissue relative to fat tissue. This training adaptation helps to enhance both functional performance capabilities and physical appearance.

The bottom line, however, is that the most effective way for you to capitalize on the calorie – burning potential of your muscles is to actively use them.

Source: Dr. Cedric X. Bryant, ACE’s Chief Science Officer; ACE FitnessMatters, Mar/Apr 2006.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Lani Muelrath 2009 All Rights Reserved



If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment, subscribing to email notification or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.


References
1.Heymsfield, Stephen B. 1 , Dympna Gallagher 1 , Zimian Wang Volume 904 Issue “Body Composition Modeling: Application to Exploration of the Resting Energy Expenditure Fat-free Mass Relationship” In Vivo Body Composition Studies pgs. 290-297 Wiley Interscience, 2009 The New York Academy of Sciences
2.Poehlman, E.T., Denino, W.F., Beckett, T., Kinaman, K.A., Dionne, I.J., Dvorak, R., & Ades, P.A. (2002). Effects of endurance and resistance training on total daily energy expenditure in young women: a controlled randomized trial. Journal of Clinical 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

This is accurate. If you are in the Kingwood area, there are many places you can walk. Start there and build your endurance level up slowly. Eas small meals and slowly increase your exercise regimen. (drink water, cut out soda and alcohol)

Walking is all I did early on. As I started feeling better, I was able to increase the exercise. Now I can much more intense workouts than before. But I had to get some serious weight off first! 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

Ok- I do see your point. If you are only concerned with caloric burn then building muscle isn't the huge bang for your buck. What I took issue with was your comment that muscle doesn't burn more calories that fat. If you read Dr. Bryant's article it does in fact say that muscle is more metabolically active than fat. Strength training has many more benefits than just caloric expenditure- I go for the total picture not just calories. 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

Muscle IS more metabolically active than fat. Muscle needs energy constantly even at rest. I suggest you do some more research
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/metabolism/WT00006
Building muscle is a very important component of a healthy lifestyle. Aerobic conditioning( cardio), strength training, and flexibility are the components of physical fitness- add proper nutrition to complete good health



I agree. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I think it should be noted that, as with everything info related, data can be skewed and be a tricky thing, even misleading, and can prove or disprove just about anything...As far as the starvation mode issue goes, I do not believe the body STOPS burning calories or that you still can't lose weight with heavily restricted calorie count, BUT I do believe it slows the process down. Seems logical. It also seems logical this slow down of weight loss that the body deems to be in order during extreme food limitation, is a preservation mode/response from the body.

One day something is good for you, the next it's giving you cancer..

Everyone can find what works for them, and believe me, THAT should not be complicated.

Healthy eating
Regular exercise
Water

Viola! 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

Lol- you really don't have to keep quoting Dr Bryant- I have all of those articles, have attended his lectures and do not disagree with anything you've quoted.

I take exception to you statement that muscle does not burn more calories than fat. That is wrong and implies that fat is equally or more metabolically active than muscle. If you re read his work you will see that no where does he make that claim. What he is saying is that if you are just concerned with calorie burn then you need to realize that muscle does burn more calories but in the long run building more muscle is not going to greatly appreciate the caloric expenditure
I am happy that you are doing the research and wading through the BS! Keep up the good work! But don't draw erroneous conclusions from such great researchers in the industry 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Ok- I do see your point. If you are only concerned with caloric burn then building muscle isn't the huge bang for your buck. What I took issue with was your comment that muscle doesn't burn more calories that fat. If you read Dr. Bryant's article it does in fact say that muscle is more metabolically active than fat. Strength training has many more benefits than just caloric expenditure- I go for the total picture not just calories.

The difference is pretty small, like 30 calories a day, certainly not what the trainers are telling us.

But muscle sure does look a lot better than fat, so I still believe in weight training, but I'm not expecting it to burn calories. 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

I have to disagree with you Cruella. Eating smaller meals throughout the day keeps metabolism up because your body is constantly working, digesting and taking in nutrients. More meals doesn't necessarily mean more calories either. Here's what I'm gonna eat for today just to give you an idea what a fit 150lb male eats.

Breakfast: Oatmeal
Snack: banana
Lunch: Kashi frozen lunches
Snack: apple
Dinner: whatever the wife cooks



I agree doc. I eat 5 -6 small meals a day also. For me, it keeps the edge off so I don't always want to eat, and it keeps my blood sugar level rather than spiking. I have been doing this for about 2 1/2 - 3 months and have lost 46 pounds. I walk/run every day and strength train 3x per week. I also swim occasionally. Love to swim. I feel much better when I strength train. My body just feels stronger. We eat clean here now...so no additives, preservatives, splenda etc... 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

:) 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I can't say if eating breakfast boosts your metabolism or not, but it definitely boosts your appetite and energy level!

On the days that I get up early, get moving, eat breakfast....I will eat much more than the days where I get up, sit around with a cup of coffee and no breakfast... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

On the days that I get up early, get moving, eat breakfast....I will eat much more than the days where I get up, sit around with a cup of coffee and no breakfast...


Ditto, me too. I usually don't eat anything substantial til after 11:00. I drink coffee and eat fruit in the morning, then work out, by then I'm starving! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground