Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

WHY OCCUPY WALL ST. IS SPREADING: CBO study, titled “Trends in the Distribution of Household Incom

who's talking here?

smartypants 15
planemom 1
SoupIsGoodFood 11
david 1
SuperFantastic 1
Perfection 12
Hiro Protagonist 4
oneyedman 1
Warren Peace 18
voice of reason 6
jtcitrus 5
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 6
r2d2 1
TexasOma 1
Quixote 1
jessemyles 5
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Clovis 11
Dorothy Parker 2
Are we great again yet 4
txsassy 2
Tannhauser 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

wake up and face the facts:

The study that shows why Occupy Wall Street struck a nerveBy Eugene Robinson, Published: October 27

The hard-right conservatives who dominate the Republican Party claim to despise the redistribution of wealth, but secretly they love it — as long as the process involves depriving the poor and middle class to benefit the rich, not the other way around.

That is precisely what has been happening, as a jaw-dropping new report by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office demonstrates. Three decades of trickle-down economic theory, see-no-evil deregulation and tax-cutting fervor have led to massive redistribution. Another word for what’s been happening might be theft.

The gist of the CBO study, titled “Trends in the Distribution of Household Income Between 1979 and 2007,” is that while we’ve become wealthier overall, these new riches have largely bypassed many Americans and instead flowed mostly to the affluent. Perhaps my memory is faulty, but I don’t remember voting to turn the United States into a nation starkly divided between haves and have-nots. Yet that’s where we’ve been led.

Overall, in inflation-adjusted dollars, average after-tax household income grew by 62 percent during the period under study, according to the CBO. This sounds great — but only until you look a little closer.

For those at the bottom — the one-fifth of households with the lowest incomes — the increase was just 18 percent. For the middle three-fifths, the average increase was 40 percent. Spread over nearly 30 years, these gains are modest, not meteoric.

By contrast, look at the top 1 percent of earners. Their after-tax household income increased by an astonishing 275 percent. For those keeping track, this means it nearly quadrupled. Nice work, if you can get it.

This is not what Republicans want you to think of when you hear the word redistribution. You’re supposed to imagine the evil masterminds as Bolsheviks, not bankers. You’re supposed to envision the lazy free-riders who benefit from redistribution as the “poor,” and the industrious job-creators who get robbed as the “wealthy” — not the other way around.

If Americans were to realize they’ve been the victims of Republican-style redistribution — stealing from the poor to give to the rich — the whole political atmosphere might change. I believe that’s one reason why the Occupy Wall Street protests have struck such a nerve. The far-right and its media mouthpieces have worked themselves into a frenzy trying to disregard, dismiss or discredit the demonstrations. Thus far, fortunately, all this effort has been to no avail.

The right maintains that inequality is the wrong measure. To argue about how the income pie should be sliced is “class warfare,” and what we should do instead is give the private sector the right incentives to make the pie bigger. This way, according to conservative doctrine, everyone’s slice gets bigger — even if some slices grow faster than others.

Indeed, the CBO report says that even the poorest households saw at least a little income growth. Why is it any of their business that the high-earners in the top 1 percent saw astronomical income growth? Isn’t this just sour grapes?

No, for two reasons. First, the system is rigged. Wealthy individuals and corporations have disproportionate influence over public policy because of the often decisive role that money plays in elections. If the rich and powerful act in their self-interest, as conservative ideologues believe we all should do, then the rich and powerful’s share of income will continue to soar.

Second, and more broadly, the real issue is what kind of nation we want to be. Thomas Jefferson’s “All men are created equal” is properly understood as calling for equality of opportunity, not equality of outcomes. But the more we become a nation of rich and poor, the less we can pretend to be offering the same opportunities to every American. As polarization increases, mobility declines. The whole point of the American Dream is that it is available to everyone, not just those who awaken from their slumbers on down-filled pillows and 800-thread-count sheets.

So it does matter that as the pie grows, the various slices do not grow in proportion. We’re not characters in one of those lumbering, interminable, nonsensical Ayn Rand novels. We believe in individual initiative and the free market, but we also believe that nationhood necessarily involves a commitment to our fellow citizens, an acknowledgment that we’re engaged in a common enterprise. We believe that opportunity should be more than just an empty word. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

This is not what Republicans want you to think of when you hear the word redistribution. You’re supposed to imagine the evil masterminds as Bolsheviks, not bankers. You’re supposed to envision the lazy free-riders who benefit from redistribution as the “poor,” and the industrious job-creators who get robbed as the “wealthy” — not the other way around.

If Americans were to realize they’ve been the victims of Republican-style redistribution — stealing from the poor to give to the rich — the whole political atmosphere might change. I believe that’s one reason why the Occupy Wall Street protests have struck such a nerve. The far-right and its media mouthpieces have worked themselves into a frenzy trying to disregard, dismiss or discredit the demonstrations. Thus far, fortunately, all this effort has been to no avail.

The right maintains that inequality is the wrong measure. To argue about how the income pie should be sliced is “class warfare,”
 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I don't disagree with everything in that article. However, they aren't targeting the uber-rich. They are targeting those who make over $200K/year. People making $200K aren't the ones creating any of this mess. In fact, they are our best hope for getting OUT of this mess because they are most likely small business owners with the power to hire others.

Those billionaires aren't who we are taking a stand for. We know that a lot of them are corrupt. You don't make billions of dollars (usually) by being an upstanding, moral character. But small business owners are not the problem. 

Are we great again yet --- 15 years ago -

Paul Ryan's message is F***'d! 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

they aren't targeting



who 'they' are you referring to with your faux news talking point?


Those billionaires aren't who we are taking a stand for


wake up. it's not the billionaires miss cruella de exaggeration. the top 1% earn less than a million a year, around $950000 and up. these are the top business execs that are screwing US. me AND YOU. wtfup 

Are we great again yet --- 15 years ago -

But small business owners are not the problem.

Their(GOP Spin machine) definition of Small business is not the same as yours. They consider # of owners, not worth. Hedge funds, lawyers, Koch Industries, Blackwater,XE Corp are small business ventures in their speak. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

How many of these "protesting" are really employees of unions and ACORN being paid to do this?

If you are paid to perform a service are you really expressing your truth or simply doing a menial job for $600 a week? 

Are we great again yet --- 15 years ago -

ACORN

Quit with the FOX brainwashing propaganda. 

Tannhauser --- 15 years ago -

brainwashing propaganda.

Redundant much? 

Are we great again yet --- 15 years ago -

Redundant much?
yes, blame it on Acorn is quite redundant 

Tannhauser --- 15 years ago -

yes, blame it on Acorn is quite redundant

You might want to invest in a good dictionary. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Still trying to make the OWS crowd look legitimate?

You guys are working way too hard at this.

All I see is damage control. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

Productivity has surged, but income and wages have stagnated for most Americans. If the median household income had kept pace with the economy since 1970, it would now be nearly $92,000, not $50,000.

0

More charts and information here:
http://motherjones.com/politics/2011/02/income-inequality-in-america-chart-graph 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

Still trying to make the OWS crowd look legitimate?

I've been talking about income stagnation of America's working class before OWS. The more income inequality, the closer America comes to being a third world country. That's not good for anyone, including the top 1%. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Productivity has surged


hahahahahahahahahahahaha oh hahahahaha 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

0 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

What does sitting around do to help the problem? What else are they doing to change the way business is done? Who is helping them write legislation to change the laws? They have the media's attention. Now is the time to act. If all they do is protest nothing will change. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Why can't they open a business and show others how it's done their way? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

What does sitting around do to help the problem? What else are they doing to change the way business is done?


It's at least bringing attention to some of the problems. If enough attention is garnered, and enough of the population is on the side of the protesters, the legislators will follow. Politicians tend to follow the polls. If they think it is their best interest to try to remedy some of these problems, you'll see bills drafted. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Why not just fix it themselves by opening a business and operating how they think all can be ran.

Show it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Why not just fix it themselves by opening a business and operating how they think all can be ran.


They would rather the government take it away from someone else who has it and give it to them instead. 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

Let's take this topic to a more personal level. The "redistribute the wealth" moaning and whining has gotten stale. I belong to the tax-paying workforce that's supporting almost half of the population of this entitlement-soaked nation. I, and many of my fellow workers, started with absolutely nothing and earned every bit of my wealth without help from the crooked bankers and egocentric politicians (from both political parties). I wasn't fortunate or lucky. I was tenacious and worked my behind off. Want to redistribute MY wealth? Bring a homeless shelter sack lunch and some newspapers to use as bandaids. You'll need both. Now quit whining, get over it, and let's whine about redistributing my tax load to the slackers I'm supporting. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

The far-right and its media mouthpieces have worked themselves into a frenzy trying to disregard, dismiss or discredit the demonstrations.

Isn't it great? C'mon FOX. You can try harder! Maybe Rupert will pay for a few more phone taps.

the system is rigged. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

lol...look at all of the people who are jealous of the people who have more than they do 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

It's at least bringing attention to some of the problems.

It's not. This "movement" has been hijacked. It happened a while ago. Some of you OWS defenders just never saw it happen.

The legitimate OWS crowd that might have actually had a message and some organization got quickly overran by the dregs that now inhabit the "movement". Anyone with legitimacy have long faded and moved back into their productive slots of society. What you see now are just lazy, whining, leeches. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

I've been talking about income stagnation of America's working class before OWS.

You can talk about it until the cows come home. The simple fact is that the people that have been camping in Zucotti Park for weeks now have nothing to do with America's working class. You see, they don't work, therefore they don't qualify. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

Anyone with legitimacy have long faded

Wrong. The weak go home. 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

0 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

The simple fact is that the people that have been camping in Zucotti Park for weeks now have nothing to do with America's working class. You see, they don't work, therefore they don't qualify.

For those interested in facts, demographic studies of OWS in NYC have been done by Dr. Cordero-Guzman,
School of Public Affairs, at NYU:

 64.2% of respondents were younger than 34 years of age.
 While the sample is relatively young, one in three respondents is older than 35 and one in five
respondents is 45 and older.
 7.9% of respondents have a high school degree or less.
 92.1% of the sample has some college, a college degree, or a graduate degree.
 27.4% have some college (but no degree), 35% have a college degree, 8.2% have some graduate
school (but no degree), and close to 21.5% have a graduate school degree.
 26.7% of respondents were enrolled in school and 73.3% were not enrolled in school.
50.4% were employed full-time and an additional 20.4% were employed part-time.
 13.1% of the sample are unemployed.
 2.6% of respondents were retired, 1.3% disabled, 2.6% homemakers and 9.7% are full-time
students. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

For those interested in facts, Dr. Cordero-Guzman is an extreme left-wing liberal. He is is a Program Officer in the Economic Development Unit of the Asset Building and Community Development Program at the Ford Foundation.

The Ford Foundation is a member organization of both the Peace and Security Funders Group (which supports anti-war and radical environmentalist groups) and the International Human Rights Funders Group (a network of more than six-dozen grantmakers dedicated to funding leftwing causes). 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Wrong. The weak go home.

Wrong, smarty.

The weak are there. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Cordero-Guzman,
School of Public Affairs, at NYU:


This tells me all I need to know. 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -

What you see now are just lazy, whining, leeches.

The only one whining I see is you. OWS really chaps your butt! And good to know that you think the veterans of WW2 and Iraq that are involved are lazy whining leeches. You are so brave to say that on a local message board. lol 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The only one whining I see is you. And good to know that you think the veterans of WW2 and Iraq that are involved are lazy whining leeches. You are so brave to say that on a local message board. lol

I have nothing to whine about.

I didn't see you take that same stance when you and your liberal brethren applied broad labels to the Tea Party. You remember the names: teabaggers, nazis, racists, bigots, etc. There are WW2 and Iraq vets in the Tea Party as well, but it must be just okey-dokey to call them horrible names just because their cause isn't aligned with yours. 

jtcitrus --- 15 years ago -

a jaw-dropping new report


LOL.
this is news? There's a word for what you see in the wage redistribution...

SBTC: "Skill Biased Technological Change"

Take that same Wage data, but instead of breaking it up by wage percentile, break it up by educational attainment (our broadest proxy for skills) or better yet, but far more difficult/tedious, break it up by occupation based on the following grouping:

Dynamic/skilled
Dynamic/unskilled
Repetative/skilled
Repetative/unskilled

Either way what you find is that you get a redistribution of wages that is nearly identical to the one you get when you break things up by percentile.

the research has come to a consensus: The vast majority of the real gains in income over the last thirty years went to the most highly educated (dynamic/skilled) individuals. (occupations) 

smartypants --- 15 years ago -


I have nothing to whine about.

I didn't see you take that same stance when you and your liberal brethren applied broad labels to the Tea Party. You remember the names: teabaggers, nazis, racists, bigots, etc. There are WW2 and Iraq vets in the Tea Party as well, but it must be just okey-dokey to call them horrible names just because their cause isn't aligned with yours.


Your whining is in evidence. We get it! You don't like OWS. Big surprise. Also, no surprise that you think vets are lazy whiners, but that's who you are. By the way, do share any instance where I called anyone at a tea party rally racist or a nazi. I would like to see that. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Your whining is in evidence.

Does this failing OWS movement that you and your liberal brethren support make you that upset?

We can't all bet on the winning horse. Someone has to come in last. But that's partially what's wrong with the OWS crowd. They've never experienced loss, or hardship, or had the need to fully apply themselves to succeed. It's all been handed to them over the course of their young lives. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

This thread is hardcore stupid and here's why:

Married households will earn more income than single parent households. The people advancing the statistics of household income disparity are smart enough to know this - they just hope the people they feed it to are dumb enough to not understand.

There is data out there which shows income inequality over time according to individual income. But that data indicates that there has been no change in the income gap over the past 15 years.


So we would expect that as the rate of single parent households increase over time (which tend to be heavily skewed toward lower income brackets), it would appear to create an increasing wage gap ONLY if the comparative tool is household income.


But publicizing that data would make it more difficult for the political operatives trying to advance their ideology. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground