Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What would "paying your fair share" look like?

who's talking here?

planemom 2
wayward1 1
Going off air 1
rEVOLution 4
Perfection 4
Warren Peace 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 5
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
A Simple Equation 4
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
nooneishome 6
Sekkusugami 1
One Nation Under God 1
txsassy 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

This is what the tax and income share looked like for the year that Obama inherited:
0

We can clearly see that he inherited an America where the top 1% were earning 20% of the nation's income, yet paying 38% of the nation's tax bills.

Now look at the bottom 50%. Most of those are people we would all consider to be middle class and obviously ALL lowest income households. The bottom 50% were earning 13% of the nation's income, yet were only paying a mere 3% of the tax bill.

So how much more of the nation's tax bill should the top 1% be paying?

How much less than 3% should the bottom 50% be paying?

If you're tempted to react by claiming that the top 1% should be earning only 1% of the nation's income, please explain how that would be good for the country. 

A Simple Equation --- 15 years ago -

The power to tax is the power to destroy. ABOLISH the income tax!!

 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -


Now look at the bottom 50%. Most of those are people we would all consider to be middle class


You consider 33k a year middle class????

If so, the real middle class income has eroded drastically in the last years. Much of that is probably a result of the loss of our manufacturing base... to China.

Maybe that's why people are fed up and want to soak the rich.

They wouldn't mind paying more than what they do... if there were jobs for them. Not everyone can be a rocket scientist or a business owner, fyi.

Those of us that can, should be putting our people ahead of the Indians and Chinese. Bring back manufacturing.... 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

One thing that weirds me out a bit about this chart...

I'm apparently easily in the top 5%.

I don't have an expensive house (very old and thus cheap). Yet, there are easily far more than 5% of houses in the area that one could consider McMansions.

I don't drive a fancy car (old used ones), but I see far far more luxury cars in the Houston area than not. Much more than 5%.

I don't stay at luxury hotels (unless I use points), yet they are everywhere.

I don't have a rolex, yet I see them (and the equivalent) on the arms of many people.

I go could go on an on...

I don't get it.

Are all these other people in massive debt? Did they inherit money? Do they have income that is somehow not counted as income in the above statistics?

The stats must not be telling the whole story about wealth in America. (thinking underground economy...) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Ok, the "fair share" term needs to be broken down b/c it means different things to different people. People say that and some don't understand what "fair share" actually means. Fair means the same for everyone, an equitable amount. That does NOT mean different groups pay a different amount. A flat tax is truly "fair", it means everyone pays the same.

That being said, the median income in this country is now, according to the Chronicle last week, and I posted a thread about it:

"Fifty percent of U.S. workers earned less than 26,364.00 last year, reflecting a growing income gap between the nation's rich and poor, the government reported Thursday.

The number of people making 1 million or more soared to over 18% from 2009, the Social Security Admn. reported, citing payroll data based on W-2 forms submitted by employers to the IRS."


I'm going to bump that thread where I put the info b/c there is interesting data in it. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

that being said, SSFG, is there a flat tax plan that has surfaced recently, that you prefer? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

If you don't pay taxes and only accept handouts from the government should you be able to vote?

Is that fair? 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

Ok, the "fair share" term needs to be broken down b/c it means different things to different people

That's exactly the catch.

My nephew is headed to college in 2 years and we wanted to get him a car for the balance of junior year and to have for senior year and college.

The car cost $10,000. His mother is unable to pay half so I paid 7500. She paid $2000 and my brother paid $500.

Do I feel burdened by providing what is easily mostly handled by me due to the fact they are willing to pay but can't pay half.

Is half the fair share?

When you make tons of money and have benefitted disproportionately it's not always because you work harder.

I'd say a construction worker or toolpusher offhsore work much harder than me yet make a low wage.

Should their taxes go up to be fair to the rich man? 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

What would "paying your fair share" look like?

0

At least until our Constitutional Republic is Restored. I don't agree with being forced to contribute to their schemes, scams, and murderous wars for Hegemony. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Permit me to issue and control the money of the nation and I care not who makes its laws. — Mayer Amsched Rothchild, a prominent European banker in the eighteenth century 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

reV, until the laws change, quoting Mayor Rothchild won't serve as much of a defense with the IRS! LOL 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

quoting Mayor Rothchild

That was a Federal Reserve slam. It's interesting that the Federal Reserve took an 18th century idea and is still using it today without very many people realizing it. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

yes, and mine was a joke! 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

If you don't pay taxes and only accept handouts from the government should you be able to vote?

Include every individual that works for corporations that don't pay taxes. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

I figured as much lol 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Are all these other people in massive debt? Did they inherit money? Do they have income that is somehow not counted as income in the above statistics?

Probably some of all of the above. However, many use debt to finance their lifestyle. If you read the book "The Millionaire Next Door" you'd be surprised who the average millionaire is.


The typical millionaire is more likely to drive a second-hand General Motors car, live in a house with an average property value of $320,000, wear a watch costing less than $100, and buy their suits off the rack for between $200-$300—the suit was probably on sale.

Excerpt found here. 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

If you read the book "The Millionaire Next Door" you'd be surprised who the average millionaire is.

That book is probably 20 years old?

1 million gets you nowhere and you can't even live on the interest.

But I believe that folks between $2-$10 mil net worth may adhere to the 2nd hand GM car, etc.

Over $10 mil...I know that's not true.

All the Dave ramsey crap and financial "experts" BS is just that.

They don't teach how to take chances to make money just how to rathole with a BS broker/advisor. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

If you don't pay taxes and only accept handouts from the government should you be able to vote?


NO 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

If you don't pay taxes and only accept handouts from the government should you be able to vote?

Well, there goes most of the population of Florida. Sorry Meemaw. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

They don't teach how to take chances to make money

They teach to live within your means. Living above your means will get you into trouble every time. You don't have to take big risks with your money to become wealthy. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

i dont know how ppl do it..
we have 3 cars 2 are paid off, we do rent but right now it is the only option.. but for us we have 2 kids in college.( one that needs help and one that doesnt) and 2 in high school, one we support and one we half support ( when he is with us) we dont live fancy.. rarely eat out, never vacation Unless i meet bf where he is out of town for work for some down time.. it is crazy we live so simple yet cant get ahead. :( 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

Aragon, I would like to answer one thing you mentioned-what you inherit is taxed twice-once by the original owner of the money, and again by you, if it's over a certain amount, which doesn't have to be a fortune-I inherited money when my dad died, most of it in the stock market- we were taxed on what he was worth on paper-3 months later, in 2008, the market crashed, leaving us with a fifth of his original "worth"-most of that money went to pay for taxes on a non existent amount- so inherited "wealth" is why first Reagan, and then Bush, fought to keep the death tax alive- 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

You consider 33k a year middle class????

Well it is listed as being in the middle. Isn't that what 50% is? Truthfully, middle class can best be described as some range above and below $33K, but at equal margins. Wouldn't you agree? 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

One thing that weirds me out a bit about this chart...

I'm apparently easily in the top 5%.

I don't have....


How old are you? I'm not asking for any judgmental reasons, I'm asking to make the point that people reach their peak income earning years when they reach their 50s until they retire.

So even though you may currently have an AGI in a tier that makes it appear to be an elite level, you're still saving a huge chunk for retirement and for other items of importance to you.

One of the fallacies of wealth is that many first generation rich (somewhere around 80% of all millionaires are first generation rich) are pretty miserly in their spending habits. A first generation millionaire is not likely to drive a fancy car nor live in a mansion.

They worked hard, took many risks, and found unique circumstances to take advantage of to earn their wealth. So they recognize how easily it is to lose everything by risking it on displays of wealth.


Are all these other people in massive debt?

Probably yes. Think about how many celebrities you've read about who accumulated massive wealth fast - more than you and I could acquire in a lifetime. Yet many squander it and end up declaring bankruptcy.

Signs of wealth don't always imply folks will stay wealthy. It's often a temporary state, especially if they make foolish spending decisions. Look no further than what our politicians have done to us. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -


Well it is listed as being in the middle. Isn't that what 50% is? Truthfully, middle class can best be described as some range above and below $33K, but at equal margins. Wouldn't you agree?


My perception of what middle class is, isn't scientific granted...

I view the middle class as being able to afford at least a small house and one car. Send their kids to college with some loans. Be able to afford basic health insurance.

30 years ago, that was possible at the 50% mark. I don't think it is now.

The earnings of the working middle class have lost significant value as manufacturing moves offshore as office jobs get outsourced, and as the stratification of our society continues.

The trend can't continue like this or we will end up just like Mexico. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

How old are you? I'm not asking for any judgmental reasons, I'm asking to make the point that people reach their peak income earning years when they reach their 50s until they retire.

I'm definitely not in my peak income years then.

Signs of wealth don't always imply folks will stay wealthy. It's often a temporary state, especially if they make foolish spending decisions. Look no further than what our politicians have done to us.

True, but it still pisses me off when I see people in 500k homes that I'll have to bail out someday... since they haven't saved for retirement.

Our setup, penalizes the thrifty and rewards the debtors. An example, the tax deduction on homes.

Even though I'm slight left, I want a flat tax with NO deductions. I actually bet the rich and the wasteful spenders would pay MORE than they do now.

Take away their federal subsidy for their McMansions and see how it goes....

(real estate would further crash so congress would never do it anyway). 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

So is it fair that those who do not contribute to the positive building of America vote?

Simple question.

Fair? 

txsassy --- 15 years ago -

So is it fair that those who do not contribute to the positive building of America vote?

Most of the military fall under the group that gets EIC and doesn't pay much in income taxes if any if itemize because income so low if income taxes are what you're refering to.

Interesting that you don't want military to vote...hmmm 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

If you don't pay taxes and only accept handouts from the government should you be able to vote?

Is that fair? 


Nearly everyone pays taxes. Gas taxes, sin taxes, sales taxes, and those below thresholds for income taxes still have payroll taxes.

So with your rhetorical question, how would a proposal to limit voting rights actually work? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

it may not be fair, (I agree with you, actually) but you can't fault those people who don't have to pay tax due to their income amount-(they do pay sales tax, but that's not federal- 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

that being said, SSFG, is there a flat tax plan that has surfaced recently, that you prefer?


I'm watching to see what develops. Perry supposedly has come out with one and I haven't investigated it yet. A flat tax where everyone pays the same BUT no one can cheat.. I don't want to soak the rich nor punish achievement. But the way things are now the tax code is just ripe to temp people to find loopholes and not pay when they should. And THAT really isn't fair when some can loop hole their way out of paying while the guy making 40k has to pony up all the time. I think our current tax codes and IRS need to be dismantled. Something new, fair and less complicated should be a no-brainer...it just makes sense, period. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I'd say a construction worker or toolpusher offhsore work much harder than me yet make a low wage.

Should their taxes go up to be fair to the rich man? 


I'd say they work harder too - on the job. But that's not the same as saying they sacrificed more to get there. It's also not the same as saying what they do takes more skill or knowledge.

So what would you prefer to compensate a worker for? How "hard" they work? If so, good luck defining "hard".

Right now, it appears that compensation is tied to applying skills and knowledge on the job. So I would explain the growing income gap as a reflection of what happens when one group grows their commodity knowledge and skills more than another group.

I could find a good construction worker to hire by the time I get home this evening. But the number of people vetted and qualified to be a Chief Financial Officer for a Fortune 500 company is much scarcer resource.

Scarcity increases price. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

True, but it still pisses me off when I see people in 500k homes that I'll have to bail out someday... since they haven't saved for retirement.

Our setup, penalizes the thrifty and rewards the debtors. An example, the tax deduction on homes.


You point out some key reasons why home prices got inflated. Each were caused by politicians with good intentions who failed to think things through. Although middle class home owners appreciate the homestead exemption much more than the rich, it is the rich that benefit more from the mortgage interest deduction. Each of these created incentives for people to buy bigger houses than they could otherwise afford without these incentives.

If politicians had not gotten involved, banks risking their own money would still be making lending decision based on only debt to income ratio with a 20% deposit required. If our politicians (and the Justice Dept) had not changed the rules with these notions to make home owners out of people that should have stayed renting, we would not be having this conversation. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

But the way things are now the tax code is just ripe to temp people to find loopholes and not pay when they should.

Things were actually that way for a very long time. Back when the upper brackets where above 70%, we didn't really have that many people paying at that rate. They were doing the rational thing instead - putting their money elsewhere where lower taxes would be due.

Remember this the next time you hear our President and his loyal propaganda artists in the media talking about how much better things were when upper tax brackets were sky high. They are leaving out critical information, thereby intentionally deceiving.


And THAT really isn't fair when some can loop hole their way out of paying while the guy making 40k has to pony up all the time.

Don't forget that some things we refer to as "loopholes" are actually incentives granted to get taxpayers to direct their money to things that benefit the public without the government serving as a collection agency.

Charitable giving for example. If you "close the loophole" of charitable giving which allows the rich to offset their donation to the community by lowering their taxable income at a rate much less than dollar for dollar, then how likely is it that such behavior will continue? I think it will continue, but it's reasonable to expect an erosion of charitable giving. 

A Simple Equation --- 15 years ago -

All this back and forth and hair splitting can all be solved by abolishing the income tax.

Government needs to be reduced in size greatly and can operate on a shoestring budget funded by a national sales tax, period. The more money you make, the more you buy and the more taxes you end up paying. Fair and equitable all the way around. You pay what you can afford and you can choose to avoid paying taxes by not consuming certain things.

THAT'S FREEDOM. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

Don't forget that some things we refer to as "loopholes" are actually incentives granted to get taxpayers to direct their money to things that benefit the public without the government serving as a collection agency.

I'm all for eliminating that deduction too. Why should anyone subsidize the philanthropic hobbies or religions of other people?

Flat tax, no loops at all, including charity. It's the only way. Especially since a lot of "charitable" giving is BS that covers social activities of givers. Lots of fraud in charities. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Flat tax, no loops at all, including charity. It's the only way. Especially since a lot of "charitable" giving is BS that covers social activities of givers. Lots of fraud in charities.


Yes if people need a help out let them ALL go to the governement for help. Let see how long before the flat tax rate has to be raised. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Most of the military fall under the group that gets EIC and doesn't pay much in income taxes if any if itemize because income so low if income taxes are what you're refering to.

Interesting that you don't want military to vote...hmmm



Military automatically gets to vote, they are exempt from paying taxes imo. If you put your live on the line for the country your paying your fair share and then some. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

[i]Let see how long before the flat tax rate has to be raised.

It should take an act of Congress, lol. But that is a valid issue that should be dealt with in the plan.

But all the deductions and loop holes and all that "jazz" is what makes the tax code so complicated and so easily manipulated. Gotta do away with that or we'll be right back where we started. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Why should people be subsidized to breed?

Is that fair?

Why should $100,000 cars have a $7,500 tax break for the rich who buy them? Especially when the cars aren't even made in america? Is that fair?

What's fair?

Is equal treatment fair?

Or is equal unfair? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground