Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Was Dr Kavorkian a savior......

who's talking here?

Jen 1
sunshine1881 5
Going off air 1
ghostpost 1
Perfection 1
Lillabeth 3
Laurabeth 2
Hiro Protagonist 2
oneyedman 7
combatkenpo 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 7
JohnLynch 10
OH SNAP 1
TexasOma 11
Sadie 1
freebyrd 9
Dr Aborto 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Puss In Boots 5
In AbsentiaW 2
Bornanraisedkw 1
Dorothy Parker 8
thankfulformyfour 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Zombie 4
horseymomma 8
elliemae 1
ChrisC2011 12
Kara 1
Feeling Blue 1
gardeniagirl07 2
giannasmommy 8
Kyobungee 1
Hakuna Matatted 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

........or a murderer? 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Interesting question. I was just studying views of death/dying in the US.

I dunno about a savior...but definitely not a murderer.

He filled a role in society that someone needed to. He forced us to face questions that we are often to fearful to do ourselves.

He brought a level of dignity and humanity to death that we are severely lacking in the US.

According to the CDC, the vast majority of people would prefer to die at home.
Currently in the US, 60% die in hospitals, and 19% in nursing homes.

I only hope that someone like Dr. K is around for me when it is my time to go. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

a murderer...the Bible tells us that premeditated killing is murder...only God has authority over life and death (and before someone says it...God gives authority to governments to justly carry out capital punishment)...euthanasia is mankind's way of trying to take away God's authority...going against God's will is sin...and there is no dignity in sinning 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Johnlynch does that make those who induce death upon the condemned prisoners sinners as well? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

This thread could get very lively, me thinks.

I believe that Dr. Kevorkian has spotlighted an issue that is haunting to most Americans. We are so separated from the actual experience of death (often one dies away from home, the body is cleaned and prepared for burial outside the home) that we have become afraid of death itself.

One can also argue that doctors have in a way become "God" by artificially extending the life of someone who would normally be allowed to pass on peacefully of their own accord.

I do believe in quality of life and in not extending a life simply because we have the machinery and technology to do so. Dignity in death is a real concept. And I believe that those of us who are afraid of our mortality or of simply saying goodbye to those we love, are utilizing means that rob of all of us of that dignity and of God's will.

Who is worse...Dr. Kevorkian or doctors who artificially extend life? Both interfere ultimately with God's will. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Johnlynch does that make those who induce death upon the condemned prisoners sinners as well?

"(and before someone says it...God gives authority to governments to justly carry out capital punishment)" 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I will never understand the way our society views death when it comes to a loved one with a terminal illness who is literally suffering. We won't allow our pets to suffer, but, we'll keep Grandma hopped up on pain killers or in an induced coma until she finally passes.

It makes no sense.

I think Dr. Kevorkian was a savior to the people who enlisted his help. It was a choice and it should be made available to people. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

I am not buying John's view of the world.
Because if that was truly the case, it could be said the doctors are evil for not allowing gods work to be done by healing people. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -



I only hope that someone like Dr. K is around for me when it is my time to go.



Me too.

I do not want to languish in a nursing home or hospital, not even at home. I pray that if I reach the point of laying in a bed, in my own excrement, being fed by a feeding tube, developing bedsores, unable to turn myself or do anything for myself, that God goes ahead and takes me on to where ever my soul is destined.

Back before all this modern technology and medicine that's exactly what would happen - God would take you on to heaven. AWM said it very well --- I do believe in quality of life and in not extending a life simply because we have the machinery and technology to do so. Dignity in death is a real concept. And I believe that those of us who are afraid of our mortality or of simply saying goodbye to those we love, are utilizing means that rob of all of us of that dignity and of God's will.

For those of you who do not have a Living Will and Durable Power of Attorney --- go get it now. You can download the forms off the Richard Alderman link on Channel 13. Complete the forms and have someone who does not have an interest in your death (like money/inheritance) witness the documents -- they do not have to be motorized (I think that's what Alderman said).

Next make your wishes known to your family and friends and doctors - they will be the people who make sure your wishes are followed. Make several copies of the Living Will & Durable Power of Attorney & give them to each person involved & keep the original in your home. Know that you can change your mind at anytime simply by destroying the documents and telling the people involved that you have changed your mind. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Oh --- and you are never too young to make a Living Will or Durable Power of Attorney ---- you never ever know when you will become ill or get involved in a near death accident. These documents cover you until you are able to make decisions for yourself again. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

If a family member is speaking for you, they can override your wishes as far as living wills and such. I know people who were in battles over their parents wishes vs what they wanted for their parents, etc. It is hard to let go, I can understand that, but, not following through on what the ill person wanted, happens all the time. :(

Same with burial procedures vs cremation and funeral plans, etc. If you're no longer here or unable to voice your opinion and wishes, you're at the mercy of your family members. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

If a family member is speaking for you, they can override your wishes as far as living wills and such. I know people who were in battles over their parents wishes vs what they wanted for their parents, etc. It is hard to let go, I can understand that, but, not following through on what the ill person wanted, happens all the time. :(

Same with burial procedures vs cremation and funeral plans, etc. If you're no longer here or unable to voice your opinion and wishes, you're at the mercy of your family members.



I understand that Mom --- and I don't have a solution for that other than make sure the people you pick to be your spokesperson will truly will follow through with your wishes. I only have my husband then my sister as the back-up (husband & wife could be involved in the same accident - then what?). My DH is and only child & everyone has passed on, so my sister is his backup also.

Didn't choose our daughter because she might not let go - my sis is a common sense person & will do what we want & she would see the reality of either of us being attached to life support for years. Neither of us want that. We pray nothing ever happens, but just in case - Sis will do what we want.



As for the burial stuff --- I've threatened that if they don't cremate me I'll come back and haunt them daily. :-) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

He purely creeps me out. I say that because aside from what one may think about end of life issues, why would anyone take comfort or pleasure in helping and seeing other people die? It's just plainly weird. One of the most power forces in humanity is the will to live.


As far as the end of life issues, I get that some don't want to live and are in a lot of pain. But people can refuse treatment so they can die if they wish. We also have the medical ability to make people comfortable even to the point of putting them into drug induced comas if need be. That's what they did to Farrah Fawcett, just made her unconscious til she passed.
I truly think if someone wants to kill themselves, they should do it without the aid of another person. To have someone like Kervorkian "helping" people opens a big can of worms and will also attract the loons. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Nurses have a unique perspective on this issue--they have seen it ALL.

And that is why I believe there are DNR orders (Do Not Resucitate) for those of us that do not want to live out our final days in a horrible state....machines breathing for us, brain dead, nothing left. Let us pass, and let us do it with dignity and mercy.

I do realize this is a bit off-topic....but directly related. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Oma, I feel the same way. We have 5 children and I never want them at odds over what to do about me or my husband. It scares me because these situations can tear families apart. :(

I don't like thinking about it and I like the idea of a Dr. Kevorkian because that enables you to have control over what's going on while you still can.

I also lose sleep over what would happen to my kids if my husband and I were to die in an accident. We've made our wishes known to everyone, but once faced with that actual situation, would everyone follow through??


Ugh...depressing stuff. :( 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

And that is why I believe there are DNR orders (Do Not Resucitate) for those of us that do not want to live out our final days in a horrible state....machines breathing for us, brain dead,

I agree. Legally one should do all they can in the way of last wishes, DNR's, etc. Just uncomplicates things and relieves family members of agonizing over decisions that a person should make for themselves when they are rational and healthy. 

Lillabeth --- 15 years ago -

Exactly MO5.

I have it on my DL (for an OD) and in our living will that I want to be an organ donor, with my body to be donated to Baylor for two years, then cremated.

I know none of those will happen as both my husband and my oldest do not want those for me. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Nurses have a unique perspective on this issue--they have seen it ALL.

And that is why I believe there are DNR orders (Do Not Resucitate) for those of us that do not want to live out our final days in a horrible state....machines breathing for us, brain dead, nothing left. Let us pass, and let us do it with dignity and mercy.

I do realize this is a bit off-topic....but directly related.


Very few patients will utilize the DNR option. I don't know if they don't understand it or they truly want every measure taken to keep them alive. CPR on a 90 year old most likely will not have a positive outcome -- body is usually too frail at that point to withstand the beating the body takes in CPR.

SighFiGurl --- you are correct on the drug induced coma. That's kinda what happens with hospice at the very end. I've had 2 patients that I moved into hospice and each passed away comfortably in their sleep. One patient's spouse came away claiming that hospice killed her by putting drugs into her system that the Morphine killed her.

Well, kinda-sorta. She was going to die anyway, the morphine made her comfortable & no pain. 

Jen --- 15 years ago -

I will never understand the way our society views death when it comes to a loved one with a terminal illness who is literally suffering. We won't allow our pets to suffer, but, we'll keep Grandma hopped up on pain killers or in an induced coma until she finally passes.

It makes no sense.

I think Dr. Kevorkian was a savior to the people who enlisted his help. It was a choice and it should be made available to people.


Well said.... 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

[i]I think Dr. Kevorkian was a savior to the people who enlisted his help. It was a choice and it should be made available to people. [/i]
i agree, i think you should have a choice. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

I also lose sleep over what would happen to my kids if my husband and I were to die in an accident. We've made our wishes known to everyone, but once faced with that actual situation, would everyone follow through??


If your wishes are not in writing, the doctors will make the decision. Please get the LW/DPOA documents. As I said, you never know when an accident will happen.

As for the organ donation --- I thought there was some sort of legislation a while back that you had to have paper documents ahead of time for them to harvest your organs. I thought this was because so many family members would not follow the patient's wishes and actually donate the organs. I maybe be totally mistaken about this. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

God gives authority to governments to justly carry out capital punishment

BS... The Catholic Church does not believe this, so don't paint Christianity with a broad brush.

Life is sacred in my church and we oppose the taking of life. period. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Ruh roh. 

Lillabeth --- 15 years ago -

Come on oneye. The Catholic church is pretty well known for their killing of a lot people who opposed them. Christianity as a whole has a very gruesome history. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Christianity as a whole has a very gruesome history.

Humanity has a gruesome history. you err to place the blame on the church. 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

I'm keeping vigil at my uncle's bedside. He is now in hospice in the nursing home in MN that he's been in since 2008. He's 90 and my aunt is 86, no longer physically able to care for him. Their only son died of a heart attack at 46. I am their closest living relative.

RA is what put my uncle in the nursing home and the immobility which ensues has caused him to develope a miriad of complications. He is losing his current battle with pneumonia and is considered by family & hospice to be in the "end stage" of his life.

The problem is that his vital organs will not stop. He is dosed hourly with morphine but you can see the pain come and go none the less. It has been 5 days now since he has been able to tolerate food or water. He does have a DNR.

This should not HAVE to be, yet.... Here I sit and await a merciful end for him..... 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

I am sorry for that freebyrd..... :( 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

it could be said the doctors are evil for not allowing gods work to be done by healing people.

actually, no it can't...it's in God's will for people to be healed

BS... The Catholic Church does not believe this, so don't paint Christianity with a broad brush.

i don't care what the catholic church says...the catholic church isn't God......the Bible speaks for God...the Bible is God's Word...and the Bible says that God gives government the authority to carry out capital punishment

"Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed: for in the image of God made he man." - Genesis 9:6

"And he that killeth any man shall surely be put to death" - Leviticus 24:17

"Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God.
2 Therefore he who resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment.
3 For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of him who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval,
4 for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain; he is the servant of God to execute his wrath on the wrongdoer.
5 Therefore one must be subject, not only to avoid God's wrath but also for the sake of conscience." - Romans 13:1-5 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

Wouldn't the old testament rules from leviticus and genesis no longer be applicable?

I know everyone doesn't pay any attention to most of the levitican law, so why would any of them be applicable anymore?

Serious question. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

So sorry Freebyrd....prayers for you and your family. Travel home safely.

As far as DNR orders...please, please make sure you complete the paperwork properly and obtain your Out of Hospital DNR as well if that is your wish. One of the hardest calls I ever responded to was for an elderly gentleman that was on his death bed, his wife called 911 because she though he had passed, but when we arrived, he still had a pulse and apenic breathing. She stated he was a DNR and just wanted the body removed. She didn't understand that without the proper OUT OF HOSPITAL DNR documents and with him still being a "viable" alive patient, that we HAD TO BY LAW....treat him. It was awful, so sad, the wife was so distraught. We did what the law forced us to do and did our best to maintain the mans dignity and care for his wife, but we had to treat and transport. Without the proper paperwork we have to continue with life saving measures until a doctor pronouces or there are no signs of life.

We called ahead to the hospital and had them locate the mans medical records that included his in hospital DNR, so that the doctor could pronounce him at our arrival. it was so hard, I let the wife ride in the back of the ambulance holding his hand the whole way and kept apologizing. Sometimes the laws suck, but I understand why they are in place.

I wish he could have died peacefully at home in his own bed as he wished..... 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

my dad had a DNR but the first time it wasnt filled out completly and they revived him, then the next time they couldnt find it and they reveived him, the last time with everything in order they let him go.. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

He was a visionary. Suicide booths will be plentiful in the future...and only cost 25ยข

Futurama 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Wouldn't the old testament rules from leviticus and genesis no longer be applicable?

yes...they are applicable...what makes you think they wouldn't be applicable?...do you think God has changed His mind on "Thou shalt not kill"..."Thou shalt not commit adultery..."Thou shalt not steal"...etc.? 

combatkenpo --- 15 years ago -

The only issue I have with legally assisted suicide is the Pandora's Box that it could open. If a law were passed making doctor assisted suicide legal what would be the end state? Would we move from putting granddad out of "his" misery to putting him out of "our" misery? How about the mentally handicapped boy that will never contribute to society? Lot of these babyboomers are retiring or soon will be. They'll be a huge drain on society and they'll not be producing...form a line, please.

Before you think something like this can't happen, I'll remind you that Nazi Germany killed millions of people...Jews, Slavs, Poles, Serbs, Romanians, "persons of color", homosexuals, Freemasons...all after they started with the disabled and mentally ill. The bulk of the murders happened between 1941-1944, but they started with the disabled and mentally ill in 1939 and the world just watched.

But wait...it can't happen here in the USA, right? Wrong. In 1973 Roe v Wade made it legal for a doctor to end a pregnancy if the mother's life was endangered. In 2011 a 15 year old girl can get an abortion without her parents consent. Not saying I'm for or against abortion and I'm not comparing abortion to the Holocaust. I'm saying that once you start on a path like this it can become a very slippery slope. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Check the law for assisted suicide that I think is still in effect in Oregon.

Then is euthanasia still legal in the Netherlands?

Fortunately as a country we still have safeguards to avoid what occurred under the Nazi regime. 

Hakuna Matatted --- 15 years ago -

I think he was a wonderful man. Just like hospice workers, not just anyone could do the job.

He gave people a choice for a dignified death.

I'm thankful that my Father went as soon as he did, only 3 days in hospice care, and I can't imagine what it's like for people who are just laying there in pain and waiting to die. My uncle waited 10 years as a (stage 4 spinal) cancer stricken parapalegic until pneumonia finally took him.

Dr. Kevorkian provided comfort and a much needed service for the terminally ill. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

My grandmother always said the people suffer their own hell on earth if they die a long lingering death.

The good die quickly and peacefully thanks to God's good grace. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

there's no dignity in suicide

The good die quickly and peacefully thanks to God's good grace.

amen! 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

Not a savior by any means...I do liken his practices to killing even if it is seemingly merciful. It is God's call when it comes time for me to die...not some man. 

Going off air --- 15 years ago -

too hot 2 handle

i'm not getting involved 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground