Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

House Appraised below Contract Price

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 1
AuthorMan 2
Mygirl01 1
moneypenny 2
kingwood resident 1
Cookin' Queen 2
Jpgirl 1
zapper007 1
quiettype 2
Gigix4 3
susie q 2
austin 1
Peach 1
In AbsentiaW 1
Bornanraisedkw 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Ordinary Guy 1
elliemae 5
needsleep 1
Kara 1
ap30 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

We have a contract on a house and the bank appraisal came in lower than the contract price. I don't want to fork out the extra cash not knowing which way the housing market is going. What should i do? 

Peach --- 15 years ago -

What is your realtor saying to do? 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

I'd look for another house or use it as leverage for them to lower the selling price to fit within the appraisal. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

You may try to contact Moveit on here. I think she may be able to give you some info.
It's not surprising that the bank's appraisal came in lower than the contract price.
Have you considered a counter offer to the seller? If they are in a hurry to sell, they may be willing to work with you. In some cases, the seller may consider a "side note" to cover the additional cost. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

The realtor is trying to convince me that this house has more upgrades than the comps shown in the appraisal. However, the major discrepancy is that the appraisal came in approx 200 sq ft less than the listed sq footage 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

Have you considered a counter offer to the seller? If they are in a hurry to sell, they may be willing to work with you.
i have asked them to show where the discrepancy is, in the sq footage calculations in the appraisal. 200 sq ft will make up for the difference if the appraiser didn't calculate correctly. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

is it a new or existing? This happened to a friend but it was a new build and she indeed get a ton of upgrades. Don't think I would do it on an existing house 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

The sellers are going to have the same problem with anyone who has the house appraised. I'd ask for a price adjustment. If they won't give it to you, walk away. After a few weeks/months they will end up calling you back. 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

you could ask for another appraisal but you will have to pay for it and your lender will have to approve the 2nd appraiser. A lower appraisal will have an impact on your loan, not just on how much you can borrow but your loan to value ratio. If you were putting down 20% before to avoid PMI the new appraised value might put you out of range if you are having to fund the difference out of pocket, especially if it eats into that 20% you were using for a down payment.

At the very least try to negotiate a new price with the sellers that is reflective of the appraised value. If they won't play ball you can either look at getting another appraisal or start looking for another house. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Is it a huge difference between the two?

The banks appraisal is what they think your home is worth considering they will have a vested interest in the mortgage. It tends to be "unemotional" and based on area, previous sales, ammenities, etc. The market value is what someone is willing to pay for the home. They can be different for sure, especially in this market..

So, is the problem that the amount you wanted to pay now seems unreasonable? I'd look at your realtors' comparisons of similar properties again. Also, honestly, I'd be in contact with the sellers and let them know what's going on, any way they'd renegotiate? Pretty sure this won't make them happy tho! 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

is it a new or existing?

It is an existing house. I'd ask for a price adjustment.

I tried but looks like they had the house appraised before they put it on the market and it was appraised at 200 sq ft more than what the bank's appraiser did. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

Is it a huge difference between the two?
about 2% lower than the agreed upon price.

So, is the problem that the amount you wanted to pay now seems unreasonable?

Not unreasonable, just don't want to shell out more cash in a housing market that is still shaky.

Pretty sure this won't make the happy tho! 
Yup, from what i hear, the sellers are really angry that the appraisal came in 200 sq ft less 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

have u looked at it on hcad? www.hcad.com 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

Will the bank even give you the mortgage for more than the appraisal? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Pretty sure this won't make the happy tho!
Yup, from what i hear, the sellers are really angry that the appraisal came in 200 sq ft less



Well on a 200k house, as a sample, that 2% comes out to 4k. And 4k spread out over a 20-30 year loan, is nuthin'. If you really love the house, and the sellers won't budge, I'd consider it as long as the price is reasonable for the house. Also if it makes ya feel better, many have lost a lot more than 2% of the value in their homes.. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

have u looked at it on hcad? www.hcad.com 

yes, the hcad agrees to what the appraisal came in at, but the seller had changed the plans when they built it to add more sq footage, they gave me a copy of the original layout and the new layout

Will the bank even give you the mortgage for more than the appraisal? 
no we have to make up for the difference or get PMI 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

Since it's only 2%, maybe the seller will split the difference with you. 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

I tried but looks like they had the house appraised before they put it on the market and it was appraised at 200 sq ft more than what the bank's appraiser did.

Anyway they would share the report so the bank's appraiser can see where the differences are. I had a RE license in Louisiana and when I took the classes it was clear how easy it was for everyone to come up with a different square footage for the same house but 200 is a lot of difference. Maybe if the bank's appraiser can see both he would be willing to at least investigate if he made a mistake. You could also ask the bank if the seller's appraiser is on their approved list. If so, maybe they would be willing to at least look at that appraisal if the seller will provide. 

AuthorMan --- 15 years ago -

We have a contract on a house

If you walk away, you might lose any deposit you put down on the deal.

200 sf is a big difference. Maybe you can get the two appraising companies to compare. $70 times 200 sf is $14,000. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

^yes that is what we are trying to do right now. have the bank's appraiser look at the seller's appraisal report and decide whether he agrees or not. if he doesn't agree, then we will ask the seller to split the difference. 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

If you aren't planning on being in the house long term, you will end up with the same issue when you go to sell. I'd write down all of the pros and cons and really take my time deciding. 

Kara --- 15 years ago -

2 different loans...

This happened to a friend of mine. 

moneypenny --- 15 years ago -

With the market the way it is being a buyers market. The sellers should renegotiate down to the appraised value. Every person who tries to buy the house will have the same appraisal issues. Once the square footage is worked out of course. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

If you walk away, you might lose any deposit you put down on the deal.

Are you sure, because i was told that we will not lose the earnest money if the appraisal came in lower than the contract price. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

With the market the way it is being a buyers market. The sellers should renegotiate down to the appraised value. Every person who tries to buy the house will have the same appraisal issues. Once the square footage is worked out of course.
That is exactly how we feel, but i also understand that there is an emotional factor to a house when selling and people might not want to compromise due to that 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

You won't lose your earnest money. 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

i am looking at both sq footage appraisal right now and the seller's appraisal has almost 400 sq ft as items not listed and added to the bottom, now that would be a hard one to sell to the bank. 

moneypenny --- 15 years ago -

Very true ap but they probably also don't want to pay another mortgage payment while they wait for someone else to make an offer. Just remember they are selling in this market because they have a reason to so you guys are in the drivers seat. 

austin --- 15 years ago -

FYI, banks can no longer choose their appraiser. (Thanks to govt intervention)
It now kinda works like the home warranty system: bank sends out a request that they need an appraisal, first person to respond gets it. So you could end up with a crappy appraiser just like for home warranty you could end up with a crappy plumber.

You can get your own private appraisal, but the underwriters won't be allowed to accept it. 

Ordinary Guy --- 15 years ago -

I say its a buyers market. Tell them your going to buy a house. They should want to sell theirs, or wait who knows how long til the next one. 

susie q --- 15 years ago -

I've sold 11 homes in my day, and I always hate comparisons. Through my sales, I've found that my homes had alot of different items from another home. I don't know where these realtors come up with this stuff, because they never seem to really find a true comparison, and I always felt it unfair. My homes always had alot more to offer than the comparisons, because we always put in more. 

Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

Have you taken a tape measure to the rooms in the house? Not from the har listing by actually measured the house yourself? That would be my first suggestion, then you'll see for yourself if it's really that much bigger or not. If it's truly larger then I'd start negotiations with the sellers but not until I knew for myself the real square footage of the home in question. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

Have you taken a tape measure to the rooms in the house?

I think that is what I would do and I would also think the seller would too. 

AuthorMan --- 15 years ago -

If you walk away, you might lose any deposit you put down on the deal.

Are you sure, because i was told that we will not lose the earnest money if the appraisal came in lower than the contract price.


If that clause is in the contract, you are right. 

Cookin' Queen --- 15 years ago -

This has happened to me twice. In the early 90s the house we were buying in Pecan Grove made the appraisal loan amount but was about 200 sq ft less than what we thought we were buying. In those days they did "pencil math" showing their calculations and I found their math error so we bought the house.

Recently I tried to sale my mom's house so I had it appraised. The tax rolls shows it about 100+ sq ft less than the blueprints. The appraiser measured the outside of the house (1 story) and showed me on his ipad type computer that it was what the blueprints said.

I'm guessing that your appraiser just used the tax roll number. If you can measure the perimeter of the house it is easy to figure the sq ftage. 

kingwood resident --- 15 years ago -

I would never pay more than what a house appraised for. The seller's need to come down on their price. You need to give them a counter offer, only up the amount of the appraisal. If they do not come down walk away from it. You will not loose your earnest money because the house is listed higher than the appraisal value which is your basis for having the end the contract. 

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

i am looking at both sq footage appraisal right now and the seller's appraisal has almost 400 sq ft as items not listed and added to the bottom, now that would be a hard one to sell to the bank

CAUTION...
Seems like the seller is trying to manipulate you!!!

Get another appraisal - offer to split the cost with the seller. If they refuse to share the cost, you have your answer.

Do not us an appraiser suggested by the realtor or the seller...jmho 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Ive seen sellers not budge even when the appraisal came in lower. Then they lowered the price a few weeks later. They may decide to hold out for another potential buyer who can put a bigger down payment. You have number to hit and so do they. Like a few others have said submit a counter offer for the difference. That is pretty normal to do. Do the sq ftage on hcad match up? I have seen that a few times. It sometimes can work in your advantage for property tax purposes. Incase if you are feeling this way.... dont let your emotions take hold of you on a realestate transaction. if your contract was written that earnest money will be forfeited if you back out over a low appraisal..shame on your agent for not picking up on that. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

If the problem is the square footage go to the county tax rolls and that should show you the established square footage that the property is taxed at.

Counter offer for the appraised price or walk away., 

ap30 --- 15 years ago -

right now we have sent the bank's appraiser a copy of the seller's appraisal to see if he can reconcile the diff in sq footage. if he does, good. if he stick by his number, we will counter back at the appraised price.

also, the county tax roll does show it to be close to the bank's appraisal, however the seller had added a room when they were building the house new and that added to the livable sq footage per the plans they gave us. now bear in mind, the plans they gave us were builder plans and don't have the sq footage calculation like an appraisal does.

didn't realize buying a house would be such a pain....lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground