Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Chart That Should Accompany All Discussions of the Debt Ceiling

who's talking here?

auntmarsa 1
Donkey Hodie 11
SoupIsGoodFood 1
david 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
JohnLynch 9
evolved 4
TexasOma 2
Dr Aborto 2
Toss 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
Clovis 2
Kyobungee 1
mrrhino 2
sassier 10

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

From The Atlantic

0

It's based on data from the Congressional Budget Office and the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Its significance is not partisan (who's "to blame" for the deficit) but intellectual. It demonstrates the utter incoherence of being very concerned about a structural federal deficit but ruling out of consideration the policy that was largest single contributor to that deficit, namely the Bush-era tax cuts.

An additional significance of the chart: it identifies policy changes, the things over which Congress and Administration have some control, as opposed to largely external shocks -- like the repercussions of the 9/11 attacks or the deep worldwide recession following the 2008 financial crisis. Those external events make a big difference in the deficit, and they are the major reason why deficits have increased faster in absolute terms during Obama's first two years that during the last two under Bush. (In a recession, tax revenues plunge, and government spending goes up - partly because of automatic programs like unemployment insurance, and partly in a deliberate attempt to keep the recession from getting worse.) If you want, you could even put the spending for wars in Iraq and Afghanistan in this category: those were policy choices, but right or wrong they came in response to an external shock.

The point is that governments can respond to but not control external shocks. That's why we call them "shocks." Governments can control their policies. And the policy that did the most to magnify future deficits is the Bush-era tax cuts. You could argue that the stimulative effect of those cuts is worth it ("deficits don't matter" etc). But you cannot logically argue that we absolutely must reduce deficits, but that we absolutely must also preserve every penny of those tax cuts. Which I believe precisely describes the House Republican position.


0 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

And the unemployment rate for both of these presidencies??? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

And the unemployment rate for both of these presidencies???


Has nothing to do with these charts or a discussion on the debt cieling. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

what a joke...tax cuts aren't a cost...another liberal attempt at changing the truth...just like liberals calling gov't spending "investments" 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

but but but but... 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

The Bush tax cuts are probably the single worst thing to happen to the deficit. So, where are all these jobs that these tax cuts created? Where are the overall increased tax revenues from more people having these magical jobs that flower magically from the palms of rich magical investors? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Where are the overall increased tax revenues from more people having these magical jobs that flower magically from the palms of rich magical investors? 

revenues did increase...look it up...the problem is...government spending increased at a higher rate 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

revenues did increase...look it up...the problem is...government spending increased at a higher rate

Please cite your source. I cited mine above. 

sassier --- 15 years ago -

revenues did increase...look it up...the problem is...government spending increased at a higher rate


I agree with you, but please don't use their word obfuscation


it's not 'revenues' - it's 'TAXES' 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Please cite your source. I cited mine above. 

as i said...look it up...it will do you some good 

sassier --- 15 years ago -

but but but but...


why didn't Obama and the Democrats change this when they controlled the WH and Congress? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

it's not 'revenues' - it's 'TAXES' 

it was revenue from taxes...the tax cuts produced more jobs and therefore more taxpayers 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

.the tax cuts produced more jobs and therefore more taxpayers

Please cite your source. I cited mine above. 

sassier --- 15 years ago -

The Bush tax cuts are probably the single worst thing to happen to the deficit.


but Obama extended the 'Bush tax-cuts' in December - just 9 months ago - when Pelosi was still in charge of the House and Reid presided over the Senate 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Please cite your source. I cited mine above. 

not going to do it...it's really common knowledge...but it's verifiable if you put out the effort...it's all been cited before 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

and how many of these dod B.O. vote for? How many did Bush vote for? 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

but Obama extended the 'Bush tax-cuts' in December - just 9 months ago - when Pelosi was still in charge of the House and Reid presided over the Senate

Yes, and that's something Obama did that I do not approve of. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

0 

sassier --- 15 years ago -


The Bush tax cuts are probably the single worst thing to happen to the deficit.



so the deficit GREW because the IRS took less money as authorized by Congress?


it sounds like the federal government has a spending problem to me 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

Please cite your source. I cited mine above.

not going to do it


Then please stop participating in this discussion if you are not prepared to back up your claims with evidence. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Then please stop participating in this discussion if you are not prepared to back up your claims with evidence. 

i'll participate in any discussion i choose...as i said, it's all been cited before

btw, if you stop putting up false statistics, i'll stop commenting on them 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

it sounds like the federal government has a spending problem to me

Both. There is a spending problem AND a tax revenue problem. Democrats want to approach it from one side, Republicans from the other. I think the best solution is to do BOTH. 

sassier --- 15 years ago -


but Obama extended the 'Bush tax-cuts' in December - just 9 months ago - when Pelosi was still in charge of the House and Reid presided over the Senate


Yes, and that's something Obama did that I do not approve of.



not just Obama

also Pelosi, then-Speaker of the House

also Reid, still-Leader of the Senate


are you sure they're really aligned with your beliefs on taxes? 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

as i said, it's all been cited before

Where? Where has it been cited? Specifically, where? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

but Obama extended the 'Bush tax-cuts' in December - just 9 months ago - when Pelosi was still in charge of the House and Reid presided over the Senate 

Remember, he wanted to extend the Bush tax cuts for the middle class ONLY. But the Pubs pitched a fit an threatened to just let all the cuts run out unless he extended the cuts to the rich as well. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Remember, he wanted to extend the Bush tax cuts for the middle class ONLY. But the Pubs pitched a fit an threatened to just let all the cuts run out unless he extended the cuts to the rich as well. 


Oh yeah Bush want to do things differently too but Democrats controlled the house and the senate and voted for all of the above issues. 

sassier --- 15 years ago -



it sounds like the federal government has a spending problem to me


Both. There is a spending problem AND a tax revenue problem. Democrats want to approach it from one side, Republicans from the other.


I think the best solution is to do BOTH.



that's a talking point from Obama's speech tonight, which is just more of the same - Washington has a spending problem


a fully-controlled democrat Congress had a chance to increase taxes in December and elected not to - the president signed it into law on Dec 17, 2010


Pelosi, Reid and Obama decided not to increase taxes just 9 months ago 

sassier --- 15 years ago -



but Obama extended the 'Bush tax-cuts' in December - just 9 months ago - when Pelosi was still in charge of the House and Reid presided over the Senate


Remember, he wanted to extend the Bush tax cuts for the middle class ONLY. But the Pubs pitched a fit an threatened to just let all the cuts run out unless he extended the cuts to the rich as well.



but 'the pubs' didn't control Congress in December 2010 -
the new Congress wasn't sworn in until January 2011


Reid and Pelosi voted to extend the 'Bush tax cuts' - Obama signed it into law


now, eat your peas

0 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Obama's speech tonight,


It was a campaign speech nothing more. He acted like a little kid that ran to tell on his siblings. I'm tellin!

Grow up jerk. (to be clear I'm speaking about Obama) 

auntmarsa --- 15 years ago -

To classify letting working citizens keep a a little more of their income as a goverment COST illustrates the graph creators unfortunate stance that all money belongs to the government and is simply given to the citizens as a government spend. Pitiful.

This error voids the entire chart, since it calls so blatantly illustrates the lack of credibility of the data.

ugh... back to ignoring these political arguments. 

sassier --- 15 years ago -



To classify letting working citizens keep a a little more of their income as a goverment COST illustrates the graph creators unfortunate stance that all money belongs to the government and is simply given to the citizens as a government spend. Pitiful.



if everyone had to write a check to the IRS every single paycheck - instead of having it 'automatically deducted' - we would have gotten rid Washington's addition to American's tax money decades ago! 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

The current problem in our country is that the Republicans hate, truly hate, our President more than they love our country, and they are willing to run our country into the ground to prove it.



0


Nice chart, Donkey. 

david --- 15 years ago -

We should raise taxes on the 45% that do not contribute ANYTHING. Then cut entitlements, defense and ALL foreign aid. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

The current problem in our country is that the Republicans hate, truly hate, our President more than they love our country, and they are willing to run our country into the ground to prove it.

the real current problem are the dems who believe that nonsense 

sassier --- 15 years ago -


The current problem in our country is that the Republicans hate, truly hate, our President more than they love our country, and they are willing to run our country into the ground to prove it.



but Obama hates all Americans - brothers and sisters, white, brown and red

the only person that Obama loves is his campaign manager, and of course, himself 

sassier --- 15 years ago -


The current problem in our country is that the Republicans hate, truly hate, our President more than they love our country, and they are willing to run our country into the ground to prove it.



why didn't Pelosi and Reid get this Debt Ceiling thingy taken care of the 2 years that they had full control of the Congress and Obama ruled the White House?

they love Obama, don't they?


'now, let me be clear'
- 'eat your peas'

0 

mrrhino --- 15 years ago -

I guess the Barney Franke housing and gay prostitution thingy still becomes my problem. why is this fool still in the game period...left or right? 

mrrhino --- 15 years ago -

but Obama hates all Americans - brothers and sisters, white, brown and red

the only person that Obama loves is his campaign manager, and of course, himself



No...he likes crazy environmental nuts... 

Clovis --- 15 years ago -

why didn't Pelosi and Reid get this Debt Ceiling thingy taken care of the 2 years that they had full control of the Congress and Obama ruled the White House?

Perhaps a record number of Republican filibusters...

0


the only person that Obama loves is his campaign manager, and of course, himself

Yes, he is so alien and 'other' that he couldn't possibly love his country, his wife or his children. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

Yeah David, that $$200 bucks in taxes from the less than $18,000/ yr people. Yep that's a great target. Admirable. Way to tow the xompnay line.

There it is. The GOP plan. Soak the poor. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground