Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*New LAW: CA SCHOOLS MUST TEACH GAY HISTORY

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
Deltadawn 2
Going off air 1
rEVOLution 2
oneyedman 2
OH SNAP 2
Quixote 1
Dr Aborto 5
Work in Progress 8
Puss In Boots 2
Mabs 4
In AbsentiaW 1
Gator 11
nooneishome 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

I have NO problem whatsoever with anyone who chooses a different lifestyle or who have even been genetically created the way they are. But for our government to "mandate" and be forced into purchasing new books to promote and agenda is going too far.

Public schools in California will be required to teach students about the contributions of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans starting Jan. 1 after Gov. Jerry Brown on Thursday signed a controversial bill to add the topic to the social sciences curriculum.

Textbooks now must include information on the role of LGBT Americans, as well as Americans with disabilities, though California's budget crisis has delayed the purchasing of new books until at least 2015.

"History should be honest," Brown, a Democrat, said in a statement. "This bill revises existing laws that prohibit discrimination in education and ensures that the important contributions of Americans from all backgrounds and walks of life are included in our history books."

The governor called the legislation, SB48, introduced by Sen. Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, "historic."

The law - the first of its kind in the nation - adds the two groups to an existing list of minority and other groups that are required to be part of the social sciences curriculum.
Safer schools

Gay rights supporters heralded Brown's action as a major victory. They said the law will help make public schools a safer place for LGBT students as well as give those students, and their classmates, examples of accomplished and important LGBT people.

Throughout the debate on the measure, backers noted the recent spate of suicides among young LGBT people and said it would help to combat bullying that typically occurs beforehand.

Opponents, however, fiercely opposed the measure, citing religious objections to homosexuality and questioning whether such instruction is necessary. They expressed dismay with Brown's signing of the bill.

"If children in other countries are learning math and science, and American children are learning about the private lives of historical figures, how will our students compete for jobs in the global economy?" said Sen. Sharon Runner, R-Lancaster (Los Angeles County), the vice chairwoman of the Senate Committee on Education.
Beyond California

The provision on inclusion in textbooks could reach beyond California, too, as many book publishers tailor their texts to California's standards because of the state's large population. The bill does not prescribe how schools will teach the subject, and Leno said that decision will be made by local school officials and teachers.

"What the bill calls for is for the contributions of LGBT people to be included," Leno said, adding, "We wrote it broadly for a reason. We would be subject to more criticism than we've already been getting if we were more dictatorial."

Leno said the mandates apply broadly, though, telling reporters it would affect kindergarten through high school curriculum, "and, of course, in an age-appropriate way."

Gay rights advocates said they will be vigilant about making sure schools across California comply.

Carolyn Laub, the founder and executive director of the Gay-Straight Alliance Network, which works to establish gay-straight clubs in schools, said such clubs exist in 55 percent of California's high schools.

"We'll certainly be letting all of our constituents know about this bill, and when it goes into effect I can assure you there will be thousands of students" watching to see how it is implemented, she said.

Proponents have cited slain San Francisco Supervisor Harvey Milk as a person with historical significance, along with events such as the Stonewall Riots in New York City that helped launch the LGBT rights movement as examples of topics that could be taught.

Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson, a Democrat, praised Brown's move, saying, "Our history is more complete when we recognize the contributions of people from all backgrounds and walks of life."
Cutting into class time

Still, opponents questioned the effect the bill would have and the need for explicit instruction for all students about a relatively small group.

The bill "does absolutely nothing to reduce bullying, improve the poor state of our education system, ensure students graduate or prepare them for global competitiveness," said Paulo Sibaja, legislative director of the Capitol Resource Institute, a socially conservative organization in Sacramento. "Instead it diverts precious classroom time away from science, math, reading and writing, and focuses on the agenda of a small group of people."

Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2011/07/14/BAL61KAHVQ.DTL#ixzz1SBaqfBrB 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Oh boy. This thread should get interesting. lol 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Businesses and people are fleeing the state of California.... hmmm I wonder why7? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

. But for our government to "mandate" and be forced into purchasing new books to promote and agenda is going too far.

The States decide what is taught in public schools. Because of these "mandates", teachers are forced to teach about MLK and Cesar Chaves. About their accomplishments and civil rights struggles.

In high school, I associated being gay as being weak. "Dude, that's gay" was a common phrase. I see it being positive for a gay student and a straight student learning that a few historical figures who made a difference and made some amazing accomplishments were actually gay. The LGBT community has a rich history of civil rights struggles that is still developing. I'm for learning about it. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

WTH is "Gay" history? Is it simply taught from a gay persons perspective? Why should everyone have to be taught from a certain perspective, why not just let students choose which version of history they want to learn about? Gay, Black, White,Liberal, Hetrosexual, Jewish, Conservative, Catholic and so many more....think about, there are many different versions of history, (each with it's own spin) and each individual already perscribes to the one that suits them. Why force something like this on everyone? Sounds like another case of the tail trying to wag the dog. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

why not just let students choose which version of history they want to learn about?

So kids in NY learn about how the North won the civil war and Lincoln freed the slaves. While Alabama teaches how the Gov. forced the south to give up property rights?

I'm quoting a video game but it sums it up pretty well. "History is written by the victor". 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

The point is that all teaching of history is slanted in one way or another by some group of people. Why force any one "story" off on everyone? No one side really tells the truth anyway. 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

Gay history? It should just be taught alongside history of the other civil rights movements.

As far as historical figures go, that's pretty hard to tell for sure. In some cultures (Greek, Roman, Persian and so on), everyone was gay according to our modern viewpoints. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

"History is written by the victor"

So it seems the victor in this case feels that California children should learn more about homosexual people's accomplishments though out history. So much so that they are rewriting history.

Now, this is the states rights which I'm all for. If the people don't like it they can either move or vote these people out of office.

My point is that this is a direct reflection on people not understanding the consequences of votes. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

A history class designed around historical figure's sexual preferences. Hmm. Interesting. 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

Wish CA would finally have the "big one" andfall into the Pacific. Maybe it could be filmed as the latest (and last) reality show? 

Going off air --- 15 years ago -

I am jiggy wit it so long as they "force" them to learn it from the BIBLE (The best source for info on the subject)

I love all gay people and they usually love me too (enter the barney song) 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I love all gay people and they usually love me too

I had my suspicions. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I don't see the big deal. Every history book I've had in highschool had a topic and then it was broken down into sub topics and one of the sub topics usually was about how a minority group or a group that was discriminated against contributed to that topic. I think that homosexuals fall in that category so why not?


They talk about how gay people were persecuted in the holocaust and no one kicks up a stink about that, but when it's positive contributions to history then it's bad? Lame.

I don't get why it's a big deal or a bad thing. 

Deltadawn --- 15 years ago -

I don't see why anyone's sex life is important to whatever accomplishment got them in the history books - we don't talk about George Washington because he had a female spouse, nor do I care if he also slept with some guy named Bob, or the dog, or whatever. His sex life, and that of any other historical figure is of little consequence. They only exception would be when you are teaching about prejudice and those that made history by challenging the status quo, or groups who were persecuted because they were GLTG or whatever minority. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

They only exception would be when you are teaching about prejudice and those that made history by challenging the status quo, or groups who were persecuted because they were GLTG or whatever minority. 

That's the point. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I don't see why anyone's sex life is important to whatever accomplishment got them in the history books

That's a good point but I doubt they will go into detail about what being a homosexual entails lol

I think the point of saying whether George Washington is gay (he wasn't that I know of lol) is that even though gay people were considering disgusting and were persecuted for being gay he still was a major player in history, probably having to keep his life a secret and struggle with that during that time period.

I hope that there are major sections in future history books and that my future children will be taught the struggle that homosexuals went through to be accepted by society and get rights that everyone else has, just like they teach the awful struggle endured by African Americans. It teaches them that just because you're different doesn't mean you should be discriminated against. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Don't worry this sort of thing will NEVER happen in Texas until hell freezes over and the summers here are not as hot as hell. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Ummmmm. . .I'm still questioning why that information is pertinent to a history class. . .

Are we teaching history? Or political correctness?

I'd rather my child learn some freakin' history. They will get all the PC crap from the normal media. Glee teaches that homosexuality is more normal than heterosexuality, and with singing and dancing of attractive teenagers to boot.

They don't need more brainwashing in history class.



Good grief. 

Deltadawn --- 15 years ago -

I thought that sort of thing was already part of teaching history, like learning about Madame Curie, and how hard things were for her, not only being female, she was born in Poland, two strikes against her in France at that time. Part of the history lesson is about the challenges faced by the person you are learning about, what they over came to earn their place in history. If the personal sexual orientation did not play a role, then it should be left out, but if it did, then it should be included. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

The difference between the Civil rights struggle and homosexuality is that one cannot choose to be black. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I wonder if people complained with the same excuses when CA past a similar mandate to include African American and Hispanic history in the classes? 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

People are always complaining. Even when it rains people call it crappy weather, including the meteorologists. ???? 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I thought that sort of thing was already part of teaching history, like learning about Madame Curie, and how hard things were for her, not only being female, she was born in Poland, two strikes against her in France at that time. Part of the history lesson is about the challenges faced by the person you are learning about, what they over came to earn their place in history. If the personal sexual orientation did not play a role, then it should be left out, but if it did, then it should be included.

Exactly!


They don't need more brainwashing in history class.


I'm confused by this... brainwashed to think what?

"If children in other countries are learning math and science, and American children are learning about the private lives of historical figures, how will our students compete for jobs in the global economy?" said Sen. Sharon Runner, R-Lancaster (Los Angeles County), the vice chairwoman of the Senate Committee on Education.

This stuck out to me in the article... like just because some kids in america are going to learn that there were homosexuals that contributed to history (GASP!) that all of a sudden there won't be math and science anymore? Other countries don't teach history? lol how does adding a few facts about said historical figure make american kids less intelligent?? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I wonder if people complained with the same excuses when CA past a similar mandate to include African American and Hispanic history in the classes?

Probably! What the heck is wrong with teaching just freakin' history?

I don't care if the historical figure was black, white, hispanic, purple or blue! I don't care if he/she liked sex with men, women, animals or bicycles. . .If they were important in World Events, then it needs to be taught.

Just tell the TEENAGERS the basic outline of history. How we got here, what led to our great Republic, how other nations failed, and how to avoid that ourselves!

Keep the agendas out of it, and teach them the truth! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

This stuck out to me in the article... like just because some kids in america are going to learn that there were homosexuals that contributed to history (GASP!) that all of a sudden there won't be math and science anymore? Other countries don't teach history? lol how does adding a few facts about said historical figure make american kids less intelligent??

There is only so much time allocated to a history class. It's kind of a high school joke that in a world history class, they never make it past WWII before the year runs out.

So everything that gets added in, whether it is important or not (and come on, this is NOT important), takes away from other time that could be spent on, you know, HISTORY. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

There is only so much time allocated to a history class. It's kind of a high school joke that in a world history class, they never make it past WWII before the year runs out.


That seems like the teacher, school, and districts fault, and should be addressed whether or not homosexual history is a factor.. Just because the teacher or district can't figure out how to fit world history into a school year doesn't mean that portions that some don't deem "important" should be ignored. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

My best history courses were, of course, in college. Everything else was an exercise in skim city. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Just because the teacher or district can't figure out how to fit world history into a school year doesn't mean that portions that some don't deem "important" should be ignored.

LOL!!@!!!!!! Of course it does!!!!!

That's the whole point! Figuring what is important enough to force into the "skim city" of High School History! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I mean, unless that's what Paul Revere REALLY meant when he screamed, "The British are Coming!", then who the heck cares who he had sex with? 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Idk what high schools y'all went to but the only time stuff was left out was when we had a fire drill or pep rally.


We talked about what's in the book, if homosexual history was in there we would have talked about it, well since it's kingwood there probably would have been a "surprise" fire drill on that day. It may not be important to you but to some it is important.

The point is that isn't the reason 95% of people are against it. It doesn't take a genius to figure out the real reason. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

like just because some kids in america are going to learn that there were homosexuals that contributed to history (GASP!) that all of a sudden there won't be math and science anymore?

Kind of like how allowing gay marriage will lead to having to let people marry animals and inanimate objects? 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Cruella De Vil --- 3 min ago - quote - hide comments
I mean, unless that's what Paul Revere REALLY meant when he screamed, "The British are Coming!", then who the heck cares who he had sex with? 





Pahahahahaha. Now that's funny. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Well, I can definitely admit to being one of those parents who does not want the school addressing homosexuality or any type of sex with my child. I want to be the one who has that talk with my boys and I want MY values imparted, not some teacher's who I don't know.

I also don't want teachers teaching religion, other than perhaps the basic tenants of the faiths as it pertains to history. I don't mind them reading from different religious texts in scholarly way, but I do NOT want a teacher teaching faith to my kids. That's MY job. I don't know WHAT that teacher believes, and I don't want his/her views on faith or sex to be given to my child. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

How is saying "George Washington overcame adversity as a homosexual" pushing homosexuality on anyone?

By highschool I hope that you would have addressed homosexuality with your kids.

To me sheltering children from homosexuality and ONLY letting them hear your point of view on it is brainwashing, not having it mentioned in history books. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Gator, serious question....how many kids and what ages do you have? 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I fully intend on brainwashing my kids. Most people call that by a different name. . .PARENTING!!!!!!

You are SUPPOSED to impart your values to your kids.

I do not want the STATE to teach them values that are different from mine. That is NOT their job. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Im 19 years old. I don't have any kids as of right now lol.

And before anyone says then I don't know what I'm talking about:

First it's my opinion and my opinion ONLY.
Second that is how I was raised, given a choice and my mom didn't try to stop me from being exposed to things (besides like drugs and violence obviously) 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Cruella De Vil --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments
I fully intend on brainwashing my kids. Most people call that by a different name. . .PARENTING!!!!!!



So if your son came to you and said he was gay then what? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Im 19 years old. I don't have any kids as of right now lol.

And before anyone says then I don't know what I'm talking about:



No, you won't be hearing that from me. Just note for the future, that when and if you do have kids, your opinions about a lot of things will change. It is not an "if" but a "when."

Only thing I wish to add to this discussion is, that we can't forget the basics of what a good, solid education should be. And that does not include an asterisk (*) next to each historical figure with a listing of what type of sex they engage in.

George Washington (*Heterosexual with proclivities towards sex with slaves)
Paul Revere (*Mostly heterosexual, but after some liquor, can be bi-sexual)
Martha Stewart (*Asexual)
Liberace (*Flamer)

OK, those are just examples. But why waste the time? And how is that relevant to the actual OCCURENCES of history? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground