Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What would you do???

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
whatchamacallit 2
love4bdd 1
smartypants 1
Lilteapot 2
planemom 2
My 3 and Me 1
MonzaRacer 1
*Annie* 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
Mygirl01 1
ladybeachbum 1
Syrah1214 9
Rubicon 1
lean 5
ghostpost 3
chunksNbones 1
ExLady In Blue 1
kingwood resident 1
justcat 2
Meme2my5 1
zapper007 1
voice of reason 1
crazymama87 1
Stella111 2
Gigix4 3
amyb 1
susie q 1
Quixote 1
Dr Aborto 1
Q The Rain in 5 4 3 2 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 1
Ares 3
Dorothy Parker 3
thankfulformyfour 1
Just4KU 1
horseymomma 4
Naugh T Dream 1
needsleep 1
1PorterTx 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

My kids were taking piano lessons from a lady in our neighborhood who had 15+- other students who also came to her home for lessons.

While my 6 year old was doing his lesson, he struck a key and it broke. (Piano is a digital piano). It felt like it was loose and not connecting and no sound would come out.

Anyway, fast forward 6-7 months later (now) and we are no longer taking lessons from her (because I'm 8 months pregnant and it's just too much to load up all my other kids and go to her house; she has lots of breakables, etc.) ...

She calls me out of the blue and says she had it fixed and wants me to pay her $450.00, the cost of the repair.

I had called a repairman (she says the same one she used) when it happened to find out how much it would cost because I planned on helping her pay to fix it since my child was the one at the seat when it broke, but he said those keys had a known issue and they would be fixed at no charge under warranty if she could provide a receipt. Turns out she couldn't find it so there was no "freebie".

He also said if she couldn't find the receipt, it would be around $100 at the most just to repair that one key. NOT $450.00...

He also said in his opinion, it would not be my responsibility to pay anything toward it because as someone who is giving lessons out of her home, that's a risk she takes.

During the last 6-7 months, she has continued to give lessons to her other 15 +- students 2x per week, which could have furthered the damage caused.

SO... do you think I should have to pay the full $450? or put something toward it or tell her it's been too long and the time has passed for me to put anything toward it??? 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

you owe her nothing. i'm sure everyone will agree here. once all have posted, print it out and give it to her. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

SO... do you think I should have to pay the full $450?
Heck NO! I don't think you have any responsibility - what-so-ever! It is her responsibility to have working equipment and to keep it in working condition. That's part of why you "pay" for the lessons. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it's your kids fault. If my neighbors kids sits on my chair and breaks it, I'm not charging him for it. Many people have sat on it and it was just wear and tear. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

That's a tough one. $450 sounds a bit out of line and to wait 6-7 months is odd. Yes, as the teacher she takes the responsibility of expected wear and tear. What did your son hit the key with to cause it to break? Unless he was using his fist or another object, I wouldn't think it was your responsibility to repair it. Guess I'd offer the $100 the repairman quoted and be done and I'd find a different piano teacher. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Absolutely not. You do not owe her anything. The reasonable person standard applies here. It is her cost of doing business. No different than if a Lowe's delivery truck broke down while delivering your lawn mower. Would you owe them for the repair cost because it was delivery your lawn mower? No. A reasonable person teaching piano lessons on their own equipment should be expected to maintain and repair that equipment themselves. 

Lilteapot --- 15 years ago -

I agree with what your repairman said.
She assumes the risk if she is giving lessons, UNLESS of course your child pounded or jumped on the keyboard and recklessly broke it.
She also waited 7 months? Ummm no.
Obviously it wasnt that important to her then.
You can buy a decent electric piano for that price. My ex has a Korg, cost $2000 new, if he were to sell it now, he would get approx $500. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

If your hubby really is a Dr., they are probably just going after you because of perceived wealth. 

love4bdd --- 15 years ago -

NO WAY! You do not owe her a dime! I can't believe she had the nerve to call you and even ask that! 

Just4KU --- 15 years ago -

No. She should have had insurance since she's running a business and the piano is a business tool. Not a dime. 

crazymama87 --- 15 years ago -

Ask her if your piano breaks while your child is practicing what she told them to is SHE responsible for YOUR repairs?

I say you can offer to pay the cost of one lesson no more. (if you feel your child may have been somehow responsible for playing rough) But if not I would pay nothing. 

Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

The only way I would think you would be responsible is if your son intentionally broke the piano. 

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

He definitely didn't slam anything on the keys/no fist, object, etc. He was doing his lesson and struck the key with his finger like he had been striking the other keys just the same pressure. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Not your problem then. 

Lilteapot --- 15 years ago -

Why should you have to pay, if he did nothing wrong, or reckless? And 7 months later to boot?
Heck no, and that does sound like an outrageous amount as well.

No. She should have had insurance since she's running a business and the piano is a business tool.

Agree! 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

Normal piano playing will not break a key,digital or not.If he were doing something such as horse playing,she is the teacher,and would have stopped it before any damage to the piano occurred .I call bull honkey. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

7 months has nothing to do with it. I think the statute of limitations in this case would probably be 2 years.

Regardless, it is a reasonably expected business expense and not your problem. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Money grab, pure and simple... for all the reasons others here have stated.

I wouldn't just say NO, I would say "F U". 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I'd get in writing what the repairman quoted you, so, if she tries anything, you have something in hand.

Also, like everyone else has said, when she started giving lessons, she assumed the wear and tear on her keyboard and everything that goes with it. 

Syrah1214 --- 15 years ago -

I just talked to her and she says she had *all* keys replaced on the piano, not just the one that broke while my son was taking lessons... and that the repairman said if she would have produced a receipt sometime last year, it would have been paid under warranty... but this year it's no longer a valid offer for warranty to cover it.

She still wants me to pay the full amount. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

If your child was doing what she told him to do during his lesson, then you owe her nothing. Now, if he had been wrecklessly banging on the keys in a way that broke the key I could understand you helping out but even then I don't believe you would need to pay for the whole thing. At this point, I say, you owe her nothing! 

lean --- 15 years ago -

Wow....need to know that teacher's name so I can make sure to avoid her at all costs...LOL
Seriously though...that is the cost of doing business and as far as I am concerned you don't owe her anything. 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

Yea..She had all the keys replaced because it was worn out..and she figured you would fork it over..Don't give it another thought. 

Keystone --- 15 years ago -

You owe her nothing. It's the cost of doing business. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

Wow! And why should you pay for a complete overhaul of her equipment? She was irresponsible by not keeping her receipt so that she could get the warranty deal. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

She still wants me to pay the full amount.


tell her to ask every parent whose child she gave lessons to, to shell out some cash as well...

Then I would politely tell her it's not my fault she misplaced her receipt for warranty coverage and to have a nice day. :) 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

tell her to ask every parent whose child she gave lessons to, to shell out some cash as well...

She might be doing that as well.... and not telling anyone.

Full key replacement? Wow. Seriously, tell her to "F OFF". 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

That is the cost of doing business...she is in the WRONG. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Also, could you PM me back with her name? If I (and my lawyer) manage to get my job back (lost due to company violating a law...), I will be getting my kid piano lessons.

And I really don't want him going to someone who thinks it's ok the have their students foot the bill for their equipment maintenance. 

amyb --- 15 years ago -

I would not pay her. That is ridiculous. That is a price she has to pay to teach lessons out of her home. That is part of her overhead...to repair what breaks. I would just tell her that you are sorry it broke, but that you are not liable. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

I would just tell her that you are sorry it broke, but that you are not liable.
Exactly! 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I just talked to her and she says she had *all* keys replaced on the piano, not just the one that broke while my son was taking lessons... and that the repairman said if she would have produced a receipt sometime last year, it would have been paid under warranty... but this year it's no longer a valid offer for warranty to cover it.

She still wants me to pay the full amount.


Absolutely not...and I am a real sucker for most things. First of all, if she is doing business in her home she has the liability of the extra wear and tear on her equipment. Repairing and replacing is the price of doing business...any business. As many kids as she teaches the equipment is going to take a lot more abuse over time. She can certainly use some of her profits to put into maintaining her piano.

Not to mention..she must think you are a real sucker if she is trying to get you to pay for the all the keys to be replaced. You don't owe her for even one key..that is the price of doing business.

Tell her you have thought it over and just like your husband has to replace the furniture in his office from time to time, this is a case of normal wear and tear and she needs to absorb the cost as part of her business expenses. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Change my answer. You are not responsible for replacing all the keys. She did not act in good faith when she waited 6+ plus to fix the broken key. Now, trying to stick you with the entire bill for replacing all the keys is ridiculous. It's her own fault for losing the receipt and/or waiting until the warranty expired. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Only if he was using a hammer when he hit it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Oh and go wash your face. Apparently you have F me written on your forehead. lol 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Or you could tell her, there's 88 keys on a piano. My son broke one and you paid $450 for every key being replaced...so, divide $450 by 88 and that's what I'll pay you.

:) 

Rubicon --- 15 years ago -

Or you could tell her, there's 88 keys on a piano. My son broke one and you paid $450 for every key being replaced...so, divide $450 by 88 and that's what I'll pay you.

:)


HA HA HA HA!!!

Toss $5 at her and tell her to leave you alone! 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

No way. You use your equipment to teach a lesson as your biz, that is the chance you take. 

My 3 and Me --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like she is off her rocker!!!! 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

It's cost of doing business for her. She's likely trying to soak 4 or 5 other "former" students. Tell her to enjoy the business loss when tax time rolls around. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground