Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: If you accidentally shot someone, would you feel responsible for paying their medical bills?

who's talking here?

randyjet 5
traveller 1
Mr Mark 1
Donkey Hodie 1
Perfection 1
Hiro Protagonist 3
voice of reason 3
Laura 6
JohnLynch 2
evolved 1
TexasOma 2
OPFOR 2
Train1972 5
MxMike. 1
allday 5
SighFiGurl 1
Tipsyhic 3
Biggie Smalls 1
needrnr 5
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 1
Red Dawn 8
Dorothy Parker 4
thankfulformyfour 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: If you accidentally shot someone, would you feel responsible for paying their medical bills?

Since this situation is such a hot topic for KUers, let's just ask the basic question: Should this man be responsible for her medical bills? Should anyone that accidentally shoots another be responsible financially?

Yes, if I shot someone by accident, I would be responsible for their medical bills. Vote
 
 78.3% (36)
No, it was an accident...I don't feel responsible, shite happens....that's life. Vote
 
 21.7% (10)
Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Since this situation is such a hot topic for KUers, let's just ask the basic question:

Should this man be responsible for her medical bills? Should anyone that accidentally shoots another be responsible financially? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I don't think anyone is arguing that. The real issue is should he be criminally charged and lose his gun license. But go ahead with your poll.

Of course he should pay her medical bills. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Dang right. I understand it was an accident,the man is not a common criminal. But I think anyone with a moral conscience would want to pay her bills at the very least. This was a life changing event for her and he was responsible even if it was not intentional and that is the bottom line. 

traveller --- 15 years ago -

He should at least have his chl suspended for a time. Medical bills is a no brainer. He was definitely negligent in my opinion, but a court will decide that. 

OPFOR --- 15 years ago -

Absolutely the stupidest thing I've ever seen.

A better poll would have been for everyone to guess wether or not we believe you have the ability to take your brain out and play with it.
Of course that's assuming you had one to begin with. Geez 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

What if his attorney told him to do absolutely nothing until he was told to?

You do not know what this man has discussed with his attorney .. you do not know the facts in the case .. you do not know the legal ramifications of jumping in paying for some ones medical bills BEFORE any charges are filed.

You, and most everyone who is aligned with with your mindset are out for gossiping blood. You sit there in judgment of something that hit the news 2 weeks ago and each one of you profess to be so perfect in your responsibilities and attentiveness to details, that you never make an error in judgment, you never overlook anything, never forget anything.

Oh to be so perfect.....to know everything.

And you are so blind that you cannot see the comparisons in similar negligent acts ..... all you want to do is convict this man and get your ounce of blood revenge......someone said lynch mob.

God forbid this had been someone in your circle of family or friends. I'm sure you would be singing a different tune. But then again not .... only if they were in line with designer clothes. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Absolutely! It's my gun and I'm responsible for it at ALL times!

However I also feel that Raffa's needs to take responsibility for even allowing firearms in their establishment since they serve alcohol, regardless of whether it's an actual law or not. JMO 

Train1972 --- 15 years ago -

I agree TexasOma. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Um, TexasOma, I don't believe anyone here professed to be perfect. All they said was if they ever accidentally shot someone they would feel obligated to pay for their treatment.

Not understanding where your reference to designer clothes is going either? Unless you are doing the exact thing you are accusing others of doing? 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

That was pretty harsh Jeff; don't you think? If you think that, why not just keep it to yourself and move on to something that interests you?

I don't understand why some people feel the need to say such ugly and unkind words to others? Does it feel good to be so callus? 

OPFOR --- 15 years ago -

Not any more harsh than half the stuff mom says on here. Making wild assumptions, blowing things way out of purportion, actually lying and just generally not having a clue. She has done it all.
To actually create a poll for a question that nobody disputes? For what reason? Boils down to more drama than teenage girls. Nothing more. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Red Dawn

How can you say what we say is callus, yet the position of hatred towards this man is worst than callus .... it's mean, spiteful gossiping.

Until this man is CHARGED with something he needs to sit quiet and do what his attorney says.

This poll and the 4 page thread this poll is bounced off of is extremely mean spirited on behalf of a few. Dare anyone post an opinion differing from theirs, we are called out on the carpet for daring to have faith in the justice system, for showing concern for the elderly man, for actually thinking something different than the others.

As for the designer comment .... I guess I was being ugly and snarky. 

Train1972 --- 15 years ago -

Mom of 5, what are you trying to prove. Both of these families are dealing with a tragedy.

Talk about being judgemental!!! I think you win the prize. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

I haven't seen the thread that you are talking about TexasOma but I will go read it now that you stated where your opinion is stemming from.

If that's true about people hating this man, that isn't right either, it was an accident plain and simple. It does appear this man has remorse for what happened and I'm sure his own feelings about what happened will be more harsh on him than anyone elses.

I'm sorry Jeff, I've never witnessed MomOf5 being nasty or judgemental to anyone on here. If that is how you truly feel, do two wrongs make it right?

Don't mean to sound motherly but I've even gotten on to my friends about being ugly to others as I feel it happens too much and part of the attitude problem being bred into our youth. Again, JMO. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I'm sorry Jeff, I've never witnessed MomOf5 being nasty or judgemental to anyone on here.

lol, you must not get on here very often 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Hahaha Touche', I'm not an avid poster. ;P 

Train1972 --- 15 years ago -

I think this poll is disgusting! I feel sorry for both families. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Is this the thread you are talking about TexasOma? "Kingwood Restaurant Shooting"

Have to agree with the harshness of some and didn't finish reading it all due to the negativity.

It's hard when people are quick to judge but mud-slinging doesn't solve anything sweetie.

I know it's easier to be quick to attack for the defense of others; we ALL do it at times. Just try to remember to not do the exact same thing that is upsetting you when rebuttling or else your point becomes moot. Make sense? 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

I agree Train, I feel sorry for both families in this situation. Very sad. 

Biggie Smalls --- 15 years ago -

There's not a single person that can beat John Lynch in the nastiness and/or judgemental department towards other people. 

Red Dawn --- 15 years ago -

Now now Biggie, it shows more character to reserve comments about those we don't take kindly to, than to berate them in public. Do you like it when someone does that to you? 

needrnr --- 15 years ago -

So agree steve. Most people do not have that kind of money in direct disposal, to pay the medical costs. You can not admit to fault, because if you have liability insurance and know you will be sued you risk your insurance to cover you. Mof5 the better question is to put your self (as far off as it is )in the mans shoes. Do you have immediately a min of 100k in liquid assets? I am sure the victims hospital bills are more than that. Pain and suffering is something like 10 x's the amount. I do not doubt you and most people would feel obligated to pay, BUT most do not have access to that immediate amount. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Mof5 the better question is to put your self (as far off as it is )in the mans shoes. Do you have immediately a min of 100k in liquid assets? I am sure the victims hospital bills are more than that. Pain and suffering is something like 10 x's the amount. I do not doubt you and most people would feel obligated to pay, BUT most do not have access to that immediate amount.


well, since I've never carried a gun in my pocket and "forgotten" about it, I will never be in this situation...

but, from a hypothetical standpoint, if I cause bodily harm to someone by accident, I can't see myself staying distant from that person and lawyering up. That's just not the way I operate. If I was in this man's shoes, I would have gone to the hospital as soon as I was able to do so, to see how she was doing myself, without relying on the police to tell me.

According to the news articles written about this story, the family has had NO CONTACT from this man whatsoever...that's unacceptable behavior given the circumstances, imo, and it's why the family is wanting to sue him...acting like he's had no hand in this situation is wrong, period.

As far as TexasOma's comments and Train's comments...I seriously LMAO when I read them. Two old women hating their lot in life, hating anyone who has more than them and resenting the world. I hope when I'm their age, I'm not that bitter and angry. I have 30 years to get there...Thank God.

Jeff, I have no idea who you are, never really seen you post before, so, I'll just assume you're a troll and we'll leave it at that... 

Mr Mark --- 15 years ago -

What if his attorney told him

I do not agree w/this.

The restaurant has a policy. A sign stating the policy. One person took it upon themselves to ignore the policy and jeopardized everyone safety by bringing in & recklessly miss handled an un-secured weapon. That persons actions were nothing short of reckless endangerment. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

You folks scream POS when a car accident which involves negligence occurs and hurts someone and I agree with ya'll.

This is the same thing. But the majic word "gun" gets everybody that "thinks" they're rough in a tizzy.

Idiots. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I will go even further and say that if I did something like that, I should be criminally prosecuted. 

Tipsyhic --- 15 years ago -

I for one would never do this. Only an irresponsible idiot could accidentally shoot someone. 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

POLL: If you accidentally shot someone, would you feel responsible for paying their medical bills?

Yes, just like with a car accident. A CHL carrier can and should purchase a supplemental insurance coverage to safeguard themselves, should something as tragic like this take place. 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

Some states have tried to pass legislation that requires gun owners to carry insurance....... 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

Like Illinois in 2009....

google it, interesting... 

Tipsyhic --- 15 years ago -

Oh I see where this is going. You what it mandatory for all licensed concealed hand gun owners to get insurance. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

thanks, Laura...good info! 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

A better poll would have been for everyone to guess wether or not we believe you have the ability to take your brain out and play with it.
Of course that's assuming you had one to begin with. Geez



I usually reserve calling people idiots when they name call and are rude without provocation. I guess that makes you mxmike idiots. 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/BillStatus.asp?DocTypeID=HB&DocNum=687&GAID=10&SessionID=76&LegID=41158

Oh I see where this is going. You what it mandatory for all licensed concealed hand gun owners to get insurance.


No, not at all....just discussing the options. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

I think I know a great way to murder someone now. All I have to do is a get a chl, and have an "accident." Just a tragic mistake, I didn't mean it. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

I think I know a great way to murder someone now. All I have to do is a get a chl, and have an "accident." Just a tragic mistake, I didn't mean it.

Tea Party, here i come.

Imagine if a "party" of a few million black guys were busting into health care town halls with weapons what these same advocates would say.

Idiots. 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

http://www.txgunpermit.com/blog/?p=62

Here's something that some of you might want to read.

think I know a great way to murder someone now. All I have to do is a get a chl, and have an "accident." Just a tragic mistake, I didn't mean it.


MW: That is by no means funny dude.... 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

MW: That is by no means funny dude....


Not really funny, but a pretty good criminal defense. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

POLL: If you accidentally shot someone, would you feel responsible for paying their medical bills?

Should this man be responsible for her medical bills?


Well, first of all these are two entirely different quetions Mom. To the first, I would answer YES, I would FEEL responsibble. If my negligence cause an accident that injured another human being, I would FEEL responsible and I would in fact, BE responsible.

And as to the second question. YES, he should BE responsible for the bills and most likely whether or not he feels he is responsible for her medical bills, civil liability will most likely determine this.

As to those making personal comments on here....let's not make it about the poster, let's make it a discussion about the issue. 

Laura --- 15 years ago -

Several places offer a pre-paid legal counsel for CHL holders. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground