Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Pit Bull ban isn't working!

who's talking here?

steinhoister 2
hummer 1
genxer 1
HARP 1
NICKLE PICKLE 4
MxMike. 4
allday 5
QueenofKingwood 1
karma 15
wino babrbie 1
needrnr 1
Work in Progress 4
Ares 2
Dorothy Parker 4
itstxdaddy 3
mamatoulouse 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

karma --- 15 years ago -

No surprise there. Now can we go put the lobbyists and law makers on trial for pointless murder of thousands of innocent dogs?

link

"Ontario, Canada - Breed specific legislation put in place by the provincial government back in 2005 isn't working to reduce dog bites. Surely this comes as a complete surprise to dog owners - especially Pit bull owners.

After all, everyone knows that Pit bulls are vicious man-eaters. Right? Wrong. Officials are just now discovering what savvy dog owners have known all along - it's not the breed, it is the owners.

Earlier this month, a survey of various municipalities revealed the news - reported dog bites did not significantly drop, despite the breed ban. Sadly, countless Pit bulls and Pit bull mixes were killed as a result of the flawed legislation.

Now, the Toronto Humane Society is asking that legislation banning Pit Bulls be amended. THS is hoping that irresponsible owners will be targeted and held liable for bite incidents rather than blanket legislation against one breed of dog.

Any dog can bite - the focus needs to be on owner responsibility...not only in Canada - everywhere. Just this month, a report in Queensland Australia was released of the top dogs responsible for dog bites - among those in the top? Chihuahuas and Pomeranians.....

Dog owners need to alter their pets, property socialize them, provide training, and keep them secure. Free-roaming, unaltered, un-socialized dogs of any breed are apt to cause problems...too often resulting in an unprovoked attack.

Irresponsible owners cause harm to their own dogs, other dogs, and people. Irresponsible owners have led to breed specific legislation, which has resulted in countless, unwarranted dog deaths.

Stay tuned to see if the harsh legislation currently in place in Ontario will be amended now that the truth is in black and white." 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Irresponsible owners cause harm to their own dogs, other dogs, and people. Irresponsible owners have led to breed specific legislation, which has resulted in countless, unwarranted dog deaths.

I disagree...some dogs in that breed are just born bad...period. I've experienced it first hand. 

karma --- 15 years ago -

Can you cite any credible sources that report some dogs are born bad? I've personally never heard of a dog coming out of the womb already wanting to kill anything and everything. I do know a lot of dogs who have been molded to be aggressive and crazy due to irresponsible owners not socializing and raising the dog properly from a young age. Some are aggressive because of medical conditions also.

Do you think we should punish all American pit bull terriers because of a few bad apples? By that logic we should go ahead and exterminate all labradors, boxers, westies, chihuahuas, and poodle mixes. Ive had dogs of those breeds try to rip my face off before. I actually got full on attacked by a boxer last week. 

karma --- 15 years ago -

Also a lot of people think dog aggression = human aggression. A lot of people don't realize that all bully breeds are going to be dog aggressive or selective to some degree, it is a part of their genetic makeup and not a fault. 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

karma - why didn't the study/survey answer the question that is actually worth asking?

were maiming and deaths from dog bites reduced?

the survey simply indicates that the number of dog bites did not significantly drop. notice it also said significantly... 

karma --- 15 years ago -

I can't answer that question but you can probably email the reporter, she states she is open to communication. 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

I can't answer that question but you can probably email the reporter, she states she is open to communication.

don't you think that is the more relevent stat than the number of bites? 

karma --- 15 years ago -

If I hated dogs, sure. If you want to go by that, Pretty much any medium/large/giant sized dog can overpower and seriously injure a human. That includes your bigger mutts, labs, goldens, border collies, huskies, etc and on up to the bigguns. Should they all be banned and Americans forced to only own 12 lb dogs who do nothing but shake and squeak? 

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

If I hated dogs, sure

I don't hate dogs. Nice try though. See here is one of the problems with your approach...the most relevent stat would be if maiming and death by dog bites was not significantly reduced, yet you cannot admit that. you would rather just make snide comments and not actaully address the statistics. The idea behind the ban was not to reduce dog bites but to reduce the number of people who died because of them.

That includes your bigger mutts, labs, goldens, border collies, huskies, etc and on up to the bigguns

ok, i'll buy into this. please show the actual data of the breeds you list and how many people they have killed. if it within 5% or so of the pits, then you are correct. if not, then the pits are statistically more probable to kill someone, which is the reason i would guess the ban was enacted.

Should they all be banned and Americans

this is a Canadian study and law, not American. Again, nice tyr though.

it's hard to have a debate with someone as close minded as you are. you appear to believe that no matter how much statistical evidence is presented, the breed of the dog does not matter at all. 

karma --- 15 years ago -

I'm on my phone so I'll respond to you when I get home later. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

I think BSL is a bunch of BS. Even if you ban a certain breed, the drug dealers & thugs are STILL going to own them.

We have gun laws, but the criminal still manage to get guns.

You have to punish the irresponsible owners who have these dogs, not the dogs. Do you punish a 5 yr. old child who plays with matches and burns his parents home down or do you hold the parents accountable. It's not like these dogs are born to bite & maim or kill people, most of these dogs are not properly socialized and in most cases, encouraged to be aggressive.

I have never been fearful of a pit or pit mix ever. It's not fair to ban an entire breed.

I understand if a pitbull or any dog attacked me, I would be fearful, but to ban the whole breed because of isolated incidences is absurd. They don't cull an entire population of grizzly bears if one attacks and kills hikers, they try and go after the one that did it.

This is all non-sense!! BSL does not work. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

I come from a place where dog fighting was (is) rampant. You don't necessarily teach pits to fight. You just unleash them.

I've seen the ones that are completely socailized and treated like Karma would treat them turn and kill the poodle they had lived with for 4 years. That kind of unpredictability is DNA related. It's not all of them but a high enough percentage that I believe they should come with a warning label and be regulated. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

but to ban the whole breed because of isolated incidences is absurd.


Isolated incidences?? I know of many children PERSONALLY who have been attacked by pits and pit mixes. The family pet attacked the kids...and you know the first thing the parents say? I never saw any aggressive behavior before this! I can't believe it!

So, please, love the breed all you want, but don't insult everyone by denying the fact this IS a PROVEN dangerous breed. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I've seen the ones that are completely socailized and treated like Karma would treat them turn and kill the poodle they had lived with for 4 years. That kind of unpredictability is DNA related. It's not all of them but a high enough percentage that I believe they should come with a warning label and be regulated.


AMEN! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Nickle, I understand what you are saying, but I just can't equate guns and dogs. Guns don't dig out of the yard by themselves and attack children. 

allday --- 15 years ago -

but I just can't equate guns and dogs. Guns don't dig out of the yard by themselves and attack children.

No way. The idiot with a gun just shows up as a felon, buys the gun and drives straight to his victim. No need for digging out. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

So allday, you want to outlaw guns now? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

So allday, you want to outlaw guns now?

Some people definitely should not carry. Those typically have the fear factor and do. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Some people definitely should not carry. Those typically have the fear factor and do.

You talk a lot about a lot about those with a "fear factor." It's almost as if you fear them. Would you agree that you have a fear factor? 

allday --- 15 years ago -

Would you agree that you have a fear factor?

Yes. Wacko Christian conservatives keep me awake at night. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Yes. Wacko Christian conservatives keep me awake at night.

How did I KNOW that you would write that??? So typical. And how many "wacko Christian conservatives" have called for your death? Now how many Muslims?

And you call me dumb. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Yes. Wacko Christian conservatives keep me awake at night.


well, I have to say, since the gun dropping incident at Raffas, I seriously question the general public's ability to safely carry firearms!!

That situation completely freaks me out! What if that had been a child?? :( 

allday --- 15 years ago -

And you call me dumb.

I'm sorry. I do. 

HARP --- 15 years ago -

LOL. Lets not loose track of the thread. I think Karma's reason for the post was to help enlighten people that may or may not have an opportunity to vote on legislation in Texas regarding BSL. I think she was hoping to make people informed.

While, as a rescuer, I can't answer for the dogs that have mauled, and the victims of these attacks. My personal problem with BSL is that the "pitbull" I have in my rescue is responsibly taken care of. And if at any time legislation was created enabling an "animal control" officer to knock on my door, take her from me, and euthanize her...for no reason other than her looks...I'd have a huge problem with that.

Lola is not left in the back yard to dig her way out and kill the neighborhood children. She is not ever unattended with kids, or cats. She is kept and cared for properly, and I, as a wonderful dog owner, should not be punished for other dog owners mistakes and neglect.

Lots of threads are created on this website damning the government for trying to meddle. Or laws that enable the government to determine what we can or cannot do, or own, or participate in. People argue those threads all day long. And this is the same principle.

While it might not be right for an owner to want to keep their dog, who has killed 10 neighborhood cats and put children in the hospital...there is absolutely no reason why I should not be able to keep mine, as long as I continue to be responsible and caring.

The problem with these laws is they do absolutely nothing to cure the problem. It just ends up criminalizing good people who are not hurting anyone or anything to begin with. 

wino babrbie --- 15 years ago -

Actually this breed was bred to be a working dog back in the 1800's for ranchers help herd cattle and keep coyotes and others from eating their livestock man is who made them mean and trained them to attack. most any dog is territorial and will defend their owner or turf these dogs that is in their DNA this breed wants be make their owner happy plain and simple 

karma --- 15 years ago -

I don't hate dogs. Nice try though. See here is one of the problems with your approach...the most relevent stat would be if maiming and death by dog bites was not significantly reduced, yet you cannot admit that. you would rather just make snide comments and not actaully address the statistics. The idea behind the ban was not to reduce dog bites but to reduce the number of people who died because of them.

I never assumed or stated that you did hate dogs. I was saying that if I was someone who hated dogs and was out to target them, I would want to showcase them in the worst light, anything to get them out of society.



the pits are statistically more probable to kill someone, which is the reason i would guess the ban was enacted.

You want statistics, specifically canadian ones? Well here you go.

http://nationalcanineresearchcouncil.com/dog-bites/dog-bites-worldwide/

You might also want to take a look at the complete list of fatal dog attacks in Canada here:

http://nationalcanineresearchcouncil.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/FDA-Canada-Copy-for-website.pdf

Since 1964 only one pit bull resulted in a fatal attack, AND it was provoked to act that way by a drunken idiot.




BSL is WRONG, WRONG, WRONG. It is unfair and unjust. Here is just ONE example why:

http://hubpages.com/hub/Ginger-The-Pit-Bull-Back-On-Death-Row


"For the record, there is no such breed as a "pitbull" or "Staffordshire Terrier". Yes, there have been, in a conservative estimate, over 5000 mutts destroyed based on how they look, not behaviour here in Ontario since August 29th, 2005. The dogs that have been killed have been of unknown lineage. There have been no purebreds of the named three breeds seized or killed. There simply aren't enough of them.

There are only less than 30 American Stafforshire Terriers in Ontario. There were 30 but one recently moved away, I kid you not! He is enjoying life in a province that does not practice breed discrimination.

The records are kept by the CKC for numbers in the province, and with so few in the province, we all know each other, or at least of each other. When you see Humane Societies and such labeling dogs as American Staffordshire Terrier crosses, there simply, mathematically aren't enough of them in the province to be crossing around.

Labrador Retrievers are the most popular breed (by CKC reg. numbers), Boxers are number 8 on the list.. sort of makes sense the most popular short haired mutts are likely breed mixtures of popular breeds?

So much easier just to kill dogs for how they look, to appear something is being done about public safety... Call them some slang term to justify killing good dogs not dealing with bad owners of any breed of dog.

Oh yes, and lest we forget the man who spear-headed or orchestrated the Ontario breed ban (Michael J. Bryant) has killed more people than dogs (of any breed or non breed) in the past 2 years!" 

karma --- 15 years ago -


This is all non-sense!! BSL does not work.



Prime and I agree :)

http://i1093.photobucket.com/albums/i432/GSDoberman86/bsl.jpg 

MxMike. --- 15 years ago -

It's horse sh**!!!!!!!

A pit bull is no more likely to attack someone than any other breed.

Actually the smaller ones are much more inclined to attack.

Only dog attack I've ever experienced was at the paws of a schnauzer...that little POS tore my ankles into pieces...whereas all the pits I run across are happy lap pups.

Get over it, there is nothing wrong with pit bulls. 

MxMike. --- 15 years ago -

I will never have another kind of pup!

0 

karma --- 15 years ago -

Isolated incidences?? I know of many children PERSONALLY who have been attacked by pits and pit mixes. The family pet attacked the kids...and you know the first thing the parents say? I never saw any aggressive behavior before this! I can't believe it!

So, please, love the breed all you want, but don't insult everyone by denying the fact this IS a PROVEN dangerous breed.



I can see you are emotionally passionate in your opinion so I will refrain from starting any kind of logical debate with you. The idiots who say "i have never seen aggressive behavior from my baby before" have already made the big mistake in responsible pet ownership early on. if you treat your dogs like a child, they're going to treat you like a dog. I always want to know the who, what, when, where, and why involving a dog bite/attack. 99.9% of the time is is because of HUMAN error. I can list off hundreds of examples of purely positive pit bull stories too!

Hey guess what? Here is PROOF Golden Retrievers are dangerous too:

http://www.citytv.com/toronto/citynews/news/local/article/12275--3-year-old-child-mauled-by-dog

(dog lovers, notice how slanted the media is when reporting this attack, the headline just says "dog", if it was anything that looked like a pit bull it would probably read "3 year old fatally mauled by vicious pit bull!") 

karma --- 15 years ago -

Mike, check out the canada links I posted, it will make you smile :) 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

0undefined

Mylee says BOO-HOO to BSL! 

MxMike. --- 15 years ago -

Aww she's sweet lookin!

Screwwwww the pit haters! 

mamatoulouse --- 15 years ago -

i love pits and all other bully breeds i love and trust my own dogs ... now that that is said i this bsl is is some bull sh!t..
but i do agree that their are some dogs not just bullies that are "born bad"... i think any dog with human aggression should be euthanized, i have met far more "born bad" chihuahuas than bullies... i am just saying all human aggression is dangerous.. and society should have a 0 tolerance policy...

that being said a ban on pit bulls and any dog that could be a pit mix is unconstitutional 0 

mamatoulouse --- 15 years ago -

 

MxMike. --- 15 years ago -

0

That thing looks like a mix between a pit and a bull dog. Awesome! 

karma --- 15 years ago -

toulouse I agree but also disagree with you. I think there should be an absolute zero tolerance policy on human aggression in pit bulls. They should be humanely euthanized. This is to protect the dog, the owners of the dogs, and everyone else. We do not need anymore negative headlines or bad representations of the breed out of on the streets. Pit Bulls should be bomb-proof and stellar with humans, they were bred to be friendly companions. They were never intended to be human aggressive in the least bit and any HA in a pit bull raises a serious red flag.

Now on the flip side, some breeds were bred to be protective and human aggressive to some degree. I own a Doberman and I foster German Shepherds. I fully expect these dogs to display aggression towards questionable people, and I encourage it. I got a Doberman because I wanted a protective, intimidating, and courageous companion. Otherwise I would have gotten a goofy retriever or something. So therefore I do not believe there should be a blanket zero tolerance on HA policy for every dog. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

I think if a dog shows human aggression towards their owner, the dog can't be trusted. There are sanctuaries that take problematic dogs, and they have the experience needed to care for these dogs.

If you have a german shepherd who was bred to protect their owners, then what is the difference if a pit bull or any breed dog injures someone trying to harm you or your property. Human aggression is aggression, it doesn't matter what type of dog it is. Difference is, if a chihuahua is human aggressive they will do far less damage than a german shepherd or pitbull.

For anyone to make a 100% guarantee that their dog will never bite someone is ridiculous. Any dog is capable of delivering a nasty bite for whatever reason. I trust my dogs around me, but am always cautious when they get around strangers or small children. You never ever know.

It's important for any dog owner to properly socialize their puppy/dog, this is the best thing you can do for your dog. Next, exercise. I'm guilty of this, but dogs NEED to be walked everyday. It's good for their physical and mental well being. Finally, discipline...teaching your dog obedience, consequences and limitations. Dogs are very smart, they learn quickly what's acceptable and what's not.

MOST IMPORTANTLY....BE A RESPONSIBLE PET OWNER. Don't let your dog run off leash, don't let your dog run loose in your neighborhood. Personally, I don't agree with having a dog and making it live in your backyard. Why have a dog?? Dogs are pack animals, they want nothing more than to sit in your presence. When I hear of so many dogs digging out of their yards and running away, it doesn't surprise me in the least. If you own a powerful breed, then it should never be an outside dog where it has the potential to jump your fence or dig out. I think people are just ignorant. Do you realize if your dog mauls someone, you could face felony charges and jail time. You HAVE to take precautions when you own a pitbull, german shepherd, doberman, akita, etc.

With that being said, hope to meet many dogloving KU'ers at the pet adoption tomorrow at the Humble Civic Center. Come meet Mylee, she always gushes from the extra attention. You can't miss her, she's always Pretty in Pink. She will be wearing her new Martha Stewart pink knit sweater, lol!!

Also, I will have a little labrador puppy with me who desperately needs a home. I took her and her sister from someone who posted a thread on here a few weeks back. She is a black lab, around 8 weeks old, VERY SMART with a mind and will of her own! She would make a perfect hunting dog I think. I've named her Bella, so if interested please send me PM or come out and meet her tomorrow. Mylee hates her!!! 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

No surprise there. Now can we go put the lobbyists and law makers on trial for pointless murder of thousands of innocent dogs?



No theyre Canadian...


pit bull is no more likely to attack someone than any other breed.




Just more likely to do maximum damage when they do attack... 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Are dog owners criminally responsible if their dog chews up a kid?

If that is the case, perhaps those with dogs they know are human aggressive should think twice about having them around little kids.

I'm not convinced one way or the other about pits being more damaging than other dogs.

But it is just not worth the possible risk for me to have one around my son. I think that is a reasonable and rational viewpoint.

Sure, call me a pit bigot, but I don't care. My kid's safety comes first. And it really isn't a burden for anyone else when I take the kid out of a park area or street when I see a loose pit.

Granted I will mutter about people who feel the need to have such "bad boy" image dogs.... but then I mutter about people that drive hummers and jacked up trucks as well... :) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground