Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

* Why do our children still pledge allegiance to the flag every morning?

who's talking here?

june 4
planemom 1
* 1
LAXmom 1
Tylers Journey 1
Tootsieboo 1
rEVOLution 6
kingwood resident 1
Betty 1
Laurabeth 6
Panties' Revenge 1
KUTEX 1
voice of reason 1
Mark 1
AsExpected 1
MxMike. 2
allday 1
B12Fan 1
Dr Aborto 4
Hardshell- 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
LiveFreeOrDie 1
nathan 1
gambit 2
freemarketcapitalist 1
Thunderkunt 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

The Pledge of Allegiance of the United States is an oath of loyalty to the national flag and the republic of the United States of America,

The Pledge is predominantly sworn by children in public schools in response to state laws requiring the Pledge to be offered. Congressional sessions open with the swearing of the Pledge, as do government meetings at local levels, meetings held by the Knights of Columbus, Royal Rangers, Boy Scouts of America, Fraternal Order of Eagles, Freemasons, Toastmasters International and their concordant bodies, other organizations, and many sporting events.

On September 8, 1892 a Boston-based youth magazine "The Youth's Companion" published a 22-word recitation for school children to use during planned activities the following month to commemorate the 400th anniversary of Columbus' discovery of America. (Which we know is not exactly a fact) Under the title "The Pledge to the Flag", the composition was the earliest version of what we now know as the PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.

The last change in the Pledge of Allegiance occurred on June 14 (Flag Day), 1954 when President Dwight D. Eisenhower approved adding the words "under God". As he authorized this change he said:

"In this way we are reaffirming the transcendence of religious faith in America's heritage and future; in this way we shall constantly strengthen those spiritual weapons which forever will be our country's most powerful resource in peace and war."

This was the last change made to the Pledge of Allegiance. The 23 words what had been initially penned for a Columbus Day celebration now comprised a Thirty-one profession of loyalty and devotion to not only a flag, but to a way of life....the American ideal.

__________________________________________

My question is why do we still force children to say the pledge. Do they even know what they are pledging to every morning they attend school? Shouldn't they be more informed as to what they are pledging? Just a thought. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Unless schools have quit teaching civics and social studies most students are taught what the Pledge of Allegience means and what our National Anthem means. Whether or not they remember or understand is up for debate. 

june --- 16 years ago -

Children aren't forced to say the pledge. The are given the privelege to. Hopefully, parents have already taught them this before they start school. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

My question is why do we still force children to say the pledge


Rev....are your children forced to do this at school? 

AsExpected --- 16 years ago -

We said the pledge everyday when I was a kid. The teachers even wrote it in on their displayed schedules for the kids...
Right between attendance and gather books/supplies.
We moved to TX when I was 10; and I was never asked to say it again. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

To be honest with you, throughout school we had no clue what we were pledging to.

Same with studies on the U.S. constitution and whatnot...no one cared...no one emphasized it's importance or meaning...it was just more BS that we didn't want to do that we had to if we wanted to pass. 

gambit --- 16 years ago -

rEVOLution u must be a low life to have posted this. 

Tootsieboo --- 16 years ago -

How sad that thinking that pledging to the flag is a bad thing or BS. I always felt honored to say the pledge as a child even though I didn't understand it all. I knew this that it meant I was loyal to God, my country and that men had fought and died for my freedom. If you can't say it and be proud of it maybe you need to live somewhere else. It's a sad day we live in:( 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

To be honest with you, throughout school we had no clue what we were pledging to.

I agree. I did it but didn't really know what it meant of what it stood for. I don't think it's bad if the kids do it, I don't think it's a way to "indoctrinate" them. My kids go to a Religious Private School. They learn about Jesus, the Bible and how to Pray. Yes, Dr. Aborto's kids are learning about Christ as the one and only savior. You think, I think it's gonna stick? Nope. They go there because it's a great school. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

rEVOLution u must be a low life to have posted this.



You sure have it twisted. rEV is the most honorable and patriotic American you will ever meet. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

To be honest with you, throughout school we had no clue what we were pledging to.

I agree. I did it but didn't really know what it meant of what it stood for.



:( Our parents and my Gramps especially, took the time to explain this to us. I came from a family with a strong military background. I can honestly remember standing in the morning to say the pledge as early as the second grade and having a true understanding of what the pledge meant. I remember doing it in junior high and even getting emotional because I had a friend that had three older brothers, and all of them were soliders overseas during the Gulf War.

Yes, Dr. Aborto's kids are learning about Christ as the one and only savior.

Cool, I hope they are learning all about other religions and cultures too! 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Cool, I hope they are learning all about other religions and cultures too! 

Probably not their but eventually when they go to public school. They're too young to know the difference. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

I mean at home, from family and friends too Dr. A. 

june --- 16 years ago -

It is the responsibility of parents/grandparents to make sure our children understand these things. Can they have a perfect grasp of it all at 6yrs or age?...probably not just due to their life experience, but they are certainly able at that age to grasp the meaning/honor/privelege of being able to do so. I remember knowing what it meant at a very early age. Of course, through the years the words became more real, but yes...our children can and should be taught patriotism for the wonderful country they live in. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I mean at home, from family and friends too Dr. A. 

We're CA liberals with museum passes. What do you think ;) 

Tylers Journey --- 16 years ago -

rEVOLution u must be a low life to have posted this.

I don't know how you can say this when you don't even know him. I happen to love and respect him. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

We're CA liberals with museum passes. What do you think ;)


Awesome......so they do get exposed! :)

I love that my kid is curious about other religions and cultures. We celebrated the Day of Atonement by attending a "break fast" dinner with a family of friends last month. My son engaged in a quite interesting conversation with one of the women in the group. I just sat back and listened to the two of them discussing their beliefs and she allowed him to ask several questions. It was pretty neat to listen to. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

Pay no attention Tyler's Journey, gambit is a troll that likes to spout ignorant comments to stir the pot...... 

allday --- 16 years ago -

You think, I think it's gonna stick? Nope. They go there because it's a great school.

Same here. I went to religious private because of academics and hung with the public school guys. You can tell the nuns got NONE. Not happy folks.

Most of the kids who are indoctrinated see through it. They play along for the folks. Nice of them, actually. 

gambit --- 16 years ago -

its cool laurabeth. ur a fool as well. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Awesome......so they do get exposed! :)

As much as we can but my oldest is 4 so his exposure to different cultures and religions consists of Autobots, Decepticons, Jedi and Spiderman. 

nathan --- 16 years ago -

All of my children understand what the American flag represents.

Signed,

One proud American 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

consists of Autobots, Decepticons, Jedi and Spiderman


LOL! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

BECAUSE THEY SHOULD! 

june --- 16 years ago -

Amen WWW! 

Panties' Revenge --- 16 years ago -

BECAUSE THEY SHOULD!

Der de der....I think you missed the point.

Do they even know what they are pledging to every morning they attend school? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Do they even know what they are pledging to every morning they attend school? 


They do if their parents are parenting them as well and not just expecting the school to do it all. Remember the school didn't give birth to them. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I actually tried to update my topic to remove the word "force" from my question and for what ever reason it did not update. I do not believe nor did I insinuate that the pledge was bad or "BS". However, I do question it's relevance in today's America especially when you research where the pledge even began. I'm all for Patriotic gratitude but like in my daughters example in her class where children who do not pledge their allegiance to the flag are ridiculed by some of the other children. If that's the case then it leads me to my original question, why do our children even pledge their allegiance to the flag? I'm willing to bet that the majority of an elementary school classroom could not tell you why they are pledging allegiance to the flag much less a pledge sighting "One nation under God." How many children in a classroom of 25 kids might have parents that do not teach them about God? I'm not saying the pledge is bad I'm only asking why children that do not understand what they are pledging are in most cases expected and instructed on how to pledge their allegiance?

How many of you on this forum realize that America is or is at least supposed to be a Republic? I grew up pledging my allegiance to the flag and it wasn't until a few years ago that I had any clue that America is a Republic.

"I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

Indivisible? How many elementary students know what Indivisible even means? "impossible of undergoing division; "an indivisible union of states"; "one nation indivisible". With that definition you don't have to look very far to realize that our nation is certainly divided.

Justice for All? Not since the Patriot was drafted by the Clinton administration ad signed into law by the Bush administration. The patriot act removes any question of Justice from anyone "Suspected" of being a terrorist which we now know could range from anyone supporting Ron Paul, road rage, to the CIA created al-quida.

I'm just saying that if our children are programmed into reciting a pledge every day of the week I think they should understand more about what they are Pledging to and should certainly not have to feel ridicule if they choose not to say it. 

june --- 16 years ago -

Again, I think if the parents have done their job..they have taken a little time to "take the pledge apart" and explain to the children what the phrases mean. I think the same should be done with the national anthem etc. We did it with our children..helped them to know what they were pledging, singing. We learn a lot of things in school that don't make sense completely until we are older. That is just the nature of growing up. At least give them a basic understanding before they start school. I will not get into a controversy here--this is my last post--but I have to wonder why a child who has been taught how blessed they are to live in America would refuse to recite the pledge. If they want the benefits of living here--they should learn to respect that freedom. 

freemarketcapitalist --- 16 years ago -

How many of you on this forum realize that America is or is at least supposed to be a Republic? I grew up pledging my allegiance to the flag and it wasn't until a few years ago that I had any clue that America is a Republic.

Bravo rEVOLution! The intent by the founding fathers was for us to be a decentralized republic with a very small scope of power and incluence by the fed allowing citizens the oportunity to vote with their feet.

Yhe way I have always interpreted the pledge was that it is a mini-constitution. Some of the most important items outlined in The Constitution of The United States are highlighted in the pledge with the intention of teach young ones what this great nation was founded upon in addition as a reminder to the rest of the citizens of who we are.

Unfortunately the fed has gained and swelled beyond its ranks, scope and capabilities and has turned our nation into something that looks more like tyranny of the majority that switches every few years back and forth; a very unhealthy cycle btw. Mark my word, this new model, the tyranny of majority system we have, will forever keep us divided, and I don't believe that this is not the intention because so long as we are divided the greater the federal power can become.

But back to the pledge,

June:
Children aren't forced to say the pledge. The are given the privelege to. Hopefully, parents have already taught them this before they start school.

You are absolutely correct, it is a priviledge to say this and should be taught as such or what has all the bloodshed for our independence and freedom been for. Teach them this, and teach them that America is an exceptional country and forever will be. 

Betty --- 16 years ago -

Because they love America,if they don't they need to move to another country. 

* --- 16 years ago -

BECAUSE IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO

dammit.

i hate this liberal bs 

B12Fan --- 16 years ago -

I couldn't care less about politics and all that 'fun' stuff but the pledge feels like a lame attempt at brainwashing to me. Like others have pointed out most don't have a clue what they are saying or why. They're just going through the motions.
Props to those that know exactly what it means when they say it and believe it - but this is one thing that wouldn't hurt my feelings was just done at home. 

KUTEX --- 16 years ago -

The pledge should be said. Its school, its public, its patriotic. Its embarrassing how far we have degraded. 

Hardshell- --- 16 years ago -

I do not believe nor did I insinuate that the pledge was bad or "BS". However, I do question it's relevance in today's America especially when you research where the pledge even began.

I do think it's BS. It's propaganda, pure and simple. I'll gladly stand and remove my hat, I'll gladly sing the national anthem...and I thank God that we live in this nation as opposed to some El Crapistan.....but I will never pledge allegiance to a worldly government. Never...... 

kingwood resident --- 16 years ago -

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA...yesterday, today and tomorrow. 

LAXmom --- 16 years ago -

You are absolutely correct, it is a priviledge to say this and should be taught as such or what has all the bloodshed for our independence and freedom been for. Teach them this, and teach them that America is an exceptional country and forever will be.

BRAVO! 

Thunderkunt --- 16 years ago -

'merica 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Is pledging allegiance to the Flag also pledging allegiance to our government?

I think the answer to that is going to be a personal opinion rather than fact because you would be hard pressed these days to find anyone within our government who actually is living out their "Pledge of Allegiance" to our flag? I can name one that comes to mind and few even come close to where he stands and that's Ron Paul. If our pledge is supposed to somewhat mirror our constitution than Ron Paul is one of the only ones I see supporting and defending the constitution.

Back to my question though. Is pledging allegiance to the flag pledging allegiance to the government? I'm willing to be that the government would say yes but in my opinion the pledge is to our Country, not our government. Our government is continually digressing into tyranny and it's becoming more and more apparent every day that even our government is not patriotic to America.

So please be careful when we define patriotism. Being a patriot does not mean supporting a tyrannical government. Being patriotic means defending our constitution, state and country. Being patriotic means defending our nation against tyranny, not supporting tyranny. It means supporting family values, free markets, smaller government, lower taxes, government accountability, fiscal responsibility, a humble yet firm foreign policy, no nation building, the list goes on.

The pledge should be said. Its school, its public, its patriotic.

I think that's fine so long as we know what we are pledging to. I think it's time that we realize that being patriotic does not mean supporting a tyrannical government and it does mean supporting the false Left/Right paradigm. It's time to clean house and replace them all with constitutional and honorable Representatives who will work for us and not to line their pockets. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground