Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Arizona's Next Immigration Target: Children of Illegals

who's talking here?

randyjet 9
steinhoister 2
ukchristine 1
wayward1 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
justforfun 3
~sassy~ 12
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 1
Doug & Teresa 1
Ogre1 13
Mark 1
mommie21g1b 2
james osterberg 3
toxiccutie 1
Work in Progress 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 9
~ MARY C ~ 1
gambit 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

"Anchor babies" isn't a very endearing term, but in Arizona those are the words being used to tag children born in the U.S. to illegal immigrants. While not new, the term is increasingly part of the local vernacular because the primary authors of the nation's toughest and most controversial immigration law are targeting these tots - the legal weights that anchor many undocumented aliens in the U.S. - for their next move.

Both sides expect the anchor baby bill to end up before the U.S. Supreme Court before it is enacted. "I think it would be struck down as facially unconstitutional. I can't imagine a federal judge saying this would be OK," says Dan Barr, a longtime Phoenix lawyer and constitutional litigator. Potentially joining the anchor baby bill at the Supreme Court may be SB 1070, which Arizona Republican Governor Jan Brewer signed into law in April. It is set to take effect July 29, but at least five courtroom challenges have been filed against it. Pearce says he will win them all.

What do you think? Will this bill pass?


NewsBy ADAM KLAWONN / PHOENIX Adam Klawonn / Phoenix – Sat Jun 12, 10:00 am ET 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Both sides expect the anchor baby bill to end up before the U.S. Supreme Court before it is enacted.

Bout time. I believe this law needs to be changed. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

What was the original intent of the "anchor baby" law? Why do we, as a country, grant citizenship to babies born here when other countries don't? I need to know the reasons for and against it to decide whether it should be repealed. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

If you are here illegally, then your child should also be illegal. It is just wrong to make these children legal citizens. 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

I agree Mary. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

There are varying interpretations of the original intent of Congress, based on statements made during the congressional debate over the amendment.[5] During the original debate over the amendment Senator Jacob M. Howard of Michigan—the author of the Citizenship Clause—described the clause as excluding American Indians who maintain their tribal ties, and "persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers." He was supported by other senators, including Edgar Cowan, Reverdy Johnson, and Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Lyman Trumbull.[6] Howard further stated the term jurisdiction meant "the same jurisdiction in extent and quality as applies to every citizen of the United States now"[6] and that the United States possessed a "full and complete jurisdiction" over the person described in the amendment.[7][8][6] Other senators, including Senator John Conness,[9] supported the amendment, believing citizenship should cover all children born in the United States.

In Elk v. Wilkins, 112 U.S. 94 (1884), the clause's meaning was tested regarding whether birth in the U.S. automatically extended U.S. citizenship. The Supreme Court held that Native Americans who voluntarily quit their tribes did not automatically become U.S. citizens.[10]

The meaning was tested again in the case of United States v. Wong Kim Ark, 169 U.S. 649 (1898) regarding children of non-citizen Chinese immigrants born in United States. The court ruled that the children were U.S. citizens.[11]

The difference between "legal" and "illegal" immigrants was not clear at the time of the decision of Wong Kim Ark.[12] Wong Kim Ark and subsequent cases did not explicitly decide whether such children are entitled to birthright citizenship via the amendment,[13] but such birthright is generally assumed to be the case.[14] In some cases, the Court has implicitly assumed, or suggested in dicta, that such children are entitled to birthright citizenship: these include Plyler v. Doe, 457 U.S. 202 (1982), and INS v. Rios-Pineda, 471 U.S. 444 (1985).[15][16][17]

Loss of U.S. citizenship is possible only under the following circumstances:

Fraud in the naturalization process. Technically, this is not loss of citizenship but rather a voiding of the purported naturalization and a declaration that the immigrant never was a U.S. citizen.
Voluntary relinquishment of citizenship. This may be accomplished either through renunciation procedures specially established by the State Department or through other actions that demonstrate desire to give up U.S. citizenship.[18]


Naturalization is the acquisition of citizenship and nationality by somebody who was not a citizen or national of that country when he or she was born.

In general, basic requirements for naturalization are that the applicant hold a legal status as a full-time resident for a minimum period of time and that the applicant promise to obey and uphold that country's laws, to which an oath or pledge of allegiance is sometimes added. Some countries also require that a naturalized national must renounce any other citizenship that they currently hold, forbidding dual citizenship, but whether this renunciation actually causes loss of the person's original citizenship will again depend on the laws of the countries involved


Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution

link 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

"the same jurisdiction in extent and quality as applies to every citizen of the United States now"[6] and that the United States possessed a "full and complete jurisdiction" over the person described in the amendmen

If someone is here illegally then we don't have full and complete jurisdiction over them correct? If a Mexican citizen comes here and murders someone and is given the death penalty Mexico objects to the US giving the death penalty to one of their "citizens" correct?

I don't understand why they were ever given citizenship based on the current law.

If the US has to have full and complete jurisdiction over the mother (which we do not) then how can the child be a US citizen? 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I'm not sure exactly how this citizen thing come to be but it has something to do with slaves. It come about to give slaves born in the United States citizenship. It was never intended to grant everyone citizenship. 

toxiccutie --- 16 years ago -

If you are here illegally, then your child should also be illegal. It is just wrong to make these children legal citizens.

Yup.
So, what? Are they gonna deport the parents and leave the kids, NOPE! So, therefore we would be right back to where we are now...come here illegally, refuse to become legal, dont pay taxes, live off others tax money while making money on the side TAX FREE, talk crap about America, pop out a few kids to insure you arse wont get shipped back to your own country...and continue taking more money from our actual CITIZENS! And from our citizens who should be receiving that money over you!

The ones that talk trash about America while cashing in are the ones that really pi$$ me off - I mean, hell, you don't like America? Pack your M F bags and get OUT...if you need help packing I will be more than happy to assist, and even more willing to drive your butt to the border.

I don't have an issue if you want to come here and seek out a better life for yourself and family...but don't do it at the expense and drain of others!!!!!!! Do what you are suppose to, become legal, pay some taxes - contribute to the country & people that give to YOU! 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Why do we, as a country, grant citizenship to babies born here when other countries don't?

Most countries DO grant citizenship to those who are born in that country. Germany was one of the few holdouts until a number of years ago when the EU demanded that the law change. As a matter of fact, as one who is of German descent, I could go to Germany and claim citizenship. Think that would be a good idea too for the US?

This is citizenship by blood, not by nation. THAT is extremely detrimental to having a nation since it allows only those who have a racial make-up to claim citizenship. In the US that would be rather tough, but in Europe it made some sense since the boundaries of nations changed so much as a result of the last war.

The FACT is that for this to pass will require a Constitutional Amendment since the 14th amendment is the law that established birth right citizenship. I have no problem with that at all since such children will be stateless in many countries. Thus the US could NOT even deport them since no country would take them.

It is also funny that those who say they defend the Constitution SPIT on it by advocating something so SUBVERSIVE of it and downright ILLEGAL. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

What is a Foreign National?

A foreign national is any individual in the United States who does not have U.S. citizenship.
Foreign nationals in the United States may include tourists and visitors, migrant workers with temporary permits, resident aliens, undocumented aliens, asylum-seekers, and persons in transit.



What rights do Foreign National’s have and are they granted?

Under Article 36 of the 1963 Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, local authorities must notify detained foreigners “without delay” of their right to have their consulate informed of their arrest.
With permission from the foreign national, Consuls are allowed to arrange for legal representation and other assistance.

This would seem to throw out any claim that we would have to full and complete jurisdiction.

Sounds like we just have some judges deciding what they thought was right and not following the law. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

If someone is here illegally then we don't have full and complete jurisdiction over them correct?

NO that is NOT correct. What that refers to is ALL diplomatic persons who are NOT subject to US law. The US cannot arrest them for ANY reason, thus they are NOT subject to US jurisdiction. ALL illegals most certainly ARE subject to our laws. The FACT that we deport them shows we have power over them. Also illegal males between the age of 18 and 25 are REQUIRED to register for the draft. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

NO that is NOT correct. What that refers to is ALL diplomatic persons who are NOT subject to US law. The US cannot arrest them for ANY reason, thus they are NOT subject to US jurisdiction.


Not correct -According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security a foreign national is defined simply as, "An individual who is a citizen of any country other than the United States.

A foreign Diplomat and a foreign national are two different things. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

This would seem to throw out any claim that we would have to full and complete jurisdiction.

If they are arrested, they most certainly ARE under US jurisdiction. They WILL be tried in a US court or state court. All the diplomatic reps can do is to arrange for a lawyer. If you recall your history, the US and many other nations during colonization had EXTRA-territorial rights for their citizens living abroad. There were countries like China, in which an American could NOT be tried by Chinese courts, the same was true for the Ottoman Empire in which foreign nationals would be tried in expatriate courts that were NOT subject to the laws of either country. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Here ya go RJ- I forgot the link.


Wiki 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

Nice to hear every one's thoughts on this,AGAIN. This is an election year issue.Way,way to much water to carry to change the 14th Amendment,overturn SCOTUS.
As you can imagine,conservatives hate this amendment.It's too liberal,it actually spells out a persons exact rights,not much for vagueness.

Damn those patriotic American leaders. 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

If we just kept the illegals out to begin with this wouldn't be an issue. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

I thought these guy's were all busy repealing the Heath Care bill? 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Not correct -According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security a foreign national is defined simply as, "An individual who is a citizen of any country other than the United States.

ALL foreign nationals. EXCEPT diplomats, ARE subject to US laws and jurisdiction. Thus a baby born in the US to a woman who is NOT a diplomat is automatically a US citizen. The families of ALL diplomats ARE exempt from US jurisdiction. Thus a baby born to the wife of the Ambassador from Mexico does NOT get US citizenship even though the child was born here. THAT is what the law means. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Here ya go RJ- I forgot the link.

ALL that says that if you are born outside the US you are not a citizen and are a foreign national. So what else is new? The ONLY way you can be born in the US and NOT subject to its jurisdiction is to be the child of a diplomat! It makes NO difference if your parents are US citizens or not, legal or illegal. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

So, what would the ramifications of repealing it be?

What are the benefits of the law as is? 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

i dont know about that rj...my brother was born in germany in the 60s and he was given dual citizenship... 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

So, what would the ramifications of repealing it be?

YOUR citizenship would be in question and you would have to PROVE IN COURT that your parents were US citizens. Citizenship would be a political football that would and could change with each election and change of the legislature.

The benefit is a straigh forward test for citizenship where were you born? Easy, and no muss no fuss except for racists who don't want a darker shade of citizen. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

my brother was born in germany in the 60s and he was given dual citizenship...

That was because of his racial make-up. The children of Turkish gastarbieters were NOT granted German citizenship. That was a big bone of contention in Germany and the EU. They finally granted them German citizenship. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 16 years ago -

My cousin and her husband are both lawyers in Mexico and live in Mexico, they will be having their second child here in the US while on permission to visit. They are entering the US legaly, planning to give birth here at our expense while securing their child/children US citizenship... After mission is accomplish, off they go back to Mexico.

*Baby gets citizenship.
*Mom and baby get free medical care and nutrition while hospitalized. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

... After mission is accomplish, off they go back to Mexico.

Problem is the kids have few rights in Mexico then. They will never be able to run for office, hold a government job of any kind, and not own land in certain areas, etc..

In short, those kids will have to live in the US if they want to have full rights of citizenship. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

If someone is here illegally then we don't have full and complete jurisdiction over them correct?

NO. that is not correct, and sorry if someone has already addressed this.

It's called In Personam Jurisdiction. Or Jurisdiction over the person.

"A court with jurisdiction over a particular location may exercise in personam jursidiction over a person who resides, maintains connections, or is served notice of legal proceedings in that location. It may also exercise jurisdiction over a person who consents to be subject to it.

In personam judgments can be enforced against the person where she is, while disputes over property must take place in its particular location."

and, Diplomats residing in the United States are also immune from service of process. You can't even civilly sue them!

And JURISDICTION is a full semester topic at law school so this is amazingly simplified. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

If you are here illegally, then your child should also be illegal.

BTW.. I DO NOT disagree with this statement. BUT SHOULD and reality, are not the same thing.

As long as the 14th reads the way it does, in part..."All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States;..."

Break it down, to be a citizen under the 14th you must:

A) Be a person
B) Be born or Naturalized
C) in the U.S.
D) be subject to U.S. Jurisdiction (which, barring specific exceptions (Diplomats, heads of state, etc) is EVERYONE within the borders of the U.S.)

If you meet these four requirements, you are a U.S. citizen.

ADDITIONALLY, another reason that Arizona's law will not fly is the second portion of this statement which bars states from making just this sort of law. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

What was the original intent of the "anchor baby" law? Why do we, as a country, grant citizenship to babies born here when other countries don't? I need to know the reasons for and against it to decide whether it should be repealed.


there is no law about anchor babies that I know of. Simply that anyone born on this soil is considered American....who knew there would be an influx of illegals sneaking in here for that very reason. It needs to change. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It is also funny that those who say they defend the Constitution SPIT on it by advocating something so SUBVERSIVE of it and downright ILLEGAL.


Down right illegal you say?

I haven't heard you speak against mommie sneaking in our country ILLEGALLY to birth her baby in order to STEAL citizenship for her bambino. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I haven't heard you speak against mommie sneaking in our country ILLEGALLY to birth her baby in order to STEAL citizenship for her bambino.

it's two different issues Sassy.

And she can't STEAL something that is freely given away.

As I said above, I do think it's wrong. But it's VERY unlikely that the 14th will be changed any time soon. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

And she can't STEAL something that is freely given away.

You're probably right about the 14th amendment, but in a way she IS stealing that citizenship. Were it not for her illegal actions, her child would NOT be a legal citizen. So, imo, something gained through illegal activities means she got it by stealing it. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I haven't heard you speak against mommie sneaking in our country ILLEGALLY to birth her baby in order to STEAL citizenship for her bambino.
And she can't STEAL something that is freely given away.

THAT says it ALL sassy. Doing away with birthright citizenship is subversive of the very things that we fought against when we kicked the Brits out. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Maybe, but by definition, she can't be stealing it from the very wording of the 14th. Which does not distinguish from someone being here legally or illegally. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

THAT says it ALL sassy. Doing away with birthright citizenship is subversive of the very things that we fought against when we kicked the Brits out.


So we 're only allowed to kick the Brits out but not the illegals? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

So we 're only allowed to kick the Brits out but not the illegals?

No no, that's not what he means... RJ, you need to explain what you mean... I kinda have an idea where you're going with this...but enlighten us. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Which does not distinguish from someone being here legally or illegally.

Bet if they'd had a crystal ball.

Maybe this SHOULD be heard by the SC, though with THIS court it wouldn't likely get far, but who knows. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

No no, that's not what he means... RJ, you need to explain what you mean... I kinda have an idea where you're going with this...but enlighten us.

lol, me neither 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Maybe this SHOULD be heard by the SC

Well, if it's heard by the SCOTUS now, they'll rule in favor of the 14th. it would have to be changed. 

ukchristine --- 16 years ago -

My cousin and her husband are both lawyers in Mexico and live in Mexico, they will be having their second child here in the US while on permission to visit. They are entering the US legaly, planning to give birth here at our expense while securing their child/children US citizenship... After mission is accomplish, off they go back to Mexico.

*Baby gets citizenship.
*Mom and baby get free medical care and nutrition while hospitalized.



Now THAT is STEALING 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground