Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

atheists vs agnostics

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
eterry2 8
steinhoister 18
Going off air 1
Mabbers 1
Donkey Hodie 9
POTUS 3
JusticeForAll 10
Ogre1 5
voice of reason 1
jtcitrus 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 6
JohnLynch 25
MxMike. 2
Zombie Slayer! 3
*OH SNAP* 3
~Scotch~ 3
Dr Aborto 1
SpringChicken 1
Bob Ross 4
Work in Progress 2

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

I want to pass some info about what it means to be an athiest or an agnostic on to you. I just learned this the other day from my philosophy major daughter. She has taken several religion classes at the university level because it is truly one of her passions.

I saw some confusion about this in another thread. And I must admit, I was unaware of the word meaning myself until I read her explanation. makes perfect sense if you understand the root words.

You are not athiest or agnostic. they answer different questions. Here is her explanation:


they are not either/or to the same question. they are answers to different questions about God.

here's the explanation in her words:

I'm so tired of everyone using "atheist" and "agnostic" as if they are two different answers to the same question. They answer different questions.

Here's the claim: God(s) exist(s).
If you accept that claim, you are a theist. Everyone else is an atheist. People who stay with an "I dunno" position are still atheists b/c they do not ACCEPT the claim that gods exists. Saying "I don't know" is not accepting.

Here's the claim: Humans (Or "I") have certain knowledge of whether or not god(s) exist(s).
Everyone who accepts that claim is gnostic. Everyone else is agnostic. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

More simply put, atheists reject the claim of a higher power...agnostics acknowledge there's a truth value to claims of a higher power... 

SpringChicken --- 16 years ago -

Okay, I'm still not clear. Are you gnostic if you do have certain knowledge of whether god(s) exist(s), or are you gnostic if you have certain knowledge of whether god(s) don't (doesn't) exist? 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

0 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

I think that if you have knowledge of whether God exists or not you are gnostic.

If you do not have knowledge of it, you are a-gnostic. a negates the gnostic.

So an athiest would also be agnostic. and a Christian can be gnostic or agnostic. not sure. 

Bob Ross --- 16 years ago -

gnostic

I guess the 'g' is silent? 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

yes, like lasagna and gnocchi. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

So an athiest would also be agnostic


Not exactly...an agnostic would be someone who says "I'm not religious but I'm spiritual." Meaning they believe in a soul, or an otherworldly energy, but not a particular theology. And make no claim to know how or why we're here...

An atheist doesn't believe any of it...none. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

According to those definitions, a Christian would most definitely be gnostic, because they follow Christ, which is knowledge of God in the flesh.

But I like the definitions. Turns out that what I thought they meant wasn't completely accurate. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Let's really screw things up...

You're a DEIST if you say, "Yes, there is Supreme Deity of some sort, but none of you people really have a clue what you're talking about when you apply attributes to that Supreme Being."

As to Atheist and Agnostic, the dictionary definitions are not conclusive because they don't take into account the philosophical stance:

An Atheist absolutely denies the existence of any sort of Supreme Deity.

And AGNOSTIC on the other hand is a skeptic that is willing to accept the existence of a Supreme Being (and conversely, willing to accept the NON-Existence of a S.B.) if only they had some sort of proof one way or another.

Atheists deny the significance of any holy texts whereas Agnostics deny the logic used to present them as true, as being false logic. (I.E. The Bible is the word of God because it says so in the Bible! The Koran is the word of God because Muhammad says it's so! etc.)

Whereas the Atheist, by definition cannot accept any "proof" of the existence of a S.B., and agnostic is generally seeking out such proof, for or against, the existence of a S.B.

An Atheist is a non-believer.

An Agnostic is a seeker. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

So do agnostics necessarily believe that no OTHER humans have knowledge of God? 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

There are many atheists who follow the teachings of christ...they also follow the teachings of MLK, Buddha, Ghandi, Nietzche...etc etc...I admire the teachings of Jesus,I just don't believe he was the son of a higher being. 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

I just read this and it looks like my daughter's explanation:

meanings 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

a gnostic possesses intellectual or spiritual knowledge

an agnostic doesn't

a theist believes in the existence of God or gods

an atheist doesn't 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

how could anyone possibly be an atheist? They'd have to have faith, wouldn't they? 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

how could anyone possibly be an atheist? They'd have to have faith, wouldn't they?

they do. the Bible tells us that He has given a measure of faith to every person 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

This really isn't that complicated.

agnostic = I don't know if there's a God
atheist = there is definitely no God
deist = God made us as some sort of cosmic science fair project.
everybody else = God is named...and his/her attributes are... 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

You should be in bed! 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

You should be in bed!

So true. I've had a major bout of insomnia this week. I did forget, however:

agnostic theists = there is a God, I don't know his/her/it's name, but his/her/it's attributes are...

And now I'm going to bed. 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

a gnostic possesses intellectual or spiritual knowledge

an agnostic doesn't

a theist believes in the existence of God or gods

an atheist doesn't

Precisely. You got it. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

nope, scratch that.


i guess im gnostic. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I still like my version.

*shrug* 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

a gnostic possesses intellectual or spiritual knowledge



a gnostic BELIEVES they possess spiritual knowledge...they may not in reality. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

a gnostic BELIEVES they possess spiritual knowledge...they may not in reality.

sorry steiny, but there is no "believes" in the definition



Then the definition is flawed or incomplete...Lynchy. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

in your opinion

This phrase, from this poster, is pure comedy gold! 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

Then the definition is flawed or incomplete...Lynchy.

in your opinion


There is no opinion, its a fact that the definition you are using is incomplete, which I guess is the same as being flawed...a person cannot be certain of anything that requires faith to believe. You may think you are, but logic says otherwise... 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

go back to my original post.

If you accept the claim that people (or you can substitute yourself) have knowledge of whether OR NOT God exists, you are gnostic.

If you do not accept the claim, you are agnostic.

it's all based on your acceptance of this claim, not the reality of it. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Agreed, Steinhoister! 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

This phrase, from this poster, is pure comedy gold!

lol, i only used it because that is what steiny always says. so i guess the comedy gold is on steiny


You really are dense, aren't you? The comedy comes from you saying "in your opinion", since you refuse to admit that what you post is your opinion. You always claim that you post The Word Of God, but really, it's still just your opinion. Nothing more. It's funny because of the irony. Someone else using that phrase who openly admits that what they post is just their opinion doesn't make it ironic or funny, but when you, the king posting malinformed opinions and passing them off as The Word Of God says it, it's funny. Comedy Gold. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

have no problem admitting when i post something that is my opinion

A spit-take is a comedic technique in which someone spits a beverage out of their mouth when they react to a statement. In this context, the word "take" is used in the sense of taking in information. It is similar in construction to the phrase "double-take." 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

when i post God's Word, that ISN'T my opinion because He wrote it, NOT me.

Thank you for making my point. Comedy Gold. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

0 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

and steiny, that is just another false portrayal of Christians


in your opinion. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground