Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*What are your thoughts (Israel vs Activists)

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
randyjet 8
Justwatching72 1
Going off air 1
justforfun 1
rEVOLution 8
Perfection 5
POTUS 2
Ogre1 5
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
james osterberg 1
MxMike. 2
allday 2
river chef 3
Zombie Slayer! 2
A Simple Equation 1
johnregalman517 1
rightwingdad 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I saw this last night and it gave me the chills... Then I saw this when I woke up this morning... What are your thoughts? Should the military have boarded these activist ships the way they did? Should they have killed activists who were defending themselves from armed attackers? Six ships were boarded by the military, the last one they boarded decided they weren't going to allow them to be detained by armed military. I don't know what to think yet. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

The ships were asked to stop, they did not. There is a blockade of that area and those ships chose to attempt to cross it. When boarded they began to attack. They were warned. I found it interesting that for peace loving ships, they possessed a number of weapons. Where were those weapons going? Why did they choose not to stop? Why did they choose to attempt to cross the blockade? 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

The first video will not show up when I edit it so I'm trying to post it again.  

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

Yep America will turn its back to Israel and the lions will attack them. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I think that Israel was set up or at least it was attempted. I stand with Israel all the way. Like someone said they were asked to stop and ignored the plea. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

What the Israelis did was perfectly LEGAL under international laws of the sea. They have declared a blockade of that port, and have advised all ships bound for it that they will be stopped. It makes NO difference if they are in international waters. Maybe they would have prefered to been fired on by naval gunfire? THAT would have killed a LOT more people. How about a torpedo? That would have killed more and the ship would have been lost. But given the fact that North Korea seems to be getting away with torpedoing ships, that may have been an option. Since some of the people decided to arm themselves with knives clubs, etc., then I have no problem with the Israelis defending themselves and shooting. If they want to fight with clubs and knives in a gunfight, they get to suffer the consequences. TOUGH! The FACT that these people turned down the Israeli offer to dock at an Israeli port and drive the supplies over to Gaza shows the real intent of these people. They were NOT serious about delivering supplies, but they simply wanted dead bodies and an incident. All I have to say is that I hope the Israeli troops are OK and that they did good shooting. I can care less about how many Hamas folks die. We need to see more such scum do that thing. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

That video is pure BS. She states that it is the Palestinian people who are being attacked. It is NOT! It is the Hamas DICTATORSHIP that SHE is supporting and that is the whole point of the flotilla. I hope she did as she urged and picked up a weapon and was killed. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I stand with Israel all the way. After knowing how corrupt all governments are I have a hard time being 100% behind any of them. Israel is no exception.  

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I stand with Israel all the way. I do NOT stand with any government all the way no matter what! That is an absurd proposition and refuses to hold any government to account for when they do wrong. Israel has done PLENTY of bad things in its history and is continuing to do such things. This incident is NOT one of them. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

That video on the USS Liberty is pretty good up until the end. The Medal of Honor was NOT given in secret, but was given at the Navy Yard. The Sec. of the Navy presented it which is a RADICAL departure from tradition. Israel and LBJ are the ones responsible for that. The only reason LBJ did not want the ship rescued was that it would have gotten the US into a shooting war with Israel which was in the Six Day war at the time. I have read the book written by the executive officer, and I do NOT recall he mentioned a Soviet ship. If the ship had gone down with the loss of all hands, it would have made life MUCH easier for all concerned. It was not a plot to take over the Mideast by the US. Israel did quite well on its own without US aid. I was stationed there at the time, and I can say that there was NO US build up at the time. There were no stockpiling of war material, troops, or other items which would indicate such a thing. Our base was the logistical HUB for ALL US ops in the Mideast too. The war screwed up my plans for a vacation to Egypt, Jordan, and Syria since US personnel were DEFINITELY non grata after the war. The Egyptians stopped all of our flights to and from Cairo. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

Looks to me like Israel and the rest of the world got trolled. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

If Israelis had knives and were attacked by gunmen the crying would be deafening. Let's get out of the way and watch Israel fight the Mideast and just see what happens. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

Yep America will turn its back to Israel We can only pray. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

You know the US is always crying, "we have to support Israel to the end" and yet we ignore the murdering going on in Gaza. Sure Palestine has done wrong as well, both sides have. But how can we defend the murder of people trying to get help and aid to the people who are being brutally murdered by Israel and say that Israel is doing the right thing? Is that the Christian and American thing to do? Meanwhile we "Christians" also supported Bush and Bush Sr's Murderous run on over 1 million Iraqi's. Heck we even got support form troops world wide to help in that one. 

MxMike. --- 16 years ago -

I feel ya, rEV...messsed up. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I can get very critical of Israel at times. BUT in this case, the Israeli Navy is righteous. These people were running a blockade and then tried to fight with weapons that could seriously injure or kill. Never bring a knife to a gunfight. As to what is going on onshore. BOTH sides a lot to be blamed for. And the unconditional support of Israel makes us look like hypocrites. Hamas was ELECTED to office in what was viewed as a highly FAIR election. Sure seems like we've been giving LIP SERVICE to the Democratic process ever since. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Hamas was ELECTED to office in what was viewed as a highly FAIR election. Sure seems like we've been giving LIP SERVICE to the Democratic process ever since. Actually Hamas has said the US is talking to them albeit quietly. So to say we are giving lip service is a bit disingenuous. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

I found it interesting that for peace loving ships, they possessed a number of weapons. no weapons on the ship. they tried to subdue the israeli forces by hand, with brute force, pipes etc. I think it is sickening, and i am tired of my tax dollars going to support a nation who does nothing but thumb their nose at the law. i , for the life of me, cant understand why israel didnt wait for this ship to leave intl water. it is an act opf either war or piracy to forcibly board a vessel, no mattter what your reasons. remember two years ago, when we had to track that NK frieghter for months, because we thought it was carrying nuclear material for iran. but, the boat kept trying to lose us by staying out of port. and last but not least, this was an attack an a NATO ally, a very important one at that. i think it was reckless, illegal and arrogant. and, it also sounds like the mossad got played. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

These people were running a blockade and then tried to fight with weapons that could seriously injure or kill. Never bring a knife to a gunfight. i am astounded that they turned to lethal force so quick. i think they were told that there was something far more nefarious that aid on the ship. that being said, they could have done a naval boarding, rather than rappel from blacked out choppers. i cant imagine what the people on the deck were thinking. and they hadnt violated the blockade yet, but it was their intention. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

So to say we are giving lip service is a bit disingenuous Please, so basically, we're embarrassed to speak openly with a democratically elected government. Even one we don't like or agree with. I call that lip service. blacked out choppers. Uh... Navy Seals train to do that all the time. We assisted with these sorts of boardings in the Arabian sea back in the eighties. That was a Naval boarding. And you don't wait till they're crossing your blockade to stop them, especially if you know that's their intent. 

river chef --- 16 years ago -

Uh... Navy Seals train to do that all the time. We assisted with these sorts of boardings in the Arabian sea back in the eighties. That was a Naval boarding. And you don't wait till they're crossing your blockade to stop them, especially if you know that's their intent. but you cant forcibly board a vessel in international water. my problem with the way they boarded is that they knew they were descending onto a hostile deck, yet they used no crowd control or suppression. they could have boarded by ship, not air. my point was to the mindframe of the people on the deck, who defended themselves with chairs and pipes. i dont blame them for trying to intercept it, but i question the legality of the way this was done. not to mention the idiotic tactical decision to drop your guys one at a time onto a hostile deck. i know when we do helo assaults, we drop 4 at a time, with ground suppression. the ship they were boarding was lit up like a christmas tree, with what looks like dozens of hostiles on deck. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

we need to block any sort of official condemnation and stay out of it. we have our own international crime to deal with here. 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

Sure Palestine has done wrong as well, This is what you call setting off rockets into your town on a daily basis, sometimes multible times a day. If this kind of thing happened here in the States we would all be crying for a Hard military action. Yet when Iseral finally defends it's self it's in the wrong too???? 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

This whole thing is an outrage and is just more proof that we need to police the world and solve everything. 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

Dates of the rocket attacks on Israel from Gaza in 2010 alone: (THIS YEAR !!) January 1 ,January 5 ,January 6 ,January 7 ,January 8 ,January 9 ,January 10,February 2 ,February 3 ,February 7 ,February 12 ,March 11 ,March 13 ,March 16 ,March 17 ,March 18 ,March 19 ,March 20 ,March 21 ,March 22 ,March 23 ,March 26 ,March 27 ,March 29 ,April 1 ,April 3 ,April 4 ,April 7 ,April 8 ,April 12 ,April 15 ,May 8 ,May 19 ,May 25 ,May 28 ,June 1 ------------(36 attacks in 5 mos.) Thankfully these are dumb rockets (point and shoot) and very little serious injuries have happened. List of Palestinian rocket attackets on Isreal in 2010 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So what are peace activists doing with weapons on a peace mission? Do as I say, not as I do? 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

What would you be saying if you and your family lived under this kind of terror?? 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

I stand with Israel all the way. I do NOT stand with any government all the way no matter what! That is an absurd proposition and refuses to hold any government to account for when they do wrong. Israel has done PLENTY of bad things in its history and is continuing to do such things. This incident is NOT one of them. Randy u forget God is on israel's side and HE will deal with their misdeeds I also stand with israel thats 2 against one you lose randy God being a factor makes all the difference in the world my friend 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Dates of the rocket attacks on Israel from Gaza in 2010 alone: Where are the images of the Israeli's wounded and mangled bodies from all those "attacks?" I know it doesn't make it right but neither does retaliating by killing innocent children. I guess our expectation is that they just lay in the dirt they were "given" and just suck it up, not fight back? Supposedly Muslims attacked us on 911, America decided to invade IRAQ and kill hundreds of thousands of innocent people not to mention generations to come due to the depleted uranium we used. But at least we did not put all the Muslims in America into one state and completely cut them off from the rest of the world leaving them to survive only on what they could scrounge up. So what are peace activists doing with weapons on a peace mission? They were about as armed as Palestine is against Israel. They had pipes, knives, and some said they might have found a pistol or two. They were delivering aid to an oppressed group of people. That should not have ended in attacks and death. Back the heck off, inspect the supplies as they are delivered and stop allowing Israel to murder innocent people. God is on israel's side and HE will deal with their misdeeds If God supports the murder of innocent people we should all reconsider what we support. I don't think God supported Bush when he decided to order the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqi's. But I could be wrong. I don't mean to sound snippy, this just irritates me when we blindly support murder. These are Israeli children, look how cute they are as they write on bombs with cute little markers. This is the result of those bombs in Gaza And this... 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

who would jesus bomb? 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

 

allday --- 16 years ago -

Anything for prohecy!! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So back to the questions. 1. Why did they not follow the request to go to Egypt or Israel to have the cargo inspect by UN inspectors, Egyptian or Israeli inspectors? 2. Why did they choose to cross the blockade? 3. Why did they have weapons on board if they were peace activists? 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

I know it doesn't make it right but neither does retaliating by killing innocent children. So what would you do if you were in there shoes? I don't believe for a minuit that Israel goes out with the intent to kill children. But in a war Innocent people will die. That is a horrible fact of war. All they have to do to end it is just STOP..... Both sides. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

1. Why did they not follow the request to go to Egypt or Israel to have the cargo inspect by UN inspectors, Egyptian or Israeli inspectors? 2. Why did they choose to cross the blockade? 3. Why did they have weapons on board if they were peace activists? I have no idea but most likely because they knew the supplies would never reach Gaza. as for weapons, I'm a peaceful person and would never hurt anyone unless they attacked me but I still carry a pretty big gun. 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

I'm a peaceful person and would never hurt anyone unless they attacked me but I still carry a pretty big gun.  Thats a little hypocritical don't you think? 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

If someone was blindly lobbing something into your backyard that could possibly injure or kill you or someone in your family, would you not use overwhelming force to stop it? i.e. Your "pretty big gun" 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

Now, why would Israel have the right to board these nice humanitarian vessels sponsored IHH and Union of Good – well known Radical Islamist groups? Hmmm let’s see… November 2009: The cargo ship MV Francop rented by the Cypriot shipping company UFS (United Feeding Services)was captured by Israel enroute from Iran to Gaza. Among the innocuous items concealed in the humanitarian cargo onboard: (documented in link) * More than 2,000 107mm rockets * About 700 122mm rockets * About 700 fuses for 122mm rockets * About 5,700 60mm mortar shells * About 2,300 81mm mortar shells * About 780 120mm mortar shells * About 3,000 106mm recoilless artillery shells * About 20,000 hand grenades * About 570,000 rounds of light arms ammunition for sniper rifles and machine guns 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

and on this boat they have found bullet proof vests, night vision goggles and gas masks. Just the things that every peace loving families need. Now of course those supplies could have been replaced with food, shelter items, and gas, but what fun is that? 

rightwingdad --- 16 years ago -

Now of course those supplies could have been replaced with food, shelter items, and gas, but what fun is that?  Yea, and I guess the list above was for clearing land for a children's playground.. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground