Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is the oil spill obama's Katrina?

who's talking here?

Fallon 6
randyjet 14
steinhoister 1
Mr Mark 12
Mabbers 5
R.E.B. 4
SoupIsGoodFood 4
david 7
hummer 1
fergie 7
~sassy~ 39
Diamom 1
Perfection 1
JusticeForAll 5
Ogre1 7
jtcitrus 2
Polly Ester 1
evolved 6
mommie21g1b 3
Zombie Slayer! 7
*OH SNAP* 4
Dr Aborto 2
*emily* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is the oil spill obama's Katrina?

Was the govt slow to respond?

Yes Vote
 
 38.8% (19)
No Vote
 
 61.2% (30)
david --- 16 years ago -

Was the govt slow to respond?  

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Yes they were slow to respond. Is it his Katrina? No, this is a man made disaster that should have had a different response. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Hardly. For one thing we haven't seen the general incompetence that was displayed by the Federal Government after Katrina. The Coast Guard was on site immediately assessing the situation. Opinions to the contrary are wrong because they are ignorant of the facts of just how difficult it is to assess a situation in deep-water. The first 48 hours was a rescue op, after that this thing cascaded into what it is now. Throw in a failed blow out preventer and and degrading weather and the USCG has done a bang-up job of trying to contain something that was essentially uncontainable. I do think BP could have called on the fishing community a bit faster than it did, but we are talking about a massive organizational action that required coordination. NOW if you're just talking money and size of the general catastrophe, then I do think it will compare to Katrina. But I don't think Obama owns it. We all do. 

fergie --- 16 years ago -

Well I think the fishing community will be saying yes very soon on this one. The oyster beds will be complely destroyed and many off shore fish farms too. What a mess. The fishing community will have a devastating season. Will BP be responsible for their losses as well? What about the loss to Florida, Alabama and Mississippi summer tourism? Their economies really didn't need this just as the season was getting ready to start. Yes, I think the governments response should have been faster. The difference for me is that unlike Katrina the local government doesnt have the same authority in regards to offshore activities. Katrina was a failure of the local government and then became the federal goverments failure too. The federal government should have been on this immediately. If BP didn't have the necessary tools to deal with this. The federal government should have had other emergency backup on the scene day one. Even if that meant hiring out Exxon or other oil companies to help quickly contain the situation. Even if that meant more cost to BP. The bottom line in an emergency it needs to be handled. This has not been handled. BP had no back up plan, they banked on the blowout preventer. "BP is responsible for this leak. BP will be paying the bill," Obama Thats well and good the real answer we need it is when is this going to be handled. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Well I think the fishing community will be saying yes very soon on this one. The fishing community is actually mobilizing to help mitigate this. A large percentage of fishers have gotten training in laying booms, and if the weather cooperates they will be doing so. I also think this would have been a completely different situation if Mother Nature had cooperated. With the weather the way it has been, you can't burn the slick, it breaks up too easily, you can't boom the slick, the booms break apart in high seas, and you can't scoop the slick (with special boats) because these boats can't operate in high seas. They've been spreading chemicals that break down the oil itself from the air, but that is a very limited response... after all, last I checked the slick covered than 130 miles long and 70 miles wide (that's 9100 square miles). 

*emily* --- 16 years ago -

Maybe the slick could have been contained when it first happened. There were reports when it happened that it was only the equivalent of 200 barrels. I can't say who is to blame, but people are going to suffer for it. 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

I just heard on the news that BP told the Coast Guard if they keep pumping water on the rig, it will sink and cause major leakage. They say the coast guard ignored their warnings. My father-in-law, a retired engineer for Texaco, is perplexed as to why it is still leaking. He said there are so many fail-safes that there shouldn't be any leaks at this point. Could this be sabotage? A terrorist attack? What better way to hurt our economy, and make us more dependent on Middle East oils. But could someone like Al Qaeda pull this off? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I think Obummer's a pompas ass. He hates big oil and his little speech upon arriving at the scene made me want to puke. He and his bunch must be jumping for glee at this mess. We can kiss goodbye the opening up of other portions of the gulf for drilling now, betcha money. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Isn't this a private business/big business issue? I thought people were for "less government"? It's when issues like these come up and people start demanding a "nanny state" that I shake my head...lol. You can't have it both ways, people... 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Let's see. Katrina missed New Orleans and was not as bad as the CAT IV that was thought to be. The US Army Corps of Engineers was the resposible agency for the flood control and had assured all concerned that the levees it controlled were good. When the breach did occur, it took the news media to alert the local officials to the breach. The Corps had donwplayed the disaster. The LSU prof who had warned about the Corps deficiencies was kicked out of his job because he let the rest of the world know about the incompetence of the Corps. The Bush administration had contracted with a private Republican connected firm to establish an evacuation plan well prior to the storm. The firm got paid, but never delivered the report. It still has not done the work, but since they have political connections that doesn't matter. BP on the other hand fought against stricter government oversight and regs, lied to the government about the size of the problem, and is the sole responsible party for the spill. So how does the US government get to be blamed for what a private company has done and failed to do? It seems to me that the private sector cannot do its job and that government has to come in and do it for them. Thus proving that the private sector is worse in many cases than the government. At least we can have a vote on what the government does or does not do. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

The government can't do anything about this. They are no qualified, not by any stretch of the imagination. Just like the government didn't cause Katrina. And the morons who blamed Bush looked like fools. You never heard one liberal get ticked at Blanco, and she was 100% to blame for not allowing the Fed Gov into LA to help. The only thing the gov could do right now, would be to stem the flow of lawyers beating a path to the Gulf to start the law suits. This could very easily put BP out of business. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

How can you drill for oil and not have oil spills? It sucks (rather it spews) but it obviously happens and I'm thankful for the years between the major spills. They're horrific. But political? Only KU. The Rep looks just as bad as the idiots screaming to Bush during Katrina. LOL. Like he could've plopped right down in the middle with heavenly angels on his shoulders tossing out food and water. So now y'all are screaming Obama? Hahahahaha. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

BP's CEO is the worst of the worst. Denying safety issues, having the largest fines in history levied against his outfit, denouncing government constantly. NOW....screams like a little girl that he needs government assistance and partnership to stop his little leak. His smokescreen has lit up. 

david --- 16 years ago -

Just like the government didn't cause Katrina. And the morons who blamed Bush looked like fools. You never heard one liberal get ticked at Blanco, and she was 100% to blame for not allowing the Fed Gov into LA to help. I agree 100% i dont blame obama just wanted to show the liberals how silly they looked blaming bush for katrina. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

i dont blame obama just wanted to show the liberals how silly they looked blaming bush for katrina. Yeah but you can't. People have to see things for themselves cuz if you point them out, you end up looking just as they did. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

You can't have it both ways, people... Sure you can! That is why we got Bush. A guy for fiscal restrain running the national debt to new highs and doing nothing about it, all the while chanting no new taxes and balance the budget. Remember Reagan and his mantra about a balanced budget amendment? He ran the debt to FIVE TIMES what it had been previously, yet the idiots voted for him and believed him. Reality and logic have no place in some people minds. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Isn't this a private business/big business issue? I thought people were for "less government"? You mean like the banks Obummer bailed out? And Wall street thugs? 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Reality and logic have no place in some people minds. Or in politics. And it's BECAUSE of politics that ordinary citizens put on the mask of stupidity when they bathe in political tubs. Hey, to each his own. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

No RJ, the problem was the complete misuse of funds from the levee committees. For years and years they spent this money on anything but the levees. This is a fact, and was reported on extensively. And how stupid it is to even think that Bush worked with a Republican connected firm to take care of the evacuation? Stupid does not even cover this. It was never EVER up to any Rep to form an evacuation plan. It was up to the Gov of LA, a Dem, and the pos mayor, a Dem also. (he is pos because that is what is is btw, nothing to do with his party affiliation.) But NO is perfect example of what people become when they never have to rely on themselves. The more you have to rely on the gov the less you are able to think your way out of paper bag. These people went to the Superdome after being told they would have no supplies there. They showed up with no supplies for themselves either. They knew someone else would take care of them. Someone always does. You cannot with any credibility blame any part of Katrina on the Rep. Or really the Dems. It was the fault of corruption, and incompetent people at the local level, and more corruption. And then more corruption. The local levee board members spent that money, and they did so with no regard to fixing the levees. And sadly, I bet you not much has changed. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

My father-in-law, a retired engineer for Texaco, is perplexed as to why it is still leaking. He said there are so many fail-safes that there shouldn't be any leaks at this point. My Dh is an engineer & said the same thing. He said there is like 5 fail-safes to prevent these things. He is not a conspiracy theorist but he did say he thought it was VERY strange the big O came out and said he would support more off shore drilling and then this happens shortly after. I think they should be required to have a permanent type barrier floating around them at all times to help prevent the extensive damage of these type things. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

And it's BECAUSE of politics that ordinary citizens put on the mask of stupidity when they bathe in political tubs. Poor liberals, always gettin' mugged by reality. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

how silly they looked blaming bush for katrina. BUSH was in charge of the US Army corps of engineers who were in charge of the levees. He was also the one who established the budget for the Corps. In the military the commander is responsible for ALL things that happen on his watch in his area of responsibility. I recall the poor aircraft carrier captain in Oakland who had his vessel run aground when it was coming into harbor. It was the pilots fault for the grounding, but the captain got nailed for it since he was in command at the time. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

No RJ, the problem was the complete misuse of funds from the levee committees. For years and years they spent this money on anything but the levees. This is a fact, and was reported on extensively. And how stupid it is to even think that Bush worked with a Republican connected firm to take care of the evacuation? Stupid does not even cover this. well said 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

He is not a conspiracy theorist but he did say he thought it was VERY strange the big O came out and said he would support more off shore drilling and then this happens shortly after. Hmmmmmm, makes me wonder 

R.E.B. --- 16 years ago -

He said there is like 5 fail-safes to prevent these things. My father-in-laws also said there is at least 5 or 6 fail-safes. One of the last ones is something that completely crushed the pipe so that nothing gets through. It totally seals the pipe. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

These people went to the Superdome after being told they would have no supplies there. They were told to go there. They showed up with no supplies for themselves either. They knew someone else would take care of them. Someone always does. Their homes were underwater. You cannot with any credibility blame any part of Katrina on the Rep. FEMA is the ultimate authority in fed disasters just like they were in Florida when they did a good job. FEMA was stuck at a Sam's Club in Baton Rouge while Louisiana Wildlife and Fisheries and the Cajun Navy (hundreds of individuals with boats) floated in to New Orleans to save people. With that said Nagin is a criminal and Blanco tried but you got the story a little off. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The more you have to rely on the gov the less you are able to think your way out of paper bag. I guess that includes all those convention folks who got stuck in NO too. They tried to buy their own way out and had their chartered buses commandeered and then not let in. I would like to see how YOU would get your supplies with you walking for miles with enough food to last you and your family for many days. Of course these were folks without cars or means of transportation to get out. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Incorrect like usual. People went to the Superdome, and their homes were not underwater at the time. They went before the storm hit. They were told they could go to the Superdome as a last measure. But they were told to bring supplies, there would be none there. The levees broke later, then homes were underwater. There may have been some people who did show up after their homes were underwater. But very few. By that time, if they were rescued from their rooftops, they did not go to the Superdome. Why did FEMA do such a great job everywhere but LA? Does this really not make you think at all? Why is it only LA had a problem after Katrina? Did Miss, or Alabama? Why no. They asked for help before the situation was so desperate and before it was too late. FEMA did a great job there. Blanco and Nagin are beyond incompetent. They were too busy arguing to pick up the phone and ask for help. Bush called Blanco repeatedly to ask her to request help. She would not do it. She said it was Nagin who had to, and he said it was her. And do you really have any clue what it takes to move out a massive movement like what rolled into LA to help? Did they get to Haiti in a few minutes? These things take time, which is why governors call in for help far earlier, than what Blanco did. What was it, an entire week later before Blanco made the request for help? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

The more you have to rely on the gov the less you are able to think your way out of paper bag. T Oh you know it. And doesn't it strike you odd that these same people were just gifted the little homes they've been occupying how many years now? And they say long term welfare doesn't exist. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

And how stupid it is to even think that Bush worked with a Republican connected firm to take care of the evacuation? Stupid does not even cover this. I refer you to Greg Palast and his reporting on that. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Definitely a different vibe than Katrina. Obama isn't gonna get pinned for this. Not only is it man-made but this incident just proves why the Dems have been against Off Shore drilling this whole time. It was just a matter of time. Remember "Drill Here, Drill Now, Save Money"? A lady who rescues animals from the gulf said this morning that there have been 60 oil leaks/spills in the gulf since 2006. Yes, Obama was opening up to allowing limited Off Shore drilling but I think that idea will be put on hold for a long time. Anyone trying to pin this on Obama is looking for any excuse to make him look bad. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

But they were told to bring supplies, there would be none there. They brought their cigarettes but no diapers for their babies. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

You are wrong as usual RJ. And yes I would have walked my family out. They were given plenty of warnings. They were provided buses to get out on. Like it or not, some people are idiots. Many do not have cars that live in cities, which is why there were buses provided, to evacuate people. Did they need more? No doubt. Makes you wonder why Nagin and his office of emergency preparedness had no plan in place for this. Gee, the city is under water, wonder when they were going to get around to making an actual plan. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Of course these were folks without cars or means of transportation to get out.  and nowhere to go!!! It's not like the people who stayed behind had family in different places whom they could stay with during the evacuation...From the documentaries I've seen and news reports etc, most family members were in the same situation... So, where exactly were they supposed to go? and as Evolved said, they were TOLD to go to the SuperDome...and look what happened there? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

In the Superdome Dr. Kevin Stephens who was in charge of medical services said "we got babies, old folks, infirmed folks mostly in the dome" This was prior to Katrina hitting land. The Dr. had received e-mails from FEMA on smart device saying supplies were a day away. The supplies didn't make it til much later. The Dr. was communicating with the locals mainly Doug Thornton who was a Superdome manager and Marty Buhamonde(FEMA) who told local authorities the same. Pinning this on poor people is sad and typical of you folks. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

They had a place to go. The buses were taking them to Baton Rouge, and they had shelters set up for them. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

Yes they were slow to respond. Is it his Katrina? No, this is a man made disaster that should have had a different response. They were not slow to respond. 1st. Search and rescue started right away. Fire ships were on the scene right away. Clean-up would not have been needed if the equipment in place had worked. There are two pieces of equipment in-place 1st is to crimp the line the 2nd to sever the line to stop the flow. This lays squarely on the shoulders of B.P. not P.B.O. The fact that the admin got on board is the result of the size of the disaster and at the same time a call from Louisiana for assistance. The admin acted promptly to call the D.O.D. to bring in equipment and personnel. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

. Bush called Blanco repeatedly to ask her to request help. She would not do it. She said it was Nagin who had to That is only GOP spin and NOT close to reality. I suggest you remember that Bush was on vacation in Crawford and had no idea or concern about what was happening. To think that he was on the phone with those folks shows a fairy tale mentality. The main fault is with the Corps of Engineers since they did not report immediately to the local authorities that the levees had been breached. I lived in NO for a few years and used to drive by the levees that gave way. I remember looking at them and thinking that they were totally inadequate at the time. I am not an engineer and if I can see that they were not good, I don't think that it is too much of a stretch to think that they certainly knew they were bad. From what I recall, the Corps had asked for funds to improve them, but they never got the money for it, which is the responsiblity of Congress and the Feds. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

A portion of an article I posted once before..... Welfare state, the real disaster behind Katrina Televisions flashed with notable masses of vehemently disagreeing accusations. Jesse Jackson, in short, accused President Bush of racism. NBC's live telethon for the victims of Hurricane Katrina featured rapper Kanye West declaring, "George Bush doesn't care about black people." Mayor Ray Nagin, who could have very much prevented a considerable amount of this tragedy by ordering evacuation two days earlier, began swearing at everyone else but himself for not providing instant security. Could you imagine what might have become of a move, such as that? George Bush calmly placing 15,000 soldiers in New Orleans the day the storm hit. Every NAACP member, Rev. Jackson, every race hustler in America would have screamed "Racism!" This has been a century-long system that has incriminated white America into not succumbing enough. Over the years, 10 trillion dollars in social programs, racial preference laws and apparently, not enough to settle this bickering. This is not intended to raise the issues of questionable racism, but rather to enforce an obvious man-made disaster. This man-made disaster is not the lack of response by federal relief agencies and it certainly did not happen over the past weeks. This epidemic that has grown over the past four decades, clearly has brought to the surface a suffering problem in this country. The welfare state. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

They were provided buses to get out on. Not completely true. Nagin had hundreds of buses sitting idle. There was no plan. Some buses were made available by privates and were full. The school bus drivers ran out of town as fast as they could. Some cops stayed but not many. I saw scores of cop cars LEAVING with people desperate and flagging them down. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground