Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

AZ Immigration Law - Local News Video

who's talking here?

randyjet 8
Justwatching72 1
needrnr 4
maverick 2
d:-] 3
SoupIsGoodFood 2
david 3
justforfun 4
fergie 4
~sassy~ 7
ExLady In Blue 1
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 3
Perfection 1
Meme2my5 4
jmbtx78 6
evolved 3
Zombie Slayer! 3
Dr Aborto 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Here is a local news story on an AMERICAN BORN US CITIZEN taken to immigration because he didn't have his birth certificate with him. He provided the officer with a Driver's License and Social Security number but that wasn't enough. I agree we need Immigration Reform but how does this not violate our rights? Jump to the 2:30 mark.  

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

This is the reason the law is bad. It can and MUST be fixed by stating what documents are acceptable and have to be carried by ALL citizens and legal immigrants. The law has to be changed so that it is NOT at the cops discretion. If a person shows the proper documentation, they MUST be released. Right now, they STILL can arrest you even though you have the proper documents. I agree with the intent of the law which is to allow the cops to grab gang bangers, smugglers, and drug dealers just based on their knowledge of who and what they are. Without this law, the cops must observe them committing a crime or other violation in order to stop them. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

what documents are acceptable and have to be carried by ALL citizens and legal immigrants. I agree with that. I would be okay with the law if EVERYONE is asked for their Birth Certificate once they were pulled over. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I think a quick fix and a FAR better way is to require people to carry their voter registration cards. My wife already does this, it is small, proof of citizenship, and will get more people to the polls. The GOP might not like that part though. For those who cannot vote for one past misdeeds, they can get a small copy of their birth certificate instead. I already carry my passport since I go out of the country so often. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I think a quick fix and a FAR better way is to require people to carry their voter registration cards. Write down in Black and White what you need as a form of ID. A lot of people on KU said they just need a driver's license but it turns out you need more and it might depend from cop to cop. Illegals can't vote but their American Citizen family members do. I hope they send a HUGE message come election day. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

People steal stuff all the time, I would not want my self or children to carry their birthcert. All the states need to get together and figure out a way to make sure state id and dls are issued to only legal residents for the usa. If you are here on a visa only valid for 3 years, than that is your expiration. Those ids should be obvious just as a provisional license is for someone under 21. If a ssn card is issued it must be surrendered and be made a violation just as overstaying a visa if not returned. No valid state issued id, no official ssc, no work, no school, no social services of any kind. All the states need to protect their resources. It can start at one state and others can follow suit. I don't think there is any other country if I traveled to where I would not have to present valid id when asked. Why should the AZ or for the most part any other state be any different. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Voter registration cards can't be used, because their are people who are lawfully in the country, who are not able to vote. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

The law is unlawful. Immigration enforcement is a fed authority. Local cops can't do it, that's why it's unlawful. Where are the tea sacks on this government intrusion into the lives of the majority who are legals?? Are they too dark for socialism's ills? 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 16 years ago -

Can someone translate to me what the Mexican truck driver said. TIA lol 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Voter registration cards can't be used, because their are people who are lawfully in the country, who are not able to vote. If you are NOT a citizen, you ARE required to carry your passport and visa. That is Federal law now. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

We have the Real ID Act which I fully support, and this will be enough to establish your right to be here with just your drivers license. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The law is unlawful. Immigration enforcement is a fed authority. Local cops can't do it, that's why it's unlawful. The cops cannot arrest you on the basis of Federal law, but by making it a STATE law, they now can do so. They are NOT arresting you for being here illegally, just for not having the proper documentation on you. It is up to ICE to prosecute you for being here illegally. Any challenge on this ground I think will fail. A better way and which will get it tossed is for being too vague, and discriminatory. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

The fed is the only authority that can regulate immigration. So, all the Fed. have to do to squash the law is to reject any of the folks arrested by Arizona cops. Easy Peasy. The Arizona law is giving Arizona cops the right to start the ball rolling on immigration regulation. That's a NO-NO. 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

Where are the tea sacks on this government intrusion into the lives of the majority who are legals?? So...having the courage to pass a bill enforcing a current federal law is a government intrusion? Interesting argument. Arizona simply passed a law enabling them to be more aggressive than the idiots in Washington, past and present, who refused to enforce our borders and do something about illegal immigration. Don't forget the word "illegal" as most people do when referring to the illegal immigration problem. To randy's point...it probably does need to spell out what is acceptable and what is not, but then the argument changes to (insert whiny voice) "but it's not reasonable for me to carry id with me...where's my civil rights lawyer?" /whiny voice 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

Arizona simply passed a law enabling them to be more aggressive than the idiots in Washington, Sorry, doesn't fly! Only the fed can regulate immigration. It will be shot down. 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

The Arizona law is giving Arizona cops the right to start the ball rolling on immigration regulation. That's a NO-NO. I don't understand why people are so upset that someone finally had the courage to start enforcing our laws and borders. Seems that people are so worried about offending someone that any law enforcing borders is too scary. Like someone posted here a few days ago....it's time to stop doing the politically correct thing and start doing the right thing. 

fergie --- 16 years ago -

Can someone translate to me what the Mexican truck driver said. TIA lol While I did understand what he was saying he certainly did not speak like he was "born in the usa". I am sure that it was a part of the confusion. His wife stated that he was arrested "because he did not answer the questions right". I would like to hear from both sides as to what actually happened that led to the arrest. Listening to the "victim" and the liberal bias media it sounds terrible. Maybe it was. Randy is this the same guy you were talking about several days ago or is this another truck driver arrested the same way. The reporter said that it was immediately AFTER the law was passed. 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

Only the fed can regulate immigration There's nothing to regulate - it's black and white. either you're here legally, or you're not. It's a crime to be here illegally and now Arizona can be more aggressive in getting them kicked out. Regulating immigration is a federal procedure - too bad the illegals don't follow procedure and just walk in. 

maverick --- 16 years ago -

Why didnt you post the video of the demostrators hurling bottles and rocks at police?????? If the US government WILL NOT protect our borders, it is EVERY citizens duty to help. This includes state, local and county agencies. It is everyones duty to help uphold the laws of our land. Arizona is NOT regulating ANYTHING they are simply helping the Feds out where they are currently negligent. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

While I did understand what he was saying he certainly did not speak like he was "born in the usa". He spoke with an accent. It's hard to understand the movie Fargo because their accent is so thick. Same thing goes with people from Boston. 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

Why didnt you post the video of the demostrators hurling bottles and rocks at police?????? Because it wasn't a Tea Party. Remember, the message promoted by the White House and their media lapdogs is that one idiot at a Tea Party with a bad sign speaks for all members. However, hundreds and/or thousands of violent leftists are just angry, and not representative of anything. It's quite the double standard.... 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

It's shocking that the Tea Partiers, the ones against "BIG Government infringing on our Rights" are loving this bill. 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

It's shocking that the Tea Partiers, the ones against "BIG Government infringing on our Rights" are loving this bill. You do realize security and border enforcement is part of the government's mandated duty, right? That would be why we love the bill...it's actually conforming with the government's responsibilities. Or maybe you'd be happier if I just said this was covered under the Commerce Clause? 

jmbtx78 --- 16 years ago -

Same thing goes with people from Boston. Not to mention they're usually wasted... =) 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

Arizona is NOT regulating ANYTHING they are simply helping the Feds out where they are currently negligent.  That's not what we are arguing. They are asking Citizen A for special documents that they are not asking Citizen B for. Rights are being violated. 

fergie --- 16 years ago -

From the US Department of Homeland Securities website: We work diligently with our partners from other local, state, Federal, and international law enforcement and intelligence agencies to identify individuals who may pose a threat to the U.S. and prevent their entry or, detain and remove them. As you see, our commitment to border security does not start or end with the inspection of persons at a port-of-entry. Our strong working relationships with other Federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies, international law enforcement agencies and other governments allows the INS to safeguard our nation's borders, taking a global approach. This is especially apparent along the northern border because of our close relation with Canada. The Arizona governor said that they had written, called and faxed the President asked for help and they were not even shown the decency of a reply. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 16 years ago -

He spoke with an accent. It's hard to understand the movie Fargo because their accent is so thick. Same thing goes with people from Boston. So your telling me this is a Fresno, CA accent? 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

That's not what we are arguing. They are asking Citizen A for special documents that they are not asking Citizen B for. Rights are being violated. You are assuming that everyone that gets stopped is legal. More are illegal than are legal but our laws have turned a blind eye until now. 

maverick --- 16 years ago -

That's not what we are arguing. They are asking Citizen A for special documents that they are not asking Citizen B for. Rights are being violated. They are not simply walking up to or pulling over anyone of dark persuasion and asking for documents. IF you are pulled over or stopped for probable casue and cannot produce the normal documents required - then further investigation is warranted. Why would ANYONE not want to regulate our borders from foreign invaders??? Not all are your chummy gardner coming to mow your lawns. The Feds arent doing it. SOMEONE has to. 

fergie --- 16 years ago -

So your telling me this is a Fresno, CA accent hahahaha exactly I have friends who are hispanic who were born here and they don't sound like that. In fact I know a lot of hispanics who were not born here who came here as young children and teens who have lost a lot more of their "accent" than this US born citizen. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 16 years ago -

In fact I know a lot of hispanics who were not born here who came here as young children and teens who have lost a lot more of their "accent" than this US born citizen. That would be me. I was born in Mexico and brought back home to Texas. I was taken to Mexico to be born there bc my paranoid father thought I was going to be a boy and feared I might be drafted to war against Mexico...lol 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

So your telling me this is a Fresno, CA accent I'm from Southern California and his accent isn't unique. Sound like a lot of guys I went to high school with. In fact I know a lot of hispanics who were not born here who came here as young children and teens who have lost a lot more of their "accent" than this US born citizen.  I know people from Texas who sound normal and some that sound totally country. Same thing. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Some will be inconvenienced but if for the greater good, so be it. My pocketbook doesn't like the inconvenience of caring for illegals, yet it is. They'll get over it, just like Americans have been forced to get over supporting illegals. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I keep saying this, I see nothing wrong with enforcing the laws that are on the books. If you're legal, no problem but if you're illegal you have problems. All the kinks will be worked out and I do hope other states follow suit. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

If you're legal, no problem but if you're illegal you have problems. All the kinks will be worked out and I do hope other states follow suit. ditto! 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Lol on the fresno california accent. I actually lived there. There were many people who lived there transplants from oaklahoma and texas. The parents had those accents and the kids did too, but never been to ok or tx. I loved that he didn't answer the questions right...his mother lived in mexico... I think there should be some checks and balances, but this was not thought out well enough and proper training was not given to the enforcers of this law. Tg she brought her papers she would be sharing the same"detainment" facility. Check id for vagrancy, traffic violations, (and any other criminal activities) distibution of public services, and employment. At a weigh station I could see the validity in having a check point there. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Oops I forgot the video said he was detained.... 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

The bill does not even take affect until August. No doubt here the left wouldn't wait for the facts to come in. lol So predictable. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I agree we need Immigration Reform but how does this not violate our rights? OUR rights???? We've been having our rights snickered at by illegals for yearrrrrs. I think it's a violation of MY rights in being forced to pay taxes that support their illegal arses. MOST Americans will not mind the inconvenience. The greater good, don't forget. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground