Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Another thought on why December 25th was the first Christmas

who's talking here?

eterry2 1
needrnr 1
Zionist NightOwl 5
Donkey Hodie 15
justforfun 1
Bloggin_Mom 1
Ogre1 19
JohnLynch 30

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

"When they had heard the king, they departed; and, lo, the star, which they saw in the east, went before them, till it came and stood over where the young child was. When they saw the star, they rejoiced with exceeding great joy. And when they were come into the house, they saw the young child with Mary his mother, and fell down, and worshipped him: and when they had opened their treasures, they presented unto him gifts; gold, and frankincense, and myrrh." Matthew 2: 9-11 the first Christmas was celebrated by the Magi as they worshiped Jesus and presented Him with gifts. what was this star that they saw in the sky? "All but one of the nine Biblical qualifications for the Star have now been plausibly satisfied: 1. The first conjunction signified birth by its association to the day with Virgo "birthing" the new moon. Some might argue that the unusual triple conjunction by itself could be taken to indicate a new king. 2. The Planet of King's coronation of the Star of Kings signified kingship. 3. The triple conjunction began with the Jewish New Year and took place within Leo, showing a connection with the Jewish tribe of Judah (and prophecies of the Jewish Messiah). 4. Jupiter rises in the east. 5. The conjunctions appeared at precise, identifiable times. 6. Herod was unaware of these things; they were astronomical events which had significance only when explained by experts. 7. The events took place over a span of time sufficient for the Magi to see them both from the East and upon their arrival in Jerusalem. 8. Jupiter was ahead of the Magi as they traveled south from Jerusalem to Bethlehem. But the ninth qualification would require that Jupiter stop over Bethlehem. How could a planet do that? And did Jupiter do it? To Stop a Star The problem with a planet stopping is not what you might think. The problem is not that planets can't stop. Just the opposite. The problem is that all planets are always stopped to the eye of a human observer. The sky moves above Earth at half the speed of the hour hand on a common clock. Its movement is imperceptible to the naked eye. So, if all stars are always stopped, what can Matthew have meant? Perhaps you have already anticipated the key to this final mystery: retrograde motion. An astronomer tracking the movement of planets through the star field watches not so much on the scale of minutes, but on the longer scale of days, weeks and months. On this scale of time, Jupiter did stop. On December 25 of 2 BC as it entered retrograde, Jupiter reached full stop in its travel through the fixed stars. Magi viewing from Jerusalem would have seen it stopped in the sky above the little town of Bethlehem." source - very interesting reading 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

also, i can find no references to Dec 25th being a pagan holiday in 2 bc 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

also, i can find no references to Dec 25th being a pagan holiday in 2 bc Have you ever read about Saturnalia? True, it wasn't celebrated on Dec 25th in 2 BC, but it was celebrated Dec 17-23, and then later, several hundred years AD, Christians of the time began to celebrate the birth of Jesus at the same time of Saturnalia, because they ""wished the date to coincide with the pagan Roman festival marking the 'birthday of the unconquered sun'." The festival was celebrated with similar customs (gift giving, feasting) that are done to celebrate Christmas today." 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

True, it wasn't celebrated on Dec 25th in 2 BC as i said, Dec 25th wasn't a pagan holiday. it seems like the pagans moved their holiday to coincide with the Christmas celebration 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

On December 25 of 2 BC as it entered retrograde, Jupiter reached full stop in its travel through the fixed stars. Magi viewing from Jerusalem would have seen it stopped in the sky above the little town of Bethlehem. So Jesus was born in 2 BC? Uh oh, that means 2012 is really next year. 

Bloggin_Mom --- 16 years ago -

Happy Winter Solstice to you all!!!!! 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

Happy Yule. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Merry Christmas 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

as i said, Dec 25th wasn't a pagan holiday. Actually it was. In Ancient times, Dec 25th was the day for many pagan trads that the winter solstice was celebrated (Kind of like how we celebrate holidays on the first or third thursday, this was a DESIGNATED holiday as opposed to the actual solstice... allowed for all the priestly things that had to happen which the "headcount" were not involved in.) The date of actual Winter Solstice was (is) based on a lunar calendar and not a solar calendar. As such, they moved around. This date varies between December 20 - 22 in the Northern Hemisphere and June 20 - 22 in the Southern Hemisphere. This year it just happened to fall on the 21st. Happy Solstice back to you Bloggin_Man. Additionally the ORIGINAL Roman calendaring system is something that I'm not even going to try to explain. There was actually a separate priesthood JUST to calculate the calendar. It wasn't until Julius Caesar that the calendar was standardized. Up until about 200 AD Christmas was celebrated at different times depending on the nation/church/tribe, generally around May. Never have found out how or why that changed. But the earliest mentions that Christmas was celebrated on Dec 25 was about 350 A.D. Of course, I've always said that the primary reason that the celebration of Christmas was set on Dec 25 (or thereabouts) was political in nature as it gave the pagans, whom the church was trying to lure in, an alternative celebration to attend after Constantine made the solstice celebrations illegal. Fact of the matter is, for every Christian celebration there is a Pagan celebration that it was trying to supplant. Nothing unusual about that, the church needed members and it was competing with something that people were comfortable with. Offer the poor peasant hope and food at the same time and some are BOUND to turn up. Additionally, celebrating Christmas on Dec 25 is NOT universal. The Eastern Orthodox church celebrates Christmas on Jan 7. Again, a difference in calendarial opinion. Even more entertaining, countries such as Japan and Korea celebrate Christmas in spite of NOT being Christian nations. Any excuse to party I guess. Dec 25 has never been meant to be the actual birthday of Christ. No one knows when that is. Christmas is meant to be a celebration OF the birth of Christ for those whom which this is important. As to the Astronomy. I'll leave that to the Astronomers. This is just another theory that someone has thrown out there. So be it. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

WHY is this topic dangerous??? Are some of you afraid that your lack of faith may make Christmas mean that much less for you??? PATHETIC. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

Actually it was. not in 2 bc But the earliest mentions that Christmas was celebrated on Dec 25 was about 350 A.D. nope, it was first celebrated about 2 bc. Dec 25 has never been meant to be the actual birthday of Christ. i didn't say it was Jesus' birthday. i said it was the first Christmas. also, Dec. 25th has been indicated as the date for Christ's conception So Jesus was born in 2 BC? where did you get that? i think it is very clear that the post said that the Magi visited Jesus on Dec 25th. nothing about being His birthday 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

nope, it was first celebrated about 2 bc. So you're saying that Christmas was first celebrated 2 years before Jesus was born? 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

So you're saying that Christmas was first celebrated 2 years before Jesus was born? what makes you think that Jesus was born in 1 a.d.? did you go and read the source? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

But the earliest mentions that Christmas was celebrated on Dec 25 was about 350 A.D. nope, it was first celebrated about 2 bc. You have no way of know that. As I said, the earliest MENTION of the celebration being on Dec 25 was the fourth Century. Dec. 25th has been indicated as the date for Christ's conception If it has been, then it's something I've never seen. The most common date used for Christ's conception is MARCH 25, which is 9 months before Dec 25 and another source of Dec 25 as JC's Birthday. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

You have no way of know that. yes, i do. it is recorded by Josephus and in the Bible, backed up by astronomy If it has been, then it's something I've never seen. very easy to google Elizabeth (John's mother) was in her sixth month of pregnancy when Jesus was conceived as described in Luke 1:24-36. Zacharias (John's father) was a priest serving in the Jerusalem temple during the course of Abijah (Luke 1:5). which would be June 13-19 of that year. during this time of temple service Zacharias learned that he and his wife, Elizabeth, would have a child (Luke 1:8-13). After he completed his service and traveled home, Elizabeth conceived as recorded in verses 23-24. it is assumed that John the Baptist was conceived in late June because he was born around Passover. adding 6 months to John's conception would give us a late Dec. conception for Jesus 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

So you're saying that Christmas was first celebrated 2 years before Jesus was born? Most scholars think that JC was actually born between (if I remember this correctly) 4-1 bc and not on the 0 year. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

and not on the 0 year. there was no zero year in the Gregorian calendar nor in the Julian calendar 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

it is assumed Therein lies the problem. Again, these are dates that are quite simply unknowable. Even well-educated biblical scholars cannot agree on them. Your single source is just yet another theory. And I seriously doubt that you have an in-depth understanding of Astronomy to double-check your "source". That would be some pretty impressive math, and let's face it JL, you ain't that impressive. Plus, how could the Magi visit JC on Dec 25 if he was CONCEIVED on Dec 25, that doesn't fit the story in the bible at all unless Joe and Mary stayed at the manger for three months. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

there is no zero year Don't be obtuse, you know what I mean. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

how could the Magi visit JC on Dec 25 if he was CONCEIVED on Dec 25, that doesn't fit the story in the bible at all unless Joe and Mary stayed at the manger for three months. The magi didn't visit Him immediately after His birth [edited to add: i.e., they didn't arrive immediately after His birth]. He was already in a house, and was described as a "child" rather than as an "infant" or "baby". Plus, Herod sought to have all the male children under 2 killed, which would indicate that Jesus was anywhere from a few months old to 2 yrs. at the time of the magi's visit. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

it is assumed Therein lies the problem. the assumption is a very good one and is within a few days And I seriously doubt that you have an in-depth understanding of Astronomy to double-check your "source". don't need it. if you read the source, you will see that the dates can be obtained using computer software based upon Keppler's calculations That would be some pretty impressive math, and let's face it JL, you ain't that impressive. and you think that you are? i see no math skills from you Plus, how could the Magi visit JC on Dec 25 if he was CONCEIVED on Dec 25, that doesn't fit the story in the bible at all unless Joe and Mary stayed at the manger for three months. read the Bible. "And when they were come into the house". they were in a house when the Magi came. the manger is a trough for feeding animals which was used as a crib for Jesus. why couldn't they be there for three months? there is NOTHING in the account to preclude that. we do know that by Jewish law that Mary had to still be there 41 days after the birth of Jesus so that she could accomplish "the days of her purification" 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

and was described as a "child" rather than as an "infant" or "baby". Just to clarify. . . In Luke 2, in the account of the angels and the shepherds, we see the word "baby" or "infant", as in "Ye shall find the babe (Greek, Brephos) wrapped in swaddling clothes lying in a manger". In Matthew we have the account of the Magi's visit, and throughout the chapter, we see the word "child" or "young child", as in "And when they were come into the house they saw the young child (Greek, paidion) with Mary his mother". 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

what makes you think that Jesus was born in 1 a.d.? did you go and read the source? You are the one who made the claim, you are the one who should provide the evidence. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

You are the one who made the claim, you are the one who should provide the evidence. i really don't understand what you are trying to say here, but i made no such claim that Jesus was born in 1 a.d. and i did provide the evidence for what i posted 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

i really don't understand what you are trying to say here, but i made no such claim that Jesus was born in 1 a.d. and i did provide the evidence for what i posted You said that Christmas was first celebrated in 2 BC. First, I'd like to see evidence of that. Second, celebrating Christmas in 2 BC supposes that Jesus was born before 2 BC. I'd also like to see evidence of that, too. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

You said that Christmas was first celebrated in 2 BC. Not to answer for JL, but I read that as JL saying that, technically, somebody was celebrating it--Mary and Joseph, the angels, and the shepherds. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

and you think that you are? i see no math skills from you Nope, and you never will. I HATE math. the assumption is a very good one It's STILL an assumption which indicates doubt. The problem Lynch is that you confuse faith with fact. And by doing so you cheapen your own faith. The FACT is, for every theory you find, there are ten more that say something else. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

You said that Christmas was first celebrated in 2 BC. the first Christmas was celebrated by the Magi as they worshiped Jesus and presented Him with gifts in 2 B.C. this celebration is recorded in the Bible as well as by the Jewish historian, Flavius Josephus. Herod died in 1 BC and since Herod died shortly after Christ's birth, Jesus would have to be born BEFORE 1 B.C Second, celebrating Christmas in 2 BC supposes that Jesus was born before 2 BC. I'd also like to see evidence of that, too. per the evidence of the source website, Jesus was born in September of 3 BC. when the Magi visited Jesus in December of 2 BC he would be a toddler, as described in the Bible Not to answer for JL, but I read that as JL saying that, technically, somebody was celebrating it--Mary and Joseph, the angels, and the shepherds. the somebody celebrating the first Christmas was the Magi 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

The FACT is, for every theory you find, there are ten more that say something else. the fact is, this theory has the backing of both the Bible and of scientific fact 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

his theory has the backing of both the Bible and of scientific fact I'm sure all the others do as well. Instead of simply latching onto this ONE, why don't you do a bit more research. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure all the others do as well. proof? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

proof? I'm not doing that work for you. It's a simple matter of looking for other theories. If you're not willing to do that, then no amount of "proof" will make any difference because you're just being your usual dogmatic self. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

I'm not doing that work for you. lol, it doesn't surprise me that you don't know what you are talking about. i have studied this, and this theory is the only one that includes the positioning of the planets in conjunction with the scriptures of the Bible. and this theory backs up others that derived these dates without using Keppler's mathematics 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

It doesn't surprise me that you're too lazy to do real research and that you'll latch onto some pseudo-science that you know nothing about and simply believe it. BTW.. it's Kepler's Mathematics, not KepPler. So once again you are just parroting someone else's findings without any real understanding or in depth knowledge of the subject. I also find it entertaining, the use of Kepler's theories to prove the true date of Christmas when the book he published these theories in was considered heresy by the church. (and that his mother was tried as a witch!) 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

It doesn't surprise me that you're too lazy to do real research and that you'll latch onto some pseudo-science that you know nothing about and simply believe it. LOL, so now astronomy is pseudo-science. hahaha. but you believe in evolution - the largest pseudo-science there is. hahaha So once again you are just parroting someone else's findings without any real understanding or in depth knowledge of the subject. LOL, that statement makes absolutely no sense I also find it entertaining, the use of Kepler's theories to prove the true date of Christmas when the book he published these theories in was considered heresy by the church. not "the" church - a church 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Never mind I figured it out. Maybe not? Lol 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

not "the" church In the 17th Century, THE Church. Mainly because it didn't matter what sect of Christianity one practiced, they ALL contributed to the crimes that are called witchcraft trials. And the pseudo-science isn't the astronomy, it's the methodology in which it is used and the importance that retrograde motion is given. For one thing, Each Jupiter retrograde period lasts about 4 months, and happens every 9 months. And since the other five planets visible from Earth ALSO have retrograde motion, I seriously doubt that this was so unique that the Magi would take notice of it as a significant event. SO, while there is some evidence to support this theory, much like evolution, this theory ALSO lacks something. Much like you, John. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

For one thing, Each Jupiter retrograde period lasts about 4 months, and happens every 9 months. And since the other five planets visible from Earth ALSO have retrograde motion, I seriously doubt that this was so unique that the Magi would take notice of it as a significant event. again, you have NO idea of what you are talking about "On 14th September 3 BC and 17th February and 8th May in 2 BC, Jupiter the King planet stood next to Regulus the brightest star in Leo, which also represented Royalty. Then came a climax to the display. On June 17th 2 BC, Venus and Jupiter, the two brightest planets in the Solar System, appeared to collide. They stood an Incredible 1/50th degree apart and seemed to fuse into one immense ball of Light. This was an unprecedented event. But that was not all. On 27th August in 2 BC there was a grand meeting of the planets In Virgo. Jupiter and Mars were only 1/7th degree apart and close at hand were Mercury and Venus standing together in the glare of the rising sun. This dramatic sequence of events ending in Virgo qualified for the Star spoken of by the Zend Avesta. But then Jupiter left the other planets in the dawn, and started to move to the West. This was the sign the Magoi were waiting for. Jupiter the key player in the Christmas star sequence was leading them towards Judea. And so they set out. From that moment in Mid-November, Jupiter the King planet actually went before them in the sky towards Judea. Six weeks later, as the Magoi checked the pre-dawn sky, Jupiter was on the Meridian due south of Jerusalem. It would appear directly over Bethlehem 65 degrees above the southern horizon. And just at that time, the final event occurred. Jupiter had reached its furthest point westward, and no longer moved against the background store. It actually 'stood over' where the young Child was. Incredibly, on that same day, the Sun was at its furthest point south for the year, and "stood still" in the heavens (for that is what the word 'solstice' means). Jupiter was again in the constellation Virgo,as the Zend Avesta predicted, when this occurred on 25th December in 2 BC. It was a unique sequence of events that had landed the Magoi at Bethlehem." that unprecedented event means that it hadn't previously happened NOR has it ever happened again it seems to be that when it comes to Biblical topics especially (and others, such as science) that you are just parroting someone else's findings without any real understanding or in depth knowledge of the subject they ALL contributed to the crimes that are called witchcraft trials. NO, they didn't 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

"On 14th September 3 BC and 17th February and 8th May in 2 BC, Jupiter the King planet stood next to Regulus the brightest star in Leo, which also represented Royalty. Then came a climax to the display. On June 17th 2 BC, Venus and Jupiter, the two brightest planets in the Solar System, appeared to collide. They stood an Incredible 1/50th degree apart and seemed to fuse into one immense ball of Light. This was an unprecedented event. But that was not all. On 27th August in 2 BC there was a grand meeting of the planets In Virgo. Jupiter and Mars were only 1/7th degree apart and close at hand were Mercury and Venus standing together in the glare of the rising sun. This dramatic sequence of events ending in Virgo qualified for the Star spoken of by the Zend Avesta. But then Jupiter left the other planets in the dawn, and started to move to the West. This was the sign the Magoi were waiting for. Jupiter the key player in the Christmas star sequence was leading them towards Judea. And so they set out. From that moment in Mid-November, Jupiter the King planet actually went before them in the sky towards Judea. Six weeks later, as the Magoi checked the pre-dawn sky, Jupiter was on the Meridian due south of Jerusalem. It would appear directly over Bethlehem 65 degrees above the southern horizon. And just at that time, the final event occurred. Jupiter had reached its furthest point westward, and no longer moved against the background store. It actually 'stood over' where the young Child was. Incredibly, on that same day, the Sun was at its furthest point south for the year, and "stood still" in the heavens (for that is what the word 'solstice' means). Jupiter was again in the constellation Virgo,as the Zend Avesta predicted, when this occurred on 25th December in 2 BC. It was a unique sequence of events that had landed the Magoi at Bethlehem." Even if all of this is factually correct, (which, frankly, I don't care enough about to expend the effort to fact-check, and with your track record with reality, I sincerely doubt it's veracity,) that means your biblical writers still got it wrong when they said a new star appeared. C'mon, God, the Eternal Father and Creator of the Universe can't convey the difference between a new star and and converging planetary refractions to His human scribes? It's a pretty weak God who can't get his attributions correct. It all smacks of a ret-con to me. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

that means your biblical writers still got it wrong when they said a new star appeared. the Bible doesn't say NEW star now who is it that is the one who is out of touch with reality? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground