Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

world history in 6th grade?

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
Carla 1
Momof3 1
smartypants 1
eterry2 1
planemom 1
CIA_DUDE 1
ladybughomeschool 5
POTUS 4
Mommikynz 1
mommie21g1b 1
I wish I was an oompaloompa 21
Zombie Slayer! 1
Nancy Botwin 1
KWnewbie 1
Dr Aborto 1
~bigla~ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

My son was joking and said he wanted to be a Suni Muslim..I said "well I sure hope not, since you have already made your commitment to Jesus." Then he went on to tell me that the 3 major religions worshipped the same god and that their books: the bible and the koran (sp?) all teach the same thing, they just use different words. And That Islam is a religion of peace. Just wondered opinions on this. Would this be shocking to you or do you think that this is what our children should be taught?  

~bigla~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't think that this should be taught until a child is in college...as an adult, they can listen and make better decisions...this is why it is so important for families to be unified and strong in their beliefs...children will be exposed...and if they are not morally strong or are missing this piece...they will be more easily swayed. There is a church in KW that my son has many friends at...they have great activities that appeal to teenagers...he has been invited to go and we let him...all the while reminding him that he is a catholic as he is walking out the door. We found out recently, that this church, at some point in the evening "invites" the kids who have not "been saved" into a room and tries to encourage them to sign up to be baptized. I was disgusted...these are 12-14 y/o's. I asked my ds if this has ever happened to him when he was at an activity. He said "yes". I asked him what he says and he said, I tell them that I am already baptized and I will be confirmed in 2 1/2 years. I was proud that he could handle himself so well...but I have heard how uncomfortable it makes some of the kids...Also, as a parent of a young teen, I think that I should be informed of the churches intent...VERY NERVY!! imo 

ladybughomeschool --- 16 years ago -

Since I homeschool my kids I am not faced with someone else teaching about different religions. I do not think I would be upset as long as Christianity got equal time and no religion is emphasized over another. We are Christians and my kids have all accepted Christ but I do not keep knowledge of other religions away from them. We have friends that are Jewish and Muslim and we have visited their places of worship. Above all I teach my children to respect the beliefs of others. We are Protestant but I would love to take them to a midnight mass this year so they can have one more learning experience . 

mommie21g1b --- 16 years ago -

What is wrong with this in a world history class? I don't get it? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

I'd have a problem with a history book that says the Bible and the Koran teach the same things. They don't. I don't have a problem with teaching how the different religions influenced history. Was there any mention of Buddah or Confusious? They also influenced world history. 

Nancy Botwin --- 16 years ago -

Could be worse. He could want to be an oompaloompa. 

freshhell --- 16 years ago -

Could be worse. He could want to be an oompaloompa.  Oh yeah! Your kid is using his brain, Iwiwao. He has given you an opportunity to have a good discussion. Don't ya just love smart kids?! 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

Just to correct one error here....In 6th grade in Humble ISD, the kids take a Geography class, not a history class. most geography classes do teach the students about the religions in the area that they are studying. 

ladybughomeschool --- 16 years ago -

Your kid is using his brain, Iwiwao. He has given you an opportunity to have a good discussion. Don't ya just love smart kids?! I am very sure that her kid is super smart but how is it "using your brain" to regurgitate what you have been taught by an "approved" , politically correct curriculum. I feel like a child using their brain would want to research the subject before making a commitment to something just because it is new and different to them. I like kids who question the curriculum rather than swallow it. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

We are currently doing our project about a winter holiday in Iran. Instead of going with the obvious Muslim holidays, we have decided to research the religion of Judaism in Iran. It is one of the oldest holidays in Iran with many biblical references. Because we have family that immigrated from there in the 70s, this is very interesting. My child is amazingly smart and I am glad we had this opportunity to set some things straight. Unfortunately, he does trust that his teachers are teaching him 100 % truth. He respects his teachers and looks up to them. Teaching history in any realm is difficult without adding opinion. Just an FYI, this is not Humble ISD. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

I like kids who question the curriculum rather than swallow it. Unfortunately, public school does not encourage questioning of curriculum. This is one of the many reasons we are seriously considering homeschooling. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Bigla- Sorry that you feel this church is pushing an agenda on your child. You should be proud that he is grounded in his faith and can feel free to vocalize his stance! 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

What is wrong with this in a world history class? I don't get it? I do not disagree with learning geography, culture and religion. I just disagree with the teacher saying that the three main religions are basically the same and their religious books teach the same principles. This was confusing to my son. He then thought that Judaism and Islam were the same as Christianity. They are not. I prefer to be the spiritual guide for my 11 year old. (I am very involved with their religious activity as well as educational activity). 

ladybughomeschool --- 16 years ago -

Unfortunately, public school does not encourage questioning of curriculum. This is one of the many reasons we are seriously considering homeschooling. It was the best decision we ever made. My two younger children are taught by me but my oldest son goes to a classical education school one day a week and does his work on his own the rest of the week. The lectures are socratic so that discussion and questioning are encouraged.The kids get counted of if they DO NOT ask questions and discuss. My ds is 14 and we were just looking for something for him to do for a while until he started dual credits at 16. He loves it. He asked me a few days ago if he could remain at the school until he is 18 and get college credit through CLEP. It involves a lot of writing and research but he is doing wonderfully. Here is the link if you are interested. link title 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

thank you ladybug...I am researching and plan to make a decision pretty quickly. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

My son was joking and said he wanted to be a Suni Muslim I think your son was pulling your chain to get a reaction. I wonder what would have happened if you said, "Well, in that case I guess we will have to make some changes. I won't be wearing a burqa when we go out, so I guess someone else will have to take you to the [insert activity like movies, mall, basketball game, doctor's appointment here]. I need you to give me all your books and computer games, because someone besides your father and myself will determine if they're appropriate. I'll cancel the cable TV too. Here's a prayer rug and an alarm clock. Make sure you set it for 5 am so you're not late for your morning prayers. Let us know which charity you want your allowance to go to." 

ladybughomeschool --- 16 years ago -

I am researching and plan to make a decision pretty quickly You can come by the store anytime if you need info. i am always happy to help. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

tell them that ALL MUSLIMS ARE TERRORISTS!!!! tell them that they will BURN IN HELL if they dont choose the right faith. also if they question their faith then they must not really be saved, so they are probably going to hell anyway. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Zombie Slayer, Have a blessed night! I will be praying for you. May critical thinking and context clues overcome you as you post!! 

Mommikynz --- 16 years ago -

My DD is in 6th grade in Humble isd. They were taught about all of the different religions. She never said to me that they were the same. I'm sorry your son is confused over that "I wish....". 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

What?!?!?! You're saying that your son is learning about other cultures and religions in a WORLD HISTORY CLASS? Say it aint so! Maybe you should pick up his history book to better understand how other people lived outside of Texas. 

ladybughomeschool --- 16 years ago -

What?!?!?! You're saying that your son is learning about other cultures and religions in a WORLD HISTORY CLASS? Say it aint so! Read the whole thread. She did not have a problem with her child learning about different cultures in is the incomplete, politically correct curriculum she is having an issue with. She also had a problem with her kid being told the the Koran and the Bible were the same. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Thanks ladybug :) I could go into the whole spill about how I love all people. And I respect religion and history, but I do have a choice on the way it was presented to my child. But I won't (haha, I guess I just did). But I really don't need to respond to the true haters on this thread!... Mommykinz, thanks. I am just sad that the teacher added her opinion into the history lesson. I read the history book and it did not state any of the things that I felt were alarming. 

CIA_DUDE --- 16 years ago -

They teach this all over again in the ninth grade. I would not really be to worried. This is the time where your child is most influenced and starts to gain his independence. Just help guide him and tell him what he needs to understand more clearly. For example the fact that the three books do not teach all the same thing. Nothing to worry about though :)they teach all religions in world geography ninth grade. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

She also had a problem with her kid being told the the Koran and the Bible were the same. Well, the religions technically ARE the same, once you break them down. Both religions are just organized forms of social & moral control, based on books of fiction all revolving around an invisible man who MUST BE WORSHIPPED OR ELSE. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

POTUS, I respect your opinion. We live in such a great country where we are free to worship or not. I do feel sorry for you that you have chosen to not seek out a relationship with God and in fact think that you have the right to tell others that if they do believe in God, they believe in an "invisible man". How about when your child goes to public school, they hear that they are filled with sin and will not enter heaven unless they accept Jesus.....HHHMMM, probably inappropriate for a public school to use time and money to push a religious agenda. I take my child to church every week as well as have daily discussions with him. I do not need a teacher adding her two cents in when he is this age. I recently took college Sociology, where my professor was an atheist. As he was teaching his material, he peppered his lectures with snide remarks about Christianity. I did not need his opinion in that situation either. I paid to learn Sociology, not what some over grown, self absorbed hippie who had never read the bible had to say about MY GOD. 

Momof3 --- 16 years ago -

Just to correct one error here....In 6th grade in Humble ISD, the kids take a Geography class, not a history class I have a 6th grader - the class is called 'Social Studies' which is a combination of History AND Geography. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Well, the religions technically ARE the same, once you break them down. The Koran is in fact NOTHING like the bible. I do know the history of both books and that we share lineage from Abraham. Muslims believe that Jesus was a phrophet. But if this is what they believe, then they must also believe that Jesus was mentally ill. Because a prophet would not say and do the things that Jesus did....Jesus could have chosen to not speak the truth about who he was. When he did, he knew he was going to die. I could go on and on, but you are not truly ready to hear the TRUTH, but that is okay. Jesus still loves you! 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Maybe you should pick up his history book to better understand how other people lived outside of Texas. I am very interested on learning how other people live outside of Texas, and in fact outside of the US. I hope to eventually move outside of Texas and I will be doing medical missions in Africa as well as Central and South AMerica. I have read parts of this history book, it is great. I DO NOT NEED A TEACHER TO ADD HER OPINION TO THE CURRICULUM. These are 11 year old children. Their parents are still responsible for their spiritual guidance. I pay school taxes and support my school in hopes that my child will get a good education. I am going to speak with this teacher today. I sincerely hope this was a big misunderstanding and that my child was confused on the material presented....We will see. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Steve, thank you! TO the naysayers: I would think that whatever religion you are or are not, you would agree that parents should take an active interest in what their children are learning. We should speak daily with our children and answer any questions that they have. That as children, they have the right to TRUE information that the teacher is qualified to teach on.... 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

I don't know about complaining to the teacher and school... I think this story's been played out and worn thin already. Look, if one chapter in a public school history course is enough to turn around the belief systems YOU'VE spent years brainwashing your kid with... than YOU HAVE FAILED AS A PARENT. It's not the schools fault, it's not the teacher's. Your kid is asking questions and starting to think for himself, IT'S PERFECTLY HEALTHY AND OKAY. Nothing bad is going to happen. Everything will be fine. Except for the burning in hell for all eternity because your kid didn't worship the invisible man blindly, of course. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Look, if one chapter in a public school history course is enough to turn around the belief systems YOU'VE spent years brainwashing your kid with... than YOU HAVE FAILED AS A PARENT. It's not the schools fault, it's not the teacher's. Your kid is asking questions and starting to think for himself, IT'S PERFECTLY HEALTHY AND OKAY. My child was not thinking that he should convert to Islam because he had studied it and understood the principles that is was built on. He made the statement that ALL the religions were the same and he said that religion was just called something different in the Middle East. SO if he was a Christian in the US, it was the same thing as being a Muslim in Iraq.......This is wrong information...NOT TRUE...whether you are Islamic, Jewish, or Christian you would not believe this was true...Is this point lost on you? Do you think the Middle East is teaching their children that Christians are just the same as them? That it is okay to explore other religions and that we all believe in the same God? When you wake up in Islamic America in twenty years, call me. I would love to reminesce and say remember when. I love that my children are free thinkers and incredibly smart. The school loves all my children because they ace that required state test every year and make the school district look better. Because I love my child and it is commanded by God that i guide him into adulthood, I will continue to teach him the values and religion that I KNOW to be true. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

don't know about complaining to the teacher and school... I think this story's been played out and worn thin already. No I guess I should just keep my mouth shut and let the school district decide what is best for my child....I mean I am not qualified to raise my child in the manner I see fit... insert sarcastic font here! 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

Except for the burning in hell for all eternity because your kid didn't worship the invisible man blindly, of course. Christianity is not about blind faith, it about living out your faith for all the world to see. Loving your neighbor as yourself and loving God above all things......Praise God that my children have made that commitment! 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

SO if he was a Christian in the US, it was the same thing as being a Muslim in Iraq.......This is wrong information...NOT TRUE...whether you are Islamic, Jewish, or Christian you would not believe this was true...Is this point lost on you? Actually, if this were the SAT test, it could be argued that-- Christian : US as Muslim : Middle East In basic regards, they are both comparable and equal. It seems like you're just wanting to be outraged because the class didn't come right out and declare Christianity to be greater and more peaceful than Islam. To me it sounds like both religions were addressed on a level playing field, saying they were equal. I really doubt that the course tried to portray them as both being identical in beliefs and practices, though. Do you think the Middle East is teaching their children that Christians are just the same as them? That it is okay to explore other religions and that we all believe in the same God? When you wake up in Islamic America in twenty years, call me. I would love to reminesce and say remember when. I don't really see religion being mainstream anymore in decades to come. Sure, there will always be strong sects and movements, but I'm pretty sure human kind is going to do away with literal interpretations of the Bible and Koran soon. The availability of REAL information and understanding of actual history/science is going to win out in the end, mostly due to the internet. Believe it or not, we're not very far away from the death of organized religion as we know it. There'll never be an Islamic America. People like you will make sure there is a religious war to prevent it and thin out both sides, letting them all lose credibility. I'm not even being mean, this is just what I believe. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

I really doubt that the course tried to portray them as both being identical in beliefs and practices, though. Apparently you do not understand!!!! THis is what was taught to my child. That though the practices were different they were basically the same in beliefs and principles. I have no problem with my child learning culture and religion, but I do not need the teachers interpretation of her personal beliefs added to the curriculum. Believe it or not, we're not very far away from the death of organized religion as we know it. This may be your wish but this is not backed up with fact. Do you know about the underground Christian church in China? These people are not risking death on a fad. The availability of REAL information and understanding of actual history/science is going to win out in the end, mostly due to the internet. I am a licensed nurse. The more I study the body the more I believe that there is a God....Science proves to me that there has to be a creator. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

It seems like you're just wanting to be outraged because the class didn't come right out and declare Christianity to be greater and more peaceful than Islam. I do not rely on the school to teach Christianity to my child....that is my responsibility as well as my church. You may try to speak to me as if I am some religious, narrow minded, hate filled idiot.....but you could not be further from the truth. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

I am a licensed nurse. The more I study the body the more I believe that there is a God....Science proves to me that there has to be a creator. Agreed. That does NOT validate the Bible's fairy tales, however. That's where most people go wrong. You may try to speak to me as if I am some religious, narrow minded, hate filled idiot.....but you could not be further from the truth. Not at all. I just don't see how someone who is supposedly grounded in their faith and conviction to "teach Christianity to my child" can feel threatened by some 6th grade world history teacher/lesson. It shouldn't be any surprise that the public schools are handing out bad, politically correct information. 

Carla --- 16 years ago -

It sounds like the teacher has been watching too much Oprah. But that is the big push right now, that all religions and all paths to God are the same. I think that I should be informed of the churches intent...VERY NERVY!! imo  I'm a little confused by a couple of things. First, what do you think the purpose of the church, any church, should be? To be the members' social coordinator? Churches are not only charged with helping members in their spiritual growth, but also to spread the Good News. Just in case there is still any confusion, if your child goes to a church function there is a 99 percent chance they are going to hear the Gospel. You are offended that someone asked if your child is saved? Are you saying that you don't believe in the plan of salvation? A Christian is a follower of Christ. Someone who believes that he died for our sins and that one must accept that gift for salvation. So are you saying that you are a Catholic but not a Christian? If you're a Christian, why would someone asking your child that offend you so much. My hope for my girls is that they all come to accept Christ when they reach the age of understanding. "The" Church is the body of believer and which particular building you go to worship in is not important as long as the group is doctrinely sound and helps you grow in your faith. So if my girls decide to make a different denomination than the one we attend now their church home when they are adults, I'm not going to look at it as a tragedy. I've attended Mennonite, Baptist, Methodist, Evangelical Free, and flat out nondenominational churches. The label on the door isn't important. What is being taught inside is. 

I wish I was an oompaloompa --- 16 years ago -

I just don't see how someone who is supposedly grounded in their faith and conviction to "teach Christianity to my child" can feel threatened by some 6th grade world history teacher/lesson. It shouldn't be any surprise that the public schools are handing out bad, politically correct information. I agree, sadly I am not surprised that this is happening in the US. I was shocked to see it happening in a school district I have specifically chosen and until now trusted not to have an agenda. 

page 1 2
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground