Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Dog Breeds - Question

who's talking here?

Carla 1
outermaga 3
GCan 8
Fiona 1
Fallon 1
randyjet 1
QueenCassie 3
Sandyr9111 1
♥Blessed 4 Ever♥ 1
njjk 6
Clown Vomit 2
SchoolMom 1
HuntersMommy♥ 6
RX8LVR 1
3monkeysmomma 1
ExLady In Blue 2
Scottie's Hottie 1
Lillabeth 12
Paige Paige 1
my3kiddos 3
JusticeForAll 2
jtcitrus 4
Polly Ester 2
I_Am_You 2
Cowboys Wife 5
AshleyTHEPrincess$ 1
karma 9
JTC 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

GCan --- 17 years ago -

My youngest has been asking for a pet of his own. We already have a JRT but she's partial to the oldest child. Given yesterday's break-in issue, I'm wondering if perhaps we should get a dog that would be more imposing that our Trixie. But how do you choose a dog that will be wary of strangers and alert to problems but is still good around children and another dog? 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

You can go talk to Pampered Paws about different breed temperments. I know Goldie are really sweet but I am not sure how imposing they will be. Steve loves Dobie's for this reason. The one his boys have is great with the kids and you could get them trained to be protective. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Go to the rescues, look for a lab mixed with something protective like a chow or shepherd. there's the wary of strangers part... is still good around children and another dog Depending on the mental condition of the dog you adopt from the shelter (and how young it is) that's mostly up to you and how well you socialize/train it. As long as you understand that no matter how much you love them they're DOGS and need an ordered Pack environment, nearly ANY dog will love it's entire pack... ...not always so easy to make it love non-pack members though. 

I_Am_You --- 17 years ago -

We have a boxer and I'm very partial to boxers and boxer mixes. He is a big ol brindle boy with a lean rock build. Snarls barks and bears teeth at anyone who knocks that isn't one of the family. He is also the biggest, goofiest, most lovey dovey baby ever! I 100% trust him to do his best to alert me to an intruder AND be the most gentle companion to us. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

We have a boxer and I'm very partial to boxers and boxer mixes I never met a 5yo boxer I didn't love... never met a less than 3yo boxer that wasn't so high energy as to be the most annoying... very sweet dogs, just brace yourself for the energy! 

Carla --- 17 years ago -

We have a German Shorthaired Pointer/Lab mix (at least we think that is what he is) and he is great with the girls, even my youngest who is always hanging on him. I don't know if he'd attack an intruder, but he definitely let's us know when someone comes to the house. He even barks when people walk by on the street. He has a scary big dog woof. He is very protective of my youngest and will start barking if she gets upset. I thought it was just her, but if we have him out and he sees another small child crying he wants to go and make sure they are okay. I've read that that is a trait of the GSP's. He is very sweet tempered and likes other people and dogs. While he is protective of his family, he is not aggressive. I'm not sure what he would do if we were threatened though. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

See had them happened a few days earlier i could have gotten u an awesome dog! lol Id say no on the Chow. They have a tendency to be a lil squirrelly and not real trustworthy sometimes. 

3monkeysmomma --- 17 years ago -

I'd be wary of chow mix with kids also. We had one that was absolutely the sweetest dog, with the kids and us. One day out of the blue, with NO provocation (I was standing right there) he turned and bit my then 2 yo in the face. Fortunately only grazed her but he could have torn her face off. It was truly scary. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Id say no on the Chow. Our former neighbor had a beautiful chow and exceptionally well trained but he was always warning my kids when they would come around her that just because she looked fluffy didn't mean she was friendly. I appreciated him taking a responsible and realistic approach. By contrast we had another neighbor that had a pit bull that "would never harm a fly."...that was until she bit their daughter in the face. 

Fiona --- 17 years ago -

OMGoodness G you have to see the puppy found in crosby she is a heart melter. on the adorable puppy to adopt thread. TOOO CUTE. 

my3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

We adopted an adult female lab and have been blessed with the best dog. She has a loud and mean bark at the door for strangers but lets the kids take a nap using her as a pillow. She is the most easygoing and lovable dog. The only downside is that she sheds. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

Boxers look intimidating to many people, but I can't say that ours would make a very good "protector" - our Cocker Spaniel would bite someone before she would! Lol! As far as boxers, Labs, etc go though- they have really high energy levels. Up until about 3-5 yrs old, they are truly a handful. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I would check with the local rescues and let them know what you are looking for temperament wise, and see if they have one that has been in foster care for a little bit so they would have a good feel for how they are in the situations you have outlined. I had an awesome Lab/Chow mix that I got from my local SPCA. She ended up being one of the best dogs I ever had. She was good with children, and other dogs, but strangers beware. Of course, I used to let our friends know that she would scare the crap out of you from the other side of the door, but if anyone ever got inside they could be sure they would probably be licked to death. ;-) She really sounded ferocious, so whenever we had a repairman in and I was at the house by myself, I would let them know, "she'll be fine as long as I'm here to protect you." 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

I was going to suggest Boxer to GCan but I know her well enought that she wouldn't be able to hang with all the slobbering they do.. LOL! 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I was going to suggest Boxer to GCan but I know her well enought that she wouldn't be able to hang with all the slobbering they do.. LOL! Lol! Boxers are such awesome dogs,but the slobber would drive her nuts! Mine also sheds like crazy. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Since I'll be having a slobbery baby in a few months, a slobbery pooch might be a little much. Are labs too "nice"? Seems like everyone I've ever seen is super friendly. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I would suggest a pure breed if you want a specific kind of temperment. The dobermans are great watch dogs, German Shepherds, Belgian Shepherds Tervuren. I am partial to Tervs since they are great watchdogs and love people too. Some German Shepherds can be squirrely as is the case with somem pure breeds. Golden retrievers are great with kids and everybody, including burglars. I love them dearly, but they are not good for protection. 

my3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

Mine will bark incessantly if there is a dog/person/package, basically anything out of the norm in sight. There is a definite difference in her 'stranger bark' and her 'I know you bark'. The 'stranger bark' makes the baby cry and scares the older kids. The run of the mill 'I see a squirrel' bark is not scary at all. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

GCan, if you are considering a Lab, I would highly recommend getting one from a rescue that is a few years old. With a new baby on the way, the last thing you will want is a Lab puppy. They are a LOT of work,and require so much attention, exercise,etc. They dig and chew if they get bored. 

JusticeForAll --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

my3kiddos --- 17 years ago -

I second that. We got ours at around 3 yrs of age. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

We had a lab puppy and had to give her away to a better home that had a bigger yard, other labs and no children. My son was a toddler and the lab was too much dog for us at that time. He managed to make the back yard look like the surface of the moon, ate up the rain spouts, and had a tendency to escape. It was hard for me to manage him. Dobermans have always scared me and I guess that's probably the way it's suppose to be because I've heard from their owners that they are great dogs. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

As for larger breeds, I've always been partial to German Shepherds because they appear highly intelligent and well behaved when necessary and mean when the need arises. I don't know if that's the result of training or it's normal disposition. 

JusticeForAll --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

njjk --- 17 years ago -

Most dogs are naturally going to want to protect their territory. Just know that if you go with a specific breed, while it may be a good protection dog, it will need lots of daily exercise. Working breeds such as the Dobies and Shepherds are just that, working dogs and will need to be exercised daily or they will get bored and that's where destructive and behavioral issues can come in. Retrievers are sweet and "soft" dogs but will too bark at strangers and such. They too require a lot of exercise. Certainly don't forget about the many mixed breeds. They make great family protectors and pets too. While each breed has their own described characteristics, not every dog behaves as their "description" might say they should. I've known some fairly aggressive Retrievers and some super submissive and fearful Shepherds and Dobies. Each and every dog is different. My suggestion... Get a good alarm system and adopt a good ole' family dog :) 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

I had an awesome Lab/Chow mix that I got from my local SPCA. She ended up being one of the best dogs I ever had. She was good with children, and other dogs, but strangers beware. ditto! My lab/chow loves everyone, but penned the roto-router guy to a tree and wouldn't let him leave! [Master didn't let you in bub, so STAY PUT!!!] I can't recommend a mix enough - just be aware of the set of probable traits: lab/chow = 90% AWESOME family dog; Rot/Pit = 30% AWESOME family dog. Id say no on the Chow. They have a tendency to be a lil squirrelly and not real trustworthy sometimes. Yes they're very independent and extremely intelligent, but they're loyal to the pack and the property. 9/10 times when things like "it turned on us" happen, it's b/c it doesn't know it's place, or it was provoked. WHATEVER YOU CHOOSE, REMEMBER: They're not members of your family... They're members of your pack. If you don't know the distinction, adopt a pure lab. [disclaimer: a pure breed is no guarantee of temperament/behavior... you just have better odds] 

JTC --- 17 years ago -

As you seem to realize, what you need is med to larger dog with a deep bark who will SOUND threatening and who will be concerned with what is going on. Most burglers will pass up a house if the dog inside seems threatening. Dogs I would not consider are Chows and Akitas both can be unpredictable around children/guests and Akitas tend not to bark at intruders anyway. Some labs would fit the bill but others tend to be so laid back that they would not be intimidating at all. Goldens really aren't great watchdogs and are more than likely to welcome someone in. Dobermans are great watchdogs as are German Shepherds but Dobermans tend to develop serious health problems which is a shame because IMHO they are the greatest dogs. A Boxer would serve you well too...great family dogs. You really have quite a few options and I agree with getting a mature dog a puppy isn't going to intimidate anyone anyway and older dogs (assuming they have at least some training) are alot less work. I would contact some rescues and see what they have available. I would also recommend a dog of the opposite sex of your JRT as those little dos can be scrappy. 

SchoolMom --- 17 years ago -

we have a boxer too. Great with kids. Definately intimidating (but wouldn't hurt a fly). The do have very high energy levels up until about age 4-5. They are very goofy and all love to give kisses. Mine doesn't slober at all though. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

No way you need to add a dog to the mix right now. You have a baby on the way, and this really will be too much, imo. I would not get another dog until after this baby is born. Then you will all have the time and energy a new dog will take. You know we love our lab, but they are like having a drooling 120 pound toddler, for life...lol Our dog would scare anyone away who tried to come into the yard that he did not know. Even those who do know him, are leary to just come on in when he barks and growls. (he usually growls and barks with his wubby in his mouth, but you can't see that when he is inside:) He sounds very intimidating. It would be easier cheaper and all around more effective to get a monitored alarm on the house. 

I_Am_You --- 17 years ago -

My boxer is going to be 3 soon and is honestly VERY laid back and he does not EVER lick people. Period. Ever. Not Allowed. Icky. He is a strange strange dog though (and I am a strange strange dog trainer hehe). To be perfectly honest the most loving and protective dogs I have ever known have been the brink of death breed. You know the ones I mean: starving, beaten, unloved, given up on humans, ready to pass on. I know its so old hat to say "rescue dogs will love you more than any other dog", but its the truth. 

njjk --- 17 years ago -

I would not get another dog until after this baby is born. Then you will all have the time and energy a new dog will take. I agree. Adding new dog to the family is quite an undertaking. And...we have so much over breeding in our area that unless you're prepared to spend some big money on a good quality dog, you really will not be able to rely solely on a breed's standard. So many people breed now just for money and not for quality anymore. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

We just got our sweet Ruby (black lab) Friday and I am so in love with the little maniac already! 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

I hear Pet Fair in the Woodlands Mall has some good deals right now. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Thanks to everyone who had helpful advice. I'm not sold on anything at the moment especially a pure over mixed breed. I believe both types have their positive attributes. I am not going to a "breeder" (backyard or otherwise) as their are plenty of dogs that could be good pets given the right opportunity. The only reason we have a purebred JRT is because I clicked on an thread from LTP where she had posted about a found puppy that no one had claimed after several weeks. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Pet Fair in the Woodlands Mall do NOT buy your dog from a puppymill distributor... or you know, mall pet store. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

DH wouldn't let us buy an animal from the mall. He says they are not taken care of, unhealthy, etc. I absolutely HATE seeing all of them crowded into this little, unclean kennel. 

HuntersMommy♥ --- 17 years ago -

We have dobies and absolutely love them. Ours love us and the kids so much but if someone tried to grap one of us its on! 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

do NOT buy your dog from a puppymill distributor... or you know, mall pet store. I buy all my pets and their supplies from there. I'm probably the sole person keeping them in business. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

German Shepherd or Doberman hands down. I own a rescue GSD who puts up with a husky and a pit bull terrorizing him daily, and rolls over for little kids. He also lets strangers and suspicious people know they are not welcome anywhere near me. greater houston GSD rescue houston area doberman rescue 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

HuntersMommy♥ --- 42 min ago - quote - flag comment We have dobies and absolutely love them. Ours love us and the kids so much but if someone tried to grap one of us its on! So do we!! We have two Blue Dobermans and Huskey. All three are great around the kids and big babies towards us. Now if anyone tries to break they had better be a outstanding runner. They also are great with our friends or even an new person that comes over. As long as we or our kids give the "Go ahead" they're fine. Our Huskey is useless as far as being a guard dog. He would just lick the person to death, but I love my fluffy Bolt. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground