Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should police officers be responsible for responding to calls for assistance with mentally ill

who's talking here?

planemom 1
Justwatching72 1
Zionist NightOwl 2
d:-] 1
Brennan 1
RX8LVR 2
justforfun 4
Perfection 10
Jrzygrl 1
JusticeForAll 1
Ogre1 6
JustGoWithIt 6
moltobella 5
mommie21g1b 1
just lisa 1
river chef 2
*OH SNAP* 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should police officers be responsible for responding to calls for assistance with mentally ill

Should police officers be responsible for responding to calls for assistance with mentally ill patients? With the recent murder in San Jacinto County by a mentally ill man who killed his family then himself there are calls that the police didn't take the calls from the family seriously. Are police officers whose job it is to uphold the LAWS be used to transport mental patients that families cannot control?

Yes, police should be responsible for handling mentally ill patients without even knowing what illness the person has, what meds they take or don't take and other clinical items. Vote
 
 66.7% (22)
No, the family should call an ambulance and have the person transported to a mental facility if they are unable to control them. Vote
 
 33.3% (11)
Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Should police officers be responsible for responding to calls for assistance with mentally ill patients? With the recent murder in San Jacinto County by a mentally ill man who killed his family then himself there are calls that the police didn't take the calls from the family seriously. Are police officers whose job it is to uphold the LAWS be used to transport mental patients that families cannot control? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

If the person is not breaking any laws, he is only off his meds and the family cannot control him he is not breaking any laws therefore the police are not the right folks to call. Somehow I think there is more to this, you don't go that insane to kill your family and yourself from missing one dose of medication, therefore the family should have known that he was unmedicated long before he committed these crimes. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

To those of you voting yes. What laws is the man breaking that would warrant police being removed from doing actual police work to go there? Not what MAY happen, but what laws is the man breaking by not taking his meds? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

What if this question was: Do you agree that it is appropriate for police to be called for someone refusing medication? Would you answer the same? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Do you agree that it is therefore appropriate for the police to be called if you refuse to medicate either yourself or your child for the H1N1 or any other mandated vaccine? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

The question is too generic Chunky. There are WAY too many variables. In the case you're speaking of, do you think a paramedic could have dealt with a dangerously violent individual? IF the person is a danger to themselves and others, then that is well within the duties of law enforcement, "To ensure public safety." I know that the police get called when my mentally challenged sister gets violent. And a person refusing meds CAN result in a violent confrontation. So what SPECIFICALLY is your issue here? I'm not clear what you're trying to get at. If mom refuses to take her Prozac and is crying a lot, well, maybe not. But is paranoid schizophrenic uncle Bob with the chain saw collection goes off his Thorazine and is receiving instructions from the space aliens... LEO might oughta know. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

i guess the police shouldnt respond to suicide calls either. or help scared children, since no crime is being committed. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

Technically a police officer can't do anything until someone actually commits a crime so my response is no. The police should only be called in the moment the person gets violent. Typically police don't help transport mental patients, they arrest people and take them to jail. If that's what the family wants then that's the only thing they should have to provide. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

In the case you're speaking of, do you think a paramedic could have dealt with a dangerously violent individual? The family did not describe him as dangerously violent. If the family were that worried, they could have left also. And a person refusing meds CAN result in a violent confrontation. Agreed, however at what point should the police intercept a "potentially" violent person before anything is proven? As a pseudo attorney you should understand that the police have to be sure of crimes before they can act. If they act too soon they are more often criticized. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

i guess the police shouldnt respond to suicide calls either. Suicide is a crime...... BUT when I was a dispatcher we would send an ambulance to transport them. Depending on the situation, if we feel it will get violent, then we send an officer. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

Why is this even a poll? Just tell us why you don't think they should and be done with it. This "poll" is ridiculous. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

i agree with ogre. its not a black and white issue. i bet if you ask a local sheriffs deputy, they wished they had responded. and this is a pretty biased poll, but i responded yes anyway 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Why is this even a poll? Maybe you should make a poll of that question. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

police have to be sure of crimes before they can act. As a former Military Police officer, I know that's not true. I've responded to numerous "Acting suspicious" calls, all of which turned out to be pointless. Police can only ARREST someone if there is evidence of a crime already being committed, but that doesn't preclude them from responding to various types of non-crime calls. And quite simply, police CAN respond to ANY complaint. PD should respond to any call that involves a potentially violent person. Every time. After all, how do they determine if a person is potentially violent if they don't investigate? And LaPorte and Deer Park PD's have arranged transport on several occasion for my little sister to mental health facilities. No, they don't put her in a patrol car, but they do supervise the ambulance. As to the San Jac case, I don't think we have enough information to really know what was going on. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

Here's a story..... There was a call one night that a woman wanted her husband removed from the house because he was acting strange. He kept walking around the house checking to make sure the windows and doors were locked. She said he was crazy but he wasn't being violent and he wasn't breaking any laws. It was his home also so he couldn't forcefully be removed from the property. The only thing the police could do was ask him if he would leave for the night. He refused. Their hands were tied. The next day he killed his wife, shot her child in the driveway when she tried to run and then killed himself. There are situations where a police officer can't do anything. It's the families responsibility to use good judgment and know when to get a family member help. She should have stayed with a friend for a few days, something.. and maybe this wouldn't have happened. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

Maybe you should make a poll of that question. You're not that important. lol I'm just saying this is obviously yet another thinly veiled attempt to grandstand on an issue, so why pretend you're actually considering other opinions? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

The only thing the police could do was ask him if he would leave for the night. There are other things they could have done. There is ALWAYS a way to take someone into custody. Always. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

There are other things they could have done. There is ALWAYS a way to take someone into custody. Always. Why would they have? He wasn't acting violent. Literally the only sign he was giving was the locking of the windows and doors. That could be an OCD thing. There was no reason for anyone to believe that he would do something violent. If the wife decided to stay then she obviously didn't feel in any real danger. It's situations like this that's in the gray area. Yeah, they probably could have arrested him for SOMETHING but they were given no reason to. Would you have arrested him for making sure his windows and doors were locked? Something that gets me.....Why do people not listen to their intuition anymore? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

If the wife decided to stay then she obviously didn't feel in any real danger. That's the exact point. If I had been an officer on the scene, I would have asked the woman if she felt safe alone in the house with him. (If she did, then why did she call?) If not, then I would offer to see that she made it to a shelter where she would be safe (or with friends, as moltobella suggested). Why was she only wanting him out of the house? 

RX8LVR --- 17 years ago -

I think part of their job description is to protect and serve... 

RX8LVR --- 17 years ago -

They are having the funeral services today in Cleveland. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Would you have arrested him for making sure his windows and doors were locked? Maybe, depends on how concerned the wife acted and what his demeanor was. 

Justwatching72 --- 17 years ago -

If the person is not breaking any laws, he is only off his meds and the family cannot control him he is not breaking any laws therefore the police are not the right folks to call. um yeah...he is... 5150-- danger to himself and others, that's ll the cops need to take him away... thanks for playing.. 

just lisa --- 17 years ago -

As a pseudo attorney you should understand that the police have to be sure of crimes before they can act. ridiculous statement and untrue. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

If the family says he was out of control #1 why did they stay and #2 why did they not get him help. You can have someone committed if you think they are a danger to themselves or others. At least they would be under mental supervision, etc. 

JusticeForAll --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

#1 why did they stay and #2 why did they not get him help. #1 - maybe they had no place else to go. Or no way to get there. Or maybe they were scared he'd hurt himself. I can do this all night. #2 - maybe they had no $$$$$ to afford to get him help. And getting someone committed in Texas is not as easy as all that. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

The police can't even haul off illegals (law breakers) how can they haul off someone who is not breaking a law? 

Jrzygrl --- 17 years ago -

I called the cops on my crazy neighbor who stated she wanted kill herself the suppousdly she went to go check herself into an institue then she came home like 2 hours later and I know good and well she never went! I have done a few suicide watches in my military time. Then when she did get home she took out a rifle out of her car wasn't pointing it at anyone. Cops said there wasn't anything they could do because she wasn't threatening anyone. She took the gun out of her and had it outside for a few minutes then brought into the house. 

d:-] --- 17 years ago -

The answers in your poll are too detailed. Police should be called when someone is in danger of being harmed. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

The police can't even haul off illegals (law breakers) That's a completely different issue. It's a political problem, not a legal one (or more accurately, the legal issue is subservient of political issue). 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

It's the families responsibility to use good judgment and know when to get a family member help Isnt calling the police getting help? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Isnt calling the police getting help? How can the police help with a clinical problem? 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

Isnt calling the police getting help? How can the police help with a clinical problem? I was responding to Molto Bella's story about the woman who said her husband was acting strange and then killed his family. I am not saying it was or was not right for the cops to not show up, but if the woman called the police - she was trying to get help. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

This discussion just makes me think that there should be more resources out there for people dealing with mental health issues. Sometimes in the moment you just know something is wrong and do not know who to turn to. Both in the case of the San Jac family and the woman killed by her husband, I am sure if they knew of a better place to turn for help in the moment they would have. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

So, and here is the fun part. Since the majority believe that it is acceptable for police to be used in situations where someone feels another person's lack of medication is causing a potential issue - they must also feel that the government mandating which vaccines you have given to your children is acceptable and if you refuse, they can use police force to ensure that the medications are given. All for the greater good of course. There is a potential for the child to get something and give it to another. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Should the police respond if someone is in danger? Yes. If a person is legally required to take medication but won't that person should be institutionalized. There are not enough police officers on the job to make medication enforcement part of their duty. When people call 911 because someone didn't take their medication and is now violent they should tell the operator. This way the police have an idea of what to expect. It is not the job of a police officer to determine that if John doesn't take his medicine he's going to kill his family so we need to arrest John. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Where is the responsibility of the family? It seems no one wants to take blame for being negligent. It isn't the job of the police to make someone take meds. Maybe the family should have called an ambulance and had this man taken to the hospital for observation. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

Clearly Chunky had a different agenda with his poll and did not want to have a discussion about mentally ill people and the police. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Clearly Chunky had a different agenda with his poll and did not want to have a discussion about mentally ill people and the police. Chunky is a girl. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground