Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Keith Olbermann's Special Comment on Health Care Reform

who's talking here?

maverick 6
lizandmike 1
Donkey Hodie 5
david 1
justforfun 2
~sassy~ 6
Perfection 2
Wilstar77 2
Agent of Change 1
Warren Peace 1
Former CofC Member 5
JustGoWithIt 14
JohnLynch 1
NewNanna 2
james osterberg 1
JeffSpicoli 1
river chef 22
Zombie Slayer! 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Please watch/listen to this entire presentation before commenting.

 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

Fantastic. it made me look at the folks who disagree with me about this a new light. the part about meeting his friend outside of the cancer center broke my heart. this situation has become shameful. ps, i watched last night. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

ps, i watched last night. As did I,too bad it will fall on deaf ears to those 90% of people covered by Insurance that have never had a Major event with first hand experience dealing with the communist healthcare insurance denial industry. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

ps, i watched last night. I did too. I agree with what he says. I don't agree with public option, but I do think the government needs to come up with ways to help the needy buy affordable health care without jeopardizing all of us being thrown into Government run health care. Look what the government's done to Medicare. Bankrupt in 8 years. Why would we trust them to run a much bigger health care system....a MASSIVE system? Why would we tust them to do that? 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

thats what gets me, is people opposed to health care reform defend the insurance industry and their practices. i understand a philosophical difference on the role of government, but to say that everything is fine, and that the insurance companies are benevolent caretakers of the american people is not just laughable, it is downright BS. i have insurance, and i have to fight all the time to get them to pay the bill to my sons doctor in a timely manner. my insurance fund payed 2 million dollars in admin costs, and 1 million in actual claims! thats efficient? cost effective? the part about your employer taking life insurance out on you is downright creepy. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

Look what the government's done to Medicare. Bankrupt in 8 years. my argument regarding this is that medicare is going bankrupt for 2 reasons 1. fraud, which no one can blame solely on washington. it is the citizens of this country who perpetrate billions in medicare fraud a year. 2. govt spending of the medicare trust. al gore wanted to put this off limits 9 years ago, to keep congress from using medicare funds to underwrite spending. i agree, medicare funds should only be used for medicare. the only way, in my opinion, to make sure you and i have medicare when we reach retirement is to act now to save it, by reducing costs, stopping fraud and implementing the "lockbox" 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I pay over $400 a month for insurance for me and my family a month only to fight with them over crap that should be covered. I thought my insurance was fine...until I had to use it. If you guys are interested on how Universal Health Care works in Canada or England, check out my other posts with clips from the movie SiCKO. I would gladly pay $500 a month in taxes for Universal Health Care for all. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

> 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

he only way, in my opinion, to make sure you and i have medicare when we reach retirement is to act now to save it, by reducing costs, stopping fraud and implementing the "lockbox" I think it SHOULD be saved, we just disagree on how best to do that. Putting the government in charge of universal care is doomed to fail with that bunch in Washington. I mean that sincerely. I'm as opposed to UHC as one gets, but I'm for anything that doesn't put the government directly in charge of my health care. I think the plan they're looking at involves creating co ops which make care affordable for those needing it. I suspect many could actually afford insurance now but are unwilling to give up creature comforts to do so, and I'm willing to bet even when faced with fines for not doing so, many won't. And the rest of will end up carrying that burden, just like with the illegals. Life isn't fair and I will accept whatever comes down the pike. lol like I have a choice. Perhaps if that bunch of thieves had kept their grubby hands out of our social security fund we could use that money to help fund this cause. I fail to understand the lack of rage over them STILL pilfering the SS fund 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

If you guys are interested on how Universal Health Care works in Canada or England, check out my other posts with clips from the movie SiCKO. that does not stop them (people in Canada or England) from fighting with their "insurance company" (the government) for health care they think they deserve 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

That video is sad but it sounds like a big F-up, human error. The doctor didn't put her on a list, then the doc dropped her when her son threatened him. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

sassy i am a single payer guy, but i would gladly take any of the options you present. but, the single payer program isnt government run, it will still be run by the likes of aetna and blue cross. the deal with the public option is that in order for an insurance company to be a participant in the plan, they would have to conform to certain criteria, like non denial of existing conditions, portablity etc. it will not be run, or managed, by the government, just funded. the best comparison, and its not really a good one, would be to compare the public option to flood or windstorm insurance. these are federally funded, privately managed policies. i like the co-op idea as well, i only worry about their ability to compete in rural areas, and provide traetment for catastrophic illnesses. seems they would work great in houston, but what about in uvalde? i do appreciate your remarks, and hopefully our folks in washington can get us some help. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Jonathon, I'm on my way to lunch but will get back to this when I retuen. I'm always willing to listen :) 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

good eatin 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

> 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

I'm for anything that doesn't put the government directly in charge of my health care. The alternative is to let "the market" take care of it, aka insurance companies. Those same companies have an incentive to charge high premiums, high deductibles, and limit payouts. If we leave it up to the insurance companies, we all lose. You may say, "Well, then have insurance companies administer the program, but have oversight." Who is going to do the oversight? The government. So, we need to have government involvement at some level. Even at it's bare minimum it needs to oversee and enforce fair regulations. I think the problem is that some people don't want any government involvement, but that's just ridiculous. Unless you truly want anarchy and chaos, there needs to be some level of government involvement. But, to suggest government involvement at any level brings out the libertarians and tin-foil-hat-wearing crowd in force. You can't have a rational discussion with those folks, because they don't use reason at all. It's a tricky problem. But I don't think leaving it up to "the market" is going to do anything but raise costs, reduce levels of care, and hurt more people in the long run. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 17 years ago -

cool post, thanks for sharing. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Here is the transcript. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

Even at it's bare minimum it needs to oversee and enforce fair regulations. I think the problem is that some people don't want any government involvement, but that's just ridiculous. Most conservatives want insurance reform and regulation. they oppose mandates, tax increases, and public options 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

No one is defending the insurance companies. But the Dems REFUSE to even discuss real issues that would lower premiums and healtcare costs. Such as TORT reform - many are lawyers including Obama. The rest are paid off by the lawyers. Competition across state lines would be huge factor and something that is actually in the Constitution for them to regulate. These people are looking for more government power and money to flow through Washington. They show no real interest in healthcare reform. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

No one is defending the insurance companies. thank you - agreed. why cant it be two separate bills, 2 separate debates? 1. regulate insurance companies, lower health care costs/premiums 2. provide health care to uninsured I think that if we could accomplish number 1 first, then the uninsured amount will go down and would be a more manageable issue. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

Most conservatives want insurance reform and regulation. they oppose mandates, tax increases, and public options This is correct. There are so many more options than a government mandate to really reform healthacare but Obama, Pelosi and Reid refuse to listen. If it doesnt increase their power and cash flow they arent interested. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

Most conservatives want insurance reform and regulation. they oppose mandates, tax increases, and public options i do not doubt your sincerity, but as a liberal, i have a hard time believing that the GOP really wants to do anything. if the GOP agrees with us about the need for insurance reform, why havent they done anything about it since clinton failed? it is not a priority to them, and , in my opinion, they proved it by refusing to take it on at anytime during the last 16 years, while dems have been hounding the issue nonstop. why havent they introduced a competing bill, like the opposition party typically does? they act like Obama taking on healthcare is a surprise to them, yet he campaigned for over a year on this platform. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Most conservatives want insurance reform and regulation. they oppose mandates, tax increases, and public options I'd like to examine your claims, and I hope you don't feel like I'm attacking you, because I am not intending that. I think old-style "conservatives" don't want any regulation. I think that goes against the core purpose of the movement. But I don't like your use of the word "mandate". What is a mandate? It's a rule or law or regulation. How can conservatives be for regulation but against mandates? They are the same thing. Nobody wants tax increases, and we need to have a more reasoned national debate about our financial priorities. I don't like high taxes, but the reality is that they exist. As long as I'm being taxed, I'd rather pay for healthcare for my fellow citizens more than I want aggressive war against other countries. Providing health insurance for all americans would be vastly cheaper than what we've spent in Iraq. That's a tangent that I don't want to spend a ton of time on, but c'mon, modern "conservatives" aren't about small government and low taxes anymore, it's all about where that tax money is spent. War or social programs for our own? What is really more important? Lastly, I think too many people fear the "public option" boogeyman. Those who argue against the public option do so out of fear. Fear that their tenuous grasp on whatever security they currently have will be lost if they expand care & coverage for others. The irony, of course, is that the status quo will do that on its own in a few years, so arguing against reform is the surest way to ensure that its opponents, and everyone else, see diminished coverage in the future. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

Such as TORT reform this is one argument i dont understand. my insurance premiums didnt go down after we passed the liability cap, it has gone up at the same rate. and i find it odd that you trust a jury to put a citizen to death, but not to decide if a doctor acted negligently. the public option would not be run by the government. it would still be enacted by the private insurance companies, only paid by the gov. i wouldnt have USA healthcare, i would have aetna, or blue cross, but the plans that i would choose from would all include the consumer protections that we all apparently agree on. i would rather have this, than the GOP's solution of actually subsidizing insurance companies with taxpayer dollars, and not getting quality guarantees. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

i have to say, in the last 2 weeks the discourse around this conversation has changed, and for the better. it is refreshing to see us of differing opinions argue our points fairly and rationally, rather than insulting each other. i honestly respect the differences pubs and i have on government, i used to be a pub myself. thanks for the honest debate. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

Such as TORT reform this is one argument i dont understand. my insurance premiums didnt go down after we passed the liability cap, it has gone up at the same rate. and i find it odd that you trust a jury to put a citizen to death, but not to decide if a doctor acted negligently. Tort reform would target the HUGE class action lawsuits that do nothing but enrich lawyers - see John Edwards currently biggest sleaze bag in the world. Previously Democratic Presidential nominee. The biggest cost in healthcare is malpractice insurance and lawsuit avoidance. Pretty much common knowledge. Then allow ALL insurance companies to compete in EVERY state. Pre- existing conditions can go into a pool and insurance companies would be required to take them. Tax credits for all health insurance payments and any out of pocket expneses. WHY - will the Dems not discuss these options. I say they are the ones that dont want real reform. They just want to take over from the health isurance companies. Once the the government has it we as a nation are done. If the government (we the people are actually paying) is paying for it - they are running it, make no mistake. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

I dont even know where to start and I dont have the time to right a long thought out post! First of all, I agree that Obama does deserve credit for being proactive on health care. In my opinion, it does absolutely no good to argue over why things have not been done in the past. All politicians are at fault - not one party. I need to take a break before I comment further - there is too much to say! 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

But I don't like your use of the word "mandate". What is a mandate? It's a rule or law or regulation. How can conservatives be for regulation but against mandates? They are the same thing. I am specifically referring to the provision that everyone must purchase health insurance or pay a fine. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

Obama may be proactive on healthcare, but he has and continues to go down the wrong path. Ignorance or arrogance? It is clear the majority of Americans do not support his agenda. Why will he not compremise with republicans and at least entertain the ideas discussed above?? They have been presented to him and have been dismissed out of hand. I believe it says alot about him. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

The biggest cost in healthcare is malpractice insurance and lawsuit avoidance. thats the biggest cost to providers, not the entire system. and, like i stated, my premiums havent changed since we enacted these reforms in texas what, 6 years ago? Then allow ALL insurance companies to compete in EVERY state. i dont buy this one at all. they do compete in every state. blue cross is in texas and Pa.. the reason that they are different entities is because each state regulates their own insurance industry.the requirements in texas are different than the are montana, and thus, we have two insurance companies. my point is this, if we do what ypu suggest, i dont think we will have any more choice than we do now, or anymore competition. it is not as if there are insurance companies that do business in NY but not TX. if you are for federally mandated consumer protections, irregardless of residency, than i could get on board with this idea. 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

I am specifically referring to the provision that everyone must purchase health insurance or pay a fine. i suppose you are against mandated car, home and flood insurance as well 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

nothing about this debate has delivered on any of Obama's promises. I thought he was going to bring new ideas on how to solve problems in innovative, non-partisan ways? these past 10 months have been very politically divisive 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

Pre- existing conditions can go into a pool and insurance companies would be required to take them. and how is this more palatable than a public option? this is the public option, except replace the word pre-existing with uninsured 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

I thought he was going to bring new ideas on how to solve problems in innovative, non-partisan ways? you guys fail to realize that to those of us who support a single payer system, a public option is a huge compromise 

river chef --- 17 years ago -

these past 10 months have been very politically divisive so, its obamas fault that people spread lies like death panels, and misrepresentations of the public option. its obamas fault i am called a socialist for wanting to help out folks? its obamas fault that the GOP didnt even send anyone to negotiate? man, i thought i had high expectations 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

i suppose you are against mandated car, home and flood insurance as well I dont see how these are the same. if I don't want to pay for car insurance I dont have to drive a car. state's and mortgage companies having their own specific insurance requirements is different than the federal government putting a requirement on every citizen in the country. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

so, its obamas fault that people spread lies like death panels, and misrepresentations of the public option. its obamas fault i am called a socialist for wanting to help out folks? its obamas fault that the GOP didnt even send anyone to negotiate? I believe that I have been let down by my conservative reps in DC. It seems that they care more about Dems and Obama failing than solving the problem. I HATE it when they throw phrases like death panels and communists around. BUT, I still believe in conservative principles. I am not even opposed to considering a public option in the future. I just think that insurance reform should be the number one focus right now. 

JustGoWithIt --- 17 years ago -

I believe that the government should be doing more to keep money in Americans pockets. why not subsidize health insurance costs to small businesses for their employees? 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

The biggest cost in healthcare is malpractice insurance and lawsuit avoidance. thats the biggest cost to providers, If it is their cost it is YOUR cost, they just pass it down. Texas is the worst about restricting health insurance companies competing in the state. That is why you dont see reduction in premiums. About 3 companies control almost all insurance in the state. Sound competetive? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground