Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Innocent but Dead

who's talking here?

randyjet 6
Sandyr9111 1
AuthorMan 3
Going off air 1
R.E.B. 2
txdaddy 11
~sassy~ 1
POTUS 2
zapper007 2
*maryc 1
Ogre1 10
JohnLynch 3
BigPantiesHatesMe 2
*momof5* 4
oldsouth 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

oldsouth --- 17 years ago -

Innocent but Dead BOB HERBERT Published: August 31, 2009 There is a long and remarkable article in the current New Yorker about a man who was executed in Texas in 2004 for deliberately setting a fire that killed his three small children. Rigorous scientific analysis has since shown that there was no evidence that the fire in a one-story, wood frame house in Corsicana was the result of arson, as the authorities had alleged. In other words, it was an accident. No crime had occurred. Cameron Todd Willingham, who refused to accept a guilty plea that would have spared his life, and who insisted until his last painful breath that he was innocent, had in fact been telling the truth all along. It was inevitable that some case in which a clearly innocent person had been put to death would come to light. It was far from inevitable that this case would be the one. “I was extremely skeptical in the beginning,” said the New Yorker reporter, David Grann, who began investigating the case last December. The fire broke out on the morning of Dec. 23, 1991. Willingham was awakened by the cries of his 2-year-old daughter, Amber. Also in the house were his year-old twin girls, Karmon and Kameron. The family was poor, and Willingham’s wife, Stacy, had gone out to pick up a Christmas present for the children from the Salvation Army. Willingham said he tried to rescue the kids but was driven back by smoke and flames. At one point his hair caught fire. As the heat intensified, the windows of the children’s room exploded and flames leapt out. Willingham, who was 23 at the time, had to be restrained and eventually handcuffed as he tried again to get into the room. There was no reason to believe at first that the fire was anything other than a horrible accident. But fire investigators, moving slowly through the ruined house, began seeing things (not unlike someone viewing a Rorschach pattern) that they interpreted as evidence of arson. They noticed deep charring at the base of some of the walls and patterns of soot that made them suspicious. They noticed what they felt were ominous fracture patterns in pieces of broken window glass. They had no motive, but they were convinced the fire had been set. And if it had been set, who else but Willingham would have set it? With no real motive in sight, the local district attorney, Pat Batchelor, was quoted as saying, “The children were interfering with his beer drinking and dart throwing.” Willingham was arrested and charged with capital murder. When official suspicion fell on Willingham, eyewitness testimony began to change. Whereas initially he was described by neighbors as screaming and hysterical — “My babies are burning up!” — and desperate to have the children saved, he now was described as behaving oddly, and not having made enough of an effort to get to the girls. And you could almost have guaranteed that a jailhouse snitch would emerge. They almost always do. This time his name was Johnny Webb, a jumpy individual with a lengthy arrest record who would later admit to being “mentally impaired” and on medication, and who had started taking illegal drugs at the age of 9. The jury took barely an hour to return a guilty verdict, and Willingham was sentenced to death. He remained on death row for 12 years, but it was only in the weeks leading up to his execution that convincing scientific evidence of his innocence began to emerge. A renowned scientist and arson investigator, Gerald Hurst, educated at Cambridge and widely recognized as a brilliant chemist, reviewed the evidence in the Willingham case and began systematically knocking down every indication of arson. The authorities were unmoved. Willingham was executed by lethal injection on Feb. 17, 2004. Now comes a report on the case from another noted scientist, Craig Beyler, who was hired by a special commission, established by the state of Texas to investigate errors and misconduct in the handling of forensic evidence. The report is devastating, the kind of disclosure that should send a tremor through one’s conscience. There was absolutely no scientific basis for determining that the fire was arson, said Beyler. No basis at all. He added that the state fire marshal who investigated the case and testified against Willingham “seems to be wholly without any realistic understanding of fires.” He said the marshal’s approach seemed to lack “rational reasoning” and he likened it to the practices “of mystics or psychics.” Grann told me on Monday that when he recently informed the jailhouse snitch, Johnny Webb, that new scientific evidence would show that the fire wasn’t arson and that an innocent man had been killed, Webb seemed taken aback. “Nothing can save me now,” he said.  

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Very sad! 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

How horrible. Theres nothing worse than shoddy investigations or them just hanging crap on someone for multiple crimes just to clear them off the books. I started studying fire investigation and its very interesting how things burn and the patterns they make. It makes it pretty clean most times unless it is a total loss how and where a fire started. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I don's see how anyone can come to a conclusion about the source of a fire 19 years after the fact. They should be more careful with their opinions. 

BigPantiesHatesMe --- 17 years ago -

AuthorMan, "I don's see how anyone can come to a conclusion about the source of a fire 19 years after the fact. " I AGREE!! It's not like a blood specimen that can stored and tested decades later. It was a fire. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

i did not read anything in this story that convinced me he was innocent. i see a lot of conjecture and opinions but no opportunity to rebut by the presenting officials. seriously, so one scientist refuted the evidence presented at the trial? happens all the time, doesn't make it true or the right interpretation. seems like a reporter trying to gain fame more than an innocent person put to death. why didn't the reporter actually report on the evidence presented at trial? he seems convinced the man was innocent, why could explain the slant to the article. i am no fire expert and would not pretend to be, but not sure how this article proves anything other than someone disagreed with the conviction and penalty. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I don't know, most people that do something deliberately, wouldn't try to go back into the fire and have their hair catch on fire and have to be handcuffed to stop them from trying to save their children...that would be a hell of an act. What a sad situation :( At least he's exonerated in death, that has to mean something to those that are still here and believed in his innocence. This is exactly why I hate the death penalty. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

interesting.... Two days before Christmas in 1991, Willingham poured a combustible liquid on the floor throughout his home and intentionally set the house on fire, resulting in the death of his three children. According to autopsy reports, Amber, age two, and twins Karmon and Kameron, age 1, died of acute carbon monoxide poisoning as a result of smoke inhalation. Neighbors of Willingham testified that as the house began smoldering, Willingham was “crouched down” in the front yard, and despite the neighbors’ pleas, refused to go into the house in any attempt to rescue the children. An expert witness for the State testified that the floors, front threshold, and front concrete porch were burned, which only occurs when an accelerant has been used to purposely burn these areas. The witness further testified that this igniting of the floors and thresholds is typically employed to impede firemen in their rescue attempts. The testimony at trial demonstrates that Willingham neither showed remorse for his actions nor grieved the loss of his three children. Willingham’s neighbors testified that when the fire “blew out” the windows, Willingham “hollered about his car” and ran to move it away from the fire to avoid its being damaged. A fire fighter also testified that Willingham was upset that his dart board was burned. Willingham told authorities that the fire started while he and the children were asleep. An investigation revealed that it was intentionally set with a flammable liquid. His claims of heroic effort to save the girls were not borne out by his unscathed escape with little smoke in his lungs. http://www.clarkprosecutor.org/html/death/US/willingham899.htm 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

from same source... Final Words: "The only statement I want to make is that I am an innocent man convicted of a crime I did not commit. I have been persecuted for 12 years for something I did not do. From God's dust I came and to dust I will return so the Earth shall become my throne. I gotta go, Road Dog." He expressed love to someone named Gabby and then addressed his ex-wife, Stacy Kuykendall, who was watching about 8 feet away through a window and said several times, "I hope you rot in Hell, b*tch." He then attempted to maneuver his hand, strapped at the wrist, into an obscene gesture. His former wife showed no reaction to the outburst. wow...no "so sorry for the loss of our kids"...nothing like that? hmmmmmmmmm 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

Willingham poured a combustible liquid on the floor throughout his home and intentionally set the house on fire, resulting in the death of his three children. He was guilty of a horrible crime. Those children died a frightening and painful death. He deserved the death penalty. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Willingham said he tried to rescue the kids but was driven back by smoke and flames. At one point his hair caught fire. As the heat intensified, the windows of the children’s room exploded and flames leapt out. Willingham, who was 23 at the time, had to be restrained and eventually handcuffed as he tried again to get into the room. It would be interesting to hear what the cops/firefighters on the scene said and what the eyewitness testimony had been before suspicion landed on the father. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

seriously...NO MENTION of his children in his final words before death? sound innocent to you? not me. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

It would be interesting to hear what the cops/firefighters on the scene said and what the eyewitness testimony had been before suspicion landed on the father. you don't think all of that was presented at the trial? if not, then his lawyer failed him. how would it be possible for this hack of a reporter to report that unless it was presented somewhere at some point in time. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

wow...no "so sorry for the loss of our kids"...nothing like that? hmmmmmmmmm well, if your wife had accused you of murdering your children and you were innocent and she came to watch your execution, would you be warm and fuzzy toward her? I have no idea if he's guilty or not. I'm not privy to the investigation of his guilt or his innocence. But, on an emotional level, if I was accused of something I didn't do, especially something as vile as the murder of my children, I'm not going to be really receptive to a visit by my accusers. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

well, if your wife had accused you of murdering your children and you were innocent and she came to watch your execution, would you be warm and fuzzy toward her? his wife was gone, the police and investigators accused him and they succeeded in convicting him with the death penalty. if i was her, i would want to watch his pos a$$ be put to death too. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

This is exactly why I hate the death penalty. The death penality should be abolished because without a doubt innocent men and women have been - and will be - put to death for a crime they did not commit. Given that it costs more to kill them than house them for life, the death penality makes no sense. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You forget how juries in this part and many if not most parts of Texas work. Not too long ago we had a guy here in New Caney who was convicted of rape on a woman who was killed. The ONLY evidence against him was testimony from a co-worker who said that the guy told him he forced a woman to give him a blow job on that night. There was NO forensic evidence despite the cops dismantling his truck, no other witnesses against him. His boss said that he HAD to have worked a lot longer than the prosecutor said since the number of trees he had felled would not allow him enough time to get to the crime scene and back. The judge in the case, regreted that he even let the trial procede, and he overturned the juries verdict since it was WAY out of line with the evidence. The state appealed and won a reversal of the judges ruling. The guy spent years in prison before DNA evidence showed he had NOTHING to do with the case. Then the Montgomery DA presented a novel new idea that he must have used a condum, so he was still guilty no matter what the DNA said. Judge Keller, who is now under investigation and possible impeachment was the leader on the Court of Appeals which refused to accept the DNA evidence. Then Governor Bush looked at the evidence, and after a petitioning campaign here, granted him a pardon. I will give W Bush some credit for that act of common sense and decency. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

PS The ONLY thing this guy was guilty of was being alone and having no alibi to clear him. THUS, he was guilty if the prosecutor said so. Glad we are rid of McDougal! Too bad we can't get better juries. 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

Never forget that, at the height of Texas' execution frenzy under Bush (50 executions per year), he told a reporter that he always spent at least 15 minutes deciding if clemency should be granted to death row inmates. Now - this is even sadder, in light of the revelations concerning those that have been murdered by the State of Texas for murders they did not commit. You do not have to take a political stand to appreciate the absolute profoundness of the statement by “W” on this topic. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

There is no question that Texas has executed many innocent people. Illinios found that about 17% of its death row inmates were wrongly convicted by police fraud and misconduct. We have had many other cases here which have come close to executing innocents, but were stopped at the last minute. Texas has probably the worst record on this score, and yet we are the most active in using the death penalty. THAT is plain dumb and scary. I am not completely against the death penalty, but it should be reserved for the most egregious crimes and NO question of guilt. 

BigPantiesHatesMe --- 17 years ago -

randyjet.....are you completely against the death penalty?? 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

I believe there SHOULD be a death penalty for some crimes, but I don't trust our justice system enough to have that power. Too many crooked cops, lawyers, prosecutors, judges and shady backroom deals. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

randyjet.....are you completely against the death penalty??  I am not completely against the death penalty, but it should be reserved for the most egregious crimes and NO question of guilt.  no, he isn't. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

only thing i know is that i would have never left that house without my children 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I don's see how anyone can come to a conclusion about the source of a fire 19 years after the fact. That's because you are not an experienced investigator and do not understand REAL forensics..not the Sci Fi cr@p they show on CSI. i did not read anything in this story that convinced me he was innocent. that's because this story did not directly address the man's innocence, but addressed the inadequacies of the initial investigation. so one scientist refuted the evidence presented at the trial? So, you also don't understand how the criminal justice systems works. You have to prove that someone is guilty BEYOND ALL REASONABLE DOUBT. That's a pretty high standard. If the defense attorney had this expert testify, that very well could have resulted in reasonable doubt. TXDADDY - could you have found a MORE biased source??? I seriously doubt the Clark County Prosecutor's office is going to post something that exonerates the man they are responsible for sending to the death chamber. The statements from that website prove NOTHING. Those children died a frightening and painful death. Carbon Monoxide poisoning... more than likely the died in their sleep, well before the fire reached them. ...you don't think all of that was presented at the trial? if not, then his lawyer failed him. We live in the state where if you're attorney is asleep, drunk, stoned, or crazy, BUT IS PRESENT in the courtroom, then you have effective counsel. I can think of HUNDREDS of reasons that counter testimony may not have been presented... incompetent attorney, police pressure on witnesses, the godsd@mned hearsay rules..etc. I will give W Bush some credit for that act of common sense and decency. A rare moment of clarity. NOW, I should say, that I firmly believe there are some crimes for which one should lose one's life. HOWEVER, I also believe that our system of administering capital punishment is flawed in many ways. 1. As long as DA's are elected, the process will be driven by politics. 2. The use of circumstantial, NON-SCIENTIFIC evidence, in my opinion, if a violation of a person's due process rights when it comes to cap pun. 3. Judges and DA's ignoring scientific evidence (I.E. DNA) should be disallowed. You always hear some dipweed DA saying "he got a good trial" in defense of his prosecution, but did he REALLY get a good trial if the evidence was incomplete? TRUTH should trump procedure..period. 4. The longest a person has been on Death Row in Texas was 19 years. That is WAYYY too long. it is inefficient. I'm not advocating taking the guilty out back to the lime filled ditch, but at the same time, a decade or more waiting for your fate is just ludicrous. 5. We must also punish DA's for overzealous prosecution. We must ABSOLUTELY punish DA's, Cops, Investigators for fabricating evidence. I could go on and on about this. But, as long as the system is not perfect, innocent people will die. There is just nothing to be done about that. But the U.S. Jury system is the best in the world at protecting the rights of the accused, sometimes, maybe even often at the expense of the victim. But that's better than the alternative which is putting the innocent in prison, or on death row willy nilly. 

Going off air --- 17 years ago -

I could go on and on about this. Please Do!!!! U R ona Roll! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

only thing i know is that i would have never left that house without my children You ever been in a fire? NOT around one.. IN ONE. My first fire was a massive conflagration in the #1 engineroom onboard the USS Hoel. Smoke, heat, darkness (yes, darkness - as if the fire is absorbing light). When it hits 1800 degrees in the house, you WILL flee. My second big fire was on board a Leahy class cruiser whose #2 boiler exploded. Six men died in that fire (the entire watch team) and we went in as a back up team to put it out... in this case, we also had to deal with 800 degree steam blowing out a main steam line. That's like being INSIDE a jet engine. I've put out four other, much smaller fires, dealt with one other boiler explosion and I've been shot at. Given a choice, I would rather be shot at. So maybe you wouldn't have left, but if not, I'd betting that you'd be dead. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

So maybe you wouldn't have left, but if not, I'd betting that you'd be dead. yes, i have been "IN ONE" and the point was that i would be dead with my children and not alive without them 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

TXDADDY - could you have found a MORE biased source??? I seriously doubt the Clark County Prosecutor's office is going to post something that exonerates the man they are responsible for sending to the death chamber. The statements from that website prove NOTHING. gee, and the new yorker would absolutely include the real evidence against him that got him convicted. i am starting to doubt your skills in anything legal to be honest. maybe it's been too long since you allegedly performed in that capacity??? 'legal clerk' does not count. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

lol txdaddy, what is wrong with you? don't you know that ogre has done EVERYTHING 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

I don's see how anyone can come to a conclusion about the source of a fire 19 years after the fact. That's because you are not an experienced investigator and do not understand REAL forensics..not the Sci Fi cr@p they show on CSI. How's the weather in left field. 19 years after the fire- nothing would be left to form an opinion on. But you, the 'expert', have that capacity. Classic. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

yes, i have been "IN ONE" and the point was that i would be dead with my children and not alive without them I agree with you on this one, John. I would rather die trying to save my kids, then live without them. There are some things worse than dying, and loosing your kids is one of them IMO. I do not want to outlive my kids. In 1991, I did rush into a neighbor's burning house to save their dog, which was tied up in the living room. They were not home. One of the firefighters, who arrived as I was exiting the house with the dog, told me that was a stupid thing to do. Maybe it was, but I couldn't let that dog burn to death. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

BWAHAHAHAHahahahahahahaaaaa Ogre has chewed up txdiddy into d@#kwad and spit him out!!!!! just ripe for a 'your mother' comment... 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

just ripe for a 'your mother' comment... There you go assuming stuff again, txdaddy. You assume he has a mother. :-) 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Slim Jim is actually a KU bot, programmed to spur debate and outrage. Factual. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Given a choice, I would rather be shot at. As chief operator on a refinery unit, I got to fight lots of fires not only on my own unit, but on others. I have not been shot at yet, but I second your opinion. You have no idea of where or when another blast will come or if a line will blow up next to you. Not to mention the smoke which is incredible along with the heat. I damn near killed myself when I got complacent one time when I was inspecting the gas fired heaters on my unit. Instead of keeping to the side when openning the inspection port, I simply assumed the fire was good and stood at arms length from it when I openned it. Fortunately I am big and have long arms, but my face still got scorched when I openned it and the fire leaped out. I had no idea I could move so fast, and I had enough room so I didn't go over the side of the heater as I sprang back and hit the railing. Lesson learned the HARD way! 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

randyjet.....are you completely against the death penalty?? I rather like the British system which only applies the death penalty in wartime or civil insurrection. The government is in such a fight and killing lots of innocent folks and the times are so extreme, that while mistakenly killing some innocents is regrettable, I think that you can take that risk. 

oldsouth --- 17 years ago -

From the Corsicana Daily Sun Published: August 26, 2009 08:58 pm Report claims Willingham investigation flawed DALLAS (AP) — A fire investigation that led to the execution of Cameron Todd Willingham of Corsicana in the 1991 deaths of his three young children was so seriously flawed that its conclusion of arson can’t be supported, a fire expert hired by the state said in a new report. In a report to the Texas Forensic Science Commission released Tuesday, Craig Beyler said the fire investigation in Willingham’s case didn’t adhere to the standards of care in place at the time, nor to current standards. Beyler, chairman of the London-based International Association for Fire Safety Science, said in the report that the opinions of a state fire official in the case were “nothing more than a collection of personal beliefs that have nothing to do with science-based fire investigation.” Willingham was sentenced to death after being found guilty of setting the fire that took the lives of 2-year-old Amber Kuykendall and 1-year-old twins Karmon and Kameron Willingham two days before Christmas 1991 in their Corsicana home. The State Fire Marshal’s office led the investigation into the 1991 fire. It was the state agency’s report that was introduced as evidence in Willingham’s trial, and whose validity is being questioned in Beyler’s report. The commission, created in 2005 to review forensic misconduct allegations, requested the independent analysis after the Innocence Project submitted claims of questionable evidence in the cases of Willingham and another man who was convicted in a similar case but was later released. Commission Chairman Sam Bassett called Beyler’s report “a major step” in the panel’s review of both cases. Before issuing its final report, the commission will seek responses from the State Fire Marshal’s Office and other parties, and will interview Beyler in October, Bassett said. He said he expects the commission to release its report next spring. Beyler said that in both cases, “The investigators had poor understandings of fire science ... Their methodologies did not comport with the scientific method or the process of elimination.” He said Manuel Vasquez, a deputy state fire marshal who investigated the Willingham case, appeared “wholly without any realistic understanding of fires and how fire injuries are created.” Beyler said witnesses contradicted Vasquez’s arson hypothesis and that Vasquez admitted he had not eliminated other possible causes. Eric Ferrero, spokesman for the Innocence Project, a New York-based organization dedicated to exonerating wrongfully convicted people, said Beyler’s findings on the Willingham case “confirms what several experts have found over the last five years after reviewing thousands of pages of evidence.” “Every expert who has looked at this case has determined there was no reason to call it arson,” he said. Willingham, 36, was executed in 2004. He told The Associated Press before his execution that he was innocent, calling his 1992 trial “a joke.” “The most distressing thing is the state of Texas will kill an innocent man and doesn’t care they’re making a mistake,” he said. Willingham’s cousin, Patricia Cox, of Ardmore, Okla., said she has never doubted her cousin’s innocence. Family members tried for years to free him. “I would definitely like the state of Texas to take responsibility and admit in fact they wrongfully executed Todd Willingham,” she said. “Is that going to happen? Probably not. I’m not optimistic.” Willingham’s stepmother, Eugenia Willingham, called the report another step in the “long, drawn-out process” of clearing his name. “He lived 12 years on death row,” she said. “He went through hell, I’m telling you. It was probably worse than hell.” She said her husband died in 2005, the year after his son’s execution, of prostate cancer and “a broken heart.” Vasquez investigated the case with Douglas Fogg, the assistant Corsicana fire chief. The report said they cited burn patterns on the floor of the children’s room, hallway and porch, indicating an accelerant spill. Beyler said those determinations have no basis in modern fire science. Ben Gonzalez, a spokesman for the Texas Department of Insurance, of which the State Fire Marshal’s Office is a part, said he had no comment on the report, saying officials there had not yet seen it. He said Vasquez died in 1994. A call by the Associated Press to a Douglas Fogg in Corsicana was not immediately returned Wednesday. In the other case cited in the report, Ernest Ray Willis was convicted in 1987 in a fatal house fire in Iraan, but was freed after 17 years on death row when a federal judge ruled that authorities concealed evidence and needlessly drugged him during his trial. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

yes, i have been "IN ONE" and the point was that i would be dead with my children and not alive without them And MY point was that you don't know that until you've actually been in one. You may flee like Pentecost from a mini-skirt convention. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

new yorker would absolutely include the real evidence against him that got him convicted. And the New Yorker will not be in depth enough to make any sort of decisions. And I don't give a rats arse what you think of my legal skills. let's see.. which of us has actually both PUT people in jail and got them out? Oh, that would be ME. So frak off. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground